PDA

View Full Version : Match Ratings:



Pedantic_Hibee
10-02-2024, 09:24 PM
In the absence of Jonnyboy and for those of us who weren’t there or couldn’t catch up on a stream, let’s be having your player ratings…

Mikey_1875
10-02-2024, 10:22 PM
This is from what I can remember so might have misremembered or forgotten parts!

Marshall - 6 - Nothing much to do and couldn’t do anything for the goal.

Miller - 5.5- Got forward more often than usual but had some poor touches in the first half.

Fish - 6 - Clean and tidy, done everything he had to do.

Triantis - 7 - Similar to Fish but had more effective forward passing.

Obita - 7 - Solid performance and got forward well at times.

Amos - 5 - I’ve seen conflicting opinions on his performance today. I didn’t think he was great but it’s not as if he stood out like a sore thumb as Robbo has meant to have made out. Rightly subbed at HT imo.

Moriah Welsh - 6.5 - Busy again. Not as noticeable today as we had more of the ball than against Celtic but he still covered every blade of grass and got stuck in.

Newell - 6.5 - A bit guilty of falling into the habit of playing backwards and sitting too deep. Improved in the second half playing in the same three as midweek.

Boyle - 8 - Motm for me, worked very hard and looked a threat all day. We have definitely missed him.

Myziane - 7 - Struggled to find space in the first half and some sloppy touches. Improved in the second half and got his goal. I think he has a good connection with Youan and this could be a partnership to keep an eye on.

Mayenda - 4.5 - Got a shot away in the first half that was easily parried but that was about it. Struggled and again was rightly hooked at HT.

Subs

Youan - 7.5 - Looked good today. Had his usual lapses of concentration at times but he was taking on and beating players for fun at others. The good definitely outweighed the bad and I noticed he worked hard to get the ball back if he did lose it. Glad to see him on the scoresheet.

Levitt - 7 - Improved our midfield when he came on. Nearly on the scoresheet again with a cracking strike. Brought more urgency to our midfield and bagged an assist.

Alf - 6 - Didn’t get much coming his way but still had a couple of clever runs and touches.

Marcondes - 5.5 - not much time to make a meaningful impact but we did score two goals after he came on.

Cadden - 6.5 - see Marcondes but an extra point just for being back in the mix again.

Monty - 8 - We controlled the game and he made the correct changes to give us a bit more going forward. Comfortable win in the end.

Fans - 9 - Good atmosphere throughout and fantastic at the end. Perhaps understandably a wee bit of frustration and nerves creeping in towards the end of the first half until we scored.

Ref - 4 - Strange character and didn’t seem to give us much all game. Luckily didn’t have any major calls to make.

Hibernian Verse
10-02-2024, 10:32 PM
This is from what I can remember so might have misremembered or forgotten parts!

Marshall - 6 - Nothing much to do and couldn’t do anything for the goal.

Miller - 5.5- Got forward more often than usual but had some poor touches in the first half.

Fish - 6 - Clean and tidy, done everything he had to do.

Triantis - 7 - Similar to Fish but had more effective forward passing.

Obita - 7 - Solid performance and got forward well at times.

Amos - 5 - I’ve seen conflicting opinions on his performance today. I didn’t think he was great but it’s not as if he stood out like a sore thumb as Robbo has meant to have made out. Rightly subbed at HT imo.

Moriah Welsh - 6.5 - Busy again. Not as noticeable today as we had more of the ball than against Celtic but he still covered every blade of grass and got stuck in.

Newell - 6.5 - A bit guilty of falling into the habit of playing backwards and sitting too deep. Improved in the second half playing in the same three as midweek.

Boyle - 8 - Motm for me, worked very hard and looked a threat all day. We have definitely missed him.

Myziane - 7 - Struggled to find space in the first half and some sloppy touches. Improved in the second half and got his goal. I think he has a good connection with Youan and this could be a partnership to keep an eye on.

Mayenda - 4.5 - Got a shot away in the first half that was easily parried but that was about it. Struggled and again was rightly hooked at HT.

Subs

Youan - 7.5 - Looked good today. Had his usual lapses of concentration at times but he was taking on and beating players for fun at others. The good definitely outweighed the bad and I noticed he worked hard to get the ball back if he did lose it. Glad to see him on the scoresheet.

Levitt - 7 - Improved our midfield when he came on. Nearly on the scoresheet again with a cracking strike. Brought more urgency to our midfield and bagged an assist.

Alf - 6 - Didn’t get much coming his way but still had a couple of clever runs and touches.

Marcondes - 5.5 - not much time to make a meaningful impact but we did score two goals after he came on.

Cadden - 6.5 - see Marcondes but an extra point just for being back in the mix again.

Monty - 8 - We controlled the game and he made the correct changes to give us a bit more going forward. Comfortable win in the end.

Fans - 9 - Good atmosphere throughout and fantastic at the end. Perhaps understandably a wee bit of frustration and nerves creeping in towards the end of the first half until we scored.

Ref - 4 - Strange character and didn’t seem to give us much all game. Luckily didn’t have any major calls to make.

Just on Marcondes, his meaningful impact was the great ball to ALF/Boyle who squared to Youan.

Glasgowhibby95
11-02-2024, 11:40 AM
In the absence of Jonnyboy and for those of us who weren’t there or couldn’t catch up on a stream, let’s be having your player ratings…

What’s happened to Jonnyboy? His ‘this is how it feels’ threads always made for great reading and were a go to for me if I hadn’t been at the game. Hope he is keeping alright.