Bad decisions *for* Hibs

[JeMeSouviens]

Can anyone think of any? I mean there must be some, right? These things "even themselves out" after all...

[darwenhibby]

I didn’t think it was a hibs free kick at 90+2
Sky game Monday night v Aberdeen
The ball crossed the line in the first half at famous five end

[KWJ]

Good thread!

Kyle Vassell's red card at ER.

The one that sticks out most is Matty Jack's penalty but it was deserved for all their time wasting.

[Bushwoof]

Did I imagine this, or did part-time barman Rudi play for the Arabs at some point and have a goal wrongly disallowed for offside on his first visit back to ER?

[Jones28]

Garry O’Connor won a penalty with a dive that makes Boyle look angelic.

St Johnson maybe? Defo at ER.

[WeeRussell]

In the dying seconds of our historic, fantastic, never be surpassed, Scottish cup win.. I recall a free-kick going in our favour when we were sure it was the ref giving them a dodgy one. Or maybe we just didn’t see what it was for at the time.. but even more remarkable it was given against THEM at THAT time.

*edit - just seen already mentioned above

[Pinkie]

I have a sneaky feeling that Scottish VAR would now take a very close look at the Stokes equaliser in May 2016. There was a hint of a wee nudge in the back of Tavernier that probably wouldn’t get past Scottish VAR these days…

[Carheenlea]

I didn’t think it was a hibs free kick at 90+2


Did we ever get to the bottom of what that free kick was awarded for?

Proper head scratcher at the time!

[Jones28]

Did we ever get to the bottom of what that free kick was awarded for?

Proper head scratcher at the time!

It was the start of Steven McLeans slow descent in to madness that has him where he is today.

[easty]

I have a sneaky feeling that Scottish VAR would now take a very close look at the Stokes equaliser in May 2016. There was a hint of a wee nudge in the back of Tavernier that probably wouldn’t get past Scottish VAR these days…

100%

Barely anything in it, but VAR would’ve ruled it out

[Kato]

Garry O’Connor won a penalty with a dive that makes Boyle look angelic.

St Johnson maybe? Defo at ER.

We were right in line with that. The St Johnstone player flicked his leg backwards as GOC was running behind him and tripped him. I know the aftermath of calling GOC a cheat was firm and went on for months later.

Sent from my SM-A528B using Tapatalk

[BoomtownHibees]

I have a sneaky feeling that Scottish VAR would now take a very close look at the Stokes equaliser in May 2016. There was a hint of a wee nudge in the back of Tavernier that probably wouldn’t get past Scottish VAR these days…

No sure about that one but I reckon Stevenson’s push on Waghorn would have been given by VAR

[Vini1875]

Penalty v Forfar was soft. However I seem to think every time we get a very soft Penalty we rarely convert it into a goal.

[MKHIBEE]

I have a sneaky feeling that Scottish VAR would now take a very close look at the Stokes equaliser in May 2016. There was a hint of a wee nudge in the back of Tavernier that probably wouldn’t get past Scottish VAR these days…

”You’re absolutely allowed to do that” was the commentators take on it.

[Mango Man]

Can't think of many VAR decisions that have went our way, The Yellow card upgraded to a red for the Killie boy a couple of weeks back, and last season I think Jeggo got a red downgraded to a yellow.

[SeanWilson]

I have a sneaky feeling that Scottish VAR would now take a very close look at the Stokes equaliser in May 2016. There was a hint of a wee nudge in the back of Tavernier that probably wouldn’t get past Scottish VAR these days…

Bang on. I’ve thought that every single time I watch the replay, how on earth were the masons not giving that as a foul. Hey ho. 💚

[Greensunshine]

I can vaguely remember a couple of times the ball crossed the goal line against Hearts, one home and one away. Not given! The rage 😡 😡 😡

VAR would have surely cleared them up and goals been given.

[Seekyit]

Did I imagine this, or did part-time barman Rudi play for the Arabs at some point and have a goal wrongly disallowed for offside on his first visit back to ER?

You are correct. 11/11/12. Hibs 2-1.

[Pagan Hibernia]

The penalty against hearts at an empty hampden in the delayed 2020 scottish Cup semi final.

It mattered little as Nisbet fluffed it anyway, and then they got their customary dodgy one minutes later

[VoltaireHibs]

There has definitely developed a feeling of us V them when it comes to playing the old firm, including the ref. It feels like the ref, Walsh and Beaton especially, are out to show us who's boss. It's almost antagonistic. The Goldson handballs at the weekend were stick on penalties for any non OF teams, so the idea it's in any way accidental or unconscious is a total nonsense. West coast refs are like arrogant untouchables. Everyone else is just a pawn in their game. We really need a root and branch reform of the refs. Move the headquarters to Edinburgh or Dundee or whatever, hell, they can all train at HTC for all I care, just get them out of Glasgow.


I do wonder what players that come up from England or from abroad make of it. Would be good to get a recently retired players thoughts on this. I think Goldson in particular has realised he can act with impunity, and does so on a regular basis.

[Bushwoof]

Going back a long time, I remember Ally MacLeod punching a rangers player in the Hibs penalty area in a particularly ill-tempered game, and no action being taken. IIRC the game finished 1-1 after we equalised from the penalty spot! Can anyone imagine such a thing happening nowadays?
There has always been bias in favour of the cheeks (especially the huns - lets not forget the 1979 final) but I think it's worse that it has ever been, possibly because the financial stakes are so much higher.

[Potty78]

Did Paul Hanlon score a dodgy goal against the Pars at the end of the 2012 season? Sure it wasn't over the line?

[superfurryhibby]

Did Paul Hanlon score a dodgy goal against the Pars at the end of the 2012 season? Sure it wasn't over the line?

Seem to remember that we smashed them in a game that could have been significant, but wasn't. Hanlon rattled one in that bounced off the cross bar and on the line.

Struggling to remember really, Darren McGregor virtually halfling a Greek guy in the game at Easter Road v Asterios Tripolis. No sending off. It was quite a robust challenge to say the least.

[Kato]

Going back a long time, I remember Ally MacLeod punching a rangers player in the Hibs penalty area in a particularly ill-tempered game, and no action being taken. IIRC the game finished 1-1 after we equalised from the penalty spot! Can anyone imagine such a thing happening nowadays?
There has always been bias in favour of the cheeks (especially the huns - lets not forget the 1979 final) but I think it's worse that it has ever been, possibly because the financial stakes are so much higher.Jackie McNamara did some naughty things to Derek Parlane ( I think ) and nothing happened. Vauge memory of Parlane being penalised.

Sent from my SM-A528B using Tapatalk

[Kato]

Struggling to remember really, Darren McGregor virtually halfling a Greek guy in the game at Easter Road v Asterios Tripolis. No sending off. It was quite a robust challenge to say the least.


That was merely "robust".



Sent from my SM-A528B using Tapatalk

[nonshinyfinish]

Struggling to remember really, Darren McGregor virtually halfling a Greek guy in the game at Easter Road v Asterios Tripolis. No sending off. It was quite a robust challenge to say the least.

https://twitter.com/AidanGW99/status/1022781396652384256

We got the free kick as well.

[AL-Qaholik]

Lundstram red in the 2-2 comeback at ER.

[basehibby]

Our penalty in the League Cup Final vs Dunfermline in '91 - Mickey Weir himself has stated he took an air-swipe at the ball and fell over - only to be awarded the spot kick.

We'd probably have won anyway with Keith's goal but it certainly allowed us Hibees to relax a bit and get the party started rather than enduring squeaky bum time in the closing stages.

[JimBHibees]

The penalty against hearts at an empty hampden in the delayed 2020 scottish Cup semi final.

It mattered little as Nisbet fluffed it anyway, and then they got their customary dodgy one minutes later

How about the penalty not given in injury time when Doidge was dragged to the ground. Madden two yards away doesn't give it as official on the goal line. Stick on pen.

[JimBHibees]

Can't think of many VAR decisions that have went our way, The Yellow card upgraded to a red for the Killie boy a couple of weeks back, and last season I think Jeggo got a red downgraded to a yellow.

Unfortunately Jeggo was sent off by Napier meaning we played with ten for an hour.

[Donegal Hibby]

I honestly can't remember one bad decision that went for us that we didn't deserve :greengrin

[He's here!]

We got a pen in about the 95th minute circa 2001 to beat Dundee Utd 1-0. Very soft with Matty Jack deemed to have had his foot stood on. IIRC Alan Combe then booted the ball out the ground in anger, but I might be mixing that up with another incident.

Latapy scored the pen.

[McD]

That was merely "robust".



Sent from my SM-A528B using Tapatalk



Cant remember which hearts player, but McGregor robustly challenged/walloped him just inside the hearts half as they were attempting to break out from a corner (I think). Commentators thought he could be off but the ref went straight to a yellow, pretty sure Darren moved back into position looking particularly smug :greengrin

[BILLYHIBS]

Cant remember which hearts player, but McGregor robustly challenged/walloped him just inside the hearts half as they were attempting to break out from a corner (I think). Commentators thought he could be off but the ref went straight to a yellow, pretty sure Darren moved back into position looking particularly smug :greengrin

Peter Haring was quality

[Just_Jimmy]

Tam Mcmanus won a penalty at Dens and lying on his front with his arms stretched out, his hands weren't inside the box. Penalty Hibs.

Poetic.

Sent from my SM-G991B using Tapatalk

[KWJ]

Not for Hibs but against a Jambo.

The other skol cup semi - Airdrie v Dunfermline. Ref gives a penalty for handball against jbo Jimmy Sandison. It hit his chest, outside the box 😂😂

[HendoDelivered]

Scotty allans tackle on Rossiter in the 5-5 game

[superfurryhibby]

Mickey Weir cup final penalty, one of the greatest bad decisions for Hibs ? :cb:greengrin

[Pagan Hibernia]

Scotty allans tackle on Rossiter in the 5-5 game

Legendary. Could watch it all day on loop

[Bishop Hibee]

Mickey Weir cup final penalty, one of the greatest bad decisions for Hibs ? :cb:greengrin

Weir gets fouled before his fresh air swipe I think although that’s not what the pen was given for.

I remembers Hibs getting a penalty for nothing at Tannadice, fair tackle on Eddie May, and Stevie Cowan missing the penalty anyway.