Welcome - Myziane Maolida

[Up-the-slope]

Sounds a confident laddie saying he is quick and likes to score and assist

[Up-the-slope]

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=caBCO4bpW0E

[Keith_M]

Any Hertha fans on here that's seen him play?

[HibbyAndy]

Loan or permanent?

[Torto7]

Scott Burns having a nightmare. This guy has some CV. Hopefully we have the right to buy?

[hibsbollah]

I watch a lot of ligue 1 and he passed me by at both clubs. But you dont get on the fringes of the first team at either club or a big money move to Hertha without being a player who is normally well out of our price range. Quite a statement. Fantastic news.

[Torto7]

I just noticed he scored against Smelltic for Lyon in a 4 nil win.

[Trinity Hibee]

This looks like a really positive signing. Good pedigree

[LaMotta]

I had never even heard of his country Comoros until 5 minutes ago ( It's an island off the coast of Mozambique, population 821,000 :nerd:). He's played twice for the national team since making the switch from France - scored in both games including this belter v Ghana in a 1 nil WC Qualifying win :cool2:

https://twitter.com/ActuFootAfrique/status/1727007350262046740

On the flip side the Hertha Berlin coach said he was "Lazy like few players I have ever seen in my life" :hilarious

He also had a 100 million euro release clause in his contract when he signed for Nice.:shocked:

[Up-the-slope]

Loan or permanent?
Loan

[Up-the-slope]

could be a cracking - loan - signing... or could end up with him and Ellie busting out a stepover / tricks contest :greengrin...

I wonder how the nervous in our support who have a heart attack when there are more that 2 passes between CH's will take to him dribbling out of his own box like he does in show reel :faf:

[Daniel 1875]

Looks like an exciting signing. It’ll be interesting to see where he fits in across the front line - I wonder if the paperwork will come through in time for the weekend and/or Wednesday night.

[hibsbollah]

could be a cracking - loan - signing... or could end up with him and Ellie busting out a stepover / tricks contest :greengrin...

I wonder how the nervous in our support who have a heart attack when there are more that 2 passes between CH's will take to him dribbling out of his own box like he does in show reel :faf:

Let’s play him at sweeper. Theres a guy behind me who is ready to burst an artery at ‘pishing aboot at the back’ instead of punting it upfield like Scottish teams are supposed tae dae, just need this boy to push him over the edge.

[Nicho87]

Genuianly reminds me of watching youans videos when he signed.

Looks a carbon copy type player

Wonder if he will try Youan through the middle as this guy looks like he is a winger in all the clips

[Up-the-slope]

Let’s play him at sweeper. Theres a guy behind me who is ready to burst an artery at ‘pishing aboot at the back’ instead of punting it upfield like Scottish teams are supposed tae dae, just need this boy to push him over the edge.

:aok: exactly lets do that .... maybe you should invest in an umbrella first as defence against the red 'rain' :devil:

[Basildon Hibs]

Does he come across well in interviews...? 🤣��

[Hibrandenburg]

Any Hertha fans on here that's seen him play?

German 3rd division with only 10 starts and 3 goals. Transfermarkt.de describing the move as "Hertha being finally able to offload" doesn't really get me excited. But who knows, maybe he'll do well at this level.

[Torto7]

Genuianly reminds me of watching youans videos when he signed.

Looks a carbon copy type player

Wonder if he will try Youan through the middle as this guy looks like he is a winger in all the clips

Really? I thought Youan lacked technique in his videos but this guys technique is excellent.

[1875Sean]

German 3rd division with only 10 starts and 3 goals. Transfermarkt.de describing the move as "Hertha being finally able to offload" doesn't really get me excited. But who knows, maybe he'll do well at this level.

2nd division not 3rd?

[Forza Fred]

Let’s play him at sweeper. Theres a guy behind me who is ready to burst an artery at ‘pishing aboot at the back’ instead of punting it upfield like Scottish teams are supposed tae dae, just need this boy to push him over the edge.

:greengrin

[Musselbound]

2nd division not 3rd?

Been playing with Hertha reserves in the German 4th division according to BBC.

According to Monty he can play centrally or wide. Not a criticism of the player as I know nothing about him but with Boyle, Youan and Jair I just don't understand why this type of player is seen as a priority.

[Rumble de Thump]

Been playing with Hertha reserves in the German 4th division according to BBC.

According to Monty he can play centrally or wide. Not a criticism of the player as I know nothing about him but with Boyle, Youan and Jair I just don't understand why this type of player is seen as a priority.

Youan and Tavares started for us in our last match. We had no fully fit senior players as replacements for them on the bench. Boyle is in Qatar.

[Centre Hawf]

Been playing with Hertha reserves in the German 4th division according to BBC.

According to Monty he can play centrally or wide. Not a criticism of the player as I know nothing about him but with Boyle, Youan and Jair I just don't understand why this type of player is seen as a priority.

If we wanted him and others were sniffing then there was no point waiting until we signed a midfielder or defender to get him.

[KWJ]

Some pedigree as said.

Looked him up on my FM save and he went to Hertha for £3.4m after going to Nice for £8.75m.

Has him down as rapid, strong, agile, good first touch and great dribbler. Not great at heading despite being 6". Poor tackler and marking but that's not what we're after.

Very exciting even for a loan.

[Zazu62]

https://www.dailyrecord.co.uk/sport/football/football-transfer-news/new-hibs-signing-myziane-maolida-31915958#google_vignette

[neil7908]

https://www.dailyrecord.co.uk/sport/football/football-transfer-news/new-hibs-signing-myziane-maolida-31915958#google_vignette

Him and Youan potentially in the same team? We'll have to win 5-4 I guess 😂😂😂

[cubehindthegoal]

could be a cracking - loan - signing... or could end up with him and Ellie busting out a stepover / tricks contest :greengrin...

I wonder how the nervous in our support who have a heart attack when there are more that 2 passes between CH's will take to him dribbling out of his own box like he does in show reel :faf:

😂 I think the past week has been encouraging .. no lazy desperate decisions on signing players (whether on loan or buying) because they are Brazilian or from Leeds … our manager doesn’t just sit and say “yeh he sounds fine” .. he checks them out as thoroughly as possible … and when he chooses quicker, he has good reason .. which I think this loan merits. But if it doesn’t work out … hey we move on in six months. Like your work, Monty 👍

[cubehindthegoal]

Him and Youan potentially in the same team? We'll have to win 5-4 I guess 😂😂😂

😂

Good !

[cubehindthegoal]

Been playing with Hertha reserves in the German 4th division according to BBC.

According to Monty he can play centrally or wide. Not a criticism of the player as I know nothing about him but with Boyle, Youan and Jair I just don't understand why this type of player is seen as a priority.

😂 2nd ?? 3rd ?? I see the BBCs 4th, and raise you 8th Division. Seriously though .. I’m sure there are a few players in the German lower leagues and reserves that will be playing in future World Cup Finals.

This isn’t a huge risk for a 6 month loan, and won’t stop other signings coming in if and where he can find the quality needed. If he can’t … I’m happy to wait until the summer.

I know … some aren’t … hopefully the club are more patient 🙄

[King Cosell]

I just noticed he scored against Smelltic for Lyon in a 4 nil win.

Pre-season friendly. Highlights on YouTube, scores the second on 61 mins and it's wonder goal. Amazing.

[cubehindthegoal]

German 3rd division with only 10 starts and 3 goals. Transfermarkt.de describing the move as "Hertha being finally able to offload" doesn't really get me excited. But who knows, maybe he'll do well at this level.

The manager of Hertha Berlin ripped him a bit on leaving … funny though part of that was saying, “He scored goals because he was fit.”

So sour grapes might be playing a part here too ?

[Callum_62]

https://www.dailyrecord.co.uk/sport/football/football-transfer-news/new-hibs-signing-myziane-maolida-31915958#google_vignetteLove it

Does well doesn't sound like Hertha will be difficult to deal with when we try and sign him permanently [emoji1787]

Sent from my Pixel 7 Pro using Tapatalk

[King Cosell]

Love it

Does well doesn't sound like Hertha will be difficult to deal with when we try and sign him permanently [emoji1787]

Sent from my Pixel 7 Pro using Tapatalk

Wages might be a problem, 18 months left on his contract, reportedly on 15k a week. We're probably about a third of that.

[HoboHarry]

It's a bit mind boggling that his English is as good as it is. Didn't grow up speaking English and never played in an English speaking country. Kind of makes us 1st language English lot look a little bit silly.

[stokesmessiah]

It's a bit mind boggling that his English is as good as it is. Didn't grow up speaking English and never played in an English speaking country. Kind of makes us 1st language English lot look a little bit silly.

I am just travelling back from CZ where I was doing some management training. The were Czech people, Italians and Dutch people in the room….i was the only native English speaker and before every session there was a disclaimer to let them know if they couldn’t understand my English ha ha

[Hibrandenburg]

2nd division not 3rd?

4th actually. He's been getting the occasional game for Hertha II in the Regionalliga.

[Hibrandenburg]

The manager of Hertha Berlin ripped him a bit on leaving … funny though part of that was saying, “He scored goals because he was fit.”

So sour grapes might be playing a part here too ?

No idea. Although I live in Berlin I've never been able to warm to Hertha. Just know my WhatsApp is getting battered from mates taking the piss. Hope I have the last laugh.

[Hibernian Verse]

4th actually. He's been getting the occasional game for Hertha II in the Regionalliga.

Presumably not through ability but more his apparent laziness?

[Hibrandenburg]

Presumably not through ability but more his apparent laziness?

No idea, but for whatever reason he's been deemed not good enough to train or play for the first team and certainly didn't impress the Hertha fans that I know who go to games regularly. Doesn't mean he won't succeed here though.

[JasonC1875]

Scott Burns having a nightmare. This guy has some CV. Hopefully we have the right to buy?

Apparently no option to buy.

[Tambo]

Sounds promising, welcome to the Hibees.

[Gettin' Auld]

Some pedigree as said.

Looked him up on my FM save and he went to Hertha for £3.4m after going to Nice for £8.75m.

Has him down as rapid, strong, agile, good first touch and great dribbler. Not great at heading despite being 6". Poor tackler and marking but that's not what we're after.

Very exciting even for a loan.
If he's only 6 inches tall, i'm not surprised that heading isn't his strong point. :greengrin

[Percy Vere]

Been playing with Hertha reserves in the German 4th division according to BBC.

According to Monty he can play centrally or wide. Not a criticism of the player as I know nothing about him but with Boyle, Youan and Jair I just don't understand why this type of player is seen as a priority.

Sometimes you take quality where you find it. Gift horse and all that.
Can play through the middle, think there's been a lot of people wanting midfield playmaker. Fingers crossed

[AlbertK86]

https://www.dailyrecord.co.uk/sport/football/football-transfer-news/new-hibs-signing-myziane-maolida-31915958#google_vignette

Daily Rangers love any opportunity to dig Hibs out and paint players managers in a bad light especially after saying he was too expensive for us [emoji16]

If the bum cheek from the weedge had signed him there would have been a completely different spin


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[Alex Trager]

Daily Rangers love any opportunity to dig Hibs out and paint players managers in a bad light especially after saying he was too expensive for us [emoji16]

If the bum cheek from the weedge had signed him there would have been a completely different spin


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

Tbf, I think it’s fair to pull these comments up.

I see what you are saying re the record. Scott Burns (though not this article’s author) will be licking his wounds re this one.

I am not sure about this guy, I dono what it is, perhaps because I feel like it’s not really an area I see as being paramount we address.

He certainly has had a lot of hype around him, so I am hopeful that he comes in and tears it up.

Monty seems the type to get these kinds of players working better so hopefully this is another one of these situations.

[He's here!]

Tbf, I think it’s fair to pull these comments up.

I see what you are saying re the record. Scott Burns (though not this article’s author) will be licking his wounds re this one.

I am not sure about this guy, I dono what it is, perhaps because I feel like it’s not really an area I see as being paramount we address.

He certainly has had a lot of hype around him, so I am hopeful that he comes in and tears it up.

Monty seems the type to get these kinds of players working better so hopefully this is another one of these situations.

Who is Scott Burns?

[GreenCastle]

No idea, but for whatever reason he's been deemed not good enough to train or play for the first team and certainly didn't impress the Hertha fans that I know who go to games regularly. Doesn't mean he won't succeed here though.

It seems he didn’t get on with the manager - who thinks he’s lazy plus he was causing some other issues within Hertha according to Hertha fans.

As always I’m sure there will be various different stories and opinions.

Let’s just hope he turns up focused and does well in 6 months.

Think it will depend on where Hibs play him (assume on the left ? Jair as impact sub?) and what supply midfield gives him..(that’s an issue). Bigger issue is us stop losing goals with better defending.

Having a friend / French speaking colleague will hopefully help Youan too.

[JimBHibees]

Who is Scott Burns?

Think DR journo who frequently gets Hibs stuff wrong

[Alex Trager]

Who is Scott Burns?

The Journo who hates hibs. In fact, that’s Ewan Murray the golf guy I am thinking of.

SB could tell you Hibs play at Easter Road, and you could fairly confidently put money on Hibs not playing in Edinburgh if he had said that.

He is constantly wrong about us.

Said he was out of our price range on twitter.

Swiftly deleted tweet last night though.

[147lothian]

The loan system works well when we bring in players we otherwise couldn't afford, I know we already have Boyle, Youan and Jair, but there will still be a role for him, even if it starts with coming off the bench it will put pressure on the said three to up there game to keep the shirt, I still think we need creativity in the middle of the park and IMO Monty has identified this by bringing him in, I don't know anything about him but I'm excited to see him play.

[wookie70]

Just spotted the Israel International St Johnstone signed got his clearance. He was announced on 9 January

[Aldo]

The Journo who hates hibs. In fact, that’s Ewan Murray the golf guy I am thinking of.

SB could tell you Hibs play at Easter Road, and you could fairly confidently put money on Hibs not playing in Edinburgh if he had said that.

He is constantly wrong about us.

Said he was out of our price range on twitter.

Swiftly deleted tweet last night though.

Definitely does. He loves a negative Hibs story and regularly printed that Hibs were chasing a player (when we weren’t) so he could headline….. Aberdeen beat Hibs or Hearts beat Hibs to transfer target!

[Alex Trager]

Definitely does. He loves a negative Hibs story and regularly printed that Hibs were chasing a player (when we weren’t) so he could headline….. Aberdeen beat Hibs or Hearts beat Hibs to transfer target!

Aye that’s right.

That’s where my understanding of him as a Hibs hater comes from.

[Aldo]

Aye that’s right.

That’s where my understanding of him as a Hibs hater comes from.

Mine too. Took over the mantle from Jackson.

[matty_f]

Who is Scott Burns?

I never trust anyone whose name can be a true or false question.

[headshrinker]

https://www.dailyrecord.co.uk/sport/football/football-transfer-news/new-hibs-signing-myziane-maolida-31915958#google_vignette

Sounds to me a bit like Johnson with Jair! Cutting his nose off to spite his face.

[Brightside]

The Journo who hates hibs. In fact, that’s Ewan Murray the golf guy I am thinking of.

SB could tell you Hibs play at Easter Road, and you could fairly confidently put money on Hibs not playing in Edinburgh if he had said that.

He is constantly wrong about us.

Said he was out of our price range on twitter.

Swiftly deleted tweet last night though.

Just ignore pretty much any journo now. You’ll get more info on here than any paper

[RIP]

Wonder if he will try Youan through the middle as this guy looks like he is a winger in all the clips

Elie has proven time and time again that he can get goals when he receives the ball within 25 yards of the goalline. He's wasted out on the touchline or picking up the ball on the halfway line.

He came to the club as a 9 and never deserved being punted out to the wings.

[KWJ]

Elie has proven time and time again that he can get goals when he receives the ball within 25 yards of the goalline. He's wasted out on the touchline or picking up the ball on the halfway line.

He came to the club as a 9 and never deserved being punted out to the wings.

Disagree with the being wide but agree about half way line
. Problem when he plays wide, recently anyway, is that he runs inside too deep and into danger. He'd be better holding his width and coming in nearer the box as well as getting onto things at back post.

[KWJ]

If he's only 6 inches tall, i'm not surprised that heading isn't his strong point. :greengrin

Good spot! 😂

[RIP]

Disagree with the being wide but agree about half way line
. Problem when he plays wide, recently anyway, is that he runs inside too deep and into danger. He'd be better holding his width and coming in nearer the box as well as getting onto things at back post.

I think these faults arise because:-

1. Elie's not a natural winger.
2. As we see repeatedly, when crosses are played into the box, there's never anyone on the end of them.
3. He looks for other attackers to play a 1-2 with, but because of our shape, we never have enough players forward and central

[He's here!]

Just spotted the Israel International St Johnstone signed got his clearance. He was announced on 9 January


Had we been linked with him?

[KWJ]

I think these faults arise because:-

1. Elie's not a natural winger.
2. As we see repeatedly, when crosses are played into the box, there's never anyone on the end of them.
3. He looks for other attackers to play a 1-2 with, but because of our shape, we never have enough players forward and central

Hmm. I don't think we've really seen enough of him up top to know for sure. I'd certainly rather play him there than Boyle going by recent games.

[Dashing Bob S]

Everything about this suggests he’s quality, but also a nutter/boy who has lost his way. Unfortunately, as we know, you have to take a punt on a rehab case if you want that genuine quality. I’ll be delighted if he’s got class and turns it on for us. I’m sick of clogging up our roster with journeymen who can ‘do a job’. Leave the 33 year old Greg Stewart’s to the Killies of this world

[Callum_62]

Get the badge in!https://uploads.tapatalk-cdn.com/20240119/6d022704631a2f6d1ad216f62d6c0565.jpg

Sent from my Pixel 7 Pro using Tapatalk

[Rumble de Thump]

Is it true that the Hertha Berlin manager is a regular subscriber to Lee Johnson's man management webinars?

[Saint Hibee]

Everything about this suggests he’s quality, but also a nutter/boy who has lost his way. Unfortunately, as we know, you have to take a punt on a rehab case if you want that genuine quality. I’ll be delighted if he’s got class and turns it on for us. I’m sick of clogging up our roster with journeymen who can ‘do a job’. Leave the 33 year old Greg Stewart’s to the Killies of this world

100% agreed. He might be amazing or he might be a complete disaster, but he doesn't seem like the kind of guy to bore us to death with endless sideways passes.

[cubehindthegoal]

If he's only 6 inches tall, i'm not surprised that heading isn't his strong point. :greengrin

… though he might have an advantage for diving headers 😉

[Baader]

Mine too. Took over the mantle from Jackson.
Current Buns who can't take their spite out on Celtic as its too risky and they need to live in Glasgow so just transfer it to Hibs instead...

[Stubbsy90+2]

Everything about this suggests he’s quality, but also a nutter/boy who has lost his way. Unfortunately, as we know, you have to take a punt on a rehab case if you want that genuine quality. I’ll be delighted if he’s got class and turns it on for us. I’m sick of clogging up our roster with journeymen who can ‘do a job’. Leave the 33 year old Greg Stewart’s to the Killies of this world

The thought of us ever signing 33 yo Greg Stewart is thoroughly depressing. Much rather see us attempt something like this.

[Aldo]

Current Buns who can't take their spite out on Celtic as its too risky and they need to live in Glasgow so just transfer it to Hibs instead...

Something like that.

[ruthven_raiders]

Elie has proven time and time again that he can get goals when he receives the ball within 25 yards of the goalline. He's wasted out on the touchline or picking up the ball on the halfway line.

He came to the club as a 9 and never deserved being punted out to the wings.

Exactly this, he is too hot and cold out wide, but ball breaks to him in box, bang ball is in the net, aka tynecastle Derby 💚

[scm70nyd1973]

Good spot! 😂

Highly impressive - GA notes a short arse and KWJ spots a pluke 🤭😂

I’m off to get ma coat 🫢

[Hibees1973]

When he was at Lyon he played 13 games in the first team and scored 1 goal.

Nice then bought him for 10M euros.

Does his form at Lyon really merit a transfer fee like that, then Nice insert a 100M euro release clause. He played 52 games for Nice over 3 seasons and scored 4 goals. Some teams really have money to burn.

Could be a gem for our level, who knows.

A loan signing and little risk to us, as long as there are no clauses we overlook.

[JimBHibees]

Current Buns who can't take their spite out on Celtic as its too risky and they need to live in Glasgow so just transfer it to Hibs instead...

Especially post 2016 and their campaign to catch all pitch offending Hibs fans while obviously the vast majority of ex Rangers news journos bitter we won anyway. :greengrin

[flash]

When he was at Lyon he played 13 games in the first team and scored 1 goal.

Nice then bought him for 10M euros.

Does his form at Lyon really merit a transfer fee like that, then Nice insert a 100M euro release clause. He played 52 games for Nice over 3 seasons and scored 4 goals. Some teams really have money to burn.

Could be a gem for our level, who knows.

A loan signing and little risk to us, as long as there are no clauses we overlook.

Strangely negative way of looking at an exciting signing.

[JimBHibees]

Strangely negative way of looking at an exciting signing.

Yes I think it is fair to say we are not at the level of top French teams. Must be draining that everything the club does is analysed from such a negative lens.

[WhileTheChief..]

Strangely negative way of looking at an exciting signing.

Those pesky stats getting in the way again :greengrin

[flash]

Those pesky stats getting in the way again :greengrin

You know what I mean.

[Not In The Know]

When he was at Lyon he played 13 games in the first team and scored 1 goal.

Nice then bought him for 10M euros.

Does his form at Lyon really merit a transfer fee like that, then Nice insert a 100M euro release clause. He played 52 games for Nice over 3 seasons and scored 4 goals. Some teams really have money to burn.

Could be a gem for our level, who knows.

A loan signing and little risk to us, as long as there are no clauses we overlook.


Peak Hibs net. We aren’t even excited about getting a 10million pound striker. 😔

[Jones28]

When he was at Lyon he played 13 games in the first team and scored 1 goal.

Nice then bought him for 10M euros.

Does his form at Lyon really merit a transfer fee like that, then Nice insert a 100M euro release clause. He played 52 games for Nice over 3 seasons and scored 4 goals. Some teams really have money to burn.

Could be a gem for our level, who knows.

A loan signing and little risk to us, as long as there are no clauses we overlook.

Do you find anything Hibs do exciting or positive?

[TheGreenMan]

I never trust anyone whose name can be a true or false question.

😂

[Hibees1973]

Do you find anything Hibs do exciting or positive?

Yes, when it is appropriate to get excited and positive.

The guy has been playing his football most recently in the German Bundesliga 4th tier.

Can judge when we see how he gets on in Forfar and once he makes a few appearances.

[Torto7]

Get the badge in!https://uploads.tapatalk-cdn.com/20240119/6d022704631a2f6d1ad216f62d6c0565.jpg

Sent from my Pixel 7 Pro using Tapatalk

Nice Cargo's tbf.

[A Hi-Bee]

Yes, when it is appropriate to get excited and positive.

The guy has been playing his football most recently in the German Bundesliga 4th tier.

Can judge when we see how he gets on in Forfar and once he makes a few appearances.

Who are you to judge? have an opinion by all means and we all have that, but judge..... He will not even be playing until he gets international clearance and you think you are in a position to judge, I leave that with the people who pick the team. e10mill player dont care if he has been playing down the Links this kind of signing is positive and in my humble a potentially exiting signing, more so than anything the manky mob from gorgie have signed!!!!!

[SChibs]

Can see this from Hertha's point of view. Hope he bags 10 goals and 5 assists then they try recoup some of the £m's they paid for him. If they can't they maybe give him a second chance

[7Hero]

Peak Hibs net. We aren’t even excited about getting a 10million pound striker. 😔

But he's not a £10 million pound signing.

[7Hero]

Who are you to judge? have an opinion by all means and we all have that, but judge..... He will not even be playing until he gets international clearance and you think you are in a position to judge, I leave that with the people who pick the team. e10mill player dont care if he has been playing down the Links this kind of signing is positive and in my humble a potentially exiting signing, more so than anything the manky mob from gorgie have signed!!!!!

Anybody can judge..

[CentreForward]

He’s not a striker,, His goal scoring record is abysmal.

[Greenbeard]

Who are you to judge? have an opinion by all means and we all have that, but judge..... He will not even be playing until he gets international clearance and you think you are in a position to judge, I leave that with the people who pick the team. e10mill player dont care if he has been playing down the Links this kind of signing is positive and in my humble a potentially exiting signing, more so than anything the manky mob from gorgie have signed!!!!!
Nee-naw, nee-naw. Here come the semantics polis.
My view is that we are all currently expressing an opinion on the guy's merits and whether or not he is a good signing because we don't have any objective evidence of how he is going to play at Hibs. After he has played a few games and settled in and we have such evidence, we can give reasons for our opinion (which might have changed) and therefore make our own personal judgement.
Doppler nee-naw, nee-naw.......

[Hibees1973]

Who are you to judge? have an opinion by all means and we all have that, but judge..... He will not even be playing until he gets international clearance and you think you are in a position to judge, I leave that with the people who pick the team. e10mill player dont care if he has been playing down the Links this kind of signing is positive and in my humble a potentially exiting signing, more so than anything the manky mob from gorgie have signed!!!!!

Pftt, have you missed the bus to Forfar?

The meaning of judge is:

'form an opinion or conclusion about'

As far as I'm aware we are all allowed to do this on hibs.net

Hope you get to Forfar on time.

[blackpoolhibs]

I will judge him when i see him play, not a minute before.

[greenlex]

Pftt, have you missed the bus to Forfar?

The meaning of judge is:

'form an opinion or conclusion about'

As far as I'm aware we are all allowed to do this on hibs.net

Hope you get to Forfar on time.






so go on. Tell us how you’ve formed your opinion? :rolleyes:

[Hibees1973]

so go on. Tell us how you’ve formed your opinion? :rolleyes:

It gets a bit tiresome when some posters don't read in full what others have said.

My previous comment was :

'Can judge when we see how he gets on in Forfar and once he makes a few appearances'

At no point have I said I will judge or form an opinion before even seeing him in a Hibs jersey.

Hope this is clear. I can't really spell it out more than this.

[brydekirk]

After watching the videos, if he applies himself 100% he will light up the SPL.

[Irish_Steve]

Nee-naw, nee-naw. Here come the semantics polis.
My view is that we are all currently expressing an opinion on the guy's merits and whether or not he is a good signing because we don't have any objective evidence of how he is going to play at Hibs. After he has played a few games and settled in and we have such evidence, we can give reasons for our opinion (which might have changed) and therefore make our own personal judgement.
Doppler nee-naw, nee-naw.......

This made me laugh way more than it should have :greengrin:greengrin:greengrin

[greenlex]

It gets a bit tiresome when some posters don't read in full what others have said.

My previous comment was :

'Can judge when we see how he gets on in Forfar and once he makes a few appearances'

At no point have I said I will judge or form an opinion before even seeing him in a Hibs jersey.

Hope this is clear. I can't really spell it out more than this.


To quote you from the first part of the post.

“ When he was at Lyon he played 13 games in the first team and scored 1 goal.

Nice then bought him for 10M euros.

Does his form at Lyon really merit a transfer fee like that, then Nice insert a 100M euro release clause. He played 52 games for Nice over 3 seasons and scored 4 goals. Some teams really have money to burn.”

The very epitome of judgement. You’ve already formed an opinion. Tiresome indeed.

[TrinityHFC]

It gets a bit tiresome when some posters don't read in full what others have said.

My previous comment was :

'Can judge when we see how he gets on in Forfar and once he makes a few appearances'

At no point have I said I will judge or form an opinion before even seeing him in a Hibs jersey.

Hope this is clear. I can't really spell it out more than this.

He’s not going to be available to play at Forfar.

[Hibees1973]

To quote you from the first part of the post.

“ When he was at Lyon he played 13 games in the first team and scored 1 goal.

Nice then bought him for 10M euros.

Does his form at Lyon really merit a transfer fee like that, then Nice insert a 100M euro release clause. He played 52 games for Nice over 3 seasons and scored 4 goals. Some teams really have money to burn.”

The very epitome of judgement. You’ve already formed an opinion. Tiresome indeed.


And to quote the second part of my post, which you conveniently omitted.

'Could be a gem for our level, who knows.

A loan signing and little risk to us, as long as there are no clauses we overlook.'

A master of lazy editing you are greenlex.

[greenlex]

And to quote the second part of my post, which you conveniently omitted.

'Could be a gem for our level, who knows.

A loan signing and little risk to us, as long as there are no clauses we overlook.'

A master of lazy editing you are greenlex.

Pot and kettle mate. There’s nothing lazy about it. You conveniently ommitted the first part that I was merely highlighting. You have formed an opinion by posting that and the quotes at the end are you wanting to have it changed. But you crack on and have the last word.

[basehibby]

WELCOME MYZIANE!

This has the potential to be a great loan move for all parties.
It's plain that Myziane has not hit the ground running at Hertha Berlin but, hopefully he will be busting a gut to make a point - particularly with the bizzare rantings of his former coach at HB ringing in his ears.
His path so far in football indicates there is certainly a quality player in there - hopefully Hibs is the team where this is proven definitively.

[hibsbollah]

But he's not a £10 million pound signing.

This must be the most pointless contribution i have ever read on here :faf:

If Hibs had spent £10 million on any player, they would have borrowed against the club, with money we dont have, and we all KNOW this hasn’t happened. Nobody wants us to spend £10 million on a player. Hes a player that has been considered as worth that sort of money in the past. Obviously he hasnt reached the level he was expected of him yet, but…

We’re entitled to be a bit excited about the possibilities, if we want to be. Or we can sit in front of our pc and be miserable and tornfaced.

[Hibrandenburg]

This must be the most pointless contribution i have ever read on here :faf:

If Hibs had spent £10 million on any player, they would have borrowed against the club, with money we dont have, and we all KNOW this hasn’t happened. Nobody wants us to spend £10 million on a player. Hes a player that has been considered as worth that sort of money in the past. Obviously he hasnt reached the level he was expected of him yet, but…

We’re entitled to be a bit excited about the possibilities, if we want to be. Or we can sit in front of our pc and be miserable and tornfaced.

Are you new to Hibs Net?

[hibsbollah]

Are you new to Hibs Net?

Yep. Seems like a friendly vibe. I might hang around for a bit :greengrin

[jakeshibs]

Anyone know how long it will take to get international clearance to play

[CapitalGreen]

Anyone know how long it will take to get international clearance to play

Monty said post match he’s hopeful he’ll be available for Wednesday night.

[jacomo]

Yep. Seems like a friendly vibe. I might hang around for a bit :greengrin


:faf:

[Exuberance1875]

I thought he was going to be playing today? Was it red tape? Perhaps I am wrong

[brydekirk]

Anyone know how long it will take to get international clearance to play

Should be done quickly as he has international caps.

[California-Hibs]

Didn't Montgomery reference that he'd be available for selection on Wednesday?

[JimBHibees]

Didn't Montgomery reference that he'd be available for selection on Wednesday?

Think it may have been hope he is available

[jakeshibs]

Monty said post match he’s hopeful he’ll be available for Wednesday night.

Thank you most kindly as high hopes