Fish

[Hibbyradge]

Everyone was desperate for him to re-sign for us and we were delighted when he did, but that's twice he's cost us, arguably 3 times.

Hearts last season, again today and being slow back last week was part of our downfall.

Very, very disappointing.

[Willis1875]

Not returned the same player as we had the second half of last season so far

[Unseen work]

Not been good since he’s came back; but none of the defensive side of the team has.

Still a good player though they will come good

[Smartie]

Everyone was desperate for him to re-sign for us and we were delighted when he did, but that's twice he's cost us, arguably 3 times.

Hearts last season, again today and being slow back last week was part of our downfall.

Very, very disappointing.

He was immense second half of last season but he needs to give himself a shake - what we’ve had from him so far this season has been nowhere near good enough.

We’ve got other scapegoats who we tend to go more readily on days like today but he needs to buckle his ideas up, especially with Harbottle looking like a ready made replacement in reserve.

Funny though that we seemed to look solid with the pairing of Hanlon and Fish with Jeggo protecting last season - a combination we’re yet to see this season. I’m not mad on a Jeggo type in front of a 3 or a pair with no defensive protection.

[Hibbyradge]

He was immense second half of last season but he needs to give himself a shake - what we’ve had from him so far this season has been nowhere near good enough.

We’ve got other scapegoats who we tend to go more readily on days like today but he needs to buckle his ideas up, especially with Harbottle looking like a ready made replacement in reserve.

Funny though that we seemed to look solid with the pairing of Hanlon and Fish with Jeggo protecting last season and looked solid - a combination we’re yet to see this season. I’m not mad on a Jeggo type in front of a 3 or a pair with no defensive protection.

I certainly don't want to scapegoat him, but if Hanlon or Rocky had made the same mistake today, they'd be getting it tight. (In fact, Hanlon is getting grief and he played well!)

Hopefully he'll find last season's form soon and we'll reap the benefits.

[Northernhibee]

Clearly hasn't had enough instruction for what to do on the pitch, but if he finds himself lost in Edinburgh Zoo he's quids in.

[Centre Hawf]

I certainly don't want to scapegoat him, but if Hanlon or Rocky had made the same mistake today, they'd be getting it tight. (In fact, Hanlon is getting grief and he played well!)

Hopefully he'll find last season's form soon and we'll reap the benefits.

If Rocky gifted that second goal like Will Fish did today we'd be seeing it on all the banter pages on Twitter.

[J-C]

Was he not supposed to be pretty poor on loan at Stockport prior to us and it did take him a while to settle into the team after a few iffy games, maybe this is his level like Rocky, bang average with the odd bad game in him.

[Bridge hibs]

Was he not supposed to be pretty poor on loan at Stockport prior to us and it did take him a while to settle into the team after a few iffy games, maybe this is his level like Rocky, bang average with the odd bad game in him.Bang average but highly rated by Man utd ?

[J-C]

Bang average but highly rated by Man utd ?


Thing is he didn't have a good loan at Stockpost and eventually found his feet here, he seems a completely different players to the one that finished last season.

[Bridge hibs]

Thing is he didn't have a good loan at Stockpost and eventually found his feet here, he seems a completely different players to the one that finished last season.Maybe just a confidence issue, he just doesnt turn into a bad player overnight

https://www.thesun.co.uk/sport/14656937/man-utd-will-fish-europa-league/amp/

[B.H.F.C]

Not had a good start since he came back. I thought he was poor for the St Mirren winner, poor for the equaliser on Thursday, and obviously poor for the goal today.

I thought he was very good latter part of last season. Needs to find his form again quickly.

[Alfred E Newman]

If Rocky gifted that second goal like Will Fish did today we'd be seeing it on all the banter pages on Twitter.

I’ve just seen the highlights and in Fish’s defence, he was clearly pushed in the back which threw him off balance.
Perhaps it’s because the Hibs players didn’t shout for it but I’m surprised VAR didn’t pick that up, or maybe I’m not.

[LaMotta]

I’ve just seen the highlights and in Fish’s defence, he was clearly pushed in the back which threw him off balance.
Perhaps it’s because the Hibs players didn’t shout for it but I’m surprised VAR didn’t pick that up, or maybe I’m not.

It looks like a blatant push on first viewing, but from the replays less so. As you say, No Hibs player appealed for a foul which makes me think there wasn't much of a push. If there was then Fish should have been going mental at the ref which may have triggered Var to check it.