PDA

View Full Version : This is how it feels (Livingston 04 03 23)



Jonnyboy
04-03-2023, 07:35 PM
A large and very vocal Hibs support turned out in their numbers to roar the team to an entertaining and deserved 4-1 win against a Livingston side that had taken the lead but couldn’t deal with a visiting side that caused them untold problems at the back. My brother and I had seats right next to Block 7 and although they were cramming into the stairways and bundling into us in the mayhem following the first two goals I still think they were amazing from start to finish, and even after the final whistle when the singing continued as the players came across to join in the celebrations.

In McGeady’s absence due to injury, Matthew Hoppe was drafted in to an otherwise unchanged line up. Included amongst the subs were the returning Nisbet and Kuharevich together with Mikey Devlin.

Following an impeccably observed minute of silence to mark the passing of Ron Gordon, Livi started the stronger and it was immediately obvious that Cabraja would have to deal with the threat of Joel Nouble who got in early to set a chance up for Nicky Devlin but the Livi full back had his shot charged down. A similar fate was the outcome of a Montero shot before Hibs crafted their first effort when Hanlon’s shot following a corner was easily saved by Shamal George in the Livi goal.

The hosts had decided they’d get some mileage from playing the ball over the top and in behind our back four and that ploy worked to good effect in the tenth minute when the impressive Morgan Boyes picked out Nouble. The big striker tied Cabraja in knots, strode into the penalty area and smashed a shot high into David Marshall’s net from a difficult angle. Nouble has been described on here at times as a ‘big huddy’ but I’ll tell you what he’s almost impossibly hard to take the ball off and he made his quick feet and body weight create the opportunity for the goal.

It took Hibs a wee while to recover from that blow as Livi continued with their high ball plan but thankfully Fish and Hanlon were up to the challenge whilst Cadden and Cabraja got help from our sitting midfielders of Jeggo and Egan-Riley. To be fair, Hibs continued to play through the thirds and on a couple of occasions were frustrated when Elie Youan lost possession by trying to be a bit too clever. Henderson came close after good work by Hoppe created a shooting chance but Ewan’s effort hit the top of the bar and flew over.

Some around me were giving Youan pelters but as the half hour mark approached, Will Fish fired a ball into space for Youan who ran in on goal and stroked the ball past the advancing George to level things up. Things were a tad physical at times but referee Chris Graham allowed the game to flow and if a player went down too easily he wasn’t being conned into awarding free kicks. At times, Livi were getting into decent positions but failed to really trouble David Marshall whilst at the other end just eight minutes after his first, Elie Youan worked a clever one-two with Matthew Hoppe before sclaffing a left footed shot into the far corner of the net from about ten yards.

In the midfield battle, Jason Holt and CJ Egan-Riley were in constant opposition and I’m not exaggerating when I say CJ won that duel handsomely, ensuring the Livi man trooped off at half time with his head well down.

Neither manager made changes at half time and Hibs started the half on the front foot. Just a few minutes in, a sublime ball from Ewan Henderson set Hoppe free to run in on goal but the big striker never looked totally in control of a bobbling ball and got too close to George before getting a shot away and that allowed the keeper to make a save. Less than five minutes later, Hoppe was again put through the middle but was fouled by Jack Fitzwater as he made to shoot and referee Chris Graham instantly produced a red card to reduce Livi to ten men. There was a bit of confusion when Graham placed the ball for the resultant free kick because it was a good ten yards from where the offence was committed. A clear and obvious error, corrected by the VAR official – I know, incredible wasn’t it given our recent record in VAR, or lack of, decisions! Eventually, Cabraja took the free kick, but his shot hit the wall, felling Morgan Boyes in the process.

On the hour mark there was an astonishing coming together of players on the shy line in front of the stand. Lots of jostling and the matter finally settled when the ref booked Montano who, I would guess was carded not for anything physical, more the fact that he launched a verbal tirade at the referee. Just a minute later, Hibs broke from defence when Youan played the ball out to Cadden on the right and with the Livi players straining to get back, Cadden looked up and tried to pick out the unmarked Youan for his hat trick. Instead, the retreating Omeonga stuck out a leg and diverted the ball past a stranded Shamal George.

There was still thirty minutes to play and in a commanding position, Hibs spent time retaining possession and trying to break when the chance arose and on one such occasion, the ball fell to Will Fish but he was miles off balance when he fired the ball high over the bar. With a two goal lead and a man advantage, Lee Johnson decided to bring Nisbet and Kuharevich on in place of Hoppe and Henderson with Livi making changes too in replacing Anderson, Pittman and Montano with Shinnie, Penrice and Bahamboula.

Referee Chris Graham was becoming a busy man as he flashed a few yellow cards with CJ Egan-Riley amongst those punished when he caught Obileye in a rash challenge as he stretched to try and retain possession of the ball. The Livi man limped off and was replaced De Lucas who arrived just in time to see first Kuharevich and then Hanlon getting headers on target but failing to beat the keeper. Kevin Nisbet was then booked for a foul on Omeonga and minutes later the former Hibs man had to leave the field thereby reducing Livi to nine men as they’d used all their substitutes. Around the same time, Lewis Miller replaced Egan-Riley who left the field to warm applause from the Hibs fans.

Bizarrely, with just nine men, Livi had probably their best spell in the game in terms of possession although they couldn’t use that to pose any real threat to the Hibs goal. Jeggo then found his name in the book for a foul on Nicky Devlin and from the resultant free kick, Andrew Shinnie got a shot away but the effort flew wide. Moving in to added time, which was considerable following the numerous stoppages, Oscar MacIntyre came on to relace Youan and arrived in time to see a fourth goal for Hibs by Kuharevich after George couldn’t hold a Nisbet effort. The goal was initially ruled out for offside against Nisbet but it was clearly wrong and after a few minutes of deliberation from the VAR official the goal was correctly allowed to stand. In that little window of time as the players hailed the fans at full time, I’m pretty sure I saw a red card being flashed at someone on the Livi bench and have since been told it was David Martindale although I’m unsure why he was mumping or indeed what he was mumping about.

The players

Marshall – I was surprised the Nouble effort beat him but in fairness it was fiercely struck and was probably moving at a pace the keeper found difficult to deal with.

Cadden – Took a wee while to get going and was caught upfield a few times but overall it was a decent performance.

Fish – Another wonderful performance from this young man who dealt with pretty much everything that came his way. Wins my man of the match award.

Hanlon – I thought he failed to react quickly to help Cabraja at the Nouble goal but otherwise had a decent game.

Cabraja – Nouble gave him a torrid time early in the game but to be fair he eventually, with a bit of help, got to grips with the Livi striker.

Egan-Riley – Is a quality addition and looks so at home in a midfield holding role. Impressively, he wasn’t held back by having Jason Holt in his back pocket.

Jeggo – Gets about the pitch, closes down routes and generally looks like he’s played in Scottish football all his life.

Henderson – Once again I was delighted to see him putting himself about as well as finding time to stroke a fair few classy passes.

Campbell – I was tempted to say a quiet afternoon from him but as I think back I recall his endless energy, willingness to run with and without the ball and formed an acquaintance with every inch of that horrendous playing surface.

Youan – Infuriates and entertains in equal measure at times. His finishing for the first goal was faultless even if he did sclaff the second.

Hoppe – Worked really hard and though he should have scored in his first one-on-one he was back again moments later to force a challenge from a defender that brought a red card.

Nisbet – Great to see him back and hungry he was really unlucky a couple of times when he found space in the box only for the awaited cross to be headed clear.

Kuharevich – Such has his luck been in the past with goals ruled out I was delighted to see that today’s counted.

Miller – Looks fit again and slotted in seamlessly.

MacIntyre – Oscar didn’t get many minutes, but he’ll be delighted that he featured in a 4-1 win.

Lee Johnson – Chuffed for him and loved his celebration at the end in front of a bouncing B7.

Referee – Chris Graham is a new name to me and though he made a couple of puzzling decisions, I thought he had a decent game.

bordergreen
04-03-2023, 08:39 PM
I thought the game looked a bit like mates 5 a side game in the first half, with the ball bouncing around everywhere. That is probably down to their pitch though. Really good win for us today. Jeggo and Egan Riley are the difference in this team. I would love to take something against the knuckle draggers midweek. GGTTH!

GreenCastle
04-03-2023, 09:45 PM
Have we got more points this season than last season already?!

ancient hibee
04-03-2023, 09:56 PM
Good to see us playing in a more abrasive way. Same again on Wednesday please.

Baldy Foghorn
04-03-2023, 10:58 PM
A large and very vocal Hibs support turned out in their numbers to roar the team to an entertaining and deserved 4-1 win against a Livingston side that had taken the lead but couldn’t deal with a visiting side that caused them untold problems at the back. My brother and I had seats right next to Block 7 and although they were cramming into the stairways and bundling into us in the mayhem following the first two goals I still think they were amazing from start to finish, and even after the final whistle when the singing continued as the players came across to join in the celebrations.

In McGeady’s absence due to injury, Matthew Hoppe was drafted in to an otherwise unchanged line up. Included amongst the subs were the returning Nisbet and Kuharevich together with Mikey Devlin.

Following an impeccably observed minute of silence to mark the passing of Ron Gordon, Livi started the stronger and it was immediately obvious that Cabraja would have to deal with the threat of Joel Nouble who got in early to set a chance up for Nicky Devlin but the Livi full back had his shot charged down. A similar fate was the outcome of a Montero shot before Hibs crafted their first effort when Hanlon’s shot following a corner was easily saved by Shamal George in the Livi goal.

The hosts had decided they’d get some mileage from playing the ball over the top and in behind our back four and that ploy worked to good effect in the tenth minute when the impressive Morgan Boyes picked out Nouble. The big striker tied Cabraja in knots, strode into the penalty area and smashed a shot high into David Marshall’s net from a difficult angle. Nouble has been described on here at times as a ‘big huddy’ but I’ll tell you what he’s almost impossibly hard to take the ball off and he made his quick feet and body weight create the opportunity for the goal.

It took Hibs a wee while to recover from that blow as Livi continued with their high ball plan but thankfully Fish and Hanlon were up to the challenge whilst Cadden and Cabraja got help from our sitting midfielders of Jeggo and Egan-Riley. To be fair, Hibs continued to play through the thirds and on a couple of occasions were frustrated when Elie Youan lost possession by trying to be a bit too clever. Henderson came close after good work by Hoppe created a shooting chance but Ewan’s effort hit the top of the bar and flew over.

Some around me were giving Youan pelters but as the half hour mark approached, Will Fish fired a ball into space for Youan who ran in on goal and stroked the ball past the advancing George to level things up. Things were a tad physical at times but referee Chris Graham allowed the game to flow and if a player went down too easily he wasn’t being conned into awarding free kicks. At times, Livi were getting into decent positions but failed to really trouble David Marshall whilst at the other end just eight minutes after his first, Elie Youan worked a clever one-two with Matthew Hoppe before sclaffing a left footed shot into the far corner of the net from about ten yards.

In the midfield battle, Jason Holt and CJ Egan-Riley were in constant opposition and I’m not exaggerating when I say CJ won that duel handsomely, ensuring the Livi man trooped off at half time with his head well down.

Neither manager made changes at half time and Hibs started the half on the front foot. Just a few minutes in, a sublime ball from Ewan Henderson set Hoppe free to run in on goal but the big striker never looked totally in control of a bobbling ball and got too close to George before getting a shot away and that allowed the keeper to make a save. Less than five minutes later, Hoppe was again put through the middle but was fouled by Jack Fitzwater as he made to shoot and referee Chris Graham instantly produced a red card to reduce Livi to ten men. There was a bit of confusion when Graham placed the ball for the resultant free kick because it was a good ten yards from where the offence was committed. A clear and obvious error, corrected by the VAR official – I know, incredible wasn’t it given our recent record in VAR, or lack of, decisions! Eventually, Cabraja took the free kick, but his shot hit the wall, felling Morgan Boyes in the process.

On the hour mark there was an astonishing coming together of players on the shy line in front of the stand. Lots of jostling and the matter finally settled when the ref booked Montano who, I would guess was carded not for anything physical, more the fact that he launched a verbal tirade at the referee. Just a minute later, Hibs broke from defence when Youan played the ball out to Cadden on the right and with the Livi players straining to get back, Cadden looked up and tried to pick out the unmarked Youan for his hat trick. Instead, the retreating Omeonga stuck out a leg and diverted the ball past a stranded Shamal George.

There was still thirty minutes to play and in a commanding position, Hibs spent time retaining possession and trying to break when the chance arose and on one such occasion, the ball fell to Will Fish but he was miles off balance when he fired the ball high over the bar. With a two goal lead and a man advantage, Lee Johnson decided to bring Nisbet and Kuharevich on in place of Hoppe and Henderson with Livi making changes too in replacing Anderson, Pittman and Montano with Shinnie, Penrice and Bahamboula.

Referee Chris Graham was becoming a busy man as he flashed a few yellow cards with CJ Egan-Riley amongst those punished when he caught Obileye in a rash challenge as he stretched to try and retain possession of the ball. The Livi man limped off and was replaced De Lucas who arrived just in time to see first Kuharevich and then Hanlon getting headers on target but failing to beat the keeper. Kevin Nisbet was then booked for a foul on Omeonga and minutes later the former Hibs man had to leave the field thereby reducing Livi to nine men as they’d used all their substitutes. Around the same time, Lewis Miller replaced Egan-Riley who left the field to warm applause from the Hibs fans.

Bizarrely, with just nine men, Livi had probably their best spell in the game in terms of possession although they couldn’t use that to pose any real threat to the Hibs goal. Jeggo then found his name in the book for a foul on Nicky Devlin and from the resultant free kick, Andrew Shinnie got a shot away but the effort flew wide. Moving in to added time, which was considerable following the numerous stoppages, Oscar MacIntyre came on to relace Youan and arrived in time to see a fourth goal for Hibs by Kuharevich after George couldn’t hold a Nisbet effort. The goal was initially ruled out for offside against Nisbet but it was clearly wrong and after a few minutes of deliberation from the VAR official the goal was correctly allowed to stand. In that little window of time as the players hailed the fans at full time, I’m pretty sure I saw a red card being flashed at someone on the Livi bench and have since been told it was David Martindale although I’m unsure why he was mumping or indeed what he was mumping about.

The players

Marshall – I was surprised the Nouble effort beat him but in fairness it was fiercely struck and was probably moving at a pace the keeper found difficult to deal with.

Cadden – Took a wee while to get going and was caught upfield a few times but overall it was a decent performance.

Fish – Another wonderful performance from this young man who dealt with pretty much everything that came his way. Wins my man of the match award.

Hanlon – I thought he failed to react quickly to help Cabraja at the Nouble goal but otherwise had a decent game.

Cabraja – Nouble gave him a torrid time early in the game but to be fair he eventually, with a bit of help, got to grips with the Livi striker.

Egan-Riley – Is a quality addition and looks so at home in a midfield holding role. Impressively, he wasn’t held back by having Jason Holt in his back pocket.

Jeggo – Gets about the pitch, closes down routes and generally looks like he’s played in Scottish football all his life.

Henderson – Once again I was delighted to see him putting himself about as well as finding time to stroke a fair few classy passes.

Campbell – I was tempted to say a quiet afternoon from him but as I think back I recall his endless energy, willingness to run with and without the ball and formed an acquaintance with every inch of that horrendous playing surface.

Youan – Infuriates and entertains in equal measure at times. His finishing for the first goal was faultless even if he did sclaff the second.

Hoppe – Worked really hard and though he should have scored in his first one-on-one he was back again moments later to force a challenge from a defender that brought a red card.

Nisbet – Great to see him back and hungry he was really unlucky a couple of times when he found space in the box only for the awaited cross to be headed clear.

Kuharevich – Such has his luck been in the past with goals ruled out I was delighted to see that today’s counted.

Miller – Looks fit again and slotted in seamlessly.

MacIntyre – Oscar didn’t get many minutes, but he’ll be delighted that he featured in a 4-1 win.

Lee Johnson – Chuffed for him and loved his celebration at the end in front of a bouncing B7.

Referee – Chris Graham is a new name to me and though he made a couple of puzzling decisions, I thought he had a decent game.

Couldn't see far end of pitch, for their tv shack, what was LJ's celebration?

NAE NOOKIE
05-03-2023, 12:34 AM
One pm and just finished watching on ALBA.

In all honesty for the first 20 minutes or so I thought we were a bit ragged and the number of times both Cabraja and Hanlon got caught on the wrong side was a real worry. From a Livvi point of view their goal was well taken, but with two defenders on him and the keeper at a good angle there's just no way Nouble should have been allowed to get a shot away, never mind score, it was poor all round from our defence.

What can you say about Youan, as JB said he can drive you nuts and then do something great, it was fantastic to see that he actually can finish one on one, his second was as sponny as they come but who cares, the amount of bad luck we have in front of goal we are sure due some, talking of which Cadden took far too long to square the ball for Youan for what should have been a tap in for his hat trick, luckily for him Omeonga helped him out.

We didn't have a bad player, but special mention for Fish, Egan Riley and Jeggo who were all solid as anything ..... When it comes to Jeggo I'm with JB it looks like the guy has been at Hibs for a hundred years, he has slotted in absolutely seamlessly and just goes about his business without fuss, so much so you kind of forget to mention him, but so far the guy has been a great signing and I've yet to see him have a bad game.

Great to see Kukharevych get on the score sheet too.

A wee note about Cadden ... after they went down to 9 men he got a lot of the ball in advanced positions and did very little with it, I can't deny I found that just a wee bit frustrating and I'm sure Nisbet, Kukharevych and Lee Johnson felt the same.

Still, all and all a great result at a venue it's always a pain in the arse to play at for a number of reasons so well done to the team. The game on Wednesday night will obviously be a totally different affair and the slightly ragged performance we put up in the first 20 minutes or so simply can't happen.

ChilliEater
05-03-2023, 03:21 AM
Only seen the brief You Tube highlights, but the 4th goal - both Nisbet and Myk offside when the pass is played, but it deflects off the defender playing them on. That may well be the correct decision now, but I hate the rule. I'm sure it used to be called when the pass was played. You were onside if a defender had posession and then played it, like a pass back to the keeper for example, but not if a pass from an attacking player hit them on it's way through.
It means now defenders would have to pull out of blocking a pass if they thought an opponent was offside. Almost as stupid as being red carded for kicking the ball, but then an opponent gets in the way of your follow through.

MWHIBBIES
05-03-2023, 05:07 AM
Cadden was excellent imo. Drove us forward all day.

BoyledEgg
05-03-2023, 06:17 AM
Only seen the brief You Tube highlights, but the 4th goal - both Nisbet and Myk offside when the pass is played, but it deflects off the defender playing them on. That may well be the correct decision now, but I hate the rule. I'm sure it used to be called when the pass was played. You were onside if a defender had posession and then played it, like a pass back to the keeper for example, but not if a pass from an attacking player hit them on it's way through.
It means now defenders would have to pull out of blocking a pass if they thought an opponent was offside. Almost as stupid as being red carded for kicking the ball, but then an opponent gets in the way of your follow through.

Yip, baffling rule. Defender has no choice to try play it, in situations like yesterday it’s impossible for the defender to know if Nisbit is offside or not. He’s got to assume he’s on and try go for the ball.

Hibernian Verse
05-03-2023, 06:37 AM
Cadden was excellent imo. Drove us forward all day.

Agree, him and Miller linked well late on too.

Hibernian Verse
05-03-2023, 06:37 AM
Yip, baffling rule. Defender has no choice to try play it, in situations like yesterday it’s impossible for the defender to know if Nisbit is offside or not. He’s got to assume he’s on and try go for the ball.

IMO, Nisbet should still have been called offside as he’s making the defender play the ball therefore affecting the play.

greenlex
05-03-2023, 08:02 AM
Couldn't see far end of pitch, for their tv shack, what was LJ's celebration?

Think Klop and you’ve got it.

B.H.F.C
05-03-2023, 08:21 AM
IMO, Nisbet should still have been called offside as he’s making the defender play the ball therefore affecting the play.

They got it right per the rule but the rule is crap IMO.

Even worse is the rule that the goalie gets the ball back when a defender has went down in the box and the game is stopped. Happened yesterday when we were in complete control of the ball on the left wing.

easty
05-03-2023, 09:12 AM
They got it right per the rule but the rule is crap IMO.

Even worse is the rule that the goalie gets the ball back when a defender has went down in the box and the game is stopped. Happened yesterday when we were in complete control of the ball on the left wing.

Is that the rule now?

I did wonder at the time why the keeper had got the ball back, I thought it should clearly have been a drop ball for us out on the touchline, where we had the ball when the ref stopped play.

B.H.F.C
05-03-2023, 09:31 AM
Is that the rule now?

I did wonder at the time why the keeper had got the ball back, I thought it should clearly have been a drop ball for us out on the touchline, where we had the ball when the ref stopped play.

Aye and it’s ridiculous. It’s an easy out for the defending team, needs addressed. There needs to be some kind of deterrent. Saying that, for a team that like to be physical, there were a couple of occasions where I thought we were going to see surgery performed in the pitch with the length of time treatment took.

BILLYHIBS
05-03-2023, 09:52 AM
Don’t think Marsh had much chance with the goal

Nouble turned Cabraja inside out twice before blasting a shot from point blank range at 100 mph in off the underside of the crossbar

Cadden was excellent has energy in abundance but still needs to look up

I can see the Uglies taking note of Youan especially the Hun who are desperate for new recruits according to recent reports

Great work Jonnyboy

SJNB Hibby
05-03-2023, 12:58 PM
Have we got more points this season than last season already?!
5 short

BILLYHIBS
05-03-2023, 01:10 PM
Have we got more points this season than last season already?!

Exactly the same 37 points at the time of year 5th March

45 total last year

NAE NOOKIE
05-03-2023, 01:54 PM
They got it right per the rule but the rule is crap IMO.

Even worse is the rule that the goalie gets the ball back when a defender has went down in the box and the game is stopped. Happened yesterday when we were in complete control of the ball on the left wing.

Absolutely agree ... the point is that the defender cant not play the ball presuming the forward will be given offside, hell page one chapter one ... play to the whistle. An offside player putting a defended in a position where he has to play the ball is by definition actively affecting the play ... as you say the current rule is crap ...... unless it works in your favour of course :greengrin

As for the drop ball rule ... Hibs have suffered from that a number of times at ER this season, if proof was needed how daft it is yesterday provided it, the guy was definitely hurt, but Hibs were in total control of the play after it came off him, how the hell is it fair that they got the ball back? We've seen it already this season that players are happy to go down exaggerating an injury because they know the ball will be given back to them.

If the folk who make the rules don't want to give the ball back to the team in possession in an attacking area why not give the team who were in possession the ball back at the apex of the centre circle nearest their goal ... yes they have to build the attack again, but at least they have possession of the ball.

easty
05-03-2023, 03:26 PM
Hanlon – I thought he failed to react quickly to help Cabraja at the Nouble goal but otherwise had a decent game.



I don't think Hanlon is at all culpable for that goal. There's no way he should have been over helping. He's in position, marking Anderson. It's Cabrajas man, and Jeggo is also there but doesn't really do anything.

greenlex
05-03-2023, 04:18 PM
Absolutely agree ... the point is that the defender cant not play the ball presuming the forward will be given offside, hell page one chapter one ... play to the whistle. An offside player putting a defended in a position where he has to play the ball is by definition actively affecting the play ... as you say the current rule is crap ...... unless it works in your favour of course :greengrin

As for the drop ball rule ... Hibs have suffered from that a number of times at ER this season, if proof was needed how daft it is yesterday provided it, the guy was definitely hurt, but Hibs were in total control of the play after it came off him, how the hell is it fair that they got the ball back? We've seen it already this season that players are happy to go down exaggerating an injury because they know the ball will be given back to them.

If the folk who make the rules don't want to give the ball back to the team in possession in an attacking area why not give the team who were in possession the ball back at the apex of the centre circle nearest their goal ... yes they have to build the attack again, but at least they have possession of the ball.
if the defender knows the player is offside he doesn’t and shouldn’t play the ball. It’s a risk these days granted but being aware of your surroundings is more important than playing the whistle. There’s nothing wrong with that part of offside rule.

BoomtownHibees
05-03-2023, 04:30 PM
if the defender knows the player is offside he doesn’t and shouldn’t play the ball. It’s a risk these days granted but being aware of your surroundings is more important than playing the whistle. There’s nothing wrong with that part of offside rule.

The issue with the rule is exactly what happened yesterday, there’s no way the defender knew if Nisbet was offside so played the ball, meaning Nisbet was then onside again. There’s no way the defender could have left it

greenlex
05-03-2023, 04:36 PM
The issue with the rule is exactly what happened yesterday, there’s no way the defender knew if Nisbet was offside so played the ball, meaning Nisbet was then onside again. There’s no way the defender could have left it
Nothing wrong with it tho. Had he made a better job if it it wouldn’t have mattered. It’s a non issue. If you don’t know you deal with it or not as happened yesterday. Ironically if he had missed his clearance completely it would have been offside.

Eyrie
05-03-2023, 06:07 PM
Nothing wrong with it tho. Had he made a better job if it it wouldn’t have mattered. It’s a non issue. If you don’t know you deal with it or not as happened yesterday. Ironically if he had missed his clearance completely it would have been offside.

It's an issue because the player in an offside position has interfered with play because if he hadn't been there the defender wouldn't have touched the ball.

It's an issue because the player in the offside position may not have been able to get to the ball if he had been onside.

greenlex
05-03-2023, 06:47 PM
It's an issue because the player in an offside position has interfered with play because if he hadn't been there the defender wouldn't have touched the ball.

It's an issue because the player in the offside position may not have been able to get to the ball if he had been onside.
Have to disagree. The defender has to deal with it if he’s not sure and deal with it effectively. It’s not that new of a thing. It’s been like this for a good number of years. I really don’t see the issue. It was however a lot easier back in the day when you were either offside or not.

Carheenlea
05-03-2023, 07:39 PM
Couldn't see far end of pitch, for their tv shack, what was LJ's celebration?

https://twitter.com/hibernianfc/status/1632071182529990657?s=46&t=03KvtapbemQQWjh_HZzAeA

Good to see a rapport building with manager and fans - can only get stronger if we continue in this vein of form.