Hanlon-Stevenson (goal 3)

[Dashing Bob S]

I mean, come on. Enough really is enough.

[HibsGW]

Please for their own good replace them before any reputation they have is in tatters. They are both nowhere near good enough for us now.

[loanheadhibby]

Pathetic but the blame lies squarely with Marshall

[Shrekko]

Absolutely diabolical from Marshall - horrendous.

[The Modfather]

Why are we so frightened to give someone like Macintyre their chance?

[cameronw-hfc]

Pathetic but the blame lies squarely with Marshall

Surely no lol. Aye he made a hash of it but for him to be in that scenario there was multiple mistakes leading up to it. If we defended properly he wouldn't have had a decision to make.

[Tricla]

Pathetic but the blame lies squarely with Marshall

Hanlon gave up. Shocking.

[Pagan Hibernia]

All three goals completely preventable, and hearts did little else… while we completely squandered huge chances and numerous promising situations.

that hearts team were absolutely beatable and we sh*• it

[GreenNWhiteArmy]

Marshall, no? Felt like he could come and collect easily

[Dashing Bob S]

All three goals completely preventable, and hearts did little else… while we completely squandered huge chances and numerous promising situations.

that hearts team were absolutely beatable and we sh*• it

We didn’t ***** it we’re just poor. Unfortunately you only have to be less than average to cost against this Hibs team.

[Brightside]

I mean, come on. Enough really is enough.

It’s Marshall’s ball!

[Leith Green]

Hanlon just gives up

[Big_Franck]

Marshall, no? Felt like he could come and collect easily

Definitely. The striker eventually makes contact with the ball around the penalty spot. Marshall should absolutely be coming out for that.

[darwenhibby]

Marshall even moves to his right
But Hanlon giving up is a disgrace

[Dashing Bob S]

People saying it’s Marshall’s ball. Fair enough it wasn’t the best judgement on his part but there are still two defenders between the Hearts forward and the goal. Neither of whom put a challenge in.

[Stuart93]

Pathetic but the blame lies squarely with Marshall

That’s bull ****.

Humphreys tan past hanlon and Stevenson like they weren’t there. Right through the middle of them.

They’re ****ing finished and I feel embarrassed for them that we’re still having to rely on them

[Unseen work]

The amount of times I’ve seen a striker run past Hanlon like he’s not there.

Twice in two games it’s happened now.

Nothing brilliant from the striker, peel off and run in a straight line

[A Hi-Bee]

Pathetic but the blame lies squarely with Marshall

Correct, he dont come out for a simple ball. Result is goal 3

[norhfc]

Was it no Newell who lost the ball in the first place and just couldnt be arsed trying to get it back. Shambles of a goal.

[EVENTUALLY]

Pathetic but the blame lies squarely with Marshall

Hanlon pulls up because its the goalie's ball 100%. 5' 7" Stevenson will always be brushed off the ball by a 6' 2" fresh legs bustling forward. Both defenders could have done better but Marshall misjudged the weight of the ball and was culpable.

[Callum_62]

That’s bull ****.

Humphreys tan past hanlon and Stevenson like they weren’t there. Right through the middle of them.

They’re ****ing finished and I feel embarrassed for them that we’re still having to rely on themIt's not bull**** at all though - keepers balls easily 100 percent of the time

Shouldn't have mattered if Hanlon and Lewis lay down

I reckon Marsh had some kind of dizzy spell based on his reaction and body language

Sent from my VOG-L29 using Tapatalk

[Tricla]

Hanlon pulls up because its the goalie's ball 100%. 5' 7" Stevenson will always be brushed off the ball by a 6' 2" fresh legs bustling forward. Both defenders could have done better but Marshall misjudged the weight of the ball and was culpable.

He should never give up. What if the ball takes a bobble or the keeper makes a mistake? Hanlon could've won the ball had he not packed in.

Maybe Marshall didn't come out because he could see Hanlon see Hanlon had it under control.

[Onceinawhile]

All 3 of them contributed to it. All 3 are not currently good enough and I doubt whether at least 2 of them ever will be again.

[loanheadhibby]

Surely no lol. Aye he made a hash of it but for him to be in that scenario there was multiple mistakes leading up to it. If we defended properly he wouldn't have had a decision to make.

Agreed it could have been stopped on several occasions but if Marshall is even on his penalty spot, he just boots it away.

Hanlon & Stevenson are finished. Everyone knows it. We can’t rely on either now so Marshall should be thinking worst case scenario.

[500miles]

Marshall fault all day long. We were playing a high line, the only thing that we would have gained from Hanlon putting a tackle in is a red card and suspension.

Marshall looked like he was back at the goal getting a water bottle?

[loanheadhibby]

Marshall fault all day long. We were playing a high line, the only thing that we would have gained from Hanlon putting a tackle in is a red card and suspension.

Marshall looked like he was back at the goal getting a water bottle?

I thought same re Marshall. He was either chatting to crowd, drying his hands or drinking water. I’d give Schofield a run but then again, he might be as bad as Fish.

Why we never signed Clark, I have no idea.

[Allant1981]

I thought same re Marshall. He was either chatting to crowd, drying his hands or drinking water. I’d give Schofield a run but then again, he might be as bad as Fish.

Why we never signed Clark, I have no idea.

Marshall is a better keeper than Clarke that's why

[Torto7062]

We didn’t ***** it we’re just poor. Unfortunately you only have to be less than average to cost against this Hibs team.

Or if your on a winless run and you need a win lol

[loanheadhibby]

Marshall is a better keeper than Clarke that's why

No he’s not. Possibly 5 years ago. Marshall was terrible at 1st and 3rd goal.

Clarke came away with a clean sheet

[Allant1981]

No he’s not. Possibly 5 years ago. Marshall was terrible at 1st and 3rd goal.

Clarke came away with a clean sheet

We will agree to disagree on this one!

['mon the beers]

If only today was a one-off, twice in a week Hanlon has lost a goal from a through ball that he should have done better with. He at least knew where Humphrys was today compared to Kyogo midweek but him and Stevenson are beyond finished.

[truehibernian]

If you’re a physical young athletic striker you’re licking yer footballing lips knowing you’re up against Paul Hanlon. He’s absolutely finished at this level and has been for a good while. As for Lewy, I’m an unashamed fan and for me I’d have put him on Devlin and got some dig in there as he’s still a stalwart player in those areas. He’s limited now at full back - like Paul, for a good while.

Sentiment no more though, both need to go.

[Stevie Reid]

No one’s contribution was good but it was absolutely staggering to see the penalty area come into the camera shot, and not only not see Marshall there to gather/boot clear, but to see him somehow scrambling from the opposite side of the goal.

Absolutely inexplicable from him.

[loanheadhibby]

No one’s contribution was good but it was absolutely staggering to see the penalty area come into the camera shot, and not only not see Marshall there to gather/boot clear, but to see him somehow scrambling from the opposite side of the goal.

Absolutely inexplicable from him.

Marshall’s best days are well behind him. He let us down badly today just like every other player.

He gets away with it due to his reputation and Scotland exploits. If Macey had put in that kind of performance today, he’d have been hunted out the club.

[Stevie Reid]

Marshall’s best days are well behind him. He let us down badly today just like every other player.

He gets away with it due to his reputation and Scotland exploits. If Macey had put in that kind of performance today, he’d have been hunted out the club.

I don’t agree with that, I think he’s been good for us this season.

Can’t explain what he was doing at goal number three though.

[hibee_girl]

Marshall’s best days are well behind him. He let us down badly today just like every other player.

He gets away with it due to his reputation and Scotland exploits. If Macey had put in that kind of performance today, he’d have been hunted out the club.

I think that's quite harsh on Marshall, he's been excellent for us this season so far.

He had a bad one today but it happens.

[loanheadhibby]

I don’t agree with that, I think he’s been good for us this season.

Can’t explain what he was doing at goal number three though.

I remember when we had keepers like Goram/Rough and Leighton. The team might be playing crap and these guys would make save after save and Nick you a point. Marshall has never nicked us a point or produced an incredible display to make sure we draw or win a game.

I think his mind wanders during games. He’s slightly better than Macey but like the rest of our players, he’s actually bang average.

[h1bs4life]

It’s never Hanlon or Stevenson’s fault for anything.
Another disaster to add to their lengthy list of disasters and probably another squad that they have been part of that has got a manager sacked .

[Callum_62]

I remember when we had keepers like Goram/Rough and Leighton. The team might be playing crap and these guys would make save after save and Nick you a point. Marshall has never nicked us a point or produced an incredible display to make sure we draw or win a game.

I think his mind wanders during games. He’s slightly better than Macey but like the rest of our players, he’s actually bang average.I also seen Leighton gift the ball to Colin Cameron for another hearts goal at ER

None were faultless

Claiming Zander Clarke is better than David Marshall though is some take

Sent from my VOG-L29 using Tapatalk

[loanheadhibby]

I think that's quite harsh on Marshall, he's been excellent for us this season so far.

He had a bad one today but it happens.

You know the stats about our recent form. How can he have had an excellent season when he’s contributing to a team that’s losing every week?

Tell me one game when he’s saved us from a real doing? He concedes goals every week. Very rarely single handily saves us a point or earns us wins.

He’s as culpable as every other player

[supermcginn]

It’s never Hanlon or Stevenson’s fault for anything.
Another disaster to add to their lengthy list of disasters and probably another squad that they have been part of that has got a manager sacked .

Spot on.

[LaMotta]

I also seen Leighton gift the ball to Colin Cameron for another hearts goal at ER

None were faultless

Claiming Zander Clarke is better than David Marshall though is some take

Sent from my VOG-L29 using Tapatalk

Goram and Leighton were class but both made absiute holwers in derbies.

Clark not a better player than Marshall but given their ages, might have been a better signing longer term.

[loanheadhibby]

I also seen Leighton gift the ball to Colin Cameron for another hearts goal at ER

None were faultless

Claiming Zander Clarke is better than David Marshall though is some take

Sent from my VOG-L29 using Tapatalk

I can only talk about what I’ve seen with my eyes today mate. One keeper got a clean sheet and the other conceded 3 and he was at least partly to blame for 2.

[Allant1981]

I remember when we had keepers like Goram/Rough and Leighton. The team might be playing crap and these guys would make save after save and Nick you a point. Marshall has never nicked us a point or produced an incredible display to make sure we draw or win a game.

I think his mind wanders during games. He’s slightly better than Macey but like the rest of our players, he’s actually bang average.

Bang average and slightly better than macey🤣🤣🤣🤣

[Stevie Reid]

I remember when we had keepers like Goram/Rough and Leighton. The team might be playing crap and these guys would make save after save and Nick you a point. Marshall has never nicked us a point or produced an incredible display to make sure we draw or win a game.

I think his mind wanders during games. He’s slightly better than Macey but like the rest of our players, he’s actually bang average.

The first derby I ever went to was at Tynie and Rough made a mad dash from his goal and cost us the winner. Leighton let in two carbon copy goals to Colin Cameron in successive derbies at ER. Even Goram let in a tame free kick from John Robertson, albeit with an injured hand.

We have many, many, many issues at the football club just now. Our goalkeeper is most certainly not one of them.

[Allant1981]

Not a better player but given their ages, might have been a better signing longer term.

Think they have high hopes for Murray which might be the thinking of Marshall signing

[Since90+2]

I remember when we had keepers like Goram/Rough and Leighton. The team might be playing crap and these guys would make save after save and Nick you a point. Marshall has never nicked us a point or produced an incredible display to make sure we draw or win a game.

I think his mind wanders during games. He’s slightly better than Macey but like the rest of our players, he’s actually bang average.

Marshall is the best keeper we've had in years. Miles better than Macey.

[LaMotta]

Think they have high hopes for Murray which might be the thinking of Marshall signing

Hopefully, however right now I'd quite like a strategy of signing several tried and tested players coming into their prime (eg Clarke, Shankland, B Mackay etc)

[Allant1981]

Hopefully, however right now I'd quite like a strategy of signing several tried and tested players coming into their prime (eg Clarke, Shankland, B Mackay etc)

Totally agree, the signing policy is all over the place just now

[Callum_62]

I can only talk about what I’ve seen with my eyes today mate. One keeper got a clean sheet and the other conceded 3 and he was at least partly to blame for 2.Well then, case closed [emoji106]

Sent from my VOG-L29 using Tapatalk

[California-Hibs]

If anyone still needs convincing that Hanlon needs to be booted out this team asap then I'd encourage them to rewatch that 3rd goal.

[loanheadhibby]

Well then, case closed [emoji106]

Sent from my VOG-L29 using Tapatalk

Glad you’re coming round to my way of thinking.

[LewysGot2]

Marshall is the best keeper we've had in years. Miles better than Macey.

Best keeper since Rocky, that's fair comment.

[truehibernian]

If anyone still needs convincing that Hanlon needs to be booted out this team asap then I'd encourage them to rewatch that 3rd goal.

Or watch the 6-6 Motherwell game years ago when Yogi behind the scenes called it right 👍 can’t handle big strikers 👍 and that was well over a decade ago.

[loanheadhibby]

Marshall is the best keeper we've had in years. Miles better than Macey.

He’s not really based on actual stats tho. He’s contributing to a team in 8th. Macey contributed to a team that finished 8th. Marciano better than them both. Bogdan as good as both Marshall & Macey.

[WeeRussell]

Marshall is the best keeper we've had in years. Miles better than Macey.

And will probably rightly finish as our player of the season this year.

[WeeRussell]

He’s not really based on actual stats tho. He’s contributing to a team in 8th. Macey contributed to a team that finished 8th. Marciano better than them both. Bogdan as good as both Marshall & Macey.

Are those your ‘actual stats’?

[Callum_62]

He’s not really based on actual stats tho. He’s contributing to a team in 8th. Macey contributed to a team that finished 8th. Marciano better than them both. Bogdan as good as both Marshall & Macey.John Mcginn played alongside Kenny McLean for St Mirren and were relegated

I think you need to view things as they are - a team sport

Marshall for me had a hand in one and could have done better for the 1st - that doenst in anyway make him comparable to Zander Clarke or matt macey though

Its a kind of childish comparison

Its like saying whoever was in goals for Hearts in they games Jim Leighton (your shout as top goalie btw) gifted a couple of howler goals to them so must be better

Sent from my VOG-L29 using Tapatalk

[loanheadhibby]

John Mcginn played alongside Kenny McLean for St Mirren and were relegated

I think you need to view things as they are - a team sport

Marshall for me had a hand in one and could have done better for the 1st - that doenst in anyway make him comparable to Zander Clarke or matt macey though

Its a kind of childish comparison

Sent from my VOG-L29 using Tapatalk

Comparing several goalkeepers is childish? You’ll need to explain that to me.

[Keepthefaith]

Agree, both have had their time. Thought lewy did well against Livingston but time to give young McIntyre a chance. Paul needs dropped, return to a back 4!

[Callum_62]

Comparing several goalkeepers is childish? You’ll need to explain that to me.Comparing them based on 1 game is

Sent from my VOG-L29 using Tapatalk

[BoomtownHibees]

Agree, both have had their time. Thought lewy did well against Livingston but time to give young McIntyre a chance. Paul needs dropped, return to a back 4!

We have been playing a back 4

[Not In The Know]

People saying it’s Marshall’s ball. Fair enough it wasn’t the best judgement on his part but there are still two defenders between the Hearts forward and the goal. Neither of whom put a challenge in.

Marshall is the least of our worries.

[loanheadhibby]

Comparing them based on 1 game is

Sent from my VOG-L29 using Tapatalk

I think that it’s fair to compare both keepers today that played in same game? Out of interest, which keeper did you think performed better today?

[loanheadhibby]

Marshall is the least of our worries.

i don’t think he is. His reputation is the least of our worries. Tell me a game where he’s pulled us out the mire?

I remember Macey having a blinder last season at Tynie in a scoreless draw. I can’t recollect Marshall having any form of blinder this season.

I agree he’s a step up from Macey but I’m unconvinced he’s the least of our worries.

[loanheadhibby]

Think they have high hopes for Murray which might be the thinking of Marshall signing

Do you mean Murray Johnston

[kentao]

i don’t think he is. His reputation is the least of our worries. Tell me a game where he’s pulled us out the mire?

I remember Macey having a blinder last season at Tynie in a scoreless draw. I can’t recollect Marshall having any form of blinder this season.

I agree he’s a step up from Macey but I’m unconvinced he’s the least of our worries.

One keeper is a international class Goalkeeper the other was lucky to get a gig at Easter Road. Macey isn't even in the same league as Marsh.

De Gea wouldn't be able to keep a clean sheet with some of the defensive performances in front of him. for example Will Fish today, Hanlon and Stevenson for the 3rd, Rocky nutmegging himself with a diving header. We don't stop crosses into the box and then the CHs fail to challenge for the ball.

A whole new back 4 is required Stevenson and Hanlon are finished, Will Fish not at the level required, Rocky doesn't look comfortable on the ball which is a worry with Porto leaving soon.

Hope the recruitment team are able to get at least 4 1st team quality players in for end of Jan.

[Allant1981]

Do you mean Murray Johnston

Yip, friends of mine are involved with airdrie and when he was on loan there they said he was very highly rated by hibs

[loanheadhibby]

One keeper is a international class Goalkeeper the other was lucky to get a gig at Easter Road. Macey isn't even in the same league as Marsh.

De Gea wouldn't be able to keep a clean sheet with some of the defensive performances in front of him. for example Will Fish today, Hanlon and Stevenson for the 3rd, Rocky nutmegging himself with a diving header. We don't stop crosses into the box and then the CHs fail to challenge for the ball.

A whole new back 4 is required Stevenson and Hanlon are finished, Will Fish not at the level required, Rocky doesn't look comfortable on the ball which is a worry with Porto leaving soon.

Hope the recruitment team are able to get at least 4 1st team quality players in for end of Jan.

I think you are in for a disappointment. Johnson has just said he’d take one quality signing if he can get 10 players out the door.

Guaranteed that Cadden/Hanlon/Rocky & Stevenson will be at least some part of defence in cup tie & on 1st league game after 31st January.