PDA

View Full Version : Whole new midfield needed



dastardly8
27-08-2022, 02:53 PM
Has to be the worst Hibs midfield I’ve seen in 40 something years , Newell and Doyle Hayes are total mince , don’t think Henderson and Kenneh are improvements either

MWHIBBIES
27-08-2022, 02:54 PM
Jdh and Newell haven't even been that bad. At least not compared to their teammates. Easy targets though.

RoxburghHibs
27-08-2022, 02:55 PM
Newell, Campbell and Doyle-Hayes in the same midfield does not work.

Every time I see that line up I know it's going to be a tough afternoon.

Come on Hibs we can still turn this round..

:flag:

Benny Brazil
27-08-2022, 02:59 PM
Add in a new defence as well

Heisenberg
27-08-2022, 03:06 PM
Jdh and Newell haven't even been that bad. At least not compared to their teammates. Easy targets though.

They are though. Majority of the time it doesn’t work when they are paired in the midfield. We have absolutely no creativity, no one taking the ball forward. It’s pish.

blackpoolhibs
27-08-2022, 03:09 PM
They are though. Majority of the time it doesn’t work when they are paired in the midfield. We have absolutely no creativity, no one taking the ball forward. It’s pish.

I know, it's easy to target them because of that.

WhileTheChief..
27-08-2022, 03:17 PM
Jdh and Newell haven't even been that bad. At least not compared to their teammates. Easy targets though.

Forget about today, they're still not good enough.

They made themselves easy targets with their crap performances over the last year.

Brummie_Hibs
27-08-2022, 03:18 PM
Add in a new defence as well
Don't forget forwards too.

Happy with keeper tho!!

LeithMike
27-08-2022, 03:24 PM
Saw an interview this morning when he signed with Man Utd. Described himself as a player who gets up and down. We don't have anyone who gets up and down. Campbell might be able to do it but his confidence ebbs and flows. Newell and JDH run through treacle.

I think if we could get one good all round midfielder then JDH could hold and we have to hope that Henderson can do the attacking role but there are doubts about that and, like his brother, he might end up better in the holding role too.

Whichever way you look at it, its not good recruitment to have 5 central midfielders none of whom can get up and down.

Sent from my SM-N960F using Tapatalk

Stuart93
27-08-2022, 03:44 PM
Na, that midfield three’s fine. Don’t complain about them unless you can name every game they’ve played collectively poor in.

madhatter
27-08-2022, 03:48 PM
Specialists in slow ponderous passing and no drive. Not just them though. Porteous and Hanlon are so slow at passing, especially Porteous who does his little hop when scooping the ball to his teammate (or out of play).

lyonhibs
27-08-2022, 03:49 PM
Na, that midfield three’s fine. Don’t complain about them unless you can name every game they’ve played collectively poor in.

Not sure if this is a whoosh moment, but the lack of creativity and dynamic forward thinking intent from that 3 is frightening. Anyone thinking we're getting top 4 with those 3 starting most games has had a good batch of crack and I'd quite like some

Top 6 looking like an achievement with the current midfield I'm afraid, at least 1 new, starting XI midfielder required, ideally 2.

Stuart93
27-08-2022, 03:51 PM
Not sure if this is a whoosh moment, but the lack of creativity and dynamic forward thinking intent from that 3 is frightening. Anyone thinking we're getting top 4 with those 3 starting most games has had a good batch of crack and I'd quite like some

Top 6 looking like an achievement with the current midfield I'm afraid, at least 1 new, starting XI midfielder required, ideally 2.

It’s a whoosh moment. It’s nowhere near good enough and anyone with a brain could see the way the game would go with they 3 starting together in the middle

Pretty Boy
27-08-2022, 03:51 PM
We are the core of a team short.

Ron better give junior the cheque book this week and then say his prayers or this team is in a scrap at the wrong end of the table

Keith_M
27-08-2022, 03:54 PM
Recruitment has a lot to answer for. The squad is nowhere near good enough.

Bristolhibby
27-08-2022, 03:56 PM
Chuck in a new centre half also.

Losing first goal early against teams like St Mirren is a disaster. Like when we were in the Championship we always find it impossible to break down banks of four defending all game.

J

lyonhibs
27-08-2022, 04:00 PM
It’s a whoosh moment. It’s nowhere near good enough and anyone with a brain could see the way the game would go with they 3 starting together in the middle

Ah ok,good. Agreed entirely

Steve88
27-08-2022, 04:01 PM
Fed up of this thread, not because I don't agree - but because the same premise has been going since man invented fire...

Northfield Hibby
27-08-2022, 04:01 PM
Not saying he's the answer to our midfield problems but surely Tait must b given a chance? Has Johnson not seen enough of that midfield to know its garbage.

MWHIBBIES
27-08-2022, 04:02 PM
Worrying that the midfield were probably among our better players today. Back 4 and forwards woeful.

Juice-Terry
27-08-2022, 04:03 PM
How can people in charge not see that Newell, JDH, and Campbell is the worst midfield at Hibs in living memory?

Stuarty1875
27-08-2022, 04:03 PM
Midfield issue is becoming critical. Saw performances like today too many times.

basehibby
27-08-2022, 04:15 PM
Newell, Campbell and Doyle-Hayes in the same midfield does not work.

Every time I see that line up I know it's going to be a tough afternoon....



:top marks This - we watched it enough times last season to see that the balance of their attributes just does not click. I thought we were improved in earlier games with Kenneh involved - who's instincts are to play the sitting midfielder. This seems to have a positive effect on Newell's play allowing him to venture forward more often, making him more effective in a creative sense. This would maybe work with JDH in for Newell as well, but the two together just seems to be a recipe for mundane mediocrity.

Aldo
27-08-2022, 04:19 PM
Buck stops with LJ and he needs to sort it.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

GreenCastle
27-08-2022, 04:25 PM
Groundhog Day.

Same players - same crap performances when it matters.

Adding a holding midfielder to the squad after last season is absolutely ridiculous.

B.H.F.C
27-08-2022, 04:26 PM
What unfolded today wasn’t a surprise when you saw the team.

Lack of signings in midfield is disgraceful.

Just Alf
27-08-2022, 04:28 PM
We are the core of a team short.

Ron better give junior the cheque book this week and then say his prayers or this team is in a scrap at the wrong end of the tablePretty much how I'm seeing it, I'm so hacked of with Hibs just now :-(

GreenCastle
27-08-2022, 04:29 PM
What unfolded today wasn’t a surprise when you saw the team.

Lack of signings in midfield is disgraceful.

100%

There has been many threads on here saying JDH, Newell and Campbell can’t play in same team regularly.

Our central midfield is a joke and the whole spine of the team needs fixed except GK.

Alfred E Newman
27-08-2022, 04:32 PM
When I read we had almost 70% possession and only 1 shot on target it tells me we need more than just a midfield. That statistic is ridiculous.

Thegreenside
27-08-2022, 04:39 PM
That midfield 3 will do nothing but get managers sacked. The quicker magennis is back the better.

Northernhibee
27-08-2022, 04:40 PM
I’m a bit confused as to taking Campbell off today. He was busting a gut to try to get to things and getting forward.

Individually the three are decent players but don’t work together.

LunasBoots
27-08-2022, 04:43 PM
Newell, Hayes and Campbell are too similar in style to play with each other, it doesnt work and hasnt for long enough, its an area that needs changed and has for long enough.

CL0762
27-08-2022, 04:44 PM
Worrying that the midfield were probably among our better players today. Back 4 and forwards woeful.

Because Newell had one shot presumably.

We’ll ignore the hopeless amount of crosses into the box that met no one, the boring sideways passing that went nowhere & the pointless booking in a nothing area of the park.

I would genuinely love for you to explain what it is you see in any of our midfield because I just plainly do not get it.

Eaststand
27-08-2022, 04:45 PM
When I read we had almost 70% possession and only 1 shot on target it tells me we need more than just a midfield. That statistic is ridiculous.

You're quite right it is ridiculous that we have no creative players able to play a killer pass and we also have a statuesque centre forward (Doidge) who wouldn't get on the end of a decent pass if his life depended on it.

Our midfield has no creation, up front we have no threat apart from Boyle but he was marked tightly today and that was our only chance gone.
Melkerson and Henderson both look like wee lost boys playing against men and both are continually brushed off the ball by streetwise journeyman players in our tough league.

Its sad that we've became such a poor team so quickly but there's no doubts after defeats to Livi and St Mirren that we have.

GGTTH

A Hi-Bee
27-08-2022, 04:56 PM
You're quite right it is ridiculous that we have no creative players able to play a killer pass and we also have a statuesque centre forward (Doidge) who wouldn't get on the end of a decent pass if his life depended on it.

Our midfield has no creation, up front we have no threat apart from Boyle but he was marked tightly today and that was our only chance gone.
Melkerson and Henderson both look like wee lost boys playing against men and both are continually brushed off the ball by streetwise journeyman players in our tough league.

Its sad that we've became such a poor team so quickly but there's no doubts after defeats to Livi and St Mirren that we have.

GGTTH

We have not become a poor team quickly, this has been a slow, long drawn out process, full of semi-talented players when we need some really talented players, quality players.
Right now I would go out and bring in Dylan McGeouch for starters, then a good big centre half, followed by someone who can score goals, start building from a good solid base, not a sand pit.
:flag::flag::flag:

Badge
27-08-2022, 05:04 PM
Worrying that the midfield were probably among our better players today. Back 4 and forwards woeful.

You’re at it again. Please stop this. You just can’t help yourself. Being better when the whole lot are poor is not good enough. Set your sights a bit higher and stop settling for slightly better than poor.

Libby Hibby
27-08-2022, 05:05 PM
Newell, just GTF.

Where is Dylan Tait? Just give him a try.

Hibernia&Alba
27-08-2022, 05:12 PM
The Three Stooges in midfield are horrific. Seriously, they are Championship level at best and all of them need replacing.

Hibby70
27-08-2022, 05:17 PM
Newell, just GTF.

Where is Dylan Tait? Just give him a try.

It's a strange one, I had assumed that perhaps he doesn't show much in training - but on the basis that Newell hardly shows on the pitch then surely Tait is worth a shot (and by that I mean a run not just 30 mins)

Pretty Boy
27-08-2022, 05:20 PM
Newell, just GTF.

Where is Dylan Tait? Just give him a try.

My neighbour is a Raith fan.

Said Tait had a bit of an attitude there. Good player but had a few people in his ear telling him he was better than he is.

Tbh I'd kill for a player with a bit of cockiness about him right now so not a huge problem for me. If there is anything in it I can see why a manager might not be keen to throw him in though.

Libby Hibby
27-08-2022, 05:22 PM
My neighbour is a Raith fan.

Said Tait had a bit of an attitude there. Good player but had a few people in his ear telling him he was better than he is.

Tbh I'd kill for a player with a bit of cockiness about him right now so not a huge problem for me. If there is anything in it I can see why a manager might not be keen to throw him in though.

Attitude is what this side needs

Hibs90
27-08-2022, 05:33 PM
Have to give Tait a shot.

SlickShoes
27-08-2022, 05:37 PM
When I read we had almost 70% possession and only 1 shot on target it tells me we need more than just a midfield. That statistic is ridiculous.

Because we pass it around the back or up the wing but the middle of the park is a black hole, the other team just closes down our wings and that’s it. The amount of crosses we put in that amount to nothing is also criminal, too high, too fast, too long or just wayward nowhere near anyone.

Tambo
27-08-2022, 06:58 PM
My thoughts on today that Campbell tried a few times to play a cutting ball through and a little energy but not involved enough.

Newell again not much going forward for 90 mins with a lot of keeping it safe and passing it on which is fine if you have someone else who can create something through the central area but we don't so we need to see more attacking from Joe week in week out.

JDH fine again when he was on the ball but again just not involved enough in the game.

We seen last season how much our midfield was dominated most weeks last season and it has happened a lot this season.

It's so slow passing around the back and then out wide because we don't have anyone in the centre, we was hoping Henderson would be that guy and he started really well pre season and league cup but has not had the best of 2/3 games lately.

Mcgeady could play that AM role but would he be fit for a lot of the season? LJ needs to bring someone in next week.

WeeRussell
27-08-2022, 07:01 PM
You’re at it again. Please stop this. You just can’t help yourself. Being better when the whole lot are poor is not good enough. Set your sights a bit higher and stop settling for slightly better than poor.

To be fair I don’t think anybody is at it. It’s more stubbornness and wanting to be right.

People that claimed Newell would walk into any team outside the old firm, and Doidge is better than Shankland, don’t want to back down.

I think it’s human nature during a tough time.

MWHIBBIES
27-08-2022, 07:04 PM
You’re at it again. Please stop this. You just can’t help yourself. Being better when the whole lot are poor is not good enough. Set your sights a bit higher and stop settling for slightly better than poor.

I didn't say they were good enough. Try reading my posts pal.

Whole team was awful. Why aren't there threads for Youan and Cabraja? Both were absolutely ***** today. Far worse than Newell.

Tambo
27-08-2022, 07:16 PM
I didn't say they were good enough. Try reading my posts pal.

Whole team was awful. Why aren't there threads for Youan and Cabraja? Both were absolutely ***** today. Far worse than Newell.

Probably because the two players you have mentioned have played a handful of games and tbh looked decent in a few of them.

HH81
27-08-2022, 07:22 PM
I see on twitter Mcgeady was watching Celtic B today rather then watch Hibs.

Poor.

bigwheel
27-08-2022, 07:27 PM
I see on twitter Mcgeady was watching Celtic B today rather then watch Hibs.

Poor.

McGeady has turned out to be a really poor signing . His injury will keep him out to around Xmas ..even then no guarantee he will recover fully ..he will be on one of our higher wages too. Disaster for us …

CMac1988
27-08-2022, 07:30 PM
I see on twitter Mcgeady was watching Celtic B today rather then watch Hibs.

Poor.

Poor if true. Stinking attitude. Par for the course at Hibs though.

Chorley Hibee
27-08-2022, 07:31 PM
I didn't say they were good enough. Try reading my posts pal.

Whole team was awful. Why aren't there threads for Youan and Cabraja? Both were absolutely ***** today. Far worse than Newell.

Youan and Cabraja haven't been producing the same crap for well over a year.

If they do then there'll be plenty of threads about them too.

loanheadhibby
27-08-2022, 07:35 PM
I see on twitter Mcgeady was watching Celtic B today rather then watch Hibs.

Poor.

Better than sitting in a boozer with Magennis, Nisbet & Tait.

Willis1875
27-08-2022, 07:36 PM
Midfield dictate the tempo in which we play,these guys are far too slow and ponderous.
We always look better when we play at a higher tempo,absolutely critical that we get improvements in there and get the ball into our forward players quicker and utilise the obvious pace we have upfront instead of pointless balls into their feet

bigwheel
27-08-2022, 07:36 PM
Better than sitting in a boozer with Magennis, Nisbet & Tait.

With his team just along the road it suggests he doesn’t feel a lot of love and connection with Hibs ..

Badge
27-08-2022, 07:39 PM
I didn't say they were good enough. Try reading my posts pal.

Whole team was awful. Why aren't there threads for Youan and Cabraja? Both were absolutely ***** today. Far worse than Newell.

Youan has probably created more in his first month here than Newell has in his 3 years. You defend Nisbet after the loss of his father but are showing no sympathy for Cabraja.

MWHIBBIES
27-08-2022, 07:42 PM
Youan has probably created more in his first month here than Newell has in his 3 years. You defend Nisbet after the loss of his father but are showing no sympathy for Cabraja.

I defended Nisbet saying he didn't down tools. I'm not having a go at Cabrajas attitude like folk were with Nisbet. He just played dreadfully.

That's not true about Newell. Youan was really dreadful today. And at livi. Ridiculous no one will say it because he's new. He was pish in both our league defeats.

loanheadhibby
27-08-2022, 07:46 PM
With his team just along the road it suggests he doesn’t feel a lot of love and connection with Hibs ..

I think that goes without saying. He’s a Celtic man thru & thru. I don’t think he hides that fact. As previously stated on this post, he was and is a poor signing. Injured most of last season and likely to be injured most of this season unfortunately.

hibsbollah
27-08-2022, 07:46 PM
I’ve defended Newell to the hilt but some of the basic mistakes from him and Doidge today in particular just had me wanting to leave early. A terrible performance from the whole team and 1-0 flattered us.

skyehibee
27-08-2022, 07:52 PM
Newell is the route cause of our midfield problems for seasons now. He’s not good enough, he ups his performances for say 1 in 6 games usually against rangers/Celtic then becomes oblivious and useless for games against Ross county etc. You can’t afford to have players like that starting every week. But come that 1 good game he has you’ll have half this board raving about how great he is. He needs replaced and if nobody can see this then we will continue being bottom 6 for the next few years of his contract.

MWHIBBIES
27-08-2022, 07:55 PM
Newell is the route cause of our midfield problems for seasons now. He’s not good enough, he ups his performances for say 1 in 6 games usually against rangers/Celtic then becomes oblivious and useless for games against Ross county etc. You can’t afford to have players like that starting every week. But come that 1 good game he has you’ll have half this board raving about how great he is. He needs replaced and if nobody can see this then we will continue being bottom 6 for the next few years of his contract.


And yet, he is very rarely our worst midfielder never mind worst player. Replacing Newell is fine, but it's not really making us any better unless we replace a good few others.

Newell nothing like our worst today. Not even close.

Zambernardi1875
27-08-2022, 07:58 PM
And yet, he is very rarely our worst midfielder never mind worst player. Replacing Newell is fine, but it's not really making us any better unless we replace a good few others.

Newell nothing like our worst today. Not even close.

If we replaced newell with mcginn we’d be 100 times better. Silly comment

Badge
27-08-2022, 08:00 PM
And yet, he is very rarely our worst midfielder never mind worst player. Replacing Newell is fine, but it's not really making us any better unless we replace a good few others.

Newell nothing like our worst today. Not even close.
Stop defending *****. He was poor today along with the rest of the team. It’s a sad day when we are reduced to saying who was the least poorest in the team.

MWHIBBIES
27-08-2022, 08:02 PM
If we replaced newell with mcginn we’d be 100 times better. Silly comment

Yeah absolutely. If we replaced Campbell with Mcginn we'd be a 1000 times better. I'm speaking reality though.

Difference is, mcginn had much much better players around him when here. We were a better team. There are 6 or 7 guys performing rubbish. Was significantly worse out there today than Joe. Everyone needs to step up or **** off, not just Newell.

If changing manager doesn't fix everything, changing 1 player definitely won't.

MWHIBBIES
27-08-2022, 08:03 PM
Stop defending *****. He was poor today along with the rest of the team. It’s a sad day when we are reduced to saying who was the least poorest in the team.

I'll post whatever the **** I want thanks.

Badge
27-08-2022, 08:06 PM
I'll post whatever the **** I want thanks.

Oh dear

Heisenberg
27-08-2022, 08:07 PM
I see on twitter Mcgeady was watching Celtic B today rather then watch Hibs.

Poor.

McGeady can get himself to ****. He clearly doesn’t care.

stuart-farquhar
27-08-2022, 08:15 PM
McGeady can get himself to ****. He clearly doesn’t care.
If true then bog(sic) off.

Libby Hibby
27-08-2022, 08:18 PM
Newell was awful today, 2nd worst player on the pitch behind Doidge. Porto 3rd worst.

JimBHibees
27-08-2022, 08:23 PM
Newell was awful today, 2nd worst player on the pitch behind Doidge. Porto 3rd worst.

Sick of the same one paced half hearted effort. Not tracking players continually giving the ball away and feeble giving away of fouls. Utterly atrocious

supermcginn
27-08-2022, 08:28 PM
Newell was awful today, 2nd worst player on the pitch behind Doidge. Porto 3rd worst.

Yip, another game without a goal or assist for Newell and another game without a goal for doidge. Absolutely rotten both of them.

truehibernian
27-08-2022, 08:31 PM
Sick of the same one paced half hearted effort. Not tracking players continually giving the ball away and feeble giving away of fouls. Utterly atrocious

Jim, I posted in the relegation thread, that midfield today is not too dissimilar to Craig, Tudor Jones, and Robertson in terms of creativity, desire, drive, and energy. They’re on a par. Sadly, we know what happened the longer we persisted with that midfield in 2014. It’s the most important area of the pitch to get right for me , and it’s never been properly balanced or invested in.

We won’t be able to, but I’d happily start all over and replace three or four of them and build around Tait, Kenneh and Delfierre, with some proper experience and a couple of creative sparks.

B.H.F.C
27-08-2022, 08:32 PM
Yeah absolutely. If we replaced Campbell with Mcginn we'd be a 1000 times better. I'm speaking reality though.

Difference is, mcginn had much much better players around him when here. We were a better team. There are 6 or 7 guys performing rubbish. Was significantly worse out there today than Joe. Everyone needs to step up or **** off, not just Newell.

If changing manager doesn't fix everything, changing 1 player definitely won't.

It’s the manager working with the same players that means nothing is changing.

Same pish will get you the same pish results.

Northernhibee
27-08-2022, 08:33 PM
McGeady can get himself to ****. He clearly doesn’t care.
McGeady can do one.

Libby Hibby
27-08-2022, 08:34 PM
Yeah absolutely. If we replaced Campbell with Mcginn we'd be a 1000 times better. I'm speaking reality though.

Difference is, mcginn had much much better players around him when here. We were a better team. There are 6 or 7 guys performing rubbish. Was significantly worse out there today than Joe. Everyone needs to step up or **** off, not just Newell.

If changing manager doesn't fix everything, changing 1 player definitely won't.

I guarantee you swapping say Tait for Newell will bring a different dynamic to the side.

truehibernian
27-08-2022, 08:39 PM
I guarantee you swapping say Tait for Newell will bring a different dynamic to the side.

Tait bossed a midfield against a recent Premiership side. Pre season or not. Newell can’t boss Livingston or St Mirren.

Tait is already a better option than Newell for me having seen him now a few times. So was/is young Delferierre. Both worked really well together.

B.H.F.C
27-08-2022, 08:39 PM
I hate watching this Hibs team (as it’s pretty much last years Hibs team).

Soul destroying when you’re sitting in the pub and see our team, predominantly the midfield. It’s so ****ing predictable what will happen.

CapitalGreen
27-08-2022, 09:01 PM
Tait bossed a midfield against a recent Premiership side. Pre season or not. Newell can’t boss Livingston or St Mirren.

Tait is already a better option than Newell for me having seen him now a few times. So was/is young Delferierre. Both worked really well together.

Edinburgh City fans on twitter saying Delferriere is an incredible player and they don’t know how they’ve got him on loan. Obviously League 1 isn’t a high standard but he should have been given a chance here based on his preseason and development team performances.

Chorley Hibee
27-08-2022, 09:14 PM
McGeady can do one.

Wasn't comfortable with his comments whilst on Sky last week either.

Could do with a reminder as to who is employer is.

FRes Hibbie
27-08-2022, 09:18 PM
And yet, he is very rarely our worst midfielder never mind worst player. Replacing Newell is fine, but it's not really making us any better unless we replace a good few others.

Newell nothing like our worst today. Not even close.

I didn’t see the game today but on Newell generally, for ages it has felt (to me at least) that if Newell plays well the whole team plays well and occasionally it happens. Unfortunately it doesn’t happen far more often and that’s where the frustration comes from.

CMac1988
27-08-2022, 09:19 PM
Edinburgh City fans on twitter saying Delferriere is an incredible player and they don’t know how they’ve got him on loan. Obviously League 1 isn’t a high standard but he should have been given a chance here based on his preseason and development team performances.

A good number of Hibs fans who watched pre season also don't know considering the current midfield is struggling again after much of the same last season.

sorrow sorrow
27-08-2022, 09:21 PM
JDH,newell,Campbell,doidge etc are the obvious target for fans and rightly so as they are clearly not good enough but how come guys like cadden,Stevenson,henderson,melkerson get away with less abuse?
They are equally poor on a weekly basis.
That’s 7 first team starters!!
Really poor recruitment

Leith Green
27-08-2022, 09:33 PM
Henderson is powder Puff , so weak it’s ridiculous, always losing possession … Newell useless going forward and a liability defending.. Campbell full of running and hard work and his effort cant be questioned, but is nowhere near the quality we need to be challenging at the top end of the table. Doyle hayes doesnt do enough to impact the game.kenneh looks like exactly what he is , a raw young defensive midfielder. Who is a gamble .. That is our central midfield there , and that is where our biggest problems are. No power , no drive , no creativity, no tactical awareness. , no players with a proven track record of commanding the middle of the park .. Until we sort that out , we are going to continue to struggle

Stuart93
28-08-2022, 01:26 AM
And yet, he is very rarely our worst midfielder never mind worst player. Replacing Newell is fine, but it's not really making us any better unless we replace a good few others.

Newell nothing like our worst today. Not even close.

But he’s not good enough regardless

Paulie Walnuts
28-08-2022, 07:12 AM
I didn’t see the game today but on Newell generally, for ages it has felt (to me at least) that if Newell plays well the whole team plays well and occasionally it happens. Unfortunately it doesn’t happen far more often and that’s where the frustration comes from.

That’s because the rest of the team carry him.

It’s easy to look good in a good team. He is an absolutely terrible player who needs absolutely everything to go his way to have a good game. The complete opposite of a player who can take the game by the scruff of the neck.

blackpoolhibs
28-08-2022, 07:19 AM
We've signed a raft of pish over so many windows, what makes anyone think with 3 or 4 days left we will suddenly bring in 3 or 4 players who will make the huge difference needed to rescue our season.

hibsbollah
28-08-2022, 07:20 AM
I didn't say they were good enough. Try reading my posts pal.

Whole team was awful. Why aren't there threads for Youan and Cabraja? Both were absolutely ***** today. Far worse than Newell.

Like you, ive stuck up for Newell in the past. He's capable of good things from time to time.
But this line of defence 'he wasnt as bad a player x or player y' just doesn't hold water anymore. He was woeful. The shot was a good effort, but it was remarkable only because its the kind of thing he does so rarely, and was so at odds with the rest of his performance.
You know why there isnt a thread for Cabraja, because he probably isnt 100% mentally for obvious reasons and you'd be a dick to call him out on that basis. And Youan has a bit of credit in the bank. Although he wasnt good yesterday either.
I've just completely run out of patience for Newell.

MWHIBBIES
28-08-2022, 07:25 AM
Like you, ive stuck up for Newell in the past. He's capable of good things from time to time.
But this line of defence 'he wasnt as bad a player x or player y' just doesn't hold water anymore. He was woeful. The shot was a good effort, but it was remarkable only because its the kind of thing he does so rarely, and was so at odds with the rest of his performance.
You know why there isnt a thread for Cabraja, because he probably isnt 100% mentally for obvious reasons and you'd be a dick to call him out on that basis. And Youan has a bit of credit in the bank. Although he wasnt good yesterday either.
I've just completely run out of patience for Newell.


Cabraja shouldn't be playing then because he cost us a goal. Give him the time he needs to deal with something far more important than his job.

Youan has been very very poor in our last 2 away games. Not looked like scoring in any game. Not sure I'm seeing what others are. He's not very good.

Him not being as bad as X or y does hold water when he's still the one entirely getting the ****ing blame again. Post after post on him. Every time. It's ridiculous. 11 guys failed yesterday, not 1.

Paulie Walnuts
28-08-2022, 07:33 AM
Cabraja shouldn't be playing then because he cost us a goal. Give him the time he needs to deal with something far more important than his job.

Youan has been very very poor in our last 2 away games. Not looked like scoring in any game. Not sure I'm seeing what others are. He's not very good.

Him not being as bad as X or y does hold water when he's still the one entirely getting the ****ing blame again. Post after post on him. Every time. It's ridiculous. 11 guys failed yesterday, not 1.

He’s not entirely getting the blame though, is he?

There’s a thread slaughtering Ian Gordon, a thread slaughtering Doidge, a thread slaughtering the whole midfield, you’re blaming Cabraja.

Joe Newell isn’t the only person carrying the can whether you claim it after every one of his terrible performances or not.

Chorley Hibee
28-08-2022, 07:34 AM
We've signed a raft of pish over so many windows, what makes anyone think with 3 or 4 days left we will suddenly bring in 3 or 4 players who will make the huge difference needed to rescue our season.

This, but no doubt we'll have some waxing lyrical about our latest youngster on loan from some English dross.


Same ****, different season.

B.H.F.C
28-08-2022, 07:52 AM
Cabraja shouldn't be playing then because he cost us a goal. Give him the time he needs to deal with something far more important than his job.

Youan has been very very poor in our last 2 away games. Not looked like scoring in any game. Not sure I'm seeing what others are. He's not very good.

Him not being as bad as X or y does hold water when he's still the one entirely getting the ****ing blame again. Post after post on him. Every time. It's ridiculous. 11 guys failed yesterday, not 1.

Newell gets more stick because he’s a constant. He’s been largely pish for ages but he’s in the team every single week.

Cabraja had a really poor game yesterday but that’s the first one and he’s only been here 6 weeks or something.

It was totally predictable what we’d see yesterday as soon as you saw the team. And that’s largely down to watching the likes of Newell produce the same over and over again.

Paulie Walnuts
28-08-2022, 07:57 AM
This, but no doubt we'll have some waxing lyrical about our latest youngster on loan from some English dross.


Same ****, different season.

It doesn’t say a lot for Kenneh that he appears to have been dropped.

WhileTheChief..
28-08-2022, 07:58 AM
It doesn’t say a lot for Kenneh that he appears to have been dropped.

At least he’s had a turn. We’ve signed players this window I’ve forgotten about already.