Saturday's ref

[hibbyboy1]

Willie collum. Game over

[JohnM1875]

Willie collum. Game over

I'm honestly beyond caring who the ref is now, makes no difference, think all of them are poor.

[H18 SFR]

I'm honestly beyond caring who the ref is now, makes no difference, think all of them are poor.

This is where I am at as well. Beaton wasn’t able to upset me, it’s expected in terms of their pishieness.

[Lago]

Bring Bobby back from England 😅

[oneone73]

Collum's ok. No more incompetent than the rest, and not biased.

[HH81]

Least it's not Walsh or Beaton. Them two are a disgrace.

[davhibby]

This is probably the happiest I’ve been with our referee appointments in the league so far. It’s actually got to the point where Collum is probably one of our better ones. He’ll most likely make a few poor decisions but they’ll go both ways.

[Mcbizz1998]

It really doesn’t matter. They are all as bad as each other.

[SteveHFC]

Rangers penalty and Porteous booking it is.

[JammyDoidger]

Least it's not Walsh or Beaton. Them two are a disgrace.

Agree, they two don't even try and hide their bias.

[JimBHibees]

Collum is poor doesn't understand the game imo and scared of giving anything against old firm apart from that ok :greengrin

[theonlywayisup]

It really doesn’t matter. They are all as bad as each other.

Sadly agree.

[donno]

Collum is just a **** ref, not biased IMHO. Lucky its not Beaton, who stops play every 2 seconds for minor infringements. As Souness would say - It's a man's game Beaton!

Sent from my JNY-LX1 using Tapatalk

[SMAXXA]

Always found it bizarre I thought Steven Maclean was our best ref then he got demoted and hasn’t came back since. Not only was he the cup final ref but I genuinely thought he was the best of a bad bunch.

[Gloucester Hibs]

Always found it bizarre I thought Steven Maclean was our best ref then he got demoted and hasn’t came back since. Not only was he the cup final ref but I genuinely thought he was the best of a bad bunch.

Me too. Think he reffed the last derby at the PBS and wasn’t great though. Beaton and Nick Walsh are the worst of the bunch by far.

[MWHIBBIES]

Always found it bizarre I thought Steven Maclean was our best ref then he got demoted and hasn’t came back since. Not only was he the cup final ref but I genuinely thought he was the best of a bad bunch.

Cup final clouded some judgement on here. He's always been awful. They all are.

[BS44]

I saw Collum, Beaton and another two who's names I can't remember up at Heriot Watt near end of July. Gave them a shout and asked if they could give Hibs more penalties this season, 3 a game would do, Collum said we had to get in the box first while his colleague said they only do top six games.

Pair of fuds!

[Broken Gnome]

https://youtu.be/WCcev3QGvRY&t=1m25s

[flash]

I saw Collum, Beaton and another two who's names I can't remember up at Heriot Watt near end of July. Gave them a shout and asked if they could give Hibs more penalties this season, 3 a game would do, Collum said we had to get in the box first while his colleague said they only do top six games.

Pair of fuds!
Pretty good retorts to be fair.

[BoomtownHibees]

I saw Collum, Beaton and another two who's names I can't remember up at Heriot Watt near end of July. Gave them a shout and asked if they could give Hibs more penalties this season, 3 a game would do, Collum said we had to get in the box first while his colleague said they only do top six games.

Pair of fuds!

Wow, refs with a sense of humour eh

[Steve20]

Rangers penalty and Porteous booking it is.

Porteous gets himself in enough trouble. I wouldn't always be blaming refs for his stupidity at times.

[hibbyboy1]

Like I said game over never a penalty. Cheating bassa

[Green_one]

Must be a record to send two of their players off without any compensating sending off.

Beginning to warm to him :wink:

[bordergreen]

Ref had a nightmare today, went in our favour for once. If their penalty was given, which was soft, the one on Bushiri by Tavernier was a definite penalty. Lundstram's red was a booking at most. Never a sending off. Andy Walker is a welt, can't see what the Morelos one was for... Aye right. That is a red every day of the week.

[lucky]

Collum got the Rangers penalty wrong after not giving the one on Rocky and then tried to make up for it with the first sending off. Morelos was a sending off everyday of the week. Overall Callum had a nightmare, why does every game have to be about him?

[LewysGot2]

Collum is poor doesn't understand the game imo and scared of giving anything against old firm apart from that ok :greengrin

Had his big boys pants on today in the 2nd half :greengrin

[cabbageandribs1875]

I saw Collum, Beaton and another two who's names I can't remember up at Heriot Watt near end of July. Gave them a shout and asked if they could give Hibs more penalties this season, 3 a game would do, Collum said we had to get in the box first while his colleague said they only do top six games.

Pair of fuds!


i laughed at that just now


and would have laughed at the time as well :greengrin