Maloney Must Stay

[Keith_M]

...for at least another season.


As is obvious by my constant moans on here about our results and performances since the New Year, I've been far from impressed with Maloney so far.

The thing is, I'm totally sick of us constantly changing managers and would much prefer to see him given a proper summer recruitment and a full season to show us what he can (or can't) do.


I realise my viewpoint might change by the end of today if we get totally humped but that's my current, fairly rational, opinion on the matter.

[SHODAN]

He can stay for at least another six hours.

[CL0762]

...for at least another season.


As is obvious by my constant moans on here about our results and performances since the New Year, I've been far from impressed with Maloney so far.

The thing is, I'm totally sick of us constantly changing managers and would much prefer to see him given a proper summer recruitment and a full season to show us what he can (or can't) do.


I realise my viewpoint might change by the end of today if we get totally humped but that's my current, fairly rational, opinion on the matter.

+1

[Paulie Walnuts]

...for at least another season.


As is obvious by my constant moans on here about our results and performances since the New Year, I've been far from impressed with Maloney so far.

The thing is, I'm totally sick of us constantly changing managers and would much prefer to see him given a proper summer recruitment and a full season to show us what he can (or can't) do.


I realise my viewpoint might change by the end of today if we get totally humped but that's my current, fairly rational, opinion on the matter.

Agree with the sentiment but not necessarily the length of time. Sacking him regardless of the result today would be ridiculous imo.

[McGruber]

He needs to win today, it's that simple.

If we get thumped there won't be many to show what he can do next season, attendances/season tickets will fall off a cliff

[JimboHibs]

He can stay for at least another six hours.

He's not going anywhere regardless of todays result.

[madhatter]

He can stay regardless of today's result if Ron Gordon is committed to his vision. Build a really strong B squad, fine, do it. Blend very talented youth into first team, fine, do it.

We've not done either yet to any acceptable level and that lack of delivery does not sit squarely with Maloney.

We need strong first team and B squads. That needs to happen during the summer. 4-5 quality players for each squad.

[Coco Bryce]

He's not going anywhere regardless of todays result.

You really don't know this.

[MWHIBBIES]

He's not going anywhere regardless of todays result.

Today will finish him. May not be immediate but he'll never recover the fans.

Needs to win.

[Is It On....]

I think will get the first round of fixtures next season and will need to get around 14 points if he is going to avoid an early exit.

[Golden Bear]

The ones that should go are the underperforming players who regularly throw in the towel when they go behind .

However that's for another day, united we stand , divided we fall.

' Mon the Hibees!

:flag::flag::flag:

[Iain G]

He's not going anywhere regardless of todays result.

And that is as it should be, he needs time to build his team.

[Hibs90]

Get him gone now, should be punted for that line up alone. That’s utterly abysmal.

[Aldo]

Teams up with Scott leading the line!

McGinn and Stevenson back in. Looks like back 3 with Lewis in the Middle


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[Pete]

Relax. This is our rope a dope plan with all the other forwards coming on in the second half once hearts are puggled.

Let's just get behind the team, eh? Even if Scott is in it.

[hibee-boys]

He can stay for at least another six hours.

Can’t see it being much longer than that🙈

[Silky]

Get him gone now, should be punted for that line up alone. That’s utterly abysmal.

Last week the spice boys were outplayed, out fought and completely bullied at Tynie. I think change was called for. He'd have been on more of a shoogley peg going with the same team from last week imo.

[Waxy]

We’ve moaned our way through every week of this season and it might end with is winning our fourth Scottish cup

[Coco Bryce]

Get him gone now, should be punted for that line up alone. That’s utterly abysmal.

It's a comlplete shocker.

He's taking the piss.

[Lago]

Get him gone now, should be punted for that line up alone. That’s utterly abysmal.
And your alternative would be?

[Golden Bear]

Last week the spice boys were outplayed, out fought and completely bullied at Tynie. I think change was called for. He'd have been on more of a shoogley peg going with the same team from last week imo.

Exactly. This could be the last throw of the dice but changes had to be made .

[Keith_M]

...for at least another season.


As is obvious by my constant moans on here about our results and performances since the New Year, I've been far from impressed with Maloney so far.

The thing is, I'm totally sick of us constantly changing managers and would much prefer to see him given a proper summer recruitment and a full season to show us what he can (or can't) do.


I realise my viewpoint might change by the end of today if we get totally humped but that's my current, fairly rational, opinion on the matter.



See, emotions play a large part in opinions as I'd already changed my mind when they scored their second.


😏

[Hibs90]

And your alternative would be?

That’s not my decision to make.

[Joe6-2]

...for at least another season.


As is obvious by my constant moans on here about our results and performances since the New Year, I've been far from impressed with Maloney so far.

The thing is, I'm totally sick of us constantly changing managers and would much prefer to see him given a proper summer recruitment and a full season to show us what he can (or can't) do.


I realise my viewpoint might change by the end of today if we get totally humped but that's my current, fairly rational, opinion on the matter.

I agree but it is difficult to watch right now

[DaveF]

I'd keep him. Whether his ambition and desire matches that of the hibs board is another matter.

[cameronw-hfc]

I've been a big defender of him, but that's sackable. Scott staying on as long as he did, 2 subs in the 90th minute, taking our best player in Stevenson off. He'll relegate us with that sort of decision making.

[Hibs90]

Bye Shaun

[heidtheba]

Keep him. First 20 aside, that wasn't a bad performance at all. We played better with ten men today, than we have in the games I've seen on TV.

[cameronw-hfc]

Keep him. First 20 aside, that wasn't a bad performance at all. We played better with ten men today, than we have in the games I've seen on TV.

It wasn't from the players no, it was from the manager. Baffling decision after baffling decision, I don't think he got one thing right.

[hibbytam]

I've been a big defender of him, but that's sackable. Scott staying on as long as he did, 2 subs in the 90th minute, taking our best player in Stevenson off. He'll relegate us with that sort of decision making.

I thought Scott had a decent game?

[cameronw-hfc]

I thought Scott had a decent game?

I think he's an alright player, never a striker. Doesn't make runs for crosses, in his season with us he hasn't come close to scoring, I can't even think of him missing many. He's never a striker and should never have been on up front alone for so long.

[Coach Jon]

Hearts will never play that badly and manage to win a game. Maloney looked lost for ideas out there. Clueless Caldwell in his ear to give him advice.
New coaches needed.

[GreenNWhiteArmy]

It wasn't from the players no, it was from the manager. Baffling decision after baffling decision, I don't think he got one thing right.

Starting lewy in centre mid worked

As did Hendo playing off Scott (who wasn't great but led the line as well as anyone else in our squad could have done)

[cameronw-hfc]

Starting lewy in centre mid worked

As did Hendo playing off Scott (who wasn't great but led the line as well as anyone else in our squad could have done)

Aye but taking Lewy off was baffling when he was our best player. And Scott up front on his own is about as little goal threat we can have

[Heisenberg]

Henderson looked way off the standard required to me. As did Scott. Lewy being subbed was the one for me, not a clue why he came off? He was our best player by a distance.

I thought we were better but that performance is a rarity under Maloney. He’s not going anywhere soon so have to just get on with it.

[Tambo]

The only thing I am worried about is who does Maloney expect to come into Hibs to make the style he wants to play work?

Would just like him to maybe switch it up now and again as most of the time his style is not working but we all hear he needs a certain type of player.

[Callum_62]

Henderson looked way off the standard required to me. As did Scott. Lewy being subbed was the one for me, not a clue why he came off? He was our best player by a distance.

I thought we were better but that performance is a rarity under Maloney. He’s not going anywhere soon so have to just get on with it.Your first 2 sentaces is literally the opposite of what I thought [emoji23]

Sent from my VOG-L29 using Tapatalk

[Allant1981]

Henderson looked way off the standard required to me. As did Scott. Lewy being subbed was the one for me, not a clue why he came off? He was our best player by a distance.

I thought we were better but that performance is a rarity under Maloney. He’s not going anywhere soon so have to just get on with it.

Henderson was one of, if not our best player today i thought

[sleeping giant]

Henderson looked way off the standard required to me. As did Scott. Lewy being subbed was the one for me, not a clue why he came off? He was our best player by a distance.

I thought we were better but that performance is a rarity under Maloney. He’s not going anywhere soon so have to just get on with it.

Thought Henderson was very decent.

[GreenNWhiteArmy]

Your first 2 sentaces is literally the opposite of what I thought [emoji23]

Sent from my VOG-L29 using Tapatalk

Can't be many that thought hendo looked poor surely. He was brilliant. Some of his touches and turns were lovely

[Bridge hibs]

Thought Henderson was very decent.Agree, bit more upper body strength and he will be a good one

[gerry]

hand in heart is maloney aggressive passionate knows what it takes to scrap battle dig in ? if you were a player looking at him respect and follow his football opinion? david gray is the option to end of season with darren helping ?

[Heisenberg]

Seems I’m well in the minority on Henderson 😂 He just seems way too slow and weak to me. Couple of good corners though.

I’m not having it with Scott. He tried but **** me he’s a poor footballer.

[Paulie Walnuts]

Your first 2 sentaces is literally the opposite of what I thought [emoji23]

Sent from my VOG-L29 using Tapatalk

Likewise and I’ve been highly critical of both of them. They both done very well imo.

[HibbyAndy]

Has Lewis Stevenson ever lost or shat out a 50/50 ? Brilliant performance , Gutted when he went off

[A Hi-Bee]

Henderson was one of, if not our best player today i thought

Correct, he played very well, Stevenson backed him up well until he started tiring second half, after putting in some shift.

[sleeping giant]

Need one more win the league. Hopefully get that early and then start shaping the team for next season in the last 4 games.

[overdrive]

Seems I’m well in the minority on Henderson 😂 He just seems way too slow and weak to me. Couple of good corners though.

I’m not having it with Scott. He tried but **** me he’s a poor footballer.

Nope I’m the same. That was probably the best he’s played for us today but it still isn’t anywhere near good enough!

[HendoDelivered]

Just heard he’s been sacked

[JimBHibees]

Agree, bit more upper body strength and he will be a good one

Agree alot of potential needs to bulk up but has alot of ability

[Allant1981]

Just heard he’s been sacked

Doubt it

[JimBHibees]

Just heard he’s been sacked

Surely not that would make no sense

[JimBHibees]

Has Lewis Stevenson ever lost or shat out a 50/50 ? Brilliant performance , Gutted when he went off

Guy is a legend why he wasnt playing last week I dont know

[B.H.F.C]

Surely not that would make no sense

I don’t think he will be but can’t say it wouldn’t make sense if he was.

Terrible record and lost the two season defining derbies. Played well today but there’s only one thing that matters.

[Allant1981]

Surely not that would make no sense

Maloney has pretty much just finished his interviews, its rubbish

[HendoDelivered]

Surely not that would make no sense

Folk on the train saying it’s on twitter but i can’t see it

[BT58]

Hendo and Lewis were best players today. Just a pity up top we wherent the best.
B

[weecounty hibby]

Folk on the train saying it’s on twitter but i can’t see it
On twitter!! Must be right enough then. I'm not seeing anything but I don't follow the most mental Hibs sites

[marinello59]

Folk on the train saying it’s on twitter but i can’t see it

If that’s your source you may get ripped a wee bit . :greengrin

[marinello59]

On twitter!! Must be right enough then. I'm not seeing anything but I don't follow the most mental Hibs sites

I just read it on here. :greengrin

[weecounty hibby]

I just read it on here. :greengrin
That seals it then!!!🤣

[tamig]

hand in heart is maloney aggressive passionate knows what it takes to scrap battle dig in ? if you were a player looking at him respect and follow his football opinion? david gray is the option to end of season with darren helping ?

Aye very good 😀

[tamig]

I thought Scott had a decent game?

He did. Anyone suggesting otherwise knows little about the game.

[tamig]

Hearts will never play that badly and manage to win a game. Maloney looked lost for ideas out there. Clueless Caldwell in his ear to give him advice.
New coaches needed.

You’re clearly the man Jon 👍

[OldEast]

Your first 2 sentaces is literally the opposite of what I thought [emoji23]

Sent from my VOG-L29 using Tapatalk

Me too. Had to read it twice.

[GRA]

Saw enough there to convince me he needs the summer to get his own team in and take it from there.
Plenty of grit, fight and battle today but still lacking the quality up front.

[TelaStella]

The desire we saw today came from the players on the pitch taking somewhat a responsibility, not from Maloney. If that’s down to his management then where was it first half? For me he takes no credibility for anything today. Failure to try and change the team mid 2nd half speaks volumes.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[Callum_62]

The desire we saw today came from the players on the pitch taking somewhat a responsibility, not from Maloney. If that’s down to his management then where was it first half? For me he takes no credibility for anything today. Failure to try and change the team mid 2nd half speaks volumes.


Sent from my iPhone using TapatalkLol. Not one sided at. All.

Presumably last weeks capitulation wasn't on Maloney at all either?

Sent from my VOG-L29 using Tapatalk

[TelaStella]

Lol. Not one sided at. All.

Presumably last weeks capitulation wasn't on Maloney at all either?

Sent from my VOG-L29 using Tapatalk

Missing your point?


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[Callum_62]

Missing your point?


Sent from my iPhone using TapatalkIf he had no influence on today's performance do you hold the same view on last week?

Sent from my VOG-L29 using Tapatalk

[J-C]

The desire we saw today came from the players on the pitch taking somewhat a responsibility, not from Maloney. If that’s down to his management then where was it first half? For me he takes no credibility for anything today. Failure to try and change the team mid 2nd half speaks volumes.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

By that reasoning the players are purely to blame for last week and every other game this season, so Ross should still be in place and not Maloney. Can we change a whole squad of players every season instead of the manager? There's a novel idea.

[TelaStella]

If he had no influence on today's performance do you hold the same view on last week?

Sent from my VOG-L29 using Tapatalk

Difference for me between today (2nd half) and last week was we showed the desire. My impression was that came from the players on the pitch. I think he takes responsibility for both the mess first half and last week yes. Opinions eh.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[hhibs]

Difference for me between today (2nd half) and last week was we showed the desire. My impression was that came from the players on the pitch. I think he takes responsibility for both the mess first half and last week yes. Opinions eh.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk


Pishing in the wind ,you are responding to someone who has just lost touch with the reality of the situation

[CL0762]

If he had no influence on today's performance do you hold the same view on last week?

Sent from my VOG-L29 using Tapatalk

Always the same, contrast that performance with the downed tools performances we got for JR’s last game.

That performance today tells me the players are on Maloney’s side, if they weren’t we’d see it a mile off.

[TheHarpy76]

He can resign asap!

[Ronniekirk]

I've been a big defender of him, but that's sackable. Scott staying on as long as he did, 2 subs in the 90th minute, taking our best player in Stevenson off. He'll relegate us with that sort of decision making.

Was baffled Stevenson went off and Campbell came on


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk