James Scott

[hibsquaker]

Needs a thread of his own. Why? How is he still here and why does he make the squad and get on the pitch? We have Connor Young scoring a hatrick the other week. I've never seen such a disinterested player. I'm sure today when a cross came in, he actually ducked, probably to avoid spoiling his hair!

An absolute imposter who shouldn't be anywhere near this great club.

[Mcbizz1998]

A few weeks ago, anyone who had a the audacity to point out this guy is a complete fraud was shouted down on here.

The guy is a complete joke and the fact he is still here is baffling.

[Libby Hibby]

He can get tae fu@£

[hhibs]

Needs a thread of his own. Why? How is he still here and why does he make the squad and get on the pitch? We have Connor Young scoring a hatrick the other week. I've never seen such a disinterested player. I'm sure today when a cross came in, he actually ducked, probably to avoid spoiling his hair!

An absolute imposter who shouldn't be anywhere near this great club.



Yes,agree completely.

Hull mugged us,do not think we we could send him back but why he is anywhere near the squad is beyond me .

[Booked4Being-Ugly]

One of the worst players I’ve ever seen in a Hibs shirt.

An embarrassment for a footballer. He’s the epitome of why we’ve found ourselves in the bottom 6. No heart, no desire, no ability, no fitness!

[superfurryhibby]

Yes,agree completely.

Hull mugged us,do not think we we could send him back but why he is anywhere near the squad is beyond me .

That’s more alarming than the ****ty loan deal we must have negotiated. The fact that this guy gets game time....holy ****.

[DaveF]

We must have signed up to the world's worst loan deal in taking him on. He is barely Sunday league standard.

[MWHIBBIES]

He'd absolutely be in contention for a worst ever Hibs 11. Maybe even our worst player ever. The fact he gets minutes over Hauge is frightening.

[Allant1981]

Would love to know what maloney thinks he offers

[hibsquaker]

I don't think I've ever seen a more ineffectual player. He's like playing with 10.

[Not In The Know]

I don't think I've ever seen a more ineffectual player. He's like playing with 10.
**** him. More worrying is that the boss plays him.

[Carheenlea]

Offered no indication of what he can bring to Hibs. Painful to watch. A disastrous signing. You can file Mueller away in the same box. Offers absolutely nothing of note. It’s turning into quite a big file.

[hibsquaker]

He must have it in his contract that he's guaranteed minutes or something. I can't think of anything else!

[California-Hibs]

It blows the mind how he is deemed good enough to come on in a derby and try to change the game.

[hibsquaker]

Offered no indication of what he can bring to Hibs. Painful to watch. A disastrous signing. You can file Mueller away in the same box. Offers absolutely nothing of note.

A least Mueller tries. However I agree, I fear he's not strong enough for this level. Same with Henderson.

[hibsquaker]

It blows the mind how he is deemed good enough to come on in a derby and try to change the game.

It is truely mind boggling

[NORTHERNHIBBY]

Looks like we signed this boy based on what he might be able to do rather than what he actually can do.

[Baader]

Should have had loan terminated with immediate effect when JR said he wasn't fit. Joke of a player.

[hibsquaker]

Should have had loan terminated with immediate effect when JR said he wasn't fit. Joke of a player.

Did they not perform a fitness test or watch him in the reserves? Baffling

[Unseen work]

Dome brilliant at Motherwell.

Got a big move to Hull.

Came here and initially started not bad (Dundee).

Got told he was unfit and wasn’t seen for months.

Done nothing in the 10-15 minutes he gets in every third game.

I half think he’s not good enough and half think what chance has he got when he’s playing so infrequently.

In either scenario though, being unfit is a disgrace.

Loan should have been terminated in January.

[allezsauzee]

Tom Soares looked like a grafter compared to this imposter. I'm puzzled as to why he's getting more game time than Scott Allan. Scotty undoubtedly lacks fitness but he still does much more and can play a killer pass.

[Nakedmanoncrack]

He's crap, but its not his fault the manager stubbornly insists on bringing him on every week regardless, the mind boggles as to what he thinks this utter imposter contributes.

[Alfred E Newman]

One of the worst players I’ve ever seen in a Hibs shirt.

An embarrassment for a footballer. He’s the epitome of why we’ve found ourselves in the bottom 6. No heart, no desire, no ability, no fitness!

To claim the accolade of “ worst ever Hibs player” is a feat in itself.
We have certainly had more than our fair share of absolute duffers over the years but there is no doubt James is right up there with the worst of them.

[Jones28]

Just **** off Scott, you have done nothing in a Hibs shirt. Vine, Zarabi, Scott, etc

[The Captain....]

Offered no indication of what he can bring to Hibs. Painful to watch. A disastrous signing. You can file Mueller away in the same box. Offers absolutely nothing of note. It’s turning into quite a big file.Mueller in particular annoys me..he isn't good at anything, **** touch doesn't score, can't create, slow and lightweight. I better not see any of his ***** cod psychology tweets this week.

However Scott is in a whole different league of uselessness. It's actually incredible that he manages to contribute so little in his appearances. By far the worst player I've ever seen brought to the club..why he is persevered with is a question only the almighty might be able to answer. Maybe Mueller could ask him.

Sent from my SM-G996B using Tapatalk

[B.H.F.C]

James Scott is pish. But a like for like swap with Melkersen was madness. Neither had a chance on their own. Just play them together. Taking one player off who has had no impact, no support and whatever else to replace him with another to do the exact same is idiotic.

[hibsquaker]

Just **** off Scott, you have done nothing in a Hibs shirt. Vine, Zarabi, Scott, etc

Vine was twice the player Scott is!

[Ivan_Sproule]

I think there must be a clause in the loan agreement that Hibs pay a fee if he doesn't hit a certain number of appearances.

Maybe Maloney been promised this fee in his transfer budget if he avoids it.

That's my conspiracy theory anyway.

[hibeerealist]

Needs a thread of his own. Why? How is he still here and why does he make the squad and get on the pitch? We have Connor Young scoring a hatrick the other week. I've never seen such a disinterested player. I'm sure today when a cross came in, he actually ducked, probably to avoid spoiling his hair!

An absolute imposter who shouldn't be anywhere near this great club.

You have to wonder who made the decision that this guy would be a good loan deal for Hibs, what did they see that we cannot?

What makes the whole thing much worse is we pay Hull over £5k A WEEK for this joker.

[Smartie]

He'd absolutely be in contention for a worst ever Hibs 11. Maybe even our worst player ever. The fact he gets minutes over Hauge is frightening.

Yep.

He’s now got a handful of games against poor opposition to avoid being our worst ever.

Right now it’s between him and Rowan Vine.

Close call.

Obviously it’s REALLY not worked out but based on pedigree etc I can see why Hibs signed him.

It’s just that he looks like he ate the player that terrorised Tom James at Fir Park that time.

Tbh, I’ve been wondering if that made Tom James even worse than we thought he was.

[allezsauzee]

You have to wonder who made the decision that this guy would be a good loan deal for Hibs, what did they see that we cannot?

What makes the whole thing much worse is we pay Hull over £5k A WEEK for this joker.

If this is true, then whoever signed off on that should have been sacked by September.

[hibbyfraelibby]

If he is the answer what the French Connection UK was the question

[A Hi-Bee]

Pass

[Alfred E Newman]

You have to wonder who made the decision that this guy would be a good loan deal for Hibs, what did they see that we cannot?

What makes the whole thing much worse is we pay Hull over £5k A WEEK for this joker.

Maybe the same guy that thought bringing Mueller over the pond was a good idea.

[Vault Boy]

If this is true, then whoever signed off on that should have been sacked by September.

I believe Jack Ross was personally very keen on him and pushed for the signing. So it wasn't quite by September, but not much longer. I was reasonably excited at first, but it really has been a disaster of a signing.

[hibsquaker]

Where was the due diligence?

[MWHIBBIES]

Yep.

He’s now got a handful of games against poor opposition to avoid being our worst ever.

Right now it’s between him and Rowan Vine.

Close call.

Obviously it’s REALLY not worked out but based on pedigree etc I can see why Hibs signed him.

It’s just that he looks like he ate the player that terrorised Tom James at Fir Park that time.

Tbh, I’ve been wondering if that made Tom James even worse than we thought he was.

Tom James had more ability in his left foot than Scott has ever shown here.

[Pretty Boy]

Drive him back to Hull then drop him in the Humber. ****ing hopeless and a lazy **** who couldn't care less into the bargain.

[Onceinawhile]

Drive him back to Hull then drop him in the Humber. ****ing hopeless and a lazy **** who couldn't care less into the bargain.

Whys he still in the squad? Is it because the 18s played last night?

He won't be here next summer. Drop him and get laidlaw or O'connor in.

[Mikey_1875]

Challenging Kuqi and Vine for our worst ever striker. It takes a special effort to be that ineffective.

[Nicho87]

Like our season.

Started with optimism

Quickly went backwards

[Bobby's Cinema]

Awful. Contributed ZERO since arriving. Not sure the guy has even had a shot since he came in.
What's the point in him being here? Just another body. We will be well rid.

[truehibernian]

Drive him back to Hull then drop him in the Humber. ****ing hopeless and a lazy **** who couldn't care less into the bargain.

He’s a Junior footballer at best. And that’s being kind to him.

[GRA]

How on earth did he manage to get a contract at Hull? At least Vine was punted after a couple of months, Scott is on a par with him in terms of impact and he's still getting gametime! Shocking player.

[Alfred E Newman]

Tom James had more ability in his left foot than Scott has ever shown here.

Sid James had more ability.

[truehibernian]

Sid James had more ability.

Wendy James offered more up top !

[snedzuk]

Yep.

He’s now got a handful of games against poor opposition to avoid being our worst ever.

Right now it’s between him and Rowan Vine.

Close call.

Obviously it’s REALLY not worked out but based on pedigree etc I can see why Hibs signed him.

It’s just that he looks like he ate the player that terrorised Tom James at Fir Park that time.

Tbh, I’ve been wondering if that made Tom James even worse than we thought he was.

Ill see your Rowan Vine with a Josh Vela

[CL0762]

I think there must be a clause in the loan agreement that Hibs pay a fee if he doesn't hit a certain number of appearances.

Maybe Maloney been promised this fee in his transfer budget if he avoids it.

That's my conspiracy theory anyway.

That has to be a reason. It’s the only explanation.

It actually makes me angry watching him attempt to run about wearing that badge on his chest.

[LaMotta]

He's crap, but its not his fault the manager stubbornly insists on bringing him on every week regardless, the mind boggles as to what he thinks this utter imposter contributes.

This. Maloney is a disgrace for picking him.

[Stubbsy90+2]

If we got relegated then he’d probably be in the same bracket as Rowan Vine.

As he’s done nothing to help us avoid being relegated I’d happily stick him in that bracket anyway.

[Heisenberg]

Mental that he was our big signing in the summer to help out Doidge and Nisbet. Rowan Vine levels of ***** from him since his debut. More interested in living like a footballer than actually being one.

[NAE NOOKIE]

He's crap, but its not his fault the manager stubbornly insists on bringing him on every week regardless, the mind boggles as to what he thinks this utter imposter contributes.

Absolutely. In the end it doesn't matter a rats arse why he doesn't perform, in every single minute he has played for Hibs his affect on the game has been absolutely nil. We have three youngsters in the under 20s who score goals, even if they are given the step up and minutes on the pitch from the bench and contribute absolutely nothing they will still have had the same impact as James bloody Scott ... in view of that why the hell not give them a shot?

[Stubbsy90+2]

Can I just say, I’d fully back people booing him in the post split fixtures.

It’s time we let the club know guys like him are miles off the standard required.

[IberianHibernian]

Can I just say, I’d fully back people booing him in the post split fixtures.

It’s time we let the club know guys like him are miles off the standard required.Pretty sure manager and coaching staff will be aware of how much or little he`s contributing to team .
Why boo a player who`s struggling at a time when team might need extra support ?

[Stubbsy90+2]

Pretty sure manager and coaching staff will be aware of how much or little he`s contributing to team .
Why boo a player who`s struggling at a time when team might need extra support ?

We signed him. Since then he keeps getting minutes. So im not so sure they are aware.

He’s about the worst player I’ve seen at Hibs in a decade in terms of both application and ability.

[green with envy]

Has to be one of the most ineffective players to ever play for Hibs in my 50 years as a H&A supporter.

[thebausburst]

Offered no indication of what he can bring to Hibs. Painful to watch. A disastrous signing. You can file Mueller away in the same box. Offers absolutely nothing of note. It’s turning into quite a big file.

Agree with this Mueller is absolutely rank, does zero, game passes him by, how poor must the standard be in the MLS if he was considered good

[Callum_62]

Can I just say, I’d fully back people booing him in the post split fixtures.

It’s time we let the club know guys like him are miles off the standard required.I've just watched the highlights of the Everton vs man u game

Everton struggling big time. Last won 6 weeks ago and Goodison looked bouncing

Over at Easter Road we are asking fans to boo our players during the game

[emoji849]



Sent from my VOG-L29 using Tapatalk

[Stubbsy90+2]

I've just watched the highlights of the Everton vs man u game

Everton struggling big time. Last won 6 weeks ago and Goodison looked bouncing

Over at Easter Road we are asking fans to boo our players during the game

[emoji849]



Sent from my VOG-L29 using Tapatalk

Everton have something to play for.

Realistically, we don’t. Having seen us give four year deals to guys like Campbell I’d have absolutely no issue with fans making it absolutely clear we don’t want the likes of James Scott getting a contract here.

[Callum_62]

Everton have something to play for.

Realistically, we don’t. Having seen us give four year deals to guys like Campbell I’d have absolutely no issue with fans making it absolutely clear we don’t want the likes of James Scott getting a contract here.We have to avoid a playoff place for a start



Sent from my VOG-L29 using Tapatalk

[kaimendhibs]

He is awful, but Ive never booed a hibs player.

[Stubbsy90+2]

We have to avoid a playoff place for a start



Sent from my VOG-L29 using Tapatalk

Mathematically, yes.

Realistically, our season will be over if we get beat next week.

I have absolutely no issues with our fans making it blatantly clear we don’t want imposters like this at our club next year.

[Callum_62]

Mathematically, yes.

Realistically, our season will be over if we get beat next week.

I have absolutely no issues with our fans making it blatantly clear we don’t want imposters like this at our club next year.What a way to sell new signings to our club

Won't be asking them to come to the game before the inks dry hopefully

Sent from my VOG-L29 using Tapatalk

[Stubbsy90+2]

What a way to sell new signings to our club

Won't be asking them to come to the game before the inks dry hopefully

Sent from my VOG-L29 using Tapatalk

I’ll worry about new signings once I stop worrying about the dross we have here just now tbh.

[Callum_62]

I’ll worry about new signings once I stop worrying about the dross we have here just now tbh.Being blunt its not only poor it adds absolutely nothing to the team by booing a player - nevermind doing it when the games being played

Its counter productive and probably goes to hinder the team and individual even more

Sent from my VOG-L29 using Tapatalk

[mokie]

He'd absolutely be in contention for a worst ever Hibs 11. Maybe even our worst player ever. The fact he gets minutes over Hauge is frightening.


along with your mate Hanlon. Another cracking performance from captain marvel.

[MWHIBBIES]

along with your mate Hanlon. Another cracking performance from captain marvel.

Yes, a scottish cup winner with 500 games would make our worst 11. Good patter. Club legend.

[the_ginger_hibee]

Yes, a scottish cup winner with 500 games would make our worst 11. Good patter. Club legend.

The Scottish cup win was a sequence of just 5 ties.

Why is that so much more important than a relegation? Our worst derby defeats ever? Our lowest league finishes ever?

Just because we finally won the cup, it doesn't say anything about the ability of Paul Hanlon right now.

Just like playing 500 games isn't either. He may have played 500 games as a stand-out (he didn't) but that means nothing for game 501.

We can't keep players on emotion or sentiment alone.

[MWHIBBIES]

The Scottish cup win was a sequence of just 5 ties.

Why is that so much more important than a relegation? Our worst derby defeats ever? Our lowest league finishes ever?

Just because we finally won the cup, it doesn't say anything about the ability of Paul Hanlon.

Just like playing 500 games isn't either. He may have played 500 games as a stand-out (he didn't) but that means nothing for game 501.

We can't keep players on emotion or sentiment alone.

I agree. Thankfully Paul is still a good player at this level. Our cup win in 2016 is far, far more important than anything negative that has happened in this time. Best day of our life's. In 50 years I won't give a **** about anything negative that he was here for. I'll remember our cup win. That's what sticks.

[the_ginger_hibee]

I agree. Thankfully Paul is still a good player at this level. Our cup win in 2016 is far, far more important than anything negative that has happened in this time. Best day of our life's. In 50 years I won't give a **** about anything negative that he was here for. I'll remember our cup win. That's what sticks.

What does your experience in 2016 say about Paul Hanlon's ability today?

Absolutely nothing.

[JamesHFC]

Poor signing alongside Wood. Mackay also brought in who like many of our signings got injured and then sent out on loan and can hardly get a game in the championship.

Summer transfer window was awful. Followed by January where we sold our best player and brought in a bunch of youngsters.

Recruitment a major part of our downfall this season.

[MWHIBBIES]

What does your experience in 2016 say about Paul Hanlon's ability today?

Absolutely nothing.

No.. The part where I said I think he's still a good player is what I said about his ability.

[the_ginger_hibee]

No.. The part where I said I think he's still a good player is what I said about his ability.

Based on what though? In two weeks he's made two goal-costing mistakes at least.

[MWHIBBIES]

Based on what though? In two weeks he's made two goal-costing mistakes at least.

He joins the rest of our defenders in that regard then.

[Callum_62]

Based on what though? In two weeks he's made two goal-costing mistakes at least.He got out muscled by a big centre forward then JDH shat the bed, I'd blame JDH far more than Hanlon for hearts first today

Sent from my VOG-L29 using Tapatalk

[MWHIBBIES]

Based on what though? In two weeks he's made two goal-costing mistakes at least.

He joins the rest of our defenders in that regard then.

[SteveHFC]

The worst player i’ve seen play for Hibs in a long time.

[cabbageandribs1875]

booing our players :rolleyes:jesus wept, by all means call a player rank but to boo one of our players wearing our club colours...gtf

and i hope our captain doesn't read the forums

[Ronniekirk]

booing our players :rolleyes:jesus wept, by all means call a player rank but to boo one of our players wearing our club colours...gtf

and i hope our captain doesn't read the forums

Scott isn’t our player and has shown a complete disregard for the club by training with us snd getting more unfit
He has done nothing of any note when brought on
He rightly won’t be here next season so why include him when a hungry youngster could get the chance
Just don’t see the point and it can’t add to any harmony in the camp as other professional players probably share our view
Off topic I know but Scott Allan had options to move in last transfer window Why didn’t Maloney let him and bring someone else in as he has hardly used him


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[cabbageandribs1875]

Scott isn’t our player and has shown a complete disregard for the club by training with us snd getting more unfit
He has done nothing of any note when brought on
He rightly won’t be here next season so why include him when a hungry youngster could get the chance
Just don’t see the point and it can’t add to any harmony in the camp as other professional players probably share our view
Off topic I know but Scott Allan had options to move in last transfer window Why didn’t Maloney let him and bring someone else in as he has hardly used him


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk


and thank goodness :greengrinbut, when he puts that shirt on.....booing him(or any other player) won't improve performances :(

[Ronniekirk]

and thank goodness :greengrinbut, when he puts that shirt on.....booing him(or any other player) won't improve performances :(

You will note I didn’t condone the booing I do do that at the end of a match if it’s been a particularly inept performance as a way of venting my frustration but would never do it during a game


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[cabbageandribs1875]

You will note I didn’t condone the booing I do do that at the end of a match if it’s been a particularly inept performance as a way of venting my frustration but would never do it during a game


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk


and you will note i didn't even mention you condoning the booing of our players :confused:


glad we're on the same page :)

[LaMotta]

Tom James had more ability in his left foot than Scott has ever shown here.

Tom James was shocking for Hibs, way out his depth. Scott might just be worse.

[McGruber]

Maloney gives Scott game time.

He signs Bushiri as his number 1 target.

Rates Campbell highly

Worked with Henderson at Celtic, brings him in and doesn't play him - probably because he is a bit too physically weak and immobile for midfield despite his passing/deadball ability

Some say give Maloney the summer window to bring in his own players,....

[we are hibs]

He has contributed about the same as Phil Airey since he arrived. Only difference is Phil Airey was here about 20 minutes and this joker has not only somehow made it beyond January but also still getting any form of gametime for the first team.

Sent from my SM-G935F using Tapatalk

[delbert]

I don't think I've ever seen a more ineffectual player. He's like playing with 10.

James Scott and Joe Ward, a strike force guaranteed to go an entire season without scoring, although at present Christian Doidge would be challenging for either of their places !

[Coco Bryce]

As part of his loan deal, Scott has it in his contract that he has to play so many games to keep fit and keep him in the shop window for any potential buyers. The irony...

[loanheadhibby]

As part of his loan deal, Scott has it in his contract that he has to play some many games to keep fit and keep him in the shop window for any potential buyers. The irony...

What’s worrying for Scott is where does he go next? He looks like an Alloa player. Hull will surely be wanting shot of him?

He’s had a great chance to show what he can do this season and he’s failed miserably.

[Stubbsy90+2]

What’s worrying for Scott is where does he go next? He looks like a Alloa player. Hull will surely be wanting shot of him?

He’s had a great chance to show what he can do this season and he’s failed miserably.

Was there not a threat from the Hull manager that he’d be recalling him in January if he was doing well :faf:

[Coco Bryce]

What’s worrying for Scott is where does he go next? He looks like a Alloa player. Hull will surely be wanting shot of him?

He’s had a great chance to show what he can do this season and he’s failed miserably.

They are and where hoping someone would buy him while playing for us.

He's the worst player I've seen at Hibs in my life and that's saying something.

[loanheadhibby]

Was there not a threat from the Hull manager that he’d be recalling him in January if he was doing well :faf:

He must have something tho if Hull signed him in the 1st place?

To be fair the lad is getting pelters on here but he can’t carry the can for yesterday or us failing to get top 6. That lies heavily on the whole squad, current manager & previous manager.

[we are hibs]

He must have something tho if Hull signed him in the 1st place?




Aye a good agent.



Sent from my SM-G935F using Tapatalk

[hibbyfraelibby]

Mathematically, yes.

Realistically, our season will be over if we get beat next week.

I have absolutely no issues with our fans making it blatantly clear we don’t want imposters like this at our club next year.

We are only 8 points clear of 11th with 5 games to play. We need 3 wins. We have 1 in 15. Deja Vu

[Stokesy's on fire]

We are only 8 points clear of 11th with 5 games to play. We need 3 wins. We have 1 in 15. Deja Vu

This

Sack the manager now and get someone in until the end of the season to steer us clear of relegation

[Stokesy's on fire]

He must have something tho if Hull signed him in the 1st place?

To be fair the lad is getting pelters on here but he can’t carry the can for yesterday or us failing to get top 6. That lies heavily on the whole squad, current manager & previous manager.


Frances Jeffers rings a bell he was once worth a lot of money but turned out to be a total flop.

[Sean1875]

Genuinely putting him in the ‘Rowan Vine’ category of strikers, which I never thought I’d ever do. Just awful.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[Ronniekirk]

As part of his loan deal, Scott has it in his contract that he has to play so many games to keep fit and keep him in the shop window for any potential buyers. The irony...

Well bring him on as a sub with a few minutes to go if That’s the case as he ain’t doing anything to put himself in the shop window ( in fact he should become a dummy if he wants to do that ffs )


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[jacomo]

As part of his loan deal, Scott has it in his contract that he has to play so many games to keep fit and keep him in the shop window for any potential buyers. The irony...


Hibs shouldn’t be agreeing clauses like this. Terrible if that’s the case.

[Northernhibee]

Genuinely putting him in the ‘Rowan Vine’ category of strikers, which I never thought I’d ever do. Just awful.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

I remember Rowan Vine hit the post with a twenty yarder once. That alone puts him above James Scott.

[Coco Bryce]

Hibs shouldn’t be agreeing clauses like this. Terrible if that’s the case.

I thinks it's common for loan deals.

The whole part of them is to keep them fit as they aren't getting a game at their current team. Clubs don't want their players back unfit and in bad shape.

Ironic as I said in Scott's case.

[GreenCastle]

I just don’t understand what position he actually plays.

He doesn’t score goals.
He doesn’t assist.
He rarely wins a header.
Doesn’t beat a player.

What actually does he contribute.

Rowan Vine was worst Hibs player I’ve seen. Scott is a close 2nd.

[WestStandWillie]

James Scott is one of those players who will sod off down south again after the loan has finished, sign for Tranmere and score every other week. We’ll then get posts about his goal scoring exploits and wonder if we were too harsh on him.

[LewysGot2]

James Collins vibe

[overdrive]

James Collins vibe

Nah at least he ran about like a headless chicken. I don’t think Scott is even capable of running.

[Tully]

Nah at least he ran about like a headless chicken. I don’t think Scott is even capable of running.

Did he actually touch the ball yesterday

[Diclonius]

I have to admit, he is verging on Vine/Collins levels of greatness now.

[Green-Hibee-7]

He’s shown absolutely zero in his time here but he is also the least of our worries to be honest.

[Onceinawhile]

I have to admit, he is verging on Vine/Collins levels of greatness now.

Collins scored in a Derby win at least.

Utterly terrible player, but James Scott has miles to go to be anywhere near as good as him for us.

[hibee-boys]

He’s shown absolutely zero in his time here but he is also the least of our worries to be honest.

Yip, I’m more concerned about the performance of the players that are spending the vast majority of the 90mins on the pitch not someone that’s been getting 10-15mins every 2nd week. I guess he’s an east target because he’s on loan or not a ‘hibs’ man. I agree that he’s looked poor but there are people who’ve played 4 or 5 times more football than him that have been equally as ineffective.

[hibsquaker]

He's at another stratosphere of sh#teness. He couldn't lace Collins' boots. Vine was crap but not at Scott's level. Whoever was involved in signing him should already be sacked.

The problem for us fans is that we expect at least for a player to care, put himself about and try. Collins did that. This boy is more interested in his hair. Substitutions are very important and even if he comes on for 10 minutes he must put in a shift otherwise we are down to ten. Baffling why he was brought on when we needed energy and commitment to get back in the game.

[hibee1875]

Was there not a threat from the Hull manager that he’d be recalling him in January if he was doing well :faf:

I think they were trying to panic us into buying him. They’ve lost a fortune on a dud. Has the physic to make it down south and showed promise at Motherwell.

Then saw the cash rolling into his bank and he thinks he’s made it. He’ll get a shock when he’s back on 80% of what Hulls paying him

[hibee1875]

He must have something tho if Hull signed him in the 1st place?

To be fair the lad is getting pelters on here but he can’t carry the can for yesterday or us failing to get top 6. That lies heavily on the whole squad, current manager & previous manager.

He’s a big part of the problem tho. He’s here to provide goals. How many times has he come on as a sub and barely had a touch?

[MWHIBBIES]

Collins was poor in a poor Hibs side, but has had a very good career. Not a chance in hell Scott achieves 1/10th of what Collins did.

[Since90+2]

We are only 8 points clear of 11th with 5 games to play. We need 3 wins. We have 1 in 15. Deja Vu

We need 1 win not 3. St Johnstone are not going to get more than 11 points in 5 games.

[jacomo]

I remember Rowan Vine hit the post with a twenty yarder once. That alone puts him above James Scott.


Yup, the opposition could all sit down on the grass and the referee announce 30mins of injury time and I still wouldn’t put money on James Scott scoring a goal.

[James70]

Regarding loan deals and having to give players game time, I know Tait is currently injured but neither him or Mackay seem to have been near Kilmarnock's team other than sitting on the bench.

[Steven79]

Regarding loan deals and having to give players game time, I know Tait is currently injured but neither him or Mackay seem to have been near Kilmarnock's team other than sitting on the bench.

Six figures for both.

Not as if that money couldn't have been spent on the here and now instead as it would have paid for itself if we had finished in the top six.

[1959 Hibby]

Forget Roman Vine: for me James Scott is possibly the worst Hibs striker since Ally Scott back in the 70s

[Diclonius]

Collins scored in a Derby win at least.

Wait a minute.

We're playing in a derby on Saturday!

Yesssssssssssssssssssssss!

[A Hi-Bee]

Forget Roman Vine: for me James Scott is possibly the worst Hibs striker since Ally Scott back in the 70s

That takes some doing, but think you may be correct.

[eastterrace]

That takes some doing, but think you may be correct.think your being a tad harsh on ally scott at least he scored a few goals for us. I would have preferred you said joe ward, now he was really pish.

[hibbydog]

Fat and sh@@te

He can do one

[Onion]

This

Sack the manager now and get someone in until the end of the season to steer us clear of relegation

Think Ron's already played that card.

Sacking Jack Ross was never the problem, making sure we brought in someone better was always the key appointment.

[Onion]

Watching James Scott come on as sub is a heart sinking experience and a sure sign the game is gone. But it's not his fault, or Malloney's for that matter. This all comes back to the owner and key decision maker. Everything filters down from his decisions and I'm starting to think he doesn't actually know what the Hell he's doing.

[LaMotta]

Watching James Scott come on as sub is a heart sinking experience and a sure sign the game is gone. But it's not his fault, or Malloney's for that matter. This all comes back to the owner and key decision maker. Everything filters down from his decisions and I'm starting to think he doesn't actually know what the Hell he's doing.

It is Maloney's fault though, he keeps putting him on despite the fact he has shown himself to be nothing other than hopeless. He also kept him in January presumably on the basis of what he had seen in training - really worrying decision making from SM. You are so right about it being a heart sinking experience when you see him about to come on - I've rarely felt about a player like that.

[hibee1875]

It is Maloney's fault though, he keeps putting him on despite the fact he has shown himself to be nothing other than hopeless. He also kept him in January presumably on the basis of what he had seen in training - really worrying decision making from SM. You are so right about it being a heart sinking experience when you see him about to come on - I've rarely felt about a player like that.

Only Maloneys fault if he’s playing him when he doesn’t have to. Different story if he’s contractually obliged.

[LaMotta]

Only Maloneys fault if he’s playing him when he doesn’t have to. Different story if he’s contractually obliged.

Well yes, but as far as I'm aware that's only a rumour on here and it sounds pretty far fetched. If it was true why did Jack Ross never play him?

[Franck Stanton]

The only way that imposter gets to pull a hib s to On is if he goes to the shop & buys one.
You could honestly pick someone, anyone, out of the crowd & you would get more fight commitment & passing than he has shown since his arrival. Get him to f out of my club. Useless wan ker

[Mcbizz1998]

If there is one silver lining to a derby defeat it’s that it seems to have focussed the collective mind of hibs.net to see this guy is a huddy.

[Carheenlea]

He won’t start next week, but very good chance he’ll be on the pitch at the full time whistle. All square after extra time, penalties, sudden death, Hearts miss, score the next one we’re through, James Scott marches up…

[MWHIBBIES]

Only Maloneys fault if he’s playing him when he doesn’t have to. Different story if he’s contractually obliged.

Not the case. He's been unused many times.

[hibsquaker]

He won’t start next week, but very good chance he’ll be on the pitch at the full time whistle. All square after extra time, penalties, sudden death, Hearts miss, score the next one we’re through, James Scott marches up…

Just don't, please no!!!

[Jones28]

If there is one silver lining to a derby defeat it’s that it seems to have focussed the collective mind of hibs.net to see this guy is a huddy.

I dont think there was any doubt that he offers nothing, has offered nothing and will offer nothing in his Hibs career.

Maloney would be as well throwing a white hankey on the pitch when he tells Scott to get stripped.

[hibee1875]

Not the case. He's been unused many times.

Yes but how do we not know he has say the last 5 games to get the remaining x appearances in to not break the contract?

[hibsquaker]

If they have to bring him on, bring him on in injury time. Even if we'd used all our subs and got an injury we'd be better with 10 men.

[snedzuk]

Come on James- 21 years old - kick start you career.

[Callum_62]

I'd start him again next week

Sent from my VOG-L29 using Tapatalk

[Allant1981]

Actually thought he was ok today, not the quickest though so needs to play a bit higher up the park

[marinello59]

I'd start him again next week

Sent from my VOG-L29 using Tapatalk

Aye, he earned that today.

[Pete]

Great effort today and did really well up top holding things up 👏.

[at last 61]

Surprised a lot of people today, at least he gave his all, I will be a bigger man and say well done, James, well done

[A Hi-Bee]

Full marks today for a good shift, lacks a cutting edge but no ones saying he is a proven goalscorer.
he was a lot better than previous games.

[LaMotta]

Jesus ****in Christ. People praising Scott because he wasn't ****. How far we have fallen.

[Stokesy's on fire]

Full marks today for a good shift, lacks a cutting edge but no ones saying he is a proven goalscorer.
he was a lot better than previous games.

The whole point of a striker is goals...he is crap and hopefully he wont be back when his loan deal ends

[Callum_62]

Jesus ****in Christ. People praising Scott because he wasn't ****. How far we have fallen.He contributed to us having the ability to keep hearts penned in for pretty much the whole 2nd half

He wasn't just not ***** as you so eloquently put it but considering his lack of game time he was pretty effective in helping the team get up the park

Sent from my VOG-L29 using Tapatalk

[A Hi-Bee]

Jesus ****in Christ. People praising Scott because he wasn't ****. How far we have fallen.

If you remember Ally Scott at Hibs or back further wi Jim Blair, you would realise that we still have a long way to fall. you would have played who in his place?

[Eaststand]

Jesus ****in Christ. People praising Scott because he wasn't ****. How far we have fallen.

Yep, it really baffles me too. I can't wait to see him as far away from our club as possible as I genuinely can't think of a single good thing he did today, or over the season that's been worth a mention.

Lots of effort from him but he doesn't read the play too well, and overall there was nowt positive about his game all day.

GGTTH

[declan macmanus]

If we had Ellis Simms up front today we would have won at a canter.

Scott is nowhere near good enough.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk Pro

[Callum_62]

If we had Ellis Simms up front today we would have won at a canter.

Scott is nowhere near good enough.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk ProCan we bring you in Declan?

Sent from my VOG-L29 using Tapatalk

[Allant1981]

Jesus ****in Christ. People praising Scott because he wasn't ****. How far we have fallen.

So cant say someone has had a decent game because they have been poor previously, good one

[TelaStella]

Pace let him down today but there can’t be much else to fault him by. Whether we see him kick on somewhat from here remains to be seen.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[Gmack7]

Too little to late I'm afraid, can't fault his efforts today and had a decent game but he's been non existant otherwise, he won't be back next season

[Diclonius]

Thanks for actually bothering for once. Good luck back at Hull.

[GreenCastle]

Playing for a transfer - no way he stays at Hibs or Hull.

Still feel he could have blocked the free kick if he was on his toes and sharper - just throw your body at it.

Just not good enough for where we need to be. Plus strikers need to score the occasional goal for me.

[LaMotta]

He contributed to us having the ability to keep hearts penned in for pretty much the whole 2nd half

He wasn't just not ***** as you so eloquently put it but considering his lack of game time he was pretty effective in helping the team get up the park

Sent from my VOG-L29 using Tapatalk


If we had Ellis Simms up front today we would have won at a canter.

Scott is nowhere near good enough.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk Pro


So cant say someone has had a decent game because they have been poor previously, good one

He contributed to another Hibs failure. An insipid display that looked good for him only because he has previously been absolutely brutal for Hibs.

Really sad how some fans accept such pish playing for our club, and the manager making decisions to persist with them. Both Scott and Maloney will be gone soon - thank ****.

[Allant1981]

He contributed to another Hibs failure. An insipid display that looked good for him only because he has previously been absolutely brutal for Hibs.

Really sad how some fans accept such pish playing for our club, and the manager making decisions to persist with them. Both Scott and Maloney will be gone soon - thank ****.

Or sad that some fans cant see when someone has had a decent game because of previous poor performances

[LaMotta]

Or sad that some fans cant see when someone has had a decent game because of previous poor performances

He wasnt decent, he was totally average. Pathetic for a Hibs striker in a derby. You are one of the most clueless posters on here, still backing up hopeless huddies.

[Coach Jon]

Or sad that some fans cant see when someone has had a decent game because of previous poor performances

No, its sad that with his previous performances he has set the bar so low to the stage where he is being praised for running about and kicking a few of the opposition without making any meaningful contribution on the football side of things.

[loanheadhibby]

He wasnt decent, he was totally average. Pathetic for a Hibs striker in a derby. You are one of the most clueless posters on here, still backing up hopeless huddies.

Bang on. We sign Scott and they signed Simms.

Who impacted the game?

[Allant1981]

He wasnt decent, he was totally average. Pathetic for a Hibs striker in a derby. You are one of the most clueless posters on here, still backing up hopeless huddies.

Yip im clueless, pot, kettle, black springs to mind

[LaMotta]

Bang on. We sign Scott and they signed Simms.

Who impacted the game?

:agree::agree::agree: What is worse is that the manager actually decided to keep him in January, and has continually given him minutes on the pitch since.

[Chorley Hibee]

He wasnt decent, he was totally average. Pathetic for a Hibs striker in a derby. You are one of the most clueless posters on here, still backing up hopeless huddies.

Said this earlier in the season when folk were praising Wright.


These folk are so bad that the most average of performances is praised by a section of the support as some sort of achievement.

Another two windows of dross sowed the seeds of defeat for today.

[wookie70]

Scott had his best game for Hibs today. Worked hard, held it up pretty well when we got it up to him and made lots of decent runs. Absolutely no goal threat though and Melkerson managed more goal threat in his very short spell on the pitch.

[Lago]

He wasnt decent, he was totally average. Pathetic for a Hibs striker in a derby. You are one of the most clueless posters on here, still backing up hopeless huddies.
Well your not far been him.

[LaMotta]

Said this earlier in the season when folk were praising Wright.


These folk are so bad that the most average of performances is praised by a section of the support as some sort of achievement.

Another two windows of dross sowed the seeds of defeat for today.

The funny thing is you've got Hibs fans coming on here thinking they are intellctually superior fans or hold some kind of moral high ground for backing these guys, despite how **** they are on a consistent basis.

[LaMotta]

Well your not far been him.

Hahaha nice attempt at a sentence.

[loanheadhibby]

:agree::agree::agree: What is worse is that the manager actually decided to keep him in January, and has continually given him minutes on the pitch since.

Another reason to get shot of Maloney. Signed Rocky and kept Scott. He’s not got much of an eye for a player.

Hence we went old school today as could not rely on the dross brought in during January window.

[LaMotta]

Another reason to get shot of Maloney. Signed Rocky and kept Simms. He’s not got much of an eye for a player.

Hence we went old school today as could not rely on the dross brought in during January window.

Absolutely mate.

[GreenCastle]

Bang on. We sign Scott and they signed Simms.

Who impacted the game?

They signed Simms an Sibbick who all started today. Atkinson came on.

Simms scoring this week and was a pain last week.

We signed Henderson and Clarke who started today.

Melkerson, Jasper and Mueller all came on and didn't get much time or do much when they came on.

Our recruitment has been woeful.

[GRA]

Scott had his best game for Hibs today. Worked hard, held it up pretty well when we got it up to him and made lots of decent runs. Absolutely no goal threat though and Melkerson managed more goal threat in his very short spell on the pitch.

Exactly this. I've slated him in the past but was his best performance this season. Where has that effort been all season?

[Ronniekirk]

Agree he played his part today


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[Wilson]

Agree he played his part today


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

Played his part in...

[MWHIBBIES]

He put in the minimum today. Nothing more. Their forward actually done a bit

Scott has been an utter disgrace all season. Would certainly make a worst ever Hibs 11. Honestly can't stand him. Can't wait till he's gone.

[cameronw-hfc]

Think there's a player in there but he's never a striker. Best form came as a winger for Motherwell. Might be nit picking but was right peeved off when he was smiling as he came off.

We were 2-1 to our rivals in a semi final, wtf does he have to smile about?

[Mainstandman]

Played his part in...

Running aboot!!

[Ronniekirk]

Played his part in...

The game Who would you have played


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[Ronniekirk]

Running aboot!!

So who would you have played


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[Ronniekirk]

Exactly this. I've slated him in the past but was his best performance this season. Where has that effort been all season?

Some people seem incapable of acknowledging this


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[Lancs Harp]

It was his best game in a Hibs shirt but come on he's cleary not good enough for where we want to aspire to be surely? He's bang average at best (if that)

[hibsquaker]

So he is expected to get plaudits for contributing, whereas he normally contributes nothing. No there is not a player in there. Please!

[loanheadhibby]

Scott had his best game for Hibs today. Worked hard, held it up pretty well when we got it up to him and made lots of decent runs. Absolutely no goal threat though and Melkerson managed more goal threat in his very short spell on the pitch.
Am I being unfair in thinking he may have made a better effort in trying to block Hearts 2nd goal.
Happy to be told I'm talking rubbish.

[Scorrie]

Am I being unfair in thinking he may have made a better effort in trying to block Hearts 2nd goal.
Happy to be told I'm talking rubbish.

No, his attempt at closing down was poor and very half hearted. But overall I don’t think Scott was too bad today

[Potty78]

He put in the minimum today. Nothing more. Their forward actually done a bit

Scott has been an utter disgrace all season. Would certainly make a worst ever Hibs 11. Honestly can't stand him. Can't wait till he's gone.
Would make a worst hibs 11? I ok🤦*♂️

[B.H.F.C]

No, his attempt at closing down was poor and very half hearted. But overall I don’t think Scott was too bad today

Agree with this but that’s the problem eh. Just ran about a wee bit but contributed nothing in an attacking sense.

[Ronniekirk]

Am I being unfair in thinking he may have made a better effort in trying to block Hearts 2nd goal.
Happy to be told I'm talking rubbish.

Have you highlighted McGinn gifting the ball to simms for the first


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[B.H.F.C]

Would make a worst hibs 11? I ok🤦*♂️

A striker that has been here a year and not scored a goal.

He’s a good shout for it.

[hibsquaker]

Would make a worst hibs 11? I ok🤦*♂️

Name 11 worse then...

[Potty78]

A striker that has been here a year and not scored a goal.

He’s a good shout for it.

He was chucked in at the deep end today because we wanted to go more aggressive. Not the greatest performance but he worked hard. Plus I've seen worse strikers

[Lancs Harp]

Name 11 worse then...

I'll start with Islam Feruz. Who i had the misfortune to watch at both Blackpool and Hibs.

[Potty78]

Name 11 worse then...

Players? Easy

[Boss_Nass]

Scott, no goals and no assists (90% sure) this season.

Should have been hooked for Melkersen, mueller, Jasper to try something different

[loanheadhibby]

He was chucked in at the deep end today because we wanted to go more aggressive. Not the greatest performance but he worked hard. Plus I've seen worse strikers

I genuinely can’t think of a worse centre forward for Hibs in the last 20 years? Lee Power and Rowan Vine on a par with Scott.

[JamesHFC]

I'll start with Islam Feruz. Who i had the misfortune to watch at both Blackpool and Hibs.

Forgot about him 😂

Kuqi, Trakys, Duffy and Matulevicius

[B.H.F.C]

He was chucked in at the deep end today because we wanted to go more aggressive. Not the greatest performance but he worked hard. Plus I've seen worse strikers

Wasn’t terrible today. But been her a season and contributed zero.

[Potty78]

I genuinely can’t think of a worse centre forward for Hibs in the last 20 years? Lee Power and Rowan Vine on a par with Scott.
The Tank, Johansen, Vine, Power but to be honest I thought he meant players not strikers 🙈

[loanheadhibby]

The Tank, Johansen, Vine, Power but to be honest I thought he meant players not strikers 🙈

Good shouts. I think Eduardo scored a couple but Johannson a definite shout.

[madhatter]

He was actually decent today. Think he'll play most games between now and end of season. Held the ball up well at times and worked hard.

[IberianHibernian]

A striker that has been here a year and not scored a goal.

He’s a good shout for it.A year here meaning about 150 minutes since he was signed while Jack Ross was manager . Could have done more at 2nd goal but otherwise put in a good shift . Doubt he`ll be with us next season but hope he gets a chance in starting team in coming matches . I actually had him in team I hoped would start but with Melkerson up front . In the end Henderson was my MOM but didn`t really work with Scott .

[JamesHFC]

He was actually decent today. Think he'll play most games between now and end of season. Held the ball up well at times and worked hard.

I’d be giving Melkersen and Mueller as much game time as possible between now and the end of the season. They are the one’s who are going to be with us next season and still need to get up to speed.

[Mikey_1875]

Still not for me on today’s showing unfortunately. A bit better second half but we need more. Went to ground sliding in a bizarre amount of times as well.

[KazHibby]

Scott was on for his challenging in the air, as we have nobody and last week we were wasted!

[Keyser Sauzee]

He gets praise for taking one of they pricks out

[madhatter]

I’d be giving Melkersen and Mueller as much game time as possible between now and the end of the season. They are the one’s who are going to be with us next season and still need to get up to speed.

Play Scott at no9 and have Melkersen and Mueller as 10s then. We still need to get some points and Melkersen gets ragdolled by most defenders so can't be our no9.

[BSEJVT]

The Tank, Johansen, Vine, Power but to be honest I thought he meant players not strikers 🙈

2 players I have never understood appearing in the worst x hibs players threads are Hurtado and Zarabi

Neither were here very long and weren't brilliant but Hurtado did score goals which alone should exempt him from some of the other striking luminaries mentioned and there are a load worse left-backs we have had than Zarabi.

How he appears in some lists and Kujabi doesn't just astonishes me.

Scott has been very very poor for Hibs, looks like the classic guy who got a big contract and enjoyed the life it gives him and his football went to hell

[Potty78]

2 players I have never understood appearing in the worst x hibs players threads are Hurtado and Zarabi

Neither were here very long and weren't brilliant but Hurtado did score goals which alone should exempt him from some of the other striking luminaries mentioned and there are a load worse left-backs we have had than Zarabi.

How he appears in some lists and Kujabi doesn't just astonishes me.

Scott has been very very poor for Hibs, looks like the classic guy who got a big contract and enjoyed the life it gives him and his football went to hell
Hurtardo scored once for Hibs👍

[Chorley Hibee]

Am I being unfair in thinking he may have made a better effort in trying to block Hearts 2nd goal.
Happy to be told I'm talking rubbish.

Just watched that on the highlights and his attempt to close down was a disgrace.

Sums up his chicken hearted performances since he arrived at ER.

[BlackSheep]

Forgot about him 😂

Kuqi, Trakys, Duffy and Matulevicius

Matulevicious scored for us…. Gotta put him up the list.

[loanheadhibby]

Have you highlighted McGinn gifting the ball to simms for the first


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
No I haven't but fair point.

[MWHIBBIES]

Matulevicious scored for us…. Gotta put him up the list.

Yeah, no way he can be there. Literally never even started 1 match. Mightve been decent.

[thebausburst]

How come we now sign strikers that can’t actually score goals, must have the worst ‘strikers’ in the league.

[The Modfather]

A terrible signing but played well yesterday, particularly in the second half. A glimpse that there’s a player in there but we’ll still be well rid of him come the summer. Hope we play the likes of Melkerson and the U18s until the end of the season.

[bigwheel]

Probably an outlier view, but I wonder if had been given more starting game time, we would have seen a lot better from him . Must be really hard to make an impact when you get 10 minutes every three weeks …

[theonlywayisup]

Probably an outlier view, but I wonder if had been given more starting game time, we would have seen a lot better from him . Must be really hard to make an impact when you get 10 minutes every three weeks …

Yes, agree and have said the same with Wright. However, I counter this by saying that if he's brought on for only 10 minutes then he would be giving 110% to show the manager that he deserves a starting position. Many teams have that "super-sub" person who comes on and the crowd are lifted by the players attitude and desire. James Scott has neve shown that.

Don't want to end on a negative - I though he did well yesterday and showed there is a player there. Thought he held up the ball really well. Just needed a Boyle type person up with him that he could link with.

[overdrive]

His ‘performance’ yesterday pretty much reflected the team’s overall performance… did the minimum expected with some effort but nothing great. Slower than a week in Saughton.

[Brightside]

One good game. Is he after a contract?

[I'm_cabbaged]

If he was a a true striker he would’ve scored the one that came off the post. He just stood there watching instead of following the ball into the net.
Disclaimer: I haven’t watched the highlights yet, so I may be wrong 😂

[Thegreenside]

Played okay, gave the absolute minimum of putting in a good shift but done little to influence the game with the ball

[MWHIBBIES]

How come we now sign strikers that can’t actually score goals, must have the worst ‘strikers’ in the league.

Like who?

[Hibernian Verse]

Like who?

I know what you’re getting at but he doesn’t need to qualify who to sign, he isn’t a paid member of the scouting team who’s job it is.

[MWHIBBIES]

I know what you’re getting at but he doesn’t need to qualify who to sign, he isn’t a paid member of the scouting team who’s job it is.

No, I mean who are our strikers than don't score? Our strikers do score, they're just never fit.

And Scott is dreadful

[Callum_62]

If he was a a true striker he would’ve scored the one that came off the post. He just stood there watching instead of following the ball into the net.
Disclaimer: I haven’t watched the highlights yet, so I may be wrong [emoji23]Yep, you are definately wrong

Sent from my VOG-L29 using Tapatalk

[hibsquaker]

Looking at the replies, he definitely makes the worst Hibs 11.

[Dr What If?]

Probably an outlier view, but I wonder if had been given more starting game time, we would have seen a lot better from him . Must be really hard to make an impact when you get 10 minutes every three weeks …
I saw him pay for Scotland U21s a few months back against Turkey and its no exaggeration to say he was Turkey's best player. When we got into the danger areas he either gave the ball away with poor control or took a shot that would clear the stand. It sticks in my mind as just how bad the display was.

Not seen much of him at Hibs but yesterday aside there has been nothing there from what I have seen to suggest he is good enough for this level. Even yesterday where he raised his game considerably he was only decent, he wasn't outstanding.

He is a young Scottish striker though and I would love it if he hit a brace in each of our last 5 games, show us he is a player, give the club a call to make....can't see it though.

[bigwheel]

I saw him pay for Scotland U21s a few months back against Turkey and its no exaggeration to say he was Turkey's best player. When we got into the danger areas he either gave the ball away with poor control or took a shot that would clear the stand. It sticks in my mind as just how bad the display was.

Not seen much of him at Hibs but yesterday aside there has been nothing there from what I have seen to suggest he is good enough for this level. Even yesterday where he raised his game considerably he was only decent, he wasn't outstanding.

He is a young Scottish striker though and I would love it if he hit a brace in each of our last 5 games, show us he is a player, give the club a call to make....can't see it though.

Interesting that and a balanced view. Thanks for sharing [emoji106]

[Winston Ingram]

Probably an outlier view, but I wonder if had been given more starting game time, we would have seen a lot better from him . Must be really hard to make an impact when you get 10 minutes every three weeks …

It’s baffled me the stick he’s got. We’ve barely seen him.

[Unseen work]

It’s baffled me the stick he’s got. We’ve barely seen him.

I’m the same as you, the abuse he gets is way OTT imo.

Very difficult to come on and make a difference in a 5 minute spell once a month.

[Hibiza]

A disaster of a loan signing.

[Not In The Know]

Did he actually play that well? His attempt to close down Kingsley for their second goal for me summed up his whole spell here. Half arsed.

[jacomo]

It’s baffled me the stick he’s got. We’ve barely seen him.


He hardly played in the autumn because he was unfit and not training hard enough.

He’s had plenty of minutes since to make an impression, and achieved f all.

[jacomo]

Did he actually play that well? His attempt to close down Kingsley for their second goal for me summed up his whole spell here. Half arsed.


He looked like he was really trying the first 20 minutes, then reverted to jogging and pointing. He contributed nothing of note yesterday.

[loanheadhibby]

I’m the same as you, the abuse he gets is way OTT imo.

Very difficult to come on and make a difference in a 5 minute spell once a month.

Turn that round on Scott. Why has he not been starting? We’ve been missing at least 1 striker all season and he still has not done enough in training to convince 2 managers to give him a chance!

And when he does make a rare appearance, he offers nothing.

Now compare him to Simms for that manky mob.

It’s an embarrassment all round.

[ErinGoBraghHFC]

Anyone pictured training in a snood can get ****ed. However he put in a good shift yesterday and played well by his standards


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk