ZitellZeTime
29-03-2022, 03:05 PM
I know a player is only worth as much as club is willing to pay or the selling club values them at to be sold, like our rejected offers for Nisbet, Porteous and alleged knocked back bids for doig in the last year.
But at same time I know usually their is roughly a value that between say 250-500k for a player, depending on form over that season etc can rise. But with Mueller being built up and ive heard some complaints about him but he seemed to have decent reputation before joining, had been doing well for Orlando City and had won two caps for his country scoring two goals before he joined, he looks good to me, stll getting used to the Scottish game and I think we will see the best of him next season. Kind of like how Jorge Claros looked dug***** when he joined for the remainder of that season, but when we extended it til end of next season he looked like a totally different player for us and we actually would have signed him if parent club hadn't been asking for stupid money for him.
So I checked out of curiosity and found this https://www.transfermarkt.co.uk/hibernian-fc/marktwertanalyse/verein/903 also found a few other sites with value for all our players and they were all pretty similar. Who the **** makes these places, do they just guess the value of players due to whos in headlines or what club they're on Loan from etc.
Like Scott Allan, I love him he already had diabetes and with the heart condition coming back shows coming over adversity, he still his that football brain but hes just not the same anymore, there is absolutely noone who would pay almost 500k for him, we were trying to offload him allegedly not long ago to make space and free a wage. As much as I love the player and gave me great memories nobody would pay that for him giving his age now, his health issues etc.
But the most shocking one was James Scott hes an absolute imposter and he is pish, I hear people saying theres a players in there, well he's had plenty time to prove it, he's just not good enough for us.
They value him at just under 500k and is according to their list our 10th or 11th most valuable player, im guessing they base this on his past form and the fact he's on loan from a farely big club as if any of them had watched him play they would not value him higher than Jasper, Magennis, Doyle Hayes, Macey, Hanlon, Hendrson , Demetri. Even the Hoff has done more in a his little game time so far and showed he has skills that Scott does not so should be rated higher, especially considering the fee we payed for him.
Does anyone know where these places get their values from, ****ing football manager is far far more accurate than these alleged accurate value for players etc sites and that a computer game. Saying that I think Football Manager use scouts etc from all over the world for the stats, value, wages etc of players which would explain why they seem more accurate, unsure what his value is in that though. Last one i bought was 2017 or something.
Sorry I have used this forum for many years, never posted much. I made an account like 12 years ago when i was at college called calypso king or something but argued with some private member who was always privvy to transfer info, well he argued with me calling me a jambo for disagreeing with what he said, soon after i was faxed back to kaunas lol.
Since then i went back to read only and used mostly for transfer threads in windows, maathday threads to see what new injuries were going to have an hour or so before the game and I do enjoy that "This it how it feels" post JonnyBoy(love your pfp/avatar whatever they call it if you see this Jonny) always makes, always a good read. So i guess im new but not new, been reading here for well over a decade lol.
But at same time I know usually their is roughly a value that between say 250-500k for a player, depending on form over that season etc can rise. But with Mueller being built up and ive heard some complaints about him but he seemed to have decent reputation before joining, had been doing well for Orlando City and had won two caps for his country scoring two goals before he joined, he looks good to me, stll getting used to the Scottish game and I think we will see the best of him next season. Kind of like how Jorge Claros looked dug***** when he joined for the remainder of that season, but when we extended it til end of next season he looked like a totally different player for us and we actually would have signed him if parent club hadn't been asking for stupid money for him.
So I checked out of curiosity and found this https://www.transfermarkt.co.uk/hibernian-fc/marktwertanalyse/verein/903 also found a few other sites with value for all our players and they were all pretty similar. Who the **** makes these places, do they just guess the value of players due to whos in headlines or what club they're on Loan from etc.
Like Scott Allan, I love him he already had diabetes and with the heart condition coming back shows coming over adversity, he still his that football brain but hes just not the same anymore, there is absolutely noone who would pay almost 500k for him, we were trying to offload him allegedly not long ago to make space and free a wage. As much as I love the player and gave me great memories nobody would pay that for him giving his age now, his health issues etc.
But the most shocking one was James Scott hes an absolute imposter and he is pish, I hear people saying theres a players in there, well he's had plenty time to prove it, he's just not good enough for us.
They value him at just under 500k and is according to their list our 10th or 11th most valuable player, im guessing they base this on his past form and the fact he's on loan from a farely big club as if any of them had watched him play they would not value him higher than Jasper, Magennis, Doyle Hayes, Macey, Hanlon, Hendrson , Demetri. Even the Hoff has done more in a his little game time so far and showed he has skills that Scott does not so should be rated higher, especially considering the fee we payed for him.
Does anyone know where these places get their values from, ****ing football manager is far far more accurate than these alleged accurate value for players etc sites and that a computer game. Saying that I think Football Manager use scouts etc from all over the world for the stats, value, wages etc of players which would explain why they seem more accurate, unsure what his value is in that though. Last one i bought was 2017 or something.
Sorry I have used this forum for many years, never posted much. I made an account like 12 years ago when i was at college called calypso king or something but argued with some private member who was always privvy to transfer info, well he argued with me calling me a jambo for disagreeing with what he said, soon after i was faxed back to kaunas lol.
Since then i went back to read only and used mostly for transfer threads in windows, maathday threads to see what new injuries were going to have an hour or so before the game and I do enjoy that "This it how it feels" post JonnyBoy(love your pfp/avatar whatever they call it if you see this Jonny) always makes, always a good read. So i guess im new but not new, been reading here for well over a decade lol.