Discipline

[Nevi_SOL]

Real Problem this season. I’m sure I read somewhere that’s our 10th red this season

[Callum_62]

The livi game somewhat ruins our stats tho!

Another thing we can blame Jack Ross for!

Sent from my VOG-L29 using Tapatalk

[Mike Berry]

Real Problem this season. I’m sure I read somewhere that’s our 10th red this seasonYou have a point I think. That performance certainly lacked discipline. I would be surprised if Maloney wasn't sending Caldwell in to kick a few doors off hinges.

Sent from my LYA-L09 using Tapatalk

[loanheadhibby]

Indiscipline and lack of ability has cost us dearly this season.

[Franck Stanton]

How many have been warranted?
Gerard legacy lives on, all started with that tackle against that diving parentless individual Aribo. Gerard Slated Porto for a tackle he won, got the ball,DIDN'T TOUCH the diving c@#& & the wedgie press have& are hounding a good player out of Scottish football.yes there are times he makes it easy for them to continue their hate campaign aimed at him. Give the lad a break will you ffs

[The dalmeny]

How many have been warranted?
Gerard legacy lives on, all started with that tackle against that diving parentless individual Aribo. Gerard Slated Porto for a tackle he won, got the ball,DIDN'T TOUCH the diving c@#& & the wedgie press have& are hounding a good player out of Scottish football.yes there are times he makes it easy for them to continue their hate campaign aimed at him. Give the lad a break will you ffs

how many times, getting the ball has nothing to do with it

[Nevi_SOL]

How many have been warranted?
Gerard legacy lives on, all started with that tackle against that diving parentless individual Aribo. Gerard Slated Porto for a tackle he won, got the ball,DIDN'T TOUCH the diving c@#& & the wedgie press have& are hounding a good player out of Scottish football.yes there are times he makes it easy for them to continue their hate campaign aimed at him. Give the lad a break will you ffs

Just giving our horrendous refs an excuse though, I’m usually a happy clapper but it’s ridiculous the lack of discipline. Needs addressed ASAP

[Lago]

Real Problem this season. I’m sure I read somewhere that’s our 10th red this season
It's poor

[Jones28]

Been so poor. The two reds against Ross County were a bit of an anomaly and I haven’t seen Porteous’s red from today yet but if Maloney is correct then that’s poor.

[Callum_62]

I'm guessing we will be appealing Ryan's red card

Sent from my VOG-L29 using Tapatalk

[Springbank]

Does Porteous miss the semi?

[Sir David Gray]

Does Porteous miss the semi?

I don't think so.

[Johnny_Leith]

10 red cards is absolutely horrific. A real lack of discipline; both tactical and personal.

BTW here's a wee analysis of how the red cards have effected us.

Fixtures in which Hibs have received a red card. Score when the card was produced. Player sent off. Final Score.

Fixture / Score at time of Red Card (S) / Player sent off (P) / Final Score (FS) / Ref (R) (domestic only)


Santa Coloma (H) / Hibs 1-0 SC / P: Newell (29) / FS: Hibs 3-0 Santa Coloma

Rijeka (A) / Rjekta 1-1 Hibs / P: McGregor (67) / FS: Rijeka 4-1 Hibs

Rangers (A) / Rangers 0-1 Hibs / P: Porteous (30) / FS: 2-1 Rangers / R: N. Walsh

Aberdeen (A) / Aberdeen 1-0 Hibs / P: McGregor (97) / FS: Aberdeen 1-0 Hibs / R: G. Aitken

Ross County (A) / County 1-0 Hibs / P: Doidge (84), Boyle (95 - after FT) / FS: County 1-0 Hibs / R: G. Duncan

Livingston (A) / Livi 1-0 Hibs / P: McGinn (85), Hanlon (89) / FS: Livi 1-0 Hibs / R: D. Robertson

Dundee (A) / Dundee 0-0 Hibs / P: Bushiri (58) / FS: Dundee 0-0 Hibs / R: D. Munro

Aberdeen (A) / Aberdeen 1-1 Hibs / P: Porteous (63) / FS: Aberdeen 3-1 / R: A. Muir

Only away to Dundee have we had a man sent off and taken anything from the game in the league.

[Jones28]

10 red cards is absolutely horrific. A real lack of discipline; both tactical and personal.

BTW here's a wee analysis of how the red cards have effected us.

Fixtures in which Hibs have received a red card. Score when the card was produced. Player sent off. Final Score.

Fixture / Score at time of Red Card (S) / Player sent off (P) / Final Score (FS) / Ref (R) (domestic only)


Santa Coloma (H) / Hibs 1-0 SC / P: Newell (29) / FS: Hibs 3-0 Santa Coloma

Rijeka (A) / Rjekta 1-1 Hibs / P: McGregor (67) / FS: Rijeka 4-1 Hibs

Rangers (A) / Rangers 0-1 Hibs / P: Porteous (30) / FS: 2-1 Rangers / R: N. Walsh

Aberdeen (A) / Aberdeen 1-0 Hibs / P: McGregor (97) / FS: Aberdeen 1-0 Hibs / R: G. Aitken

Ross County (A) / County 1-0 Hibs / P: Doidge (84), Boyle (95 - after FT) / FS: County 1-0 Hibs / R: G. Duncan

Livingston (A) / Livi 1-0 Hibs / P: McGinn (85), Hanlon (89) / FS: Livi 1-0 Hibs / R: D. Robertson

Dundee (A) / Dundee 0-0 Hibs / P: Bushiri (58) / FS: Dundee 0-0 Hibs / R: D. Munro

Aberdeen (A) / Aberdeen 1-1 Hibs / P: Porteous (63) / FS: Aberdeen 3-1 / R: A. Muir

Only away to Dundee have we had a man sent off and taken anything from the game in the league.

Honking. And having two players sent off in two different games screams of losing the plot all too often.

[matty_f]

The disciplinary record this season is awful, really awful.

[Hulk1875]

Just mentioned in other post about discipline didn’t realise had this one going, what I said I’ve never known is to be a dirty team and last couple
Seasons we haven’t been, why is so much going against us? Is it cause we’re
Poor the players are desperate to make a difference in game and go too for or is there some sort of hatred towards us for some reason

[Percy Vere]

I'm guessing we will be appealing Ryan's red card

Sent from my VOG-L29 using Tapatalk

Why?
It’s a clear red!
Fair enough he’s trying to get to the ball but he wipes out the player.
No danger that should be appealed.
If it was a similar tackle on one of our players you’d be seeing red.

[500miles]

Why?
It’s a clear red!
Fair enough he’s trying to get to the ball but he wipes out the player.
No danger that should be appealed.
If it was a similar tackle on one of our players you’d be seeing red.
Well that's no the rules mate. The rules have been discussed and posted multiple times now, and the double jeopardy rule is no longer a new rule.

[MWHIBBIES]

Why?
It’s a clear red!
Fair enough he’s trying to get to the ball but he wipes out the player.
No danger that should be appealed.
If it was a similar tackle on one of our players you’d be seeing red.
If he makes a genuine attempt for the ball it's not a red card. That's the rule. Has been since June 2016.

[J-C]

10 red cards is absolutely horrific. A real lack of discipline; both tactical and personal.

BTW here's a wee analysis of how the red cards have effected us.

Fixtures in which Hibs have received a red card. Score when the card was produced. Player sent off. Final Score.

Fixture / Score at time of Red Card (S) / Player sent off (P) / Final Score (FS) / Ref (R) (domestic only)


Santa Coloma (H) / Hibs 1-0 SC / P: Newell (29) / FS: Hibs 3-0 Santa Coloma

Rijeka (A) / Rjekta 1-1 Hibs / P: McGregor (67) / FS: Rijeka 4-1 Hibs

Rangers (A) / Rangers 0-1 Hibs / P: Porteous (30) / FS: 2-1 Rangers / R: N. Walsh

Aberdeen (A) / Aberdeen 1-0 Hibs / P: McGregor (97) / FS: Aberdeen 1-0 Hibs / R: G. Aitken

Ross County (A) / County 1-0 Hibs / P: Doidge (84), Boyle (95 - after FT) / FS: County 1-0 Hibs / R: G. Duncan

Livingston (A) / Livi 1-0 Hibs / P: McGinn (85), Hanlon (89) / FS: Livi 1-0 Hibs / R: D. Robertson

Dundee (A) / Dundee 0-0 Hibs / P: Bushiri (58) / FS: Dundee 0-0 Hibs / R: D. Munro

Aberdeen (A) / Aberdeen 1-1 Hibs / P: Porteous (63) / FS: Aberdeen 3-1 / R: A. Muir

Only away to Dundee have we had a man sent off and taken anything from the game in the league.

Interesting to note that of all the red cards, only Rijeka and Rangers games were affected by them, apart from yesterday the score remained the same in the rest.

[Johnny_Leith]

Interesting to note that of all the red cards, only Rijeka and Rangers games were affected by them, apart from yesterday the score remained the same in the rest.

I mean, yeah.... from the above, we’ve not rescued points when going down to 10 apart from Dundee.

Had doidge not been sent at Ross county who’s to say we wouldn’t have grabbed a late equaliser? Or at Livi ?

[Callum_62]

Why?
It’s a clear red!
Fair enough he’s trying to get to the ball but he wipes out the player.
No danger that should be appealed.
If it was a similar tackle on one of our players you’d be seeing red.

You've just described a situation thats not a red card

[Hibs90]

How many of the red cards we’ve been given, we’re actually red cards and we’ve not been done over by officials?

[B.H.F.C]

The livi game somewhat ruins our stats tho!

Another thing we can blame Jack Ross for!

Sent from my VOG-L29 using Tapatalk

Does it really? We received two red cards a couple of weeks before that as well.

FWIW, I don’t think the red card yesterday was down to lack of discipline. It was just someone trying to stop a certain goal.

[A Hi-Bee]

Real Problem this season. I’m sure I read somewhere that’s our 10th red this season

The main problem disguised by your stats is the level of the animal that is the Scottish (West coast) Referee.

[#2 Double Tap]

Real Problem this season. I’m sure I read somewhere that’s our 10th red this season

Lack of strong leadership.

when there is no one there to crack the whip, situations always end up in chaos.

[grunt]

Anyone else think this thread was about the 1981 album from King Crimson?

[Mike Berry]

Anyone else think this thread was about the 1981 album from King Crimson?Kudos for the most niche post on here this year.

Sent from my LYA-L09 using Tapatalk