Joe Newell

[FamousSix]

After a few weeks out injured, I believe he had to play today because of injury to JDH. I thought his performance was excellent and surprised he did the 90 minutes (I think). He fitted well into the type of game we are trying to play. Really happy to see him back.

[kaimendhibs]

Agree. I think he is a superb player. Rarely loses the ball, great passing and a fair bit of dig about him.

[Iggy Pope]

Seconded. He was very very good today.
Edit. Thirded!

[Dashing Bob S]

Great player. Once match fitness returns he’ll be a massive asset.

[flash]

One of the best midfielders in the country for my cash.

[gazzag70]

I thought Newell had a good game today. He is an underrated player, when he is at his best he is a real asset. I must admit to not being his biggest fan in the past but he really is a good player. We are a better team when he plays( most of the time).

[JohnM1875]

Absolutely chuffed to have Joe back. Thought he was fantastic today.

Really impressive performance considering he'd been out injured for a month.

[easty]

We need him in there. Always wants the ball, no scared to take it even when under pressure. Strong on the ball, strong in the tackle.

Delighted to have him back today.

[LunasBoots]

Amazing he lasted, great to have him back, glad he didn't pick up a booking aswell as he'll be crucial in the semi.

[cameronw-hfc]

Said as much on the match thread. Still baffled that he's another one with a good chunk of fans that don't rate him. Especially the social media mobs. Honestly can't wrap my head around it, has been our most important player for some time. Reminds me of McGeough.

Just knows how to treat the ball.

[wookie70]

A few of his team mates could ask Joe how he is looking much fitter than them despite being out for so long. As usual played very well and one of the only players who looks comfortable playing the high risk passing game at the back.

[hibbydog]

Needs a haircut

[Funkydunc]

Mom for me, even with the curtained darling scoring a couple of beautys.

[hibee-boys]

Maloney mentioned him in his post match interview saying he’s one of the best in the league in that position and I agree. Fantastic performance over 90mins, especially after being out.

[mokie]

Said as much on the match thread. Still baffled that he's another one with a good chunk of fans that don't rate him. Especially the social media mobs. Honestly can't wrap my head around it, has been our most important player for some time. Reminds me of McGeough.

Just knows how to treat the ball.

It's not the fact that some fans don't rate him , the issue is that he has one cracking game like today then goes totally missing the next 4 or 5 at least.. Rotherham fans said he was 1 good game in 10 and they certainly weren't wrong in that.......

[hibbysam]

It's not the fact that some fans don't rate him , the issue is that he has one cracking game like today then goes totally missing the next 4 or 5 at least.. Rotherham fans said he was 1 good game in 10 and they certainly weren't wrong in that.......

Tripe.

[bigwheel]

It's not the fact that some fans don't rate him , the issue is that he has one cracking game like today then goes totally missing the next 4 or 5 at least.. Rotherham fans said he was 1 good game in 10 and they certainly weren't wrong in that.......

Eyes painted on

[LewysGot2]

Rolls Royce of a player on his game. Comfortable in possession, can link play between the lines, plays with the head up. Considering the factors involved in his return he was immense today. Glad to have him back,

He also “gets it” regarding the club and seems a really down to earth individual, too.

[LewysGot2]

It's not the fact that some fans don't rate him , the issue is that he has one cracking game like today then goes totally missing the next 4 or 5 at least.. Rotherham fans said he was 1 good game in 10 and they certainly weren't wrong in that.......

okay dokey mokie…not sure that’s the case. :confused:

[kaimendhibs]

It's not the fact that some fans don't rate him , the issue is that he has one cracking game like today then goes totally missing the next 4 or 5 at least.. Rotherham fans said he was 1 good game in 10 and they certainly weren't wrong in that.......
Sorry but Nope. Disagree 100 per cent

[JimBHibees]

Absolute quality great to see him back

[LaMotta]

Brilliant when we go ahead in a game. Never gives it away, calms things down and breaks up play as well.

[Hiber-nation]

Best player on the park over the 90 minutes today. He does need to do it more consistently though. His return has come at just the right time for us.

[inglisavhibs]

Maloney mentioned him in his post match interview saying he’s one of the best in the league in that position and I agree. Fantastic performance over 90mins, especially after being out.
Did really well considering the long absence.Understandably ran out of legs a bit but great to have him back. We need a few others back if we are to compete in semi finals though.

[Eyrie]

Had a very good game today, always willing to show for a pass regardless of how close the Motherwell players were, kept the ball moving well and not afraid to make a tackle.

[superfurryhibby]

Showed all his qualities today. Very well played.

[Danderhall Hibs]

He was very good today - brings more to the midfield than any of the others can. I get the comments about him being inconsistent but he’s good more often than he’s not. And that’s 2 games in a row he’s been on top form (albeit weeks in between them).

[cameronw-hfc]

It's not the fact that some fans don't rate him , the issue is that he has one cracking game like today then goes totally missing the next 4 or 5 at least.. Rotherham fans said he was 1 good game in 10 and they certainly weren't wrong in that.......

This isn't even close to being true. Joe has been the one solid player for us in my opinion throughout most of this season, regardless of how the rest of the team plays.

Most people that don't think he's quality have only just realised he isn't a #10 and does his role perfectly, if not better than anyone else in the league out with the ugly sisters. It's a myth that Joe is inconsistent, just like the myth he didn't work hard last season, which has also been or en to be as far from the truth as possible.

He's a player fans took a dislike to when he struggled at first, and as Hibs fans have done for my whole life supporting them, a minority will refuse to budge their opinion, no matter how well he plays weekly.

Also, his last game was Hearts, in which he was probably man of the match. His next game he also was in for a shout for man of the match, today. That's blown your "one good game 5 bad" right out the water considering that's two Motm performances in a row

[Lago]

It's not the fact that some fans don't rate him , the issue is that he has one cracking game like today then goes totally missing the next 4 or 5 at least.. Rotherham fans said he was 1 good game in 10 and they certainly weren't wrong in that.......
News to me 🤔

[MWHIBBIES]

It's not the fact that some fans don't rate him , the issue is that he has one cracking game like today then goes totally missing the next 4 or 5 at least.. Rotherham fans said he was 1 good game in 10 and they certainly weren't wrong in that.......

Thats utter pish.

[Shrekko]

It's not the fact that some fans don't rate him , the issue is that he has one cracking game like today then goes totally missing the next 4 or 5 at least.. Rotherham fans said he was 1 good game in 10 and they certainly weren't wrong in that.......

Utter garbage.

[Bostonhibby]

This isn't even close to being true. Joe has been the one solid player for us in my opinion throughout most of this season, regardless of how the rest of the team plays.

Most people that don't think he's quality have only just realised he isn't a #10 and does his role perfectly, if not better than anyone else in the league out with the ugly sisters. It's a myth that Joe is inconsistent, just like the myth he didn't work hard last season, which has also been or en to be as far from the truth as possible.

He's a player fans took a dislike to when he struggled at first, and as Hibs fans have done for my whole life supporting them, a minority will refuse to budge their opinion, no matter how well he plays weekly.I was a bit meh at the beginning,posted at the time that my next door neighbour, a Peterborough utd fan said he was a really gifted player that Posh seemed play out of position a bit, he rated him but said he felt the application wasnt always there.

Wasnt impressed at the beginning but now clear we didn't use him right back then.

When fit he's my first pick in the current midfield, the thing is he definitely can play going forward. Will have no trouble doing what Maloney wants.

Sent from my SM-A750FN using Tapatalk

[mokie]

[QUOTE=hibbysam;6890290]Tripe.[/QUOTE

far from it...

[mokie]

Utter garbage.

No it certainly is not.

[Booked4Being-Ugly]

It’s great to have him back. He was really good today with the exception of his wayward pass leading up to the Well goal. The Hibs defending wasn’t great either at that point tbf, so wasn’t solely to blame.

[Jones28]

The way Newall got injured was spectacular, playing out his skin in the derby then gets injured making a double crunching tackle, ****ing loved it.

More than delighted to have him back in the side.

[Dmas]

I haven't been his biggest fan in the past, was brilliant against hearts and was very very good today huge bonus getting him back today, was worried he'd been rushed after seeing his knee so heavily strapped but he looked to have strolled the 90

[Mcbizz1998]

Really rate Joe. Improves out midfield massively, glad he is back.

[mokie]

This isn't even close to being true. Joe has been the one solid player for us in my opinion throughout most of this season, regardless of how the rest of the team plays.

Most people that don't think he's quality have only just realised he isn't a #10 and does his role perfectly, if not better than anyone else in the league out with the ugly sisters. It's a myth that Joe is inconsistent, just like the myth he didn't work hard last season, which has also been or en to be as far from the truth as possible.

He's a player fans took a dislike to when he struggled at first, and as Hibs fans have done for my whole life supporting them, a minority will refuse to budge their opinion, no matter how well he plays weekly.

Also, his last game was Hearts, in which he was probably man of the match. His next game he also was in for a shout for man of the match, today. That's blown your "one good game 5 bad" right out the water considering that's two Motm performances in a row

Firstly , he is nowhere near the quality of Lewis Ferguson at Aberdeen or Beni Baningime at Hertz so that's that argument blown right out of the water...

What about the rest of his time here ?? Horrendous in matches during previous seasons but the odd 8-9 / 10 chucked in every once in a while is a fair way to describe him I'd say.. JonnyBoy's reports will back that claim up..

A shout for MOTM today but let's be honest , Melkersen will walk away with that accolade after his couple of goals..

[Bostonhibby]

Close the thread, players from Sportsounds 2 favourite clubs win the day. Debate over.

Sent from my SM-A750FN using Tapatalk

[hibbysam]

Firstly , he is nowhere near the quality of Lewis Ferguson at Aberdeen or Beni Baningime at Hertz so that's that argument blown right out of the water...

What about the rest of his time here ?? Horrendous in matches during previous seasons but the odd 8-9 / 10 chucked in every once in a while is a fair way to describe him I'd say

A shout for MOTM today but let's be honest , Melkersen will walk away with that accolade after his couple of goals..

😂😂 Beni at Hearts is a holding midfielder who is limited on the ball, and Ferguson flatters to deceive every time I watch him. I’d suggest turning your head to face the pitch the next time you go to Easter road, you’ll get a better idea of how the game is played.

Newell has been consistently very good for a very long spell now, undeniable.

[LewysGot2]

😂😂 Beni at Hearts is a holding midfielder who is limited on the ball, and Ferguson flatters to deceive every time I watch him. I’d suggest turning your head to face the pitch the next time you go to Easter road, you’ll get a better idea of how the game is played.

Newell has been consistently very good for a very long spell now, undeniable.

He was a Player of the Year in the lockdown season!

[MWHIBBIES]

No it certainly is not.

It absolutely is.

[mokie]

Close the thread, players from Sportsounds 2 favourite clubs win the day. Debate over.

Sent from my SM-A750FN using Tapatalk

The poster gave his opinion and I countered it by giving him more than example of guys who I think are better ?? No harm in it is there ??

[mokie]

It absolutely is.


I don't think so but you clearly think differently which is fair enough...

[Bostonhibby]

The poster gave his opinion and I countered it by giving him more than example of guys who I think are better ?? No harm in it is there ??It's a free forum for opinions so crack on, any other hearts or Aberdeen players worth citing in what seems to be a rather undeserved attack on a Hibs player doing well?

Sent from my SM-A750FN using Tapatalk

[mokie]

😂😂 Beni at Hearts is a holding midfielder who is limited on the ball, and Ferguson flatters to deceive every time I watch him. I’d suggest turning your head to face the pitch the next time you go to Easter road, you’ll get a better idea of how the game is played.

Newell has been consistently very good for a very long spell now, undeniable.

For the record my head was facing the pitch today but also everytime I go to watch Hibs.. My eyes don't deceive me thank you very much and I am sure you are the same...

[mokie]

It's a free forum for opinions so crack on, any other hearts or Aberdeen players worth citing in what seems to be a rather undeserved attack on a Hibs player doing well?

Sent from my SM-A750FN using Tapatalk


To call it an attack is OTT but each to their own I guess.. As I said , the poster said he was the best in the league in his position and I disagreed with something to back my point up.. It looks like you're taking offence to it , I may be wrong in that observation but if you are then crack on....

I would also say that my POV isn't undeserved as during his time here , he has been pretty average at best...

[Allant1981]

It's not the fact that some fans don't rate him , the issue is that he has one cracking game like today then goes totally missing the next 4 or 5 at least.. Rotherham fans said he was 1 good game in 10 and they certainly weren't wrong in that.......

Do you ever have anything positive to say

[Bostonhibby]

To call it an attack is OTT but each to their own I guess.. As I said , the poster said he was the best in the league in his position and I disagreed with something to back my point up.. It looks like you're taking offence to it , I may be wrong in that observation but if you are then crack on....Can't remember the last time I took offence on this forum, maybe never, as I say carry on, your view is as important as anyone else properly on here.


Sent from my SM-A750FN using Tapatalk

[mokie]

Do you ever have anything positive to say

I most certainly do. If you'd been in my company today then you would've heard me very positive towards the match today.. :aok::aok::aok::aok::aok:

[Hibbyradge]

Can't remember the last time I took offence on this forum, maybe never, as I say carry on, your view is as important as anyone else properly on here.


Sent from my SM-A750FN using Tapatalk

My views are more important.

[mokie]

He was Player of the Year in the lockdown season!

Martin Boyle won that award.........

[Bostonhibby]

My views are more important.No they're not.....

You are Richard Gordon and I claim my free BBC Sportsound pencil sharpener

Sent from my SM-A750FN using Tapatalk

[Hibbyradge]

No they're not.....

You are Richard Gordon and I claim my free BBC Sportsound pencil sharpener

Sent from my SM-A750FN using Tapatalk

I'm Craig Levein and I claim my natural justice.

[Bostonhibby]

I'm Craig Levein and I claim my natural justice.Thought so but I didn't want to say anything in case you took a fence.

Sent from my SM-A750FN using Tapatalk

[FilipinoHibs]

Great to have him back, superb footballer. Yesterday showed how much we have missed him.

[The Harp Awakes]

Really rate Joe. Improves out midfield massively, glad he is back.

Yep, Joe was very good today. We've missed him. Joe and JDH are our best defensive midfielders. Get the right balance of attacking midfield options in the squad (Magennis could be the answer if he can get fit) and another striker and we are sorted.

[cameronw-hfc]

Firstly , he is nowhere near the quality of Lewis Ferguson at Aberdeen or Beni Baningime at Hertz so that's that argument blown right out of the water...

What about the rest of his time here ?? Horrendous in matches during previous seasons but the odd 8-9 / 10 chucked in every once in a while is a fair way to describe him I'd say.. JonnyBoy's reports will back that claim up..

A shout for MOTM today but let's be honest , Melkersen will walk away with that accolade after his couple of goals..

Watched Joe bully Beni and Ferguson, yet to see either of them even have much success against Joe. Respect your opinion but it's so far off😂

[mokie]

Watched Joe bully Beni and Ferguson, yet to see either of them even have much success against Joe. Respect your opinion but it's so far off😂


It may be the case in a one off game but it doesn't mean that overall they aren't better players...

[Glory Lurker]

Needs a haircut

That's a banning right there. Back to over the road with you!

[LewysGot2]

Martin Boyle won that award.........

There were 2 awards. He won most MotM awards that season and was acknowledged for that.

[Fergus52]

Firstly , he is nowhere near the quality of Lewis Ferguson at Aberdeen or Beni Baningime at Hertz so that's that argument blown right out of the water...



I don't know how anyone could watch the last derby at Easter road and come away thinking that baningame is levels above Newell.

Baningame couldn't get near him - Newell tackled him 4 or 5 times and dribbled past him a couple of times as well. Newell was instrumental in our midfield play when we had the ball, whereas Beni kept losing the ball when he got it due to Newell and JDH effectively pressing and tackling.

Both are good players but Newell was streets ahead that game, went up against him toe to toe and easily came out on top.

[SHODAN]

Immediate impact. Please don't get injured again Joe!

[mokie]

There were 2 awards. He won most MotM awards that season and was acknowledged for that.

What were the two awards then ?

Boyle won POTY
Doig won YPOTY
Gogic won goal of the season..

[mokie]

I don't know how anyone could watch the last derby at Easter road and come away thinking that baningame is levels above Newell.

Baningame couldn't get near him - Newell tackled him 4 or 5 times and dribbled past him a couple of times as well. Newell was instrumental in our midfield play when we had the ball, whereas Beni kept losing the ball when he got it due to Newell and JDH effectively pressing and tackling.

Both are good players but Newell was streets ahead that game, went up against him toe to toe and easily came out on top.


Look at what I said in a previous post , It may be the case in a one off game but it doesn't mean that overall they aren't better players...

[hibbysam]

Look at what I said in a previous post , It may be the case in a one off game but it doesn't mean that overall they aren't better players...

Except in this case Newell is better than them both.

[Ozyhibby]

I don’t rate him but recognise he had a good game today. Good in possession but still think he doesn’t work hard enough when we don’t.
What I will say is that we are still not controlling the centre of midfield whether Newall is playing or not. Today should have been much easier to do that with Well down to 10 men but it still didn’t happen. Maloney needs to get that sorted.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[LewysGot2]

What were the two awards then ?

Boyle won POTY
Doig won YPOTY
Gogic won goal of the season..

There was an award for the player who won most Man of the Match Awards - a player of the year award separate for the player with most of them. It was Newell.

Can't make it any simpler than that. There was also a Players player of the year. You missed that, too.

[HendoDelivered]

My favourite player

[Fergus52]

Look at what I said in a previous post , It may be the case in a one off game but it doesn't mean that overall they aren't better players...

Fair enough, I still really don't see it though.

Baningame is definitely a better traditional anchorman, in that he's bigger stronger and makes more tackles and interceptions (this side of Newell's game is really underrated by some though).

However whenever I've seen him play it's looked to me like his ball control, technique, passing and general creativity are all a level below Newell. Stats would back that up as well with Newell creating twice as many chances per game throughout the season than baningame

[Unseen work]

Very good player.

His ability to take the ball under pressure and turn is very good and his ability to switch play effortlessly was very important yesterday and a big part of why we were so successful in the first half imo.

Hes also good defensively, knocks boys off the ball with ease and wins his fair share of tackle.

Puts in a power of work.

[hibbysam]

Very good player.

His ability to take the ball under pressure and turn is very good and his ability to switch play effortlessly was very important yesterday and a big part of why we were so successful in the first half imo.

Hes also good defensively, knocks boys off the ball with ease and wins his fair share of tackle.

Puts in a power of work.

Thought he was extremely unlucky second half when he outmuscled the boy in their half and we broke away, only for Collum to give a foul.

[mokie]

There was an award for the player who won most Man of the Match Awards - a player of the year award separate for the player with most of them. It was Newell.

Can't make it any simpler than that. There was also a Players player of the year. You missed that, too.

I will need to take your word for that one then.. Can't seem to find any acknowledgement of it anywhere on the net..

[Since90+2]

Newell's a good player. Our best midfielder along with Mageniss whenever he's fit.

[Paulie Walnuts]

Newell's a good player. Our best midfielder along with Mageniss whenever he's fit.

To be fair that also depends on what Magennis it is.

The Magennis we got for a handful of games this season, absolutely.

The Magennis we’ve had for the majority of his appearances, then Newell is streets ahead.

Got to say I’m concerned for Magennis tbh. I wouldn’t be surprised if he’s not up to speed again this season. That’ll have been pretty much 2 full seasons of offering very little other than a month or two where he was very good.

[loanheadhibby]

Said as much on the match thread. Still baffled that he's another one with a good chunk of fans that don't rate him. Especially the social media mobs. Honestly can't wrap my head around it, has been our most important player for some time. Reminds me of McGeough.

Just knows how to treat the ball.
He's not in the same class as McGeough.
Newell is decent and an asset to our team but I think he's over rated by many on the net.
Didn't cover himself in glory at the Motherwell goal but good to see him back.

[flash]

He's not in the same class as McGeough.
Newell is decent and an asset to our team but I think he's over rated by many on the net.
Didn't cover himself in glory at the Motherwell goal but good to see him back.

Yet here he is performing at a high level almost every game he plays while McGeouch fannies about up north.

[Since90+2]

Yet here he is performing at a high level almost every game he plays while McGeouch fannies about up north.

I think McGeough when he was at Hibs was performing at a higher level than Newell currently is, but he's nowhere near that player these days.

[flash]

I think McGeough when he was at Hibs was performing at a higher level than Newell currently is, but he's nowhere near that player these days.

I admit I was being a bit facetious but I reckon Newall would have been fantastic in that team.

[LewysGot2]

I will need to take your word for that one then.. Can't seem to find any acknowledgement of it anywhere on the net..

You really don't.

Took 2 minutes to find the evidence.

HSL ran the club online Man of the Match award through that season and viewers online could vote for the Man of the Match after the final whistle. At the end of the season - on May 29th 2021 - Joe Newell won the Award as player of the year

https://twitter.com/hfcsupporters/status/1398711351070105605?t=RiqB_bfU5***SVAnQty0PA&s=19

[MWHIBBIES]

He's not in the same class as McGeough.
Newell is decent and an asset to our team but I think he's over rated by many on the net.
Didn't cover himself in glory at the Motherwell goal but good to see him back.

You mean the shot that was going 30 yards wide until it hit someone and went in? Yeah, it was a total fluke goal. Nothing to do with anyone.

[hibbysam]

I think McGeough when he was at Hibs was performing at a higher level than Newell currently is, but he's nowhere near that player these days.

McGeouch was playing beside John McGinn - no disrespect but JDH and Campbell aren’t in the same breath. I’ve no doubt Newell would’ve been a star in that team also, going by his very good performances in a poorer Hibs side.

[hibbysam]

You mean the shot that was going 30 yards wide until it hit someone and went in? Yeah, it was a total fluke goal. Nothing to do with anyone.

30 yards is generous 😂 closer to the dugouts than the goal. Macey could’ve done slightly better but listening to Maloney and seeing the fact he couldn’t kick the ball by the end, seems he was still carrying an injury so movement would’ve been limited.

[easty]

I admit I was being a bit facetious but I reckon Newall would have been fantastic in that team.

Me too.

[loanheadhibby]

You mean the shot that was going 30 yards wide until it hit someone and went in? Yeah, it was a total fluke goal. Nothing to do with anyone.
Watch the goal back before you comment.
His poor clearance put us in trouble before Roberts crossed the ball.

[Ronniekirk]

Given how long he had been out I thought he made a big difference and in second half helped us see game out


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[mokie]

You really don't.

Took 2 minutes to find the evidence.

HSL ran the club online Man of the Match award through that season and viewers online could vote for the Man of the Match after the final whistle. At the end of the season - on May 29th 2021 - Joe Newell won the Award as player of the year

https://twitter.com/hfcsupporters/status/1398711351070105605?t=RiqB_bfU5***SVAnQty0PA&s=19


That’s not what you were talking about. It’s totally different. You said that Joe newell won the clubs award for having the most MOTM’s that season at the POTYA. He was given the award by HSL and not the club. Hence why I can’t find it on the clubs official pages. It’s not a club award in the slightest.

[bigwheel]

That’s not what you were talking about. It’s totally different. You said that Joe newell won the clubs award for having the most MOTM’s that season at the POTYA. He was given the award by HSL and not the club. Hence why I can’t find it on the clubs official pages. It’s not a club award in the slightest.

You started off posting here with Lewis is crap , now it’s Newall is usually crap … both views say more about you than them tbh ……..wonder who will be next ?

[mokie]

You started off posting here with Lewis is crap , now it’s Newall is usually crap … both views say more about you than them tbh ……..wonder who will be next ?

That’s the million dollar question isn’t it ????

[bigwheel]

That’s the million dollar question isn’t it ????

[emoji3]. Well at least you made me laugh with that one …

guaranteed it will be someone - seems to be how you get your kicks

[mokie]

[emoji3]. Well at least you made me laugh with that one …

guaranteed it will be someone - seems to be how you get your kicks

if none of them weren’t so bang average then they wouldn’t get stick from me. :aok::aok::aok::aok:

[LewysGot2]

That’s not what you were talking about. It’s totally different. You said that Joe newell won the clubs award for having the most MOTM’s that season at the POTYA. He was given the award by HSL and not the club. Hence why I can’t find it on the clubs official pages. It’s not a club award in the slightest.

This was done in conjunction with the club. A second award linked to fundraising for the club via HSL. You paid to vote. The money went to club funds. Its still a Player of the Year Award and was voted for week on week by the fans.

You're determined that Newell is what you think he is. You're entitled to that opinion but the fact remains he won more MotM Awards that season from the fan base - better than a single sponsor choosing who they want to meet - than any other player. They must all be wrong.

You're certainly on a mission. Or trolling.

Either way it's not worth the bother.

[mokie]

This was done in conjunction with the club. A second award linked to fundraising for the club via HSL. You paid to vote. The money went to club funds. Its still a Player of the Year Award and was voted for week on week by the fans.

You're determined that Newell is what you think he is. You're entitled to that opinion but the fact remains he won more MotM Awards that season from the fan base - better than a single sponsor choosing who they want to meet - than any other player. They must all be wrong.

You're certainly on a mission. Or trolling.

Either way it's not worth the bother.

You’re right , I am entitled to that opinion. :aok::aok::aok:

[bigwheel]

if none of them weren’t so bang average then they wouldn’t get stick from me. :aok::aok::aok::aok:

doesn’t even rhyme ……What tune does that get sung to??

[hibbysam]

You’re right , I am entitled to that opinion. :aok::aok::aok:

You’re entitled to it, the same way I’m entitled to tell you football probably isn’t the sport for you. Sure the cricket will be back on shortly.

[cameronw-hfc]

You’re right , I am entitled to that opinion. :aok::aok::aok:

Thing is, your opinion seems to just be a dislike of Joe. You said he wasn't consistent enough, someone went and got proof he got more man of the match awards than anyone else last season and you've completely moved the goalpoasts saying it's not what you were talking about.

Joe rubbed a lot of fans the wrong way in his first few weeks/months with the club, I was one, but to deny what he brings to the team at this point is either an agenda or trolling.

[Allant1981]

Thing is, your opinion seems to just be a dislike of Joe. You said he wasn't consistent enough, someone went and got proof he got more man of the match awards than anyone else last season and you've completely moved the goalpoasts saying it's not what you were talking about.

Joe rubbed a lot of fans the wrong way in his first few weeks/months with the club, I was one, but to deny what he brings to the team at this point is either an agenda or trolling.

The poster is negative towards everything hibs, yet to see a post from them where something is positive, must be a boring life being like that all the time

[JimBHibees]

Thing is, your opinion seems to just be a dislike of Joe. You said he wasn't consistent enough, someone went and got proof he got more man of the match awards than anyone else last season and you've completely moved the goalpoasts saying it's not what you were talking about.

Joe rubbed a lot of fans the wrong way in his first few weeks/months with the club, I was one, but to deny what he brings to the team at this point is either an agenda or trolling.

Likely to be more of these kind of trolling posts with the derbies upcoming.

[Stonewall]

You’re entitled to it, the same way I’m entitled to tell you football probably isn’t the sport for you. Sure the cricket will be back on shortly.

Why cricket?

Is it okay if I like both?

[mokie]

Thing is, your opinion seems to just be a dislike of Joe. You said he wasn't consistent enough, someone went and got proof he got more man of the match awards than anyone else last season and you've completely moved the goalpoasts saying it's not what you were talking about.

Joe rubbed a lot of fans the wrong way in his first few weeks/months with the club, I was one, but to deny what he brings to the team at this point is either an agenda or trolling.


Thing is, having an opinion he isn't consistent enough isn't a dislike nor is it saying he isn't a good player. My point was that the Rotherham fans said he had 1 decent game in 10 and that's been evident this season.

With regards to the man of the match awards, I wasn't denying he won more man of the match awards that season that anyone else. The poster originally said he won POTY in lockdown season and didn't say they were referring to the HSL award and not the POTY or Players POTY awards given officially by the club......I was referring to the latter so no it is not what I was talking about.

I am not saying he doesn't bring anything to the team. As I previously said, I thought he had a cracking game on Sunday....

[mokie]

You’re entitled to it, the same way I’m entitled to tell you football probably isn’t the sport for you. Sure the cricket will be back on shortly.


Interested to hear why you think football probably isn't the sport for me....

[flash]

Thing is, having an opinion he isn't consistent enough isn't a dislike nor is it saying he isn't a good player. My point was that the Rotherham fans said he had 1 decent game in 10 and that's been evident this season.

With regards to the man of the match awards, I wasn't denying he won more man of the match awards that season that anyone else. The poster originally said he won POTY in lockdown season and didn't say they were referring to the HSL award and not the POTY or Players POTY awards given officially by the club......I was referring to the latter so no it is not what I was talking about.

I am not saying he doesn't bring anything to the team. As I previously said, I thought he had a cracking game on Sunday....

You think he has had one good game in every 10 this season?

No wonder you are being ridiculed by everybody.

[mokie]

The poster is negative towards everything hibs, yet to see a post from them where something is positive, must be a boring life being like that all the time

As I replied to you on Sunday, I had a lot of very positive things to say about the match but you've chosen to dismiss that and focus on the negative yourself.

Still waiting on your recommendations for a night at the opera...........might stop my life being so "boring" :aok::aok::aok:

[mokie]

Likely to be more of these kind of trolling posts with the derbies upcoming.


Have a different opinion therefore must be a troll or a Jambo :top marks

[CropleyWasGod]

As I replied to you on Sunday, I had a lot of very positive things to say about the match but you've chosen to dismiss that and focus on the negative yourself.

Still waiting on your recommendations for a night at the opera...........might stop my life being so "boring" :aok::aok::aok:

Madame Butterfly. :agree:

I'm going to see Carmen next month, so will let you know.

[CapitalGreen]

Thing is, having an opinion he isn't consistent enough isn't a dislike nor is it saying he isn't a good player. My point was that the Rotherham fans said he had 1 decent game in 10 and that's been evident this season.

With regards to the man of the match awards, I wasn't denying he won more man of the match awards that season that anyone else. The poster originally said he won POTY in lockdown season and didn't say they were referring to the HSL award and not the POTY or Players POTY awards given officially by the club......I was referring to the latter so no it is not what I was talking about.

I am not saying he doesn't bring anything to the team. As I previously said, I thought he had a cracking game on Sunday....

Newell has played 28 games this season, using your “1 decent game in 10” are you saying that he’s at most only had 3 decent games this season?

[Hibbyradge]

Thing is, having an opinion he isn't consistent enough isn't a dislike nor is it saying he isn't a good player. My point was that the Rotherham fans said he had 1 decent game in 10 and that's been evident this season.

With regards to the man of the match awards, I wasn't denying he won more man of the match awards that season that anyone else. The poster originally said he won POTY in lockdown season and didn't say they were referring to the HSL award and not the POTY or Players POTY awards given officially by the club......I was referring to the latter so no it is not what I was talking about.

I am not saying he doesn't bring anything to the team. As I previously said, I thought he had a cracking game on Sunday....

You seriously think that he has maybe 4 good games a year?

[Hibbyradge]

Newell has played 28 games this season, using your “1 decent game in 10” are you saying that he’s at most only had 3 decent games this season?

Beat me to it.

[JimBHibees]

Have a different opinion therefore must be a troll or a Jambo :top marks

I agree :greengrin

[mokie]

Madame Butterfly. :agree:

I'm going to see Carmen next month, so will let you know.


Seeing as some people think I need to be more upbeat I might avoid Madame Butterfly.

I'll await your review of Carmen :wink:

[Caversham Green]

Seeing as some people think I need to be more upbeat I might avoid Madame Butterfly.

I'll await your review of Carmen :wink:

Spoiler alert:

She dies in the end. In both cases.

[Allant1981]

As I replied to you on Sunday, I had a lot of very positive things to say about the match but you've chosen to dismiss that and focus on the negative yourself.

Still waiting on your recommendations for a night at the opera...........might stop my life being so "boring" :aok::aok::aok:

Because 99% of what you post is negative and clearly being picked up by other posters now

[mokie]

Because 99% of what you post is negative and clearly being picked up by other posters now

You seem to have a wee bee in your bonnet don't you ??

Clearly you like to be part of the hibs.net pile in where one poster goes against the grain and then it's a free for all...

Opinions pal are like buttholes , we all have one....:aok::aok::aok::aok::aok:

[CropleyWasGod]

spoiler alert:

She dies in the end. In both cases.

ffs

[J-C]

30 yards is generous 😂 closer to the dugouts than the goal. Macey could’ve done slightly better but listening to Maloney and seeing the fact he couldn’t kick the ball by the end, seems he was still carrying an injury so movement would’ve been limited.

Which then begs the question why was he between the sticks if still suffering from that injury.

[CropleyWasGod]

You seem to have a wee bee in your bonnet don't you ??

Clearly you like to be part of the hibs.net pile in where one poster goes against the grain and then it's a free for all...

Opinions pal are like buttholes , we all have one....:aok::aok::aok::aok::aok:

That's only your opinion, though. :wink:

https://melmagazine.com/en-us/story/five-lies-youve-been-told-about-your-butthole#:~:text=Not%20everyone%20has%20a%20buttho le,condition%20that%20can%20mean%20a

[neil7908]

Really like Newell but not sure him and JDH work together. I think Newell needs someone beside him with a bit more energy and goal threat.

[MWHIBBIES]

Thing is, having an opinion he isn't consistent enough isn't a dislike nor is it saying he isn't a good player. My point was that the Rotherham fans said he had 1 decent game in 10 and that's been evident this season.

With regards to the man of the match awards, I wasn't denying he won more man of the match awards that season that anyone else. The poster originally said he won POTY in lockdown season and didn't say they were referring to the HSL award and not the POTY or Players POTY awards given officially by the club......I was referring to the latter so no it is not what I was talking about.

I am not saying he doesn't bring anything to the team. As I previously said, I thought he had a cracking game on Sunday....

No, it has not. Not even slightly. Utter ****ing rubbish. Hes been good far more often than not for over 2 years now. Get on board, he's going nowhere.

[J-C]

Really like Newell but not sure him and JDH work together. I think Newell needs someone beside him with a bit more energy and goal threat.

That was Magennis as we seen at the start of the season, unfortunately we can't rely on Magennis, I think Maloney maybe looking for his replacement unless he can prove his fitness.

[Oscar T Grouch]

Spoiler alert:

She dies in the end. In both cases.

Well opera is all a bit stabby at times :wink:

[truehibernian]

I like Newell but I can see why he splits opinion and is a marmite type player. In his defence, he was signed by Heckingbottom as a wide(r) attacking player, and after a very inauspicious start and poor showings in that position his confidence and appearances suffered. Ross then utilised him as a central midfielder playing a little deeper and more possession based, a lynchpin between midfield and attack. That I’m itself has meant Joe having to learn a new role, very quickly, and in very inconsistent midfield selections. It’s also an area of the pitch that’s meant he’s had to be more combative which may mean more injuries.

I think he’s better higher up the pitch and certainly has great technique to link play with strikers. Good set piece taker too. In think he gets asked to do too much,,a Jack of all midfield trades, hence maybe why Maloney wants an out and out 6 which then allows the more technically gifted players to be more advanced on the pitch.

[jacomo]

I like Newell but I can see why he splits opinion and is a marmite type player. In his defence, he was signed by Heckingbottom as a wide(r) attacking player, and after a very inauspicious start and poor showings in that position his confidence and appearances suffered. Ross then utilised him as a central midfielder playing a little deeper and more possession based, a lynchpin between midfield and attack. That I’m itself has meant Joe having to learn a new role, very quickly, and in very inconsistent midfield selections. It’s also an area of the pitch that’s meant he’s had to be more combative which may mean more injuries.

I think he’s better higher up the pitch and certainly has great technique to link play with strikers. Good set piece taker too. In think he gets asked to do too much,,a Jack of all midfield trades, hence maybe why Maloney wants an out and out 6 which then allows the more technically gifted players to be more advanced on the pitch.


Joe told anyone who would listen he wasn’t a winger when he joined the club.

Hecky just got it wrong.

[Allant1981]

You seem to have a wee bee in your bonnet don't you ??

Clearly you like to be part of the hibs.net pile in where one poster goes against the grain and then it's a free for all...

Opinions pal are like buttholes , we all have one....:aok::aok::aok::aok::aok:

Nah just see through folk quite easy

[mokie]

Nah just see through folk quite easy


yeh but you still like a wee pile in don't you ??

Amazing to read that you can see through me considering we have never actually met... :wink::wink::wink::wink:

[mokie]

That's only your opinion, though. :wink:

https://melmagazine.com/en-us/story/five-lies-youve-been-told-about-your-butthole#:~:text=Not%20everyone%20has%20a%20buttho le,condition%20that%20can%20mean%20a


There you go then. Day without learning is a day lost....:agree::agree::agree:

[superfurryhibby]

You seem to have a wee bee in your bonnet don't you ??

Clearly you like to be part of the hibs.net pile in where one poster goes against the grain and then it's a free for all...

Opinions pal are like buttholes , we all have one....:aok::aok::aok::aok::aok:

Yes, and like opinions, some reek more than others.

Newell is a classy player and without doubt one of the most technically gifted guys in the squad. I'm not bothered what you say about what Rotherham fans said or the 1 in 10 gash, I'll trust what I see, he's someone that makes the side tick. Big, big player for Hibs.

[mokie]

Yes, and like opinions, some reek more than others.

Newell is a classy player and without doubt one of the most technically gifted guys in the squad. I'm not bothered what you say about what Rotherham fans said or the 1 in 10 gash, I'll trust what I see, he's someone that makes the side tick. Big, big player for Hibs.


There's one statement that we both agree on..

Yeh he's so classy that he is still playing at Hibs.. Out of contract last summer and nobody wanted to sign him on a free. Reason for that mate..

[MWHIBBIES]

There's one statement that we both agree on..

Yeh he's so classy that he is still playing at Hibs.. Out of contract last summer and nobody wanted to sign him on a free. Reason for that mate..

So good players cant be at Hibs for any period of time? Hes been here less time than Mcginn was.

He signed a new deal over a year ago, so no, he was not out of contract last summer. How do you know no one was interested?

[Allant1981]

There's one statement that we both agree on..

Yeh he's so classy that he is still playing at Hibs.. Out of contract last summer and nobody wanted to sign him on a free. Reason for that mate..

Making yourself more and more obvious now

[flash]

There's one statement that we both agree on..

Yeh he's so classy that he is still playing at Hibs.. Out of contract last summer and nobody wanted to sign him on a free. Reason for that mate..

You will find out how good he is when we tuck you away in the semi.
Blatant.

[beensaidbefore]

Another boring thread. Can we not share opinions without turning it into a dick measuring contest?

Folk are going to have different opinions, but that doesn't mean we need to make it personal every time we disagree. Seems to be the way of the site now, a lot of longstanding posters have left and this thread is a good example why.

[flash]

Another boring thread. Can we not share opinions without turning it into a dick measuring contest?

Folk are going to have different opinions, but that doesn't mean we need to make it personal every time we disagree. Seems to be the way of the site now, a lot of longstanding posters have left and this thread is a good example why.
Do you seriously think we aren't being played here?

[beensaidbefore]

Do you seriously think we aren't being played here?

No. think the poster made a genuine comment similar to others I have read on here several times, something along the lines of, Newel is good only one in 5 games, let's hope he proves us wrong and kicks on in the next game. I don't think that qualifies him as a jambo.

Regardless the sentiment stands, this place can be pretty sad at times where a bunch of posters essentially gang up on someone they disagree with. No problem with the disagreeing if a cou ter argument is being put forward, but posts like, what a load of nonsense but not offering a counter opinion are just as bad. Imo of course:wink:

[mokie]

Making yourself more and more obvious now


You're right mate.. Absolutely nothing gets past you...... Sharper than than a tack you are...........

[Allant1981]

You're right mate.. Absolutely nothing gets past you...... Sharper than than a tack you are...........

At last a sensible post from you

[mokie]

No. think the poster made a genuine comment similar to others I have read on here several times, something along the lines of, Newel is good only one in 5 games, let's hope he proves us wrong and kicks on in the next game. I don't think that qualifies him as a jambo.

Regardless the sentiment stands, this place can be pretty sad at times where a bunch of posters essentially gang up on someone they disagree with. No problem with the disagreeing if a cou ter argument is being put forward, but posts like, what a load of nonsense but not offering a counter opinion are just as bad. Imo of course:wink:

Exactly. Just because posters go against the grain and post unpopular opinions , it starts a free for all for personal abuse such as being labelled a troll or being called a jambo amongst other things. It is utterly pathetic..

I have had a season ticket for over 30 years so yeh I am a dyed in the wool Hearts supporter.

[Allant1981]

No. think the poster made a genuine comment similar to others I have read on here several times, something along the lines of, Newel is good only one in 5 games, let's hope he proves us wrong and kicks on in the next game. I don't think that qualifies him as a jambo.

Regardless the sentiment stands, this place can be pretty sad at times where a bunch of posters essentially gang up on someone they disagree with. No problem with the disagreeing if a cou ter argument is being put forward, but posts like, what a load of nonsense but not offering a counter opinion are just as bad. Imo of course:wink:

Except its not true to say he is only good 1 in 5, probably the exact opposite

[mokie]

So good players cant be at Hibs for any period of time? Hes been here less time than Mcginn was.

He signed a new deal over a year ago, so no, he was not out of contract last summer. How do you know no one was interested?


He signed a new deal in February 2021 so he would've been a free agent at the end of last season.......

https://www.edinburghnews.scotsman.com/sport/football/hibs/hibs-announce-new-two-year-deal-for-star-midfielder-joe-newell-3144500

[Hibbyradge]

Exactly. Just because posters go against the grain and post unpopular opinions , it starts a free for all for personal abuse such as being labelled a troll or being called a jambo amongst other things. It is utterly pathetic..

I have had a season ticket for over 30 years so yeh I am a dyed in the wool Hearts supporter.

You're entitled to your opinion, of course, but the thing is, you've given more than just an opinion.

You stated that Newell has 1 good game in 10 as a fact, and used an alleged comment from a Rotherham fan(s) to back it up. Had you said that in your opinion he was inconsistent then you probably wouldn't have attracted all the attention. You do seem to be revelling in it though so fair enough.

PS The expression is "pile on" not "in". :wink:

[flash]

No. think the poster made a genuine comment similar to others I have read on here several times, something along the lines of, Newel is good only one in 5 games, let's hope he proves us wrong and kicks on in the next game. I don't think that qualifies him as a jambo.

Regardless the sentiment stands, this place can be pretty sad at times where a bunch of posters essentially gang up on someone they disagree with. No problem with the disagreeing if a cou ter argument is being put forward, but posts like, what a load of nonsense but not offering a counter opinion are just as bad. Imo of course:wink:
No worries.

[mokie]

You're entitled to your opinion, of course, but the thing is, you've given more than just an opinion.

You stated that Newell has 1 good game in 10 as a fact, and used an alleged comment from a Rotherham fan(s) to back it up. Had you said that in your opinion he was inconsistent then you probably wouldn't have attracted all the attention. You do seem to be revelling in it though so fair enough.

PS The expression is "pile on" not "in". :wink:


it wasn't an alleged comment. It was on their forum at the time we signed him....

So it is now my fault I am getting all this stick because of the way I worded a post ?? :rolleyes::rolleyes::rolleyes::rolleyes::rolleyes:

[Hibbyradge]

it wasn't an alleged comment. It was on their forum at the time we signed him....

So it is now my fault I am getting all this stick because of the way I worded a post ?? :rolleyes::rolleyes::rolleyes::rolleyes::rolleyes:

Yes, it is.

[MWHIBBIES]

He signed a new deal in February 2021 so he would've been a free agent at the end of last season.......

https://www.edinburghnews.scotsman.com/sport/football/hibs/hibs-announce-new-two-year-deal-for-star-midfielder-joe-newell-3144500

Yes, except he decided to renew his contract, probably long before actually signing. Thats why others weren't interested, he wasn't available.

[mokie]

Yes, it is.


Another Hibs.net special.

Poster has a different POV to the majority and the path of the thread leads to Blaming the victim . Real classy........

[mokie]

Yes, except he decided to renew his contract, probably long before actually signing. Thats why others weren't interested, he wasn't available.

Ok if that's what you think then that's fine...

People I know who work at the club would certainly say otherwise but as I said if you look at it like that then great........

[Hibbyradge]

Another Hibs.net special.

Poster has a different POV to the majority and the path of the thread leads to Blaming the victim . Real classy........

:faf:

[flash]

Another Hibs.net special.

Poster has a different POV to the majority and the path of the thread leads to Blaming the victim . Real classy........

Dry yer eyes. You were talking mince and got called out.
It's no conspiracy. We didn't all PM each other.
If a poster talks drivel there's a sporting chance several other posters will get stuck in.
I have been that poster and you just have to hold uour hand up.

[mokie]

Dry yer eyes. You were talking mince and got called out.
It's no conspiracy. We didn't all PM each other.
If a poster talks drivel there's a sporting chance several other posters will get stuck in.
I have been that poster and you just have to hold uour hand up.

So because you and others don't agree , does it give everyone the right to then '' get stuck in '' and chuck out personal insults ??

Why should I '' just have to hold my hand up '' ?? Folk wouldn't speak like that to others in public so why should be allowed to hide behind keyboards and user names to dish out abuse ???

[Allant1981]

So because you and others don't agree , does it give everyone the right to then '' get stuck in '' and chuck out personal insults ??

Why should I '' just have to hold my hand up '' ?? Folk wouldn't speak like that to others in public so why should be allowed to hide behind keyboards and user names to dish out abuse ???

Personal insults and abuse! give it a break

[MWHIBBIES]

Ok if that's what you think then that's fine...

People I know who work at the club would certainly say otherwise but as I said if you look at it like that then great........

God you're talking rubbish, please stop.

[mokie]

Personal insults and abuse! give it a break


The abuse people get on here is utterly ridiculous at times and all because they have a different opinion to the majority.

Would you dish out some of the stuff that gets posted on here to someone face to face ???

[mokie]

God you're talking rubbish, please stop.


Believe me , I am not talking rubbish. Far from it being perfectly honest..

[MWHIBBIES]

Believe me , I am not talking rubbish. Far from it being perfectly honest..

Believe me, you are


See how easy that is

[Hibs90]

After seeing the midfield two of JDH and Campbell, then seeing Newell and Campbell. I can now safely say Newell is a level above both in my eyes. The improvement in the middle of the park with him in the team speaks volumes. We are a better team with him in it at present and to be fair I've never been his biggest fan. I hope he can stay fit and injury free for the remainder of the season in particular middle of April.

[cameronw-hfc]

it wasn't an alleged comment. It was on their forum at the time we signed him....

So it is now my fault I am getting all this stick because of the way I worded a post ?? :rolleyes::rolleyes::rolleyes::rolleyes::rolleyes:


Why do you need to take a Rotherham fans opinion of him? Have you not been watching him at hibs for the past few seasons?

Using a former clubs fan works if he's a new signing, but why do you keep using their opinion when he's been at hibs a few years now?

[Tambo]

Thought Newell strolled the first half considering he's be out.

Looked to get the ball forward when he can and kept the ball moving around the back also with a couple of key pases out wide.

He could be a key player to the way Maloney wants to play.

[Callum_62]

You think he has had one good game in every 10 this season?

No wonder you are being ridiculed by everybody.Only had 3 good games this season

FACT!

Sent from my VOG-L29 using Tapatalk

[hibbysam]

Thing is, having an opinion he isn't consistent enough isn't a dislike nor is it saying he isn't a good player. My point was that the Rotherham fans said he had 1 decent game in 10 and that's been evident this season.

With regards to the man of the match awards, I wasn't denying he won more man of the match awards that season that anyone else. The poster originally said he won POTY in lockdown season and didn't say they were referring to the HSL award and not the POTY or Players POTY awards given officially by the club......I was referring to the latter so no it is not what I was talking about.

I am not saying he doesn't bring anything to the team. As I previously said, I thought he had a cracking game on Sunday....

Your 1 in 10 comment is why football isn’t for you friend. Clueless.

[Viva_Palmeiras]

Making yourself more and more obvious now

https://www.nasa.gov/mission_pages/shuttle/launch/countdown101.html ?

[mokie]

Your 1 in 10 comment is why football isn’t for you friend. Clueless.

Your lack of knowledge when it comes to SKY's tv scheduling is maybe why football isn't for youeither friend.

[Bostonhibby]

Seems to be doing okay in the thread where Hibs fans are asked to say who their current three favourite players are.

Sent from my SM-A750FN using Tapatalk

[H18 SFR]

So because you and others don't agree , does it give everyone the right to then '' get stuck in '' and chuck out personal insults ??

Why should I '' just have to hold my hand up '' ?? Folk wouldn't speak like that to others in public so why should be allowed to hide behind keyboards and user names to dish out abuse ???

I’ve never met you but I’m beginning to genuinely worry for you. You seem so unhappy about everyone and everything. Happy to PM if you need to reach out and chat.

[mokie]

I’ve never met you but I’m beginning to genuinely worry for you. You seem so unhappy about everyone and everything. Happy to PM if you need to reach out and chat.

That’s what my therapist has been telling me to do for the last 7 years. Thanks very much , I’ll be in touch at half time of the arsenal game. . :aok::aok:

[nonshinyfinish]

Seems to be doing okay in the thread where Hibs fans are asked to say who their current three favourite players are.

Sent from my SM-A750FN using Tapatalk

In the latest totals he has 18 out 209 votes, so he’s underperforming the famous Rotherham 1 in 10…

[Bostonhibby]

In the latest totals he has 18 out 209 votes, so he’s underperforming the famous Rotherham 1 in 10…Not big in rotherham then.

100%record amongst the 2 Peterborough fans I've spoken to about him, seeing another one Friday so who knows.

Sent from my SM-A750FN using Tapatalk

[Hibbyradge]

Not big in rotherham then.

100%record amongst the 2 Peterborough fans I've spoken to about him, seeing another one Friday so who knows.

Sent from my SM-A750FN using Tapatalk

Hearts fans don't rate him...

[Bostonhibby]

Hearts fans don't rate him...Have you done a poll, or are you just plucking numbers out the air to suit your agenda?

Sent from my SM-A750FN using Tapatalk

[Hibbyradge]

Have you done a poll, or are you just plucking numbers out the air to suit your agenda?

Sent from my SM-A750FN using Tapatalk

I read about it

[Bostonhibby]

I read about itOkay, you win.

Sent from my SM-A750FN using Tapatalk

[RG04]

Joe Newell is neat and tidy on the ball, he’s not the quickest guy in the world in mind or physically but a decent passer of the ball. Struggles going forward to a point, as he has no real personal goal threat, but occasionally plays a goal threading pass. Defensively he’s pretty switched on positional but again his lack of great mobility costs him in tracking runners or picking up other lost men..

All in all he’s a decent player at our level!!

[Hibbyradge]

Okay, you win.

Sent from my SM-A750FN using Tapatalk

:tee hee:

[Eyrie]

In the latest totals he has 18 out 209 votes, so he’s underperforming the famous Rotherham 1 in 10…

You need to divide the number of votes by three to find out how many posters have voted (210/3 = 70), so he's in a very respectable 18 out of 70 top threes.

25% is outperforming his Rotherham days.