James Scott

[MWHIBBIES]

Why is this utter waste of a wage getting minutes in front of hauge or melkerson?

[Juice-Terry]

Makes NO sense.

[GreenCastle]

Drey Wright and James Scott should never feature in a match day squad again. Would rather we had Murphy or just play a younger player.

They aren’t the future and won’t be here after summer.

[Juice-Terry]

JDH should be nowhere near it either.

[SteveHFC]

Can we terminate loan deals outside the transfer window?

[Juice-Terry]

Nor should Campbell.

[AL-Qaholik]

MUST be a condition of his loan.
There can be absolutely no other explanation.

[eastmainsmsh]

Be better with Jimmy Martin Scott

[eastmainsmsh]

Be better with Jimmy Martin Scott

[Heisenberg]

A truly horrendous excuse for a footballer. Not a clue how he’s getting game time.

[Lago]

I wonder if Jack Ross has an opinion.

[Mikey_1875]

Nowhere near at fault for today but I don’t think I’ve seen a player make as little impact as him. As people have said how do we not have any better options?

[Hibee Mac]

What worries me is that anyone with a pair of eyes can see that he brings nothing but our manager seems to consistently think he's worthy of game time ahead of players like Scott Allan.

The same can be said for Drey Wright, I always question a manager when the entire fan base thinks differently than them.

[Libby Hibby]

Why try and change the game by removing Doidge then bring Scott on? It makes no football sense.

[Nicho87]

Don’t understand maloney saying weeks ago ach permit for Melkerson still not through - then never uses him.

Chuck him on. We’re pish

[Onceinawhile]

Awful, awful excuse for a footballer.

[JohnM1875]

He needs to be nowhere near Easter Road ASAP.

[Boss_Nass]

He’s horrific and the fact Maloney plays him is a very concerning indictment on his competence as a manager. I’m assuming Hull included some form of clause which meant Hibs had to pay a fee if he was to be sent back? Even if that’s not true why is he getting on ahead of Allan, Melkersen etc.

[Booked4Being-Ugly]

Makes me nostalgic for the Alan O’Brien days!

[Callum_62]

Why try and change the game by removing Doidge then bring Scott on? It makes no football sense.Doidge came off for Henderson

Sent from my VOG-L29 using Tapatalk

[Unseen work]

I was very excited when when we signed him based on his Motherwell days but he’s been rotten.

He always try’s to cut it on his right and always gets tackled. Every single time, he doesn’t even do it with any pace or real change in body shape.

So so easy to defend.

[MWHIBBIES]

It’s absolutely ridiculous that a player from that game is singled out.
Entire team and management were garbage.

Right, but they've all shown at least one positive thing in their time here. He has done absolutely nothing. Not 1 thing. Absolutely dreadful

[Joe6-2]

Why we brought him in at all beggars belief, but how he still gets game time is totally baffling.
Him and Nisbet can get to f***

[Smartie]

Not necessarily defending him here… but should it really be any sort of priority to single him out today?

By the time he went on we’d lost all shape and cohesion and were desperate.

I can think of at least a dozen people to single out before him from the playing staff alone, and that’s before you get onto coaching staff or club owners.

[Leith Green]

We have signed an absolute ****load of players in January and managed to not really improve our first 11. You could argue that its actually a weaker first 11 without boyle

[Libby Hibby]

Doidge came off for Henderson

Sent from my VOG-L29 using Tapatalk

I know but to bring on Scott later on would just be like keeping Doidge on, it makes no sense.

[Hibee_Lisa]

We have signed an absolute ****load of players in January and managed to not really improve our first 11. You could argue that its actually a weaker first 11 without boyle

Don’t think many would argue with that.

[Tommy75]

Offers about as much as Nisbet and Doidge these days.

[Hiber-nation]

His all round game reminds me a bit of Rowan Vine. Which says it all really.

[B.H.F.C]

He shouldn’t be in the squad. Back to the days of having players who don’t give a toss about being here.

[hibee1875]

Has the physic required to make it down south but has appeared to stop trying after his first big contract.

[SMAXXA]

I know but to bring on Scott later on would just be like keeping Doidge on, it makes no sense.

Doidge was pish and has been since he’s came back into the team so as pish as Scott is all the time I don’t think the point re doidge going off is valid. I actually think Nisbit is working harder these days just not getting the run of the green where am seeing nothing from doidge at all at the moment.

[Sir David Gray]

I don't like singling out individuals but he is absolutely rotten and should be nowhere near the first team.

Offers nothing.

[ahibby]

I don't like singling out individuals but he is absolutely rotten and should be nowhere near the first team.

Offers nothing.

Waste of a space on any bench.

[Since452]

Bizarre why he was even brought on.

[Libby Hibby]

Get him tae f@£k, wherever that is

[Pretty Boy]

A panic signing.

Recovering from injury so was never going to hit the ground running. Add to that he's just absolutely crap anyway and we have an issue.

Stick him with the development team until the end of the season then drive him over the Humber Bridge and tell him never to come back.

A total waste of a shirt every week.

[The 90+2]

I'm sure he was class at Motherwell as well.

Or was that Campbell?

[Sir David Gray]

I'm sure he was class at Motherwell as well.

Or was that Campbell?

I remember him playing against us at Fir Park about 3 years ago and he ripped us apart for about 45 minutes.

The fact he was up against Tom James may have had something to do with that right enough.

[The 90+2]

I remember him playing against us at Fir Park about 3 years ago and he ripped us apart for about 45 minutes.

The fact he was up against Tom James may have had something to do with that right enough.


He done the same v Hearts, with Cadden scoring the winner.

He just looks like a fancies a mince pie supper more than being a footballer now. It's weird as I'm sure he was good.

[BegbieHSC]

Makes me nostalgic for the Alan O’Brien days!

Makes me nostalgic of Chris Dagnall!!

[LaMotta]

Absolute disgrace that he gets on the pitch before Scott Allan. He's terrible.

[IberianHibernian]

Absolute disgrace that he gets on the pitch before Scott Allan. He's terrible.Both got on the pitch and both were terrible .

[Eyrie]

I saw Scott getting ready to come on and wondered why Maloney thought he would help us.

But using decidedly un .net language.

[LaMotta]

Both got on the pitch and both were terrible .

Allan got 8 minutes (not long enough) at holding midfielder (ridiculous) and done nothing wrong. He should be playing further up the pitch and be given far longer on the pitch.

Allan has also been pretty good for Hibs before on a regular basis whilst Scott has been consistently terrible.

[hibee1875]

Allan got 8 minutes (not long enough) at holding midfielder (ridiculous) and done nothing wrong. He should be playing further up the pitch and be given far longer on the pitch.

Allan has also been pretty good for Hibs before on a regular basis whilst Scott has been consistently terrible.

He wasn’t playing holding midfielder. He was just dropping deep to get the ball

[CMac1988]

It's a strange one. Doesn't seem to have the same desire as he did back at Motherwell... He's also twice the size and arguably twice as slow as a result.

Someone posted a highlight reel from his time at Motherwell and he's a completely different player. Great turn of pace and very handedly able to a man on and go past them. Add in some goals and assists and you can see why he got a good move. He's done nothing to show he's that kind of player anymore and I'd quite happily see the back of him. Like many in our team he offers nothing.

[LaMotta]

He wasn’t playing holding midfielder. He was just dropping deep to get the ball

Call it what you like he was playing as close to the defense as possible and was clearly told not to go further up the pitch. All he could do there was pass the ball out to the full backs. A total waste for a guy who has most direct goal contributions in the squad (apart from Nisbet).

[hibbydog]

Overweight and *****e

[Nicho87]

Wouldn’t get a game in our B team

[Franck Stanton]

James Scott should never play for us ever again. A complete wage thief. Not interested, no skill, passion, determination, clue.
Send him on gardening leave , get him to f***

[random sub]

It seems a long while since we have substitutes where you see them come on and think ‘this is going to get interesting’. I miss those days.

[Jones28]

Makes me nostalgic of Chris Dagnall!!

He’s a Scottish cup winning legend, how dare you!

[Jones28]

Symptomatic of a truly honking transfer window. In fairness I was pleased when he first signed but Jesus, I’ve never been more disappointed.

[GreenCastle]

His all round game reminds me a bit of Rowan Vine. Which says it all really.

He’s definitely in this territory- just not sure what he actually does when he plays.

I would love it if he came good but he really isn’t showing anything and Vine is one of the worst players I’ve ever seen play for Hibs.

I’m only concerned he doesn’t care about Hibs and will be straight back down south in summer.

[The Baldmans Comb]

Playing Drey Wright from the start in previous weeks and James Scott as a sub sum up Maloney who is a complete rookie manager making it up as he goes along and desperately searching for some sort of game plan.

You can add Scott Allan to the mix as well as while he is finished at Hibs at least give him a chance of influencing a game you are chasing by giving him more than 8 minutes and asking him to play further up the field.

Maloney treats each game as an experiment to cover up for his complete lack of preparation and his lack of experience in making big decisions under pressure.

[Chuck Rhoades]

He’s a Scottish cup winning legend, how dare you!

Honestly grow up

[matty_f]

Scott shouldn’t be anywhere near the team, offers the square root of hee-haw to any aspect of our play.

[Sean1875]

I hate doing it, cause I know he’s technically a hibs player, but I actually get angry when I see him coming on. Like ****ing infuriates me because I know there’s absolutely nothing positive coming from him. It’s like he won a competition to be a professional footballer for a year.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[LaMotta]

Playing Drey Wright from the start in previous weeks and James Scott as a sub sum up Maloney who is a complete rookie manager making it up as he goes along and desperately searching for some sort of game plan.

You can add Scott Allan to the mix as well as while he is finished at Hibs at least give him a chance of influencing a game you are chasing by giving him more than 8 minutes and asking him to play further up the field.

Maloney treats each game as an experiment to cover up for his complete lack of preparation and his lack of experience in making big decisions under pressure.

:agree::agree::agree: