PDA

View Full Version : Player Ratings



worcesterhibby
21-11-2021, 05:19 PM
Just too excited and happy to stop posting on here tonight :greengrin

Macey - 9.5 good on crosses and extra 1/2 point for the keepy uppy off the post :greengrin
McGinn - 9 solid, hard working, calm, got his blocks in when needed
Porteous - 8.5 sold a goal with that clearance but won his headers again and again and managed to stay on his feet.
Hanlon - 9 First 20 seconds aside, he was amazing..must be covered in bruises from blocking shots
Doig - 7 Not his greatest performance, but worked hard, let's hope it wasn't a serious injury
Cadden 9.5 Great energy and so positive going forward, I love it when he plays
Doyle-Hayes 9.5 put in a proper shift, won tackles, covered a huge amount of ground
Campbell 8.5 Unspectacular but didn't put a foot wrong
Newell - 10 One of his best performances for us, brilliant work rate, some real desire and some excellent passing
Nisbet - 10 played brilliantly, great ball for the 2nd, held the ball up well, unselfish, looked class
Boyler - 11 What can I say, Sproule-esque

Stevenson - brilliant and solid when he came on..that moment where he kept the ball in on their bye line...some desire.
McGregor - Great to have him on the pitch at the end
Doidge - Amazing to have him back..really helped in the last few minutes keeping hold of the ball up the top rnd of the park.

Jack Ross - 11 you proved your team can play at hampden in big matches...well done gaffer

weecounty hibby
21-11-2021, 05:39 PM
All 10/10. Outstanding from everyone

Since452
21-11-2021, 05:41 PM
10. The lot of them.

USAHibee
21-11-2021, 07:33 PM
Tough on Doig? Tavernier was anonymous before he went off..

Hibbyradge
21-11-2021, 07:34 PM
Hanlon and Boyle get 10s from me.

kaimendhibs
21-11-2021, 07:50 PM
10/10 all players, fans, coaches and manager

greenlex
21-11-2021, 07:53 PM
Tough on Doig? Tavernier was anonymous before he went off..
This 100% I was actually expecting to see Patterson at gala time.

Unseen work
21-11-2021, 08:22 PM
Thought Doig was actually very good defensively and very little came down his side.

It was very telling when he went off as Stevenson struggled to begin with IMO.

He settled in well eventually though.

Other than that everyone was brilliant and whilst Boyle will get all the headlines there were so many great performances out there for me today, all of the back 3, the wing backs, two centre mids.

I can’t remember a game that I’ve seen us so organised, compact and aggressive in our pressing/play.

Radium
21-11-2021, 08:29 PM
I think that this is one of those games where, save for a moment of hesitation between a CB and goalie, everyone did their job.

Doig was a case in point, played off Tavernier till the ball went to him then hunted him down.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

inglisavhibs
21-11-2021, 08:31 PM
Tough on Doig? Tavernier was anonymous before he went off..

Doig was really good, his best game for a while.

CmoantheHibs
21-11-2021, 08:31 PM
Can’t agree with Doig assessment. Thought he had a great game. Closed tavernier down high up the park stopping them playing their normal game. Left Tavernier just floating in useless crosses from deep when he is usually one of the huns most potent weapons going forward. Got forward well and caused them problems.

Northernhibee
21-11-2021, 08:42 PM
Macey - 7. Think he could have done better at the goal and nearly ended up on a million YouTube highlight reels from that back pass.

Doig - 8. A tough shift but largely did very well.
Hanlon - 10. He put in a massive ‘up yours’ to those commenting on his contract renewal posts on social media. I don’t think I’ve given out a ten on one of these threads before but there’s a trend coming…
Porteous - 10. Unplayable.
McGinn - 10. See Porteous.
Newell - 10. See McGinn
Doyle Hayes - 9
Campbell - 9
Cadden - 9
Boyle - 10
Nisbet - 9

That was one of the best performances over 90 minutes that I can remember. What a day.

JeMeSouviens
21-11-2021, 08:46 PM
James Tavernier - 11 :wink:

Historically, few have contributed so much to the Hibs cause at Hampden!

worcesterhibby
21-11-2021, 09:51 PM
Can’t agree with Doig assessment. Thought he had a great game. Closed tavernier down high up the park stopping them playing their normal game. Left Tavernier just floating in useless crosses from deep when he is usually one of the huns most potent weapons going forward. Got forward well and caused them problems.

fair play, I thought his distribution was lacking in the 2nd half a bit, but happy to bump up his score to 10 with the rest of the team :agree:

Glory Lurker
21-11-2021, 09:53 PM
12/10 for every one of them. Epic.

Hibee Mac
22-11-2021, 07:18 AM
Porteous was excellent, deserves a higher rating.

That goal was down to Macey for me, he should have been screaming for Porteous to leave it and you could tell Ryan was waiting and waiting for a shout that never came. As a result it was a hurried clearance.