Player of the year

[Squealing pig]

U can vote now for favourite goal , young player and player of the year if you check your emails

I went for gogic goal
Doig obviously
And Paul mcginn player of the year

[Magpie]

Mallan GOTS
Doig YPOTY
Boyle POTY

[bingo70]

Boyle player of the year

Doig young player of the year

Goal of the year- not a great amount of decent goals to choose from i don’t think. Doidge at Pittodrie maybe

[Danderhall Hibs]

McGinn, Doig and Doidge

Surprised the Nisbet goal at Cove wasn’t listed.

[Peevemor]

Doig, Doidge & Doidge. I can't be bothered with the rest of the alphabet.

[loanheadhibby]

U can vote now for favourite goal , young player and player of the year if you check your emails

I went for gogic goal
Doig obviously
And Paul mcginn player of the year
If Paul McGinn is our best player of the season we are in big trouble.
He wasn't the only one but Saturday showed how bang average he is.
We must surely get a better right back to progress.

[JohnMcM]

Gogic
Doig
Gogic

[easty]

Mallan GOTS
Doig YPOTY
Boyle POTY

Yep

[Northernhibee]

Mallan
Doig
Hanlon

[AliboyFC]

Mallan GOTS
Doig YPOTY
Boyle POTY

Yes ✅

[H18 SFR]

Gogic
Doig
Hanlon

[Eyrie]

Doidge, Doig and Boyle.

[Smiggy 7-0]

Best goal...Doidge
Best player...Doidge
Young player...Doig

[.Sean.]

Shaun Rooney

[makaveli1875]

They could do biggest ***** bag of the year and collectively award it to them all

[truehibernian]

Doidge has been my player of the year. As much as I do tend to decry him, Paul Hanlon a close second.

Doig young player of the year :aok:

[mim]

Doig, Doidge & Doidge. I can't be bothered with the rest of the alphabet.


Best goal...Doidge
Best player...Doidge
Young player...Doig


Doidge has been my player of the year. As much as I do tend to decry him, Paul Hanlon a close second.

Doig young player of the year :aok:

This :agree:

[Spudster]

If Paul McGinn is our best player of the season we are in big trouble.
He wasn't the only one but Saturday showed how bang average he is.
We must surely get a better right back to progress.

Why does average have to be proceeded with bang nowadays?
If McGinn is even considered for POTY it’s some achievement considering he’s got Boyle who can’t defend in front of him and Porteous.......who can’t defend inside of him

[Hulk1875]

Dodge for goal
Doig for young player
McGregor for Player .. not been there all season but came in and been a professional got over his injury troubles etc.

[marinello59]

If Paul McGinn is our best player of the season we are in big trouble.
He wasn't the only one but Saturday showed how bang average he is.
We must surely get a better right back to progress.

That’s pretty unfair on a player who has proved to be a fantastic signing for us, one of the SPFLs hidden gems. He has had a very good season. He just shades Boyle for my player of the year vote.
Doig for young player of the year.
Doidge for goal.

[loanheadhibby]

That’s pretty unfair on a player who has proved to be a fantastic signing for us, one of the SPFLs hidden gems. He has had a very good season. He just shades Boyle for my player of the year vote.
Doig for young player of the year.
Doidge for goal.
Apologies for the use of bang before average should have said very .
Paul McGinn a fantastic signing and a hidden gem.
I think he is so limited and we need much better if were going to stay ahead of Aberdeen and Hearts.
Opinions are what it's all about.

[Stuart93]

That’s pretty unfair on a player who has proved to be a fantastic signing for us, one of the SPFLs hidden gems. He has had a very good season. He just shades Boyle for my player of the year vote.
Doig for young player of the year.
Doidge for goal.

I like Paul Mcginn, he’s been a decent signing for us, limited with the ball at his feet but sound defensively

I’d agree though that I’d like to see a younger RB/RCB come in though

[Brightside]

Paul Hanlon by miles.

[Key West]

In ultimately what ended up in a disappointing season Boyle was easily the difference between us and the rest achieving a threat and consistency that nobody came near.

[Greenbeard]

In ultimately what ended up in a disappointing season Boyle was easily the difference between us and the rest achieving a threat and consistency that nobody came near.
Boyle and the word consistent do not go together in my book. Played during the season like a POTY at times for sure but too often played like what goes in the potty too. No-one who combined to be either as *hit or as anonymous as he was on Saturday should be even considered for POTY.
I know, I know, you can say that about most of the team but his performance, or lack of it, was *hitter than *hit itself.
The player who has most made a difference to the team this season compared to last season in my book is Goga.

[jeffers]

The one thing that was telling for me about the nominations was how little youngsters had been involved this season bar Doig. The fact Magennis has been included says it all.

[Steve88]

POTY =P. McGinn - Consistent from day one (Boyle only showed up to the party half way through..)

[Peevemor]

The one thing that was telling for me about the nominations was how little youngsters had been involved this season bar Doig. The fact Magennis has been included says it all.

The organisation of training, Covid testing, etc. has made moving players between squads/training groups pretty complicated.

Surely you're not looking for another reason to criticise. Ross's use and integration of Doig has been extremely well managed and makes me optimistic for other youngsters coming through.

[jeffers]

The organisation of training, Covid testing, etc. has made moving players between squads/training groups pretty complicated.

Surely you're not looking for another reason to criticise. Ross's use and integration of Doig has been extremely well managed and makes me optimistic for other youngsters coming through.

Does it not get tiresome trying to constantly defend everything about the club or reading something into others posts that you deem negative ? For the avoidance of doubt I wasn’t criticising the lack of youngsters involvement as I’m well aware of the issues surrounding that (although I would have liked to have seen a bit more of Bradley) merely commenting on how little they had been.

[Peevemor]

Does it not get tiresome trying to constantly defend everything about the club or reading something into others posts that you deem negative ? For the avoidance of doubt I wasn’t criticising the lack of youngsters involvement as I’m well aware of the issues surrounding that (although I would have liked to have seen a bit more of Bradley) merely commenting on how little they had been.

So there wasn't a negative slant to your post then? Sorry I must be mistaken.

Just like I must be mistaken in thinking that I was on a Hibs supporters' forum. Defending the club? What a nutter eh?

[jeffers]

So there wasn't a negative slant to your post then? Sorry I must be mistaken.

Just like I must be mistaken in thinking that I was on a Hibs supporters' forum. Defending the club? What a nutter eh?

No there wasn’t. Apology accepted. If I’d worded it as it’s a pity we hadn’t been able to get more youngsters involved this season I take it that would have been acceptable to you, cos that’s ultimately how I feel.

Defending when it’s merited absolutely. Looking at others posts and interpreting them as negative to have a pop, nah not for me.

[Peevemor]

No there wasn’t. Apology accepted.

Defending when it’s merited absolutely. Looking at others posts and interpreting them as negative to have a pop, nah not for me.

OK. So while we're on the subject of having "a pop" - there's no need for you to do so with me.

[jeffers]

OK. So while we're on the subject of having "a pop" - there's no need for you to do so with me.

And what was your comment “surely you’re not looking for another reason to criticise” then if not a pop at me ?

[Peevemor]

And what was your comment “surely you’re not looking for another reason to criticise” then if not a pop at me ?

And it was you that brought up being tiresome? :rolleyes:

[superfurryhibby]

And it was you that brought up being tiresome? :rolleyes:

You're taking the defence of everything connected to Hibs to the extreme. The guy was making an observation, which happens to be correct. It's very tiresome and contributing to the **** show this board has become since Saturday

[Northernhibee]

You're taking the defence of everything connected to Hibs to the extreme. The guy was making an observation, which happens to be correct. It's very tiresome and contributing to the **** show this board has become since Saturday

Peevemor’s observation was also correct though. Hardly “taking it to the extreme”.

[Peevemor]

You're taking the defence of everything connected to Hibs to the extreme. The guy was making an observation, which happens to be correct. It's very tiresome and contributing to the **** show this board has become since Saturday

No I'm not.

I never set out to defend Hibs, I simply agree or disagree with points made. Also -

"The one thing that was telling for me about the nominations was how little youngsters had been involved this season bar Doig. The fact Magennis has been included says it all."

...telling...how little youngsters...says it all.

For me there's a negative slant which I think is unfair.

And finally, it's really beginning to get on my tits that defending Hibs on here, even if it was in an OTT way, is viewed as a bad thing some.

[Since90+2]

Over the course of the season probably Boyle.

[Since90+2]

No I'm not.

I never set out to defend Hibs, I simply agree or disagree with points made. Also -

"The one thing that was telling for me about the nominations was how little youngsters had been involved this season bar Doig. The fact Magennis has been included says it all."

...telling...how little youngsters...says it all.

For me there's a negative slant which I think is unfair.

And finally, it's really beginning to get on my tits that defending Hibs on here, even if it was in an OTT way, is viewed as a bad thing some.

Saying how little youngsters have been involved isnt being negative it's an observation and quite an accurate one IMO.

[Peevemor]

Saying how little youngsters have been involved it's being negative it's an observation and quite an accurate one IMO.

The negativity came from the wording, not the observattion itself which I didn't question.

[Since90+2]

The negativity came from the wording, not the observattion itself which I didn't question.

Ehh, ok then.

[jeffers]

No I'm not.

I never set out to defend Hibs, I simply agree or disagree with points made. Also -

"The one thing that was telling for me about the nominations was how little youngsters had been involved this season bar Doig. The fact Magennis has been included says it all."

...telling...how little youngsters...says it all.

For me there's a negative slant which I think is unfair.

And finally, it's really beginning to get on my tits that defending Hibs on here, even if it was in an OTT way, is viewed as a bad thing some.

But that’s just you all over, you react to anything you view as criticism even if it wasn’t. I made a point that very few youngsters had been involved this season. It was a statement of fact, that was all, but you chose to see it as something else and in your reply to my post you had a pop at me.You went down that path first not me.

Had I said it’s a disgrace Jack Ross didn’t give more game time to our youngsters then that would have been me criticising.

[Peevemor]

But that’s just you all over, you react to anything you view as criticism even if it wasn’t. I made a point that very few youngsters had been involved this season. It was a statement of fact, that was all, but you chose to see it as something else and in your reply to my post you had a pop at me.You went down that path first not me.

Had I said it’s a disgrace Jack Ross didn’t give more game time to our youngsters then that would have been me criticising.

Fair enough.

[superfurryhibby]

No I'm not.

I never set out to defend Hibs, I simply agree or disagree with points made. Also -

"The one thing that was telling for me about the nominations was how little youngsters had been involved this season bar Doig. The fact Magennis has been included says it all."

...telling...how little youngsters...says it all.

For me there's a negative slant which I think is unfair.

And finally, it's really beginning to get on my tits that defending Hibs on here, even if it was in an OTT way, is viewed as a bad thing some.

Defending Hibs all the time can actually be quite divisive if the person doing so turns every comment into a debate. More so when a reasonable point is being made.

[Since90+2]

But that’s just you all over, you react to anything you view as criticism even if it wasn’t. I made a point that very few youngsters had been involved this season. It was a statement of fact, that was all, but you chose to see it as something else and in your reply to my post you had a pop at me.You went down that path first not me.

Had I said it’s a disgrace Jack Ross didn’t give more game time to our youngsters then that would have been me criticising.

What you said was totally fair and I would imagine the vast majority of Hibs fans would agree.

Infact, I find it very odd that someone would actually take offense at what you said. It's baffling to be honest.

[Peevemor]

Defending Hibs all the time can actually be quite divisive if the person doing so turns every comment into a debate. More so when a reasonable point is being made.

If you don't like my posts, stick me on ignore.

Otherwise give me peace.

[Peevemor]

What you said was totally fair and I would imagine the vast majority of Hibs fans would agree.

Infact, I find it very odd that someone would actually take offense at what you said. It's baffling to be honest.

I didn't take offense - I questioned whether he was criticising or not.

[jeffers]

What you said was totally fair and I would imagine the vast majority of Hibs fans would agree.

Infact, I find it very odd that someone would actually take offense at what you said. It's baffling to be honest.

Maybe Peevemor views me as a negative/ultra critical poster, only he can answer that. I admire his constant defence of the club, but when there are things I don’t agree with I post my thoughts and at times those thoughts are undoubtedly critical. In this instance though I wasn’t being.

[superfurryhibby]

If you don't like my posts, stick me on ignore.

Otherwise give me peace.

Give me peace, from the guy determined to turn every post into argument, how ironic.

No, I'll continue to read your posts and reserve the right to respond when I see fit. If you don't like that, feel free to put down the keyboard.

[Peevemor]

Give me peace, from the guy determined to turn every post into argument, how ironic.

No, I'll continue to read your posts and reserve the right to respond when I see fit. If you don't like that, feel free to put down the keyboard.

So it's OK for you to do it, but not me? Thanks for clearing that up.

[skyehibee]

Boyle for me with Doig young player

[superfurryhibby]

So it's OK for you to do it, but not me? Thanks for clearing that up.

I think our respective post counts say something on that point.

You are all over every thread, countering every point you see as a slight on HIbs, even where there is no slight intended. You then start debating the posters intention, even although they haven't said anything negative and have gone to some lengths to make that clear.

[SaulGoodman]

Is every single thread going to turn into arguments between the same 4 or 5 posters?

[Peevemor]

I think our respective post counts say something on that point.

You are all over every thread, countering every point you see as a slight on HIbs, even where there is no slight intended. You then start debating the posters intention, even although they haven't said anything negative and have gone to some lengths to make that clear.

Out of 40 threads on the front page of the MB, I've posted on 12. I've only become involved in "debates" on maybe half of these.

Are you finished now or are you going to keep making stuff up whilst looking to have a go at me?

[Allez Hibs]

Is every single thread going to turn into arguments between the same 4 or 5 posters?

It appears like it. This might be controversial but I think Peevemor actually has a point and you do have to admire his defending of the club, especially just now as we are very divided on Jack Ross. Peevemor and Blackpool Hibs do bring a sense of perspective and realism to where Hibs currently are and that is probably what is needed just now. Time to reflect after Saturday and let's all stay calm and look forward.

I tried yesterday to pull out the positives from the season to change the narrative a bit and got slaughtered for it.

[MinceAndTatties]

If Paul McGinn is our best player of the season we are in big trouble.
He wasn't the only one but Saturday showed how bang average he is.
We must surely get a better right back to progress.
Opinions eh FWIW I mirror Sq... Pig's selections

[Brightside]

People should really use the ignore function.....saves a huge amount of bickering.

[JohnM1875]

Gogic
Doig
Boyle

All quite clear choices as well for me.

[Allez Hibs]

People should really use the ignore function.....saves a huge amount of bickering.

There shouldn't be a need for an ignore function though.

What kind forum is that. You only see half the posts and miss the context of posts. No thanks. Time a lot of posters grow up.

[Andy74]

It appears like it. This might be controversial but I think Peevemor actually has a point and you do have to admire his defending of the club, especially just now as we are very divided on Jack Ross. Peevemor and Blackpool Hibs do bring a sense of perspective and realism to where Hibs currently are and that is probably what is needed just now. Time to reflect after Saturday and let's all stay calm and look forward.

I tried yesterday to pull out the positives from the season to change the narrative a bit and got slaughtered for it.

You were posting about getting Ross out the club at the weekend.

You seem to have a habit of doing this then stepping back from it again.

Not sure that you should now be trying to be the voice of reason.

[Allez Hibs]

You were posting about getting Ross out the club at the weekend.

You seem to have a habit of doing this then stepping back from it again.

Not sure that you should now be trying to be the voice of reason.

Does every post on here become an argument. I said time to reflect after Saturday, the final is done its gone now. We need to look forward. He needs given next season being realistic.

[Key West]

Boyle and the word consistent do not go together in my book. Played during the season like a POTY at times for sure but too often played like what goes in the potty too. No-one who combined to be either as *hit or as anonymous as he was on Saturday should be even considered for POTY.
I know, I know, you can say that about most of the team but his performance, or lack of it, was *hitter than *hit itself.
The player who has most made a difference to the team this season compared to last season in my book is Goga.

I think Boyle made a significant contribution to our season and was the difference between draws and wins, yes he was invisible on Saturday along with many others.

[Nicho87]

I'd give it to Scott Allan - for over-coming his health issues hopefully

And a reminder how valued he is by hibs supporters.

[Hibernian Verse]

We should have an English Language section of the forum so posters can disagree about hibs.net literature and let the rest of us read about Hibs.

[Andy74]

Does every post on here become an argument. I said time to reflect after Saturday, the final is done its gone now. We need to look forward. He needs given next season being realistic.

Then we lose a game you don’t like and you post Ross out messages.

Perhaps that’s why you find some of your discussions turning to arguments?

[silverhibee]

Is every single thread going to turn into arguments between the same 4 or 5 posters?

Yep, becoming tiresome

[BILLYHIBS]

PH by the length of Perth High Street

No brainer imho

Everyone else is entitled to their opinion and I respect that but my die is cast 😃

[The Sundance Kid]

For me:

Player of the season - Martin Boyle
Young player of the season - Josh Doig
Goal of the season- Alex Gogic v Kilmarnock

[tamh]

Paul Hanlon player of the year:agree::agree::flag:

[rodhibs55]

For Me:

Player of the year - Paul Hanlon
Young Player of the year - Josh Doig
Goal of the season - Christian Doige v Sheep

[147lothian]

Martin Boyle gets in for me, he also seemed to come onto a game towards the end of the season which is good news for the new campaign.

[Lancs Harp]

I'd give it to Scott Allan - for over-coming his health issues hopefully

And a reminder how valued he is by hibs supporters.

Wouldnt go with Scott personally but understand and appreciate the sentiment.