Log in

View Full Version : This is how it feels (Celtic 15 05 21)



Jonnyboy
15-05-2021, 03:23 PM
Having secured their third place finish, Hibs faced Celtic at Easter Road in the final league match of the season and as predicted by many fans and alluded to by Jack Ross himself in the lead up to the game there were wholesale changes to the starting eleven. Only McGregor, Gogic and Hallberg remained from the win at Pittodrie whilst Celtic were close to full strength in what was Scott Brown’s last game for the Hoops. Of course, the game also featured a last appearance in the shape of Ofir Marciano and he was prominent in Hibs securing a point in a 0-0 draw.

Like many, I was puzzled when I heard the names of the starting eleven for Hibs as it was unclear who would be playing in the striker role. As it turned out, both Hallberg and Wright took turns in being furthest forward, but it was evident from early in the game that the plan was, first and foremost, to frustrate Celtic and stop them playing.

The visitors started the better and early efforts by Edouard, Turnbull and Elyounoussi were blocked with the last of that three witnessing Darren McGregor clearing from almost on the goal line. On the seven minute mark, Darren McGregor should really have done better when he was afforded a free header from a corner, but the big defender guided his attempt over the bar. Minutes later, Murphy looked to break clear but was impeded by Kenny who found his name in the book as a result.

At times, it was alarming to see Ajer burst forward unimpeded but thankfully, for the most part, nothing came from his final ball. Marciano then made a fine save to deny Elyounoussi with a dive low to his left before Turnbull tested the keeper with a powerful drive that Rocky collected safely. It was all Celtic in a possession sense, but they were finding it difficult to break down a resolute Hibs. Still, the visitors were creating chances, but none could be described as clear cut and two Christie efforts and a trundler from Calum McGregor failed to trouble Marciano.

Another of those runs from Ajer led to him being brought down around twenty yards from goal. Edouard struck a fine shot into the top corner, but Willie Collum had blown for some sort of infringement and the Celtic man’s retaken effort struck the Hibs wall and was cleared. With half time looming, Edouard was once again denied and then Drey Wright got the opportunity to have a pop at goal, but his shot was both high and wide of the target.

The second half began with two fouls on the trot by Kyle Magennis and I confess I was surprised Willie Collum kept the yellow card in his pocket. Said card did emerge some five minutes in to the half when Welsh hauled Murphy back as the Hibs man tried to break forward. From the resultant free kick, Porteous headed the ball down to Hallberg but the Swede’s shot at goal flew high. Hallberg was convinced the ball had deflected off Ajer, but Willie Collum disagreed. Approaching the hour mark, Gogic was booked for as pretty harmless challenge, making me start to fret that he’d get another and perhaps miss the final.

A double substitution saw the arrival of Forest and Griffiths with John Kennedy no doubt hoping they’d be able to find cracks in the Hibs rearguard and Griffiths was soon involved but his shot was blocked and then, at the other end, an effort from Gogic suffered the same outcome. A few Hibs players were starting to tire, which was unsurprising given that they hadn’t had a lot of playing minutes lately, and both Murphy and Hallberg were replaced by Irvine and Doidge. Whatever influence Kennedy thought Forest could offer was thwarted given that the Celtic man couldn’t get the better of Stevenson and was soon moved to the other wing where he fared no better.

David Gray who looked puggled after five minutes was eventually replaced by Paul McGinn and I have to say that puggled he may have been, but he gave every ounce of his being to deny Celtic in their efforts to score. At the same time as Gray departed, so too did Drey Wright who was replaced by Josh Doig. At that point I was excited to see how Josh would do playing wide left of midfield as Stevenson retained his left back slot. Around ten minutes from the end, Scott Brown tried his luck from around twenty yards but pulled his effort wide of Marciano’s right hand post. I mention this because it had become obvious that Celtic had run out of ideas and were restricted to long range efforts.

The game was petering out but before it ended, Turnbull saw a shot blocked and then Griffiths released Forest, but Marciano was quick off his line to smother the ball at the feet of the Celtic man. Right at the death I thought Hibs had won it, but Irvine’s shot flew over the bar. With no goals in the game, it’s worth pointing out that Barkas never had a save to make whereas Rocky was superb in finishing his Hibs career on a high.

The players

Marciano – Rocky made several good saves during the game and he looked both solid and assured throughout. Over the piece he’s done a fine job and I wish him every success at his new club, wherever that may be.

Gray – As I said, SDG looked puggled early on and that’s no surprise given his substantial lack of game time but being the player he is, he offered 100% effort and commitment throughout.

McGregor – Once again Daz was immense and easily the best man on the park. Obviously, he gets my man of the match award and I’m astonished that the BBC reporter gave it to Elyounoussi who started well enough but fell away so much he was subbed before the end.

Porteous – Ryan was solid enough today with no daft decisions taken and both he and Daz have given Jack Ross a selection headache ahead of the final.

Stevenson – Lewis never gave an inch and defended extremely well. I lost count of the number of times he took up the correct position to cover his central defenders should they make a mistake. Young Josh is learning from the best, in my opinion.

Gogic – Perhaps not quite so prominent as he had been against the Dons, he still put in one hell of a shift and both Turnbull and McGregor were never given a moments peace.

Newell – Joe was involved throughout and yet hardly got a mention in commentary, though I suspect that was because he was blocking spaces for Celtic to work in, rather than spraying passes left, right and centre.

Magennis – I thought Kyle put in a great shift and the fact that he covered so much ground and yet still survived the ninety minutes seems to show he’s getting the minutes to get up to speed.

Wright – I thought he had a good first half and that he showed signs of the player we hoped we’d signed. Quieter in the second but then the whole of the second half was quieter than the first.

Murphy – Another good shift from Jamie who was asked to play a slightly deeper role than usual, which he did to good effect.

Hallberg – Proved to us all, including the West Stand assistant, that beating the offside trap is a lot harder than it looks! Fair play to him though as he was another that put in a great shift.

Irvine – Got about the park well and was unlucky not to get a corner when his shot on the turn clearly clipped Ajer’s boot on the way over the bar.

Doidge – I’m simply glad the big fella avoided injury if I’m honest.

McGinn – Had to face Forest who’d switched wings and did so admirably.

Doig – Ten minutes doesn’t give a player a lot of time to make an impact.

Jack Ross – Full of praise for his ‘fringe’ players and rightly so. It has become increasingly obvious that Jack is a good man manager and that is a precious skill in itself.

Referee – Willie Collum was largely untroubled which is a good thing for a referee.

Brooster
15-05-2021, 03:27 PM
Another great report JC. Thanks for taking the time to do this after every game, I really enjoy them.

147lothian
15-05-2021, 03:37 PM
Brilliant Jonnyboy and it's good to see you back

Killiehibbie
15-05-2021, 03:57 PM
Good read every week. Thanks for taking the time.

bythecringe
15-05-2021, 04:00 PM
Thanks JB for the match reports through the season. Hope you get the chance to make next week’s cup final report a belter.
Wishing you good health and good luck

Aldo
15-05-2021, 04:01 PM
Thanks JB and thanks very much for taking the time throughout the season to provide superb match day reports. [emoji122]


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

BILLYHIBS
15-05-2021, 04:06 PM
Brilliant as usual Jonnyboy

Thanks for posting

wfortune
15-05-2021, 04:07 PM
Thanks for the report John, a gushing celebratory one for next week please.[emoji120][emoji120]

Sent from my moto g(6) play using Tapatalk

PatHead
15-05-2021, 04:13 PM
Very good summary. I hope your next report is on another famous Hibs cup victory.

jacomo
15-05-2021, 04:21 PM
Great report as always, thank you.

I always think that making wholesale changes really demonstrates what the spirit is like in the camp. We seem to have no worries on that score.

I expected Magennis to be a great player for us, and now he’s completed his first league campaign I think we can all agree he hasn’t been. However, let’s hope that next season looks better.

northstandhibby
15-05-2021, 05:10 PM
Enjoyed reading your report. I too would like to wish Rocky all the very best wherever he goes. A great shot-stopper and all round keeper. Good to see Magennis have more game time as he's a player that will come on leaps and bounds as time goes on. Always good to prevent Celtic scoring and big Daz was also my motm. It was a real bonus that we could rest key players today for the big one next Saturday and give others an opportunity to shine. Good point well earned today.

Brightside
15-05-2021, 05:33 PM
Excellent report

scoopyboy
15-05-2021, 05:33 PM
Well done over the season, I always look forward to the how it feels thread.

My only comment for today would be Joe Newell never got much in the way of mention from the commentator for the simple reason he wasn't on the ball as much as usual. Taking it easy for next week which I am fine with.

Greenbeard
15-05-2021, 08:38 PM
Braw as ever. A very good workout for some of our European group games next season (he says with confidence) when we will have to defend for our lives with only 25% possession. Thought the defence today was as good as I have ever seen.

ABZHFC
15-05-2021, 09:24 PM
Thanks for another great report, fingers crissed you'll be too happy and too pished to even post one this time next week :greengrin

Unseen work
15-05-2021, 09:31 PM
I was critical on the Match thread of Magennis but congratulations for getting his first 90 minutes in 16 months.

Very easy to forget.

Once he gets hit fitness, sharpness and confidence up he’ll do well.

Bostonhibby
15-05-2021, 09:37 PM
Thanks for a great read as ever Jonnyboy, a game I had to miss listening to today so very welcome.

Good to have you back[emoji106]

Sent from my SM-A750FN using Tapatalk

ChooseLife
15-05-2021, 11:18 PM
Just wanted to say thanks Jonnyboy for doing these threads over the season, player ratings threads are the first thing I look for after a game and you always go out your way to make them detailed, I've not been able to watch much of hibs on Saturdays so my understanding of the players this year really all comes down to your threads.

Once again, thank you, I hope you will continue to do these next season but understand if you don't, it must take up alot of your time every week.

Jonnyboy
15-05-2021, 11:24 PM
Thanks for all the kind thoughts, they are much appreciated.

Not sure what time next weeks offering will appear 😂

Happy to keep doing these next season as I really enjoy sharing my ramblings ✅

jacomo
15-05-2021, 11:38 PM
I was critical on the Match thread of Magennis but congratulations for getting his first 90 minutes in 16 months.

Very easy to forget.

Once he gets hit fitness, sharpness and confidence up he’ll do well.



I so hope you are right. He looks like a player to me, the kind of box-to-box type who could do really well for us, but he’s not been given many opportunities to show that.

basehibby
15-05-2021, 11:58 PM
Thanks JB and hope you're feeling well after the hospital visit last week. Your stand in did a sterling job but it's great to have you back!

Can't find anything to disagree with in your enjoyable match summary. A couple of these players will probably miss out on the match day squad at Hampden and that's a wee bit sad - they have all contributed to varying degrees over the course of a successful league season. Interestingly only Lewis and Rocky out of that lot have not scored a goal this season :cb

superfurryhibby
16-05-2021, 12:01 AM
Thanks JB and hope you're feeling well after the hospital visit last week. Your stand in did a sterling job but it's great to have you back!

Can't find anything to disagree with in your enjoyable match summary. A couple of these players will probably miss out on the match day squad at Hampden and that's a wee bit sad - they have all contributed to varying degrees over the course of a successful league season. Interestingly only Lewis and Rocky out of that lot have not scored a goal this season :cb

Other than posibly Rocky, surely everyone will who was on the pitch today will be in the squad next week for the .......CUP FINAL?

joebakerforever
16-05-2021, 12:52 AM
McGregor – Once again Daz was immense and easily the best man on the park. Obviously, he gets my man of the match award and I’m astonished that the BBC reporter gave it to Elyounoussi who started well enough but fell away so much he was subbed before the end.




And incredibly, Andrew Southwick the BBC reporter, also only rated Daz 6th in the Hibs performance scores:confused:

basehibby
16-05-2021, 01:02 AM
Other than posibly Rocky, surely everyone will who was on the pitch today will be in the squad next week for the .......CUP FINAL?

Unless they've changed it from last year there's an eighteen man squad allowed for the Scottish Cup and from my counting - barring injuries - one of the outfield players playing today will likely be watching from the stand next week

AZhibee
16-05-2021, 01:03 AM
Thanks Jonnyboy

scoopyboy
16-05-2021, 06:58 AM
Thanks JB and hope you're feeling well after the hospital visit last week. Your stand in did a sterling job but it's great to have you back!

Can't find anything to disagree with in your enjoyable match summary. A couple of these players will probably miss out on the match day squad at Hampden and that's a wee bit sad - they have all contributed to varying degrees over the course of a successful league season. Interestingly only Lewis and Rocky out of that lot have not scored a goal this season :cb

Nine subs allowed for the final so I don't think any outfield player listed today will miss out.

Macey, Marciano, Gray, McGinn, Stevenson, Porteous, McGregor, Hanlon, Doig, Newell, Gogic, Jackson, Hallberg, Magennis, Wright, Boyle, Murphy, Nisbet, Doidge.

That's 19, so still space for one.

greenginger
16-05-2021, 07:49 AM
Saw the so-called disallowed goal on Sportscene last night. Did the ref not have one of those spray cans to mark a line for the wall to stand behind ? Also was there not two Celtic players on the end of our wall which is now against the rules.

I’m not sure cos neither incident was mentioned by the Sportscene geniuses.

O'Rourke3
16-05-2021, 08:40 AM
Saw the so-called disallowed goal on Sportscene last night. Did the ref not have one of those spray cans to mark a line for the wall to stand behind ? Also was there not two Celtic players on the end of our wall which is now against the rules.

I’m not sure cos neither incident was mentioned by the Sportscene geniuses.He had sprayed the lines but it took ages to get to the point the free kick took place. There's a clear whistle before the free kick was hit. No goal was disallowed. Yip the Celtc payers need to be a metre from the wall.

Also taking the opportunity to thank JB for these reports. Hope the eyes are still OK

Sent from my SM-G965F using Tapatalk

brog
16-05-2021, 11:15 AM
Thanks John, all your reports are greatly appreciated. I've not been Rocky's biggest fan but he oozed confidence yesterday and at times I thought we had signed Ederson, as his much criticised distribution was excellent.
Darren was without doubt MOTM but I suspect Ryan will get the nod for the final. Darren's at his best in a game like yesterday where it's all about clearing the ball, anywhere. We should have much more of the ball next week and I think Ryan is better in that situation than Daz. Of course we could always copy 2016 & start with a back 3/5.
Thanks again!!

Highwayman
16-05-2021, 11:19 AM
Well done JB for getting a tune out of that game yesterday.Good to see you’re carrying on next season.You’re reports are so good it saves me wasting money on a newspaper.

Don’t think JR learned anything new from the game.Barring unforeseen circumstances the team for Saturday almost picks itself,that is Macey,McGinn,Porteous,Hanlon,Doig,Boyle,Gogic,Newe ll,Irvine,Doidge,Nesbit.

One encouraging thing yesterday was the sight of Scott Brown talking to what looked like a very fit and healthy Scott Allan.

BILLYHIBS
16-05-2021, 11:26 AM
Sad to see club legend Sir David Gray looking understandably miles off the pace

Hopefully he will get his silver lining on Saturday when he goes up to lift the cup for a second time with Paul Hanlon

Fingers crossed


:cup:

basehibby
16-05-2021, 11:49 AM
Nine subs allowed for the final so I don't think any outfield player listed today will miss out.

Macey, Marciano, Gray, McGinn, Stevenson, Porteous, McGregor, Hanlon, Doig, Newell, Gogic, Jackson, Hallberg, Magennis, Wright, Boyle, Murphy, Nisbet, Doidge.

That's 19, so still space for one.

Nine subs? I looked hard but all I could find was the rules from last year which stated 7. That's good then - one less decision for Jack to agonise over.

et_hibby
16-05-2021, 11:56 AM
Thanks for all the kind thoughts, they are much appreciated.

Not sure what time next weeks offering will appear 😂

Happy to keep doing these next season as I really enjoy sharing my ramblings ✅
Thanks from me also Jonny for this season’s reports.

Billy Whizz
16-05-2021, 12:04 PM
Nine subs? I looked hard but all I could find was the rules from last year which stated 7. That's good then - one less decision for Jack to agonise over.

In the semi final Dundee Utd had 9 on the bench and Hibs 8

ozhibs
16-05-2021, 01:08 PM
Thanks for the match reports JB, I look forward to reading them after each game, but and this is a first I thought Maginnes was anonymous in the game. But I did have a bad stream , very stop start for the game
Looking forward to the cup final reort
GGTTH

Greenbeard
16-05-2021, 01:13 PM
Sad to see club legend Sir David Gray looking understandably miles off the pace

Hopefully he will get his silver lining on Saturday when he goes up to lift the cup for a second time with Paul Hanlon

Fingers crossed


:cup:
Sad? I was delighted to see him put in the performance he did with some excellent challenges. I only felt sad when he tore on the overlap like he was in his prime, only for Magennis to just hold onto the ball and slow things down.

Highwayman
16-05-2021, 01:20 PM
Thanks John, all your reports are greatly appreciated. I've not been Rocky's biggest fan but he oozed confidence yesterday and at times I thought we had signed Ederson, as his much criticised distribution was excellent.
Darren was without doubt MOTM but I suspect Ryan will get the nod for the final. Darren's at his best in a game like yesterday where it's all about clearing the ball, anywhere. We should have much more of the ball next week and I think Ryan is better in that situation than Daz. Of course we could always copy 2016 & start with a back 3/5.
Thanks again!!

I might come across as King Cynic of the Cynic people,brog but Marcianos performance yesterday had
“Shop Window” written all over it.

BILLYHIBS
16-05-2021, 02:08 PM
Sad? I was delighted to see him put in the performance he did with some excellent challenges. I only felt sad when he tore on the overlap like he was in his prime, only for Magennis to just hold onto the ball and slow things down.
Only knows one way to play

100% totally committed putting his body on the line for the cause match fit or no match fit but had his work cut out against Elyounoussi

Yes Magennis shudda played him in

Legend

brog
16-05-2021, 04:29 PM
I might come across as King Cynic of the Cynic people,brog but Marcianos performance yesterday had
“Shop Window” written all over it.

It did cross my cynical mind also but I strongly suspect Rocky's future is already settled.

Hiber-nation
16-05-2021, 04:35 PM
I might come across as King Cynic of the Cynic people,brog but Marcianos performance yesterday had
“Shop Window” written all over it.

It actually had "busy first half for a change" written all over it as far as I could see.

Bobby Coombe
17-05-2021, 02:07 PM
Thanks for the match reports JB, I look forward to reading them after each game, but and this is a first I thought Maginnes was anonymous in the game. But I did have a bad stream , very stop start for the game
Looking forward to the cup final reort
GGTTH

I would just like to add my thanks to you JB for all your match reports, which are first class. I appreciate very much all the hard work which must go into writing them.

Since452
17-05-2021, 03:54 PM
Sorry if already mentioned but don't think we've lost at home to Celtic in the league since 2013