Porteous or Daz

[Stuart93]

For the cup final?

I was still of the opinion that it would 100% be Porteous but after watching Daz tonight JR has a decision to make

Felt a lot comfier at the back with McGregor in there. The absolute no nonsense CB we sometimes need.

[calumhibee1]

McGregor by some distance. The guy is absolutely immense and has been every time he’s been called upon this season.

[WhileTheChief..]

McGregor.

We win when he plays.

[Joe6-2]

No contest
Daz

[superfurryhibby]

Daz.

[bigwheel]

Whoever Jack picks...trust him to get it right


Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk

[Stevie Reid]

Daz 100% - no decision to make for me.

[The Spaceman]

Daz every day of the week for this. St J have Porto’s number and actively target him at set pieces. Daz would love the challenge and be a much safer option for us here.

[Coco Bryce]

For the cup final?

I was still of the opinion that it would 100% be Porteous but after watching Daz tonight JR has a decision to make

Felt a lot comfier at the back with McGregor in there. The absolute no nonsense CB we sometimes need.

Daz for me 100% No nonsense does whats needed.

Porto still far far too erratic and too many mistakes.

[poulton hibs]

Definitely Daz. Immense tonight.

[OstKurve Hibs]

Got to be mcgregor, no contest.
Porto's young, he'll get his chances again whether its wi us or some1 else, but daz has to start the final ahead of him.
Oozes class and composure

[jeffers]

Yup Daz for me too. In a cup final you want a defender to defend and limit mistakes. That’s what Daz does.

[Sir David Gray]

I didn't see the match tonight but I'd say McGregor. I'd be a lot more confident with him in defence right now than Porteous.

[GreenNWhiteArmy]

Daz

A proper centre half. Laces through the ball when needed

[CapitalGreen]

I’m probably edging towards McGregor too but he’s isn’t immune to errors on the big stage at Hampden himself. Logan’s heroics bailed him out a couple of times v Dundee Utd in 2016 and the less said about his performance against Aberdeen in 2017 the better.

[lord bunberry]

It would be incredibly harsh on Porteous to be dropped for the final, but big Daz is absolutely made for a team like St Johnstone. Hopefully we’re 3-0 up and he can bring Porteous on.

[GGTTH07]

Both could play. Given the set piece threat they offer, Porteous and McGregor and probably our two best two at winning defensive headers. Tough picks for JR!

[AliboyFC]

For the cup final?

I was still of the opinion that it would 100% be Porteous but after watching Daz tonight JR has a decision to make

Felt a lot comfier at the back with McGregor in there. The absolute no nonsense CB we sometimes need.

Daz :flag:

[flash]

It would be incredibly harsh on Porteous to be dropped for the final, but big Daz is absolutely made for a team like St Johnstone. Hopefully we’re 3-0 up and he can bring Porteous on.

That's how I see it. If it was Rangers or Celtic I would pick Porteous all day long but St Johnstone are right up Daz street.
Tough, tough call mind

[Vault Boy]

Daz sneaks it, but I'd be comfortable with either.

[Stuart93]

Both could play. Given the set piece threat they offer, Porteous and McGregor and probably our two best two at winning defensive headers. Tough picks for JR!

I feel Porteous can lapse in concentration at set pieces sometimes, sometimes just in general but don’t get the same feeling with Daz

[Swedish hibee]

Daz for the final

[AliboyFC]

Daz for me 100% No nonsense does whats needed.

Porto still far far too erratic and too many mistakes.

Yeh still has a long way to come.

[hibbysam]

Porteous for me, but both are more than capable.

[JeMeSouviens]

Not much between them but I think Daz/Paul are a better pair than Porto/Paul.

[Jones28]

Brutal on Porteous who has by and large been solid this season.

There’s no time for sentiment in a cup final though, I could see him starting the back line that will play in the final against Celtic, especially for Daz’s benefit and get him some game time.

[scoopyboy]

Both could play. Given the set piece threat they offer, Porteous and McGregor and probably our two best two at winning defensive headers. Tough picks for JR!

There is no chance both will start in the final.

When defending set pieces Gogic and Doidge are excellent as well

[The Harp Awakes]

Both are massive Hibs fans and excellent players. I think Darren's power and will to win will be crucial in the final, especially with St J's physicality. I'd go with Darren.

[tonyrougier123]

Porteous had a stinker against st Johnstone at Easter Road poor passes needless yellow card,we look more assured with daz at the back when he’s came in this season both very good centre half’s however, porteous been very good at times commanding the back line.it’s tough but it’s Daz for me.

[007]

Daz for me too. Hasn't put a foot wrong every time he's come in. He's playing like every match is his last one.

[3pm]

Porteous will play. I am not saying I agree but I don't even think it'll be a decision to be honest.

[calumhibee1]

Porteous will play. I am not saying I agree but I don't even think it'll be a decision to be honest.

I’m the opposite. I don’t think it’ll be a decision either but more because Daz has made himself undroppable imo.

[TelaStella]

Daz but it’ll be Porto


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[Unseen work]

Can’t help but think Daz is better suited to playing against then. He’s just an absolute monster that dominates everything. You can also notice the difference in the organisation as hes always speaking and telling folk where to go.

It would be so harsh against Porteous as he has been very good overall.

Ideally I’d have both in but I can’t see it.

They’ll have Kane up top top who can he a handful.

[3pm]

I’m the opposite. I don’t think it’ll be a decision either but more because Daz has made himself undroppable imo.

We'll see mate.

[Stanton Spence]

I’m the opposite. I don’t think it’ll be a decision either but more because Daz has made himself undroppable imo.I agree with 3pm and think Jack Ross will also stick with Porto and I think we miss Porto carrying the ball out from the back a fair bit.
It's a tough call but for me I think JR will go with Porteous

Sent from my G3121 using Tapatalk

[WestEndHibee]

I really rate porteous and if it was Dundee Utd in the final I’d pick him over Daz but against St Johnstone McGregor is better suited for me. Either way feel both have earned the chance to play.

[green day]

No room for sentiment. Porto has made a few silly mistakes recently, but is generally a good player.

Daz is a warrior, a leader, less gifted technically, but I would start with him.

We can't afford defensive cockup v St J

Take the lead, kill it off and bring Porto on then.

[Irish_Steve]

It`s a close call but I would go for Daz as he has the experience of playing (and winning!) a cup final. I doubt it but Porto could freeze on the big day if he thinks too much about it.

Also, at one point in the second half tonight, Daz just put his foot through the ball and launched it into the Aberdeen half - sometimes you have to do that. Kicked the ball nearly as far as Kamberi can trap it

[#persevered]

I'm amazed daz hasn't played more. Porto is a lot better on the ball, his passing is great, but in my uneducated opinion - in every other respect daz is stronger.

I love them both and it's a great problem to have, two brilliant centre backs.

Both true hibees and whoever plays, I'm happy.

[wookie70]

Daz, as I think we have far more going forward that St J. so being as solid at the back is important. I also think Hanlon looks even more secure when Daz is there.

[calumhibee1]

I'm amazed daz hasn't played more. Porto is a lot better on the ball, his passing is great, but in my uneducated opinion - in every other respect daz is stronger.

I love them both and it's a great problem to have, two brilliant centre backs.

Both true hibees and whoever plays, I'm happy.

Likewise with Daz. He’s still our best defender and whilst he’s still able to play I’m surprised he’s not played a lot more.

[howdenthehibby]

Big YLT Daz.He's a class defender

[Magpie]

McGregor 110%. If he starts the final I will feel a lot more confident we will win.

[h1bs4life]

McGregor is 1st pick out the three , McGregor / Hanlon or McGregor / Porteous would be happy with either.
Hanlon is in possession of the jersey , McGregor / Hanlon for me.

[brianmc]

Daz, no question.

[delbert]

For the cup final?

I was still of the opinion that it would 100% be Porteous but after watching Daz tonight JR has a decision to make

Felt a lot comfier at the back with McGregor in there. The absolute no nonsense CB we sometimes need.

Not only do most fans feel comfier when McGregor is in there, the difference in Hanlon is there for all to see, he can defend without having to worry what Porteous is up to and he looks a completely different defender full of confidence, Porteous will go on to great things but only if he learns to defend like Darren McGregor and do the simple things properly

[cabbageandribs1875]

absolutely Daz, 110%



if Ryan is still here this time next season he can play in our finals then :)

[Ozyhibby]

McGregor.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[Centre Hawf]

I would feel for Porteous if he is dropped for the Final for Daz considering how good he has been this season and part of our success this season.

But somewhere in my head says Daz might be the right option. Very much depends on his body though.

I think Ross will go with Porteous in the end though.

[J-C]

Porteous may come back in for the Celtic game allowing Daz to rest up for the cup but for me Daz has to play in the final, he's our natural leader.

[BILLYHIBS]

Porteous may come back in for the Celtic game allowing Daz to rest up for the cup but for me Daz has to play in the final, he's our natural leader.
This

Porto is first choice but starting to be erratic again

Daz when the chips are down you just know he won’t let us down for a Final swan song

[Since90+2]

Darren is the best centre half at the club.

[Robbo6-2]

I thought he was done but Daz has been sensational when called upon this season.

[Since452]

Feel far less nervous with Daz in

[Onion]

Darren McG for me. Been there, done it, and has been sensational when been called on recently.

Porto CAN be immense but still lacks discipline. Fear is always there he'll make a catastrophic mistake or have a rush of blood and get sent off. You can't carry that risk into a Cup Final.

[Tambo]

McGregor for me. I thought between him and Gogic for motm last night.

[MKHIBEE]

I would go with Darren, I think JR will go with Ryan, hopefully the vote of confidence will inspire Ryan to play his best game

[theonlywayisup]

McGregor for me. I thought between him and Gogic for motm last night.

I agree with that, both were excellent.

I'd start with last night's team, assuming Hallberg is fit.

[.Sean.]

Easily McGregor for me.

There’s a case foot Porteous but he’s still got that rawness and often liable to do something silly. Not a chance I’d be talking in a cup final

[MunsterHibee]

Daz for me because of his experience and his physicality St J won't be able to rough him up easily and he'd relish the physical battle that comes with playing against St J. Would obviously be abit harsh on Porteous but they seem to have his number.

Sent from my SM-A515F using Tapatalk

[Hibs1969]

McGregor for me. He’s been outstanding in the games he’s played. If Saints had a Ryan Kent who ran at him and twisted and turned him I might be concerned but they don’t so is Darren for me.

[CJHibby]

Think the team for the Cup Final will be Macey, Doig, Hanlon, McGregor, McGinn, Newell, Irvine, Gogic, Boyle, Doidge and Nisbet. If Porteous gets the nod, hope he has a stormer all the same.

[mjhibby]

Daz for me. Just great at clearing with either head or feet. Lovely guy off the pitch, monster on the pitch.

[Newry Hibs]

Tough call for JR.

Maybe he'll have an eye on next season as well. Depends how Porto would react to being dropped. He could be 'the boss doesn't trust me in a big game, then why am I here'. That would be a problem.

[EdinMike]

I feel relaxed with McGregor in the side, so purely based on that it’s Daz for me.

[Since90+2]

Tough call for JR.

Maybe he'll have an eye on next season as well. Depends how Porto would react to being dropped. He could be 'the boss doesn't trust me in a big game, then why am I here'. That would be a problem.

There shouldn't be any eyes on next season IMO. This is one of the biggest games in the club's history and definitely the biggest in the last 5 years.

What matters is a week on Saturday more than anything else.

[calumhibee1]

There shouldn't be any eyes on next season IMO. This is one of the biggest games in the club's history and definitely the biggest in the last 5 years.

What matters is a week on Saturday more than anything else.

Yup. Whilst Porteous can count himself unlucky if he misses out there can be no thought given to his feelings when making the decision.

[superfurryhibby]

McGregor for me. He’s been outstanding in the games he’s played. If Saints had a Ryan Kent who ran at him and twisted and turned him I might be concerned but they don’t so is Darren for me.

St Johnston will be throwing in crosses and hoofing long balls into the box, Darren is the man for the job.

[martinmcgurk]

McGregor by some distance. The guy is absolutely immense and has been every time he’s been called upon this season.

I agree and also think Hanlon is a better player alongside McGregor.

[CapitalGreen]

If Saints go with Kane and Melhamed up front then Daz is the right choice. He’ll deal with high balls up to them well and not be bullied. Kane and Melhamed don’t have much in the way of pace to bother him.

If Saints go with Middleton and/or O’Halloran I’d be more concerned with starting Daz over Porteous. He was dreadfully exposed against the pace of Roberts and Cole in our home defeat to Motherwell resulting in his substitution just after half time.

[sorrow sorrow]

3rd in the league for the first time in 15 seasons with porteous a main stay at the heart of the defence so porteous for me but if mcgregor gets the nod I would be comfortable with that also.

[Since90+2]

If Saints go with Kane and Melhamed up front then Daz is the right choice. He’ll deal with high balls up to them well and not be bullied. Kane and Melhamed don’t have much in the way of pace to bother him.

If Saints go with Middleton and/or O’Halloran I’d be more concerned with starting Daz over Porteous. He was dreadfully exposed against the pace of Roberts and Cole in our home defeat to Motherwell resulting in his substitution just after half time.

Kane does have pace. It's one of his best attributes.

[J-C]

As pointed out I feel Hanlon is more comfortable with Daz. I get the feeling he's always covering for Porteous and maybe doesn't feel that cover is returned.

[Bostonhibby]

We are incredibly fortunate to have such great options for the position, whilst we dont have the luxury of knowing who St Johnstone will play up front I'd pick McGregor for this one if its a straight choice between the two.

Sent from my SM-A750FN using Tapatalk

[hibee-boys]

Daz’s performance last night will have certainly given Jack Ross a big decision to make. I think it’s the only position that is potentially up for grabs as I’ve no doubt he’ll go with Irvine/Gogic/Newell in midfield. I think Jack see’s Ryan and Hanlon as his preferred centre half pairing but it may come down who’s best for the team we’re playing against and the style of football they’ve likely to play. I would want Ryan in there if a team is running at us but Daz if we’ll be bombarded with high balls. Glad I don’t have to make the decision, I’ll put my faith in the gut that’s led us to our best league finish in a long time👍

[JammyDoidger]

Darren mcgregor he's a class defender.

[Paul1642]

Hard on Porteous but got to be Daz. More consistent and with St Johnstone’s hopeful lack of chances we can’t afford any mistakes.

[Baader]

Another vote for Daz. Harsh on Porteous but in a one off big game I think McGregor's experience could be crucial...

[EI255]

For me, Daz.

Ultra consistent.


Sent from my LG-H870 using Tapatalk

[Peevemor]

Daz.

[hibbydog]

Big Daz on account of his physicality and Porteous’ slight dip in form.

I think big Daz will see this as his last shot at a final. Remember his big roar when he lifted the cup in 2016? Spine tingling stuff. He’ll bring 100% to the game. I’d love it if a lifelong Hibby like him scored the winner.

It’s not just about sentiment though, I just worry that Porteous is more liable to be rash.

[jacomo]

Tough call for JR.

Maybe he'll have an eye on next season as well. Depends how Porto would react to being dropped. He could be 'the boss doesn't trust me in a big game, then why am I here'. That would be a problem.


No room for this kind of thinking imo.

We’ve got a cup final to play and given Porto’s performance against St J last time it has to be Daz.

Next season is next season.

[Hibee Mac]

If Saints go with Kane and Melhamed up front then Daz is the right choice. He’ll deal with high balls up to them well and not be bullied. Kane and Melhamed don’t have much in the way of pace to bother him.

If Saints go with Middleton and/or O’Halloran I’d be more concerned with starting Daz over Porteous. He was dreadfully exposed against the pace of Roberts and Cole in our home defeat to Motherwell resulting in his substitution just after half time.Think this is a very good point - Middleton has gotten lucky imo with a few goals recently so he'll be thinking he's billy big baws and wanting to get one over us, I mean the guy was shooshing an empty FF stand after scoring an open goal tap in FFS...

To me he's one to watch if they start him and I'm not sure how McGregor would cope with him running at him - that being said he's unlikely to play down the middle so might not be a worry.

[inglisavhibs]

McGregor by some distance. The guy is absolutely immense and has been every time he’s been called upon this season.
I will be amazed if Porteous is not playing in the final. We have had our best defensive record for many a year with Hanlon and Porteous as centre back pairing for the vast majority of our games. Porteous has made errors yes but he is a huge influence on our team. Darren is a Hibs legend but I doubt he expects to play in the final. I also don’t think we defended that well last night as Aberdeen missed a few easy chances especially the one in the first half which would have changed the game somewhat.

[WeeRussell]

I will be amazed if Porteous is not playing in the final. We have had our best defensive record for many a year with Hanlon and Porteous as centre back pairing for the vast majority of our games. Porteous has made errors yes but he is a huge influence on our team. Darren is a Hibs legend but I doubt he expects to play in the final. I also don’t think we defended that well last night as Aberdeen missed a few easy chances especially the one in the first half which would have changed the game somewhat.

Have to agree. I don’t think Porteous was having his best game before coming off in the semi-final but I’m almost certain he will start the final, and I think rightly so. Hope he has a stormer.

[WeeRussell]

St Johnston will be throwing in crosses and hoofing long balls into the box, Darren is the man for the job.

Could well be right. But also think we are likely to have the vast majority of the ball, and Ryan is the best of all our centre halves at stepping out and playing with the ball at his feet (albeit that can be to his detriment as well!) and he’s something we will lose without him in.

[mcohibs]

Daz interestingly coming out and saying he thinks Porteous deserves to start

https://www.edinburghnews.scotsman.com/sport/football/hibs/darren-mcgregor-explains-why-fellow-hibs-fan-ryan-porteous-deserves-cup-final-place-ahead-of-him-3236234

[northstandhibby]

An extremely tough call. Personally, I'd marginally plump for Daz as he has the experience and calm head and seems to have lost none of his defensive abilities as seen last night. Porto has that wee bit immaturity yet to be a bit rash at times when cooler head would refrain. Its wafer thin marginal though and I'll trust in Jack to get it right.

[Andy74]

Has to be Daz for this one.

[mcohibs]

Have to agree. I don’t think Porteous was having his best game before coming off in the semi-final but I’m almost certain he will start the final, and I think rightly so. Hope he has a stormer.

I suspect he will start. Let's hope this 'will he, won't he' narrative gives him a right boost to go and play a blinder

[Magpie]

https://www.edinburghnews.scotsman.com/sport/football/hibs/darren-mcgregor-explains-why-fellow-hibs-fan-ryan-porteous-deserves-cup-final-place-ahead-of-him-3236234?fbclid=IwAR3dDN6Jb809CuFtvX39MLA5jnMD1546W 4LxRN1dJrEszRPciuGbNNwh2OQ

Wonderful man.

[007]

https://www.edinburghnews.scotsman.com/sport/football/hibs/darren-mcgregor-explains-why-fellow-hibs-fan-ryan-porteous-deserves-cup-final-place-ahead-of-him-3236234?fbclid=IwAR3dDN6Jb809CuFtvX39MLA5jnMD1546W 4LxRN1dJrEszRPciuGbNNwh2OQ

Wonderful man.

That's a man who puts Hibs before himself. I'm hoping Daz, SDG and Lewis all get some minutes but realise it shouldn't be about sentimentality.

[Nicho87]

There’s an argument with the way st Johnstone play there is room for both

Potentially could go with

Porto....mcgregor...hanlon

McGinn Irvine Newell gogic Doig

Boyle / Doidge / Nisbet

Wouldn’t usually want to pull one of front three but think we need big guys in there

If someone was to drop out I think it would be nisbet

But

Mcgregor will sit on the bench anyway I think Ross will back Porto

[WhileTheChief..]

https://www.edinburghnews.scotsman.com/sport/football/hibs/darren-mcgregor-explains-why-fellow-hibs-fan-ryan-porteous-deserves-cup-final-place-ahead-of-him-3236234?fbclid=IwAR3dDN6Jb809CuFtvX39MLA5jnMD1546W 4LxRN1dJrEszRPciuGbNNwh2OQ

Wonderful man.

Fantastic.

Can’t think of the last time I loved a player so much. Pure Hibs.

[WeeRussell]

There’s an argument with the way st Johnstone play there is room for both

Potentially could go with

Porto....mcgregor...hanlon

McGinn Irvine Newell gogic Doig

Boyle / Doidge / Nisbet

Wouldn’t usually want to pull one of front three but think we need big guys in there

If someone was to drop out I think it would be nisbet

But

Mcgregor will sit on the bench anyway I think Ross will back Porto

I don’t think there’s even the slightest of chances a fit Kevin Nisbet is sat on the bench for the cup final.

[MWHIBBIES]

Mcgregor has never had issues dealing with pace, he is quick for a centre back. Not as quick as he was but still above average now.

Its rushing out of defence that has sometimes cost him. If you come forward and get turned, you are in trouble. It's why his best performances for hibs have been in a 3.

No real stress with whoever starts. Neither one guarantees anything and they've both made errors, Porteous' are just fresher in the memory.

[MWHIBBIES]

There’s an argument with the way st Johnstone play there is room for both

Potentially could go with

Porto....mcgregor...hanlon

McGinn Irvine Newell gogic Doig

Boyle / Doidge / Nisbet

Wouldn’t usually want to pull one of front three but think we need big guys in there

If someone was to drop out I think it would be nisbet

But

Mcgregor will sit on the bench anyway I think Ross will back Porto

There is zero argument for dropping Nisbet because we need "big guys". Ability wins games, not height.

[Since452]

There’s an argument with the way st Johnstone play there is room for both

Potentially could go with

Porto....mcgregor...hanlon

McGinn Irvine Newell gogic Doig

Boyle / Doidge / Nisbet

Wouldn’t usually want to pull one of front three but think we need big guys in there

If someone was to drop out I think it would be nisbet

But

Mcgregor will sit on the bench anyway I think Ross will back Porto

Let St Johnstone worry about us. No chance we'll drop one of our trio.

[hibbysam]

There’s an argument with the way st Johnstone play there is room for both

Potentially could go with

Porto....mcgregor...hanlon

McGinn Irvine Newell gogic Doig

Boyle / Doidge / Nisbet

Wouldn’t usually want to pull one of front three but think we need big guys in there

If someone was to drop out I think it would be nisbet

But

Mcgregor will sit on the bench anyway I think Ross will back Porto

The three players who have been instrumental in how we play and where we are, you’d drop one of them for the biggest game of the season?

[scoopyboy]

There’s an argument with the way st Johnstone play there is room for both

Potentially could go with

Porto....mcgregor...hanlon

McGinn Irvine Newell gogic Doig

Boyle / Doidge / Nisbet

Wouldn’t usually want to pull one of front three but think we need big guys in there

If someone was to drop out I think it would be nisbet

But

Mcgregor will sit on the bench anyway I think Ross will back Porto

The worst thing we could possibly do is start to sensationalise our starting line up because of bloody St.Johnstone.

Pick our strongest line up and have a good old fashioned square go with them.

Dropping Nisbet, Doidge or Boyle for the final is an absolute nonsense.

[J-C]

The cup final team will be the same as Wednesday's except Ryan for Gaz, I think Ross will show loyalty to Ryan who's been his no.1 choice all season.

[bod]

Daz gets my vote

[JimBHibees]

The worst thing we could possibly do is start to sensationalise our starting line up because of bloody St.Johnstone.

Pick our strongest line up and have a good old fashioned square go with them.

Dropping Nisbet, Doidge or Boyle for the final is an absolute nonsense.

Agree totally. Personally comfortable whoever we pick between Daz and Ryan also as we should be stronger set pieces anyway with Gogic and Doidge playing. Assume it will be Ryan. No way on earth we should be leaving any of our attacking players out.

[Andy74]

There is zero argument for dropping Nisbet because we need "big guys". Ability wins games, not height.

Nisbet is also the same height as Doidge!

[jeffers]

The cup final team will be the same as Wednesday's except Ryan for Gaz, I think Ross will show loyalty to Ryan who's been his no.1 choice all season.

And Newell for Hallberg unless the former is injured.

[Since90+2]

Nisbet is also the same height as Doidge!

Incorrect.

[Brightside]

Incorrect.

They are. Ignore Wikipedia.

[Since90+2]

They are. Ignore Wikipedia.

Doidge is a couple of inches taller than Nisbet. Not a massive difference admittedly but he is taller.

[Hibbyradge]

Ryan is our first choice CB. Darren is cover for him. Ryan will play and rightly so.

[scoopyboy]

A couple of weeks ago I would never have considered starting Darren before Porto, I must admit I am now thinking differently.

I thought Ryan struggled in the semi, he didn't appear comfortable with underfoot conditions to me.

I felt more comfortable when Darren came on.

On Wednesday I thought the McGregor man was the best player on the park.

St.Johnstone seemed to target Porto in the League Cup semi, firstly by thumping him in the first few minutes.

I think it is the managers hardest call for the final in terms of team selection.

I think Darren's interview has probably made it easier for him.

[Coco Bryce]

After the last two games, 100% Daz for me.

The guy is an absolute rock.

[Stevie Reid]

Posted this on the match day thread earlier:

If we play a back four next week, Daz has to play for me - though I appreciate that it’s unlikely to be clear cut in JR’s head.

Folk always say there’s no room for sentiment in football, and that would usually apply to an older head, who’s been a great servant, being ousted by a youngster.

In this case, it’s the other way around. Ryan is the future, but this game is bigger than his career development.

RP has had a good season, I just don’t 100% trust him at the moment. Rushes of blood to the head that can lead to mistakes or red cards have to be avoided at all costs next week.

Daz is just better suited to playing Saints as well.

[Heisenberg]

I’d pick Daz but think Porteous will get the nod.

[Onion]

After the last two games, 100% Daz for me.

The guy is an absolute rock.

CB and Goalkeeper choices could be most important decisions Jack Ross will have to make this season.

[Onion]

Good point and run out for Hibs ahead of the big game. Rocky and Daz were simply outstanding today.

[HibeeHibernian4]

Nothing against Porteous but it simply has to be McGregor.

[Unseen work]

McGregor was brilliant today.

How good was Porteous too though? Went about his business very quietly.

It’s like playing with Daz took the pressure off of him.

[flash]

Daz was man of the match today but Porto also strolled through the game even playing on the wrong side.
It's a nice problem to have.

[007]

Said McGregor before the match and I'm even more certain now.

[makaveli1875]

When hes fit Daz is the best defender we have , id start him and im sure Jack Ross must be considering it

[Hibee87]

I think Daz has cemented his place the last few weeks, harsh on Porto to miss s final however. I just hope we're 3/4 0 up with 20 to go and can afford to get him on. It's not a position you want to change in a game on a knife edge.

[Alfred E Newman]

Porto and McGregor next week?

[calumhibee1]

Porto and McGregor next week?

Has to be McGregor and Hanlon

[makaveli1875]

Porto and McGregor next week?

Hanlon was on the bench to keep him safe for the final , no chance he's getting dropped

[MWHIBBIES]

Porto and McGregor next week?

Definitely not.

[silverhibee]

Will be Hanlon & Porto.

[Aldo]

Back 3 of McGinn, Daz and Hanlon??


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[Pilrig_Sauzee]

We play the best team to win the game. So Daz.

[Sir David Gray]

It absolutely must be McGregor next week, he's solid.

[Zambernardi1875]

Porto and McGregor next week?

I would

[GGTTH07]

Why isn’t it out the question to play the both of them? Hanlons positions seems untouchable?

[ElginHibbie]

Why isn’t it out the question to play the both of them? Hanlons positions seems untouchable?

Been captain all season, today is the first league match he's not appeared in I think.

Not a chance he isn't the one to lead the team out next week

[Hibbyradge]

Why isn’t it out the question to play the both of them? Hanlons positions seems untouchable?

It is untouchable and rightly so. He's better than both Daz and Porto.

[keep the faith]

McGregor should start. Personally I would go for him and Porto, but that will never happen.

[3pm]

Ryan played very well today. Unfortunately, his mate played better...

[hibeejeebies]

Daz patrolled that 18 yard box today like a lion prowling the great plains of the Serengeti.

[jacomo]

Why isn’t it out the question to play the both of them? Hanlons positions seems untouchable?


Paul Hanlon has been turning in excellent performances for months.

His place in the cup final is assured.

[gaz1875]

Daz patrolled that 18 yard box today like a lion prowling the great plains of the Serengeti.

That made me laugh out loud :top marks

[147lothian]

Porto and McGregor next week?

If we go 2-0 up then that could be an option, but for starting the game I would play McGregor with Porteous on the bench

[hibee-boys]

Don’t have a bxxxxxxxx clue🤷🏼

[Andy74]

Now the league is out the way I’d play this team for the final:

Rocky

McGinn
McGregor
Hanlon

Boyle
Hallberg
Gogic
Irvine
Doig

Doidge
Nisbet

[pacoluna]

Daz patrolled that 18 yard box today like a lion prowling the great plains of the Serengeti.

A beautiful mane too.

[Vini1875]

Now the league is out the way I’d play this team for the final:

Rocky

McGinn
McGregor
Hanlon

Boyle
Hallberg
Gogic
Irvine
Doig

Doidge
Nisbet

Surely Macey plays ahead of Rocky in the cup and Newell ahead of Halberg?

[blackpoolhibs]

Now the league is out the way I’d play this team for the final:

Rocky

McGinn
McGregor
Hanlon

Boyle
Hallberg
Gogic
Irvine
Doig

Doidge
Nisbet

That's my team too. 👍

[Andy74]

Surely Macey plays ahead of Rocky in the cup and Newell ahead of Halberg?

That’s the team I’d play. Love Newell but it is coming together for Hallberg in recent form and taking into account the type of game it will be.

I’d play our best keeper in such a big game. That’s Rocky.

[MWHIBBIES]

That’s the team I’d play. Love Newell but it is coming together for Hallberg in recent form and taking into account the type of game it will be.

I’d play our best keeper in such a big game. That’s Rocky.

Its a difficult one. I don't think we played our best keeper in 2016 but it worked out okay. I'd probably go with Rocky as well, but Macey will be fine.

[The Baldmans Comb]

Its to late now but it seems crazy that Marciano will be on the bench but fair play to the manager for how well he has managed both goalkeepers.

Daz has come from nowhere to stake a place but there will be an intensity in this game and an increase in the pace of the game that is a bit worrying but that applies to decision making as well and Porto calls certain situations wrong.

Tough choice but just Daz.

[A Hi-Bee]

I am sure that JR will pick the right team to bring the cup back ti Leith
GGTTH

[Saint Hibee]

Saint Johnstone are to Ryan what Ryan is to The Rangers - they’ve got his number. I’ll feel much happier with North Fort Street’s finest mane manning the ramparts.

[Aldo]

Now the league is out the way I’d play this team for the final:

Rocky

McGinn
McGregor
Hanlon

Boyle
Hallberg
Gogic
Irvine
Doig

Doidge
Nisbet

Andy barring the keeper that’s the outfield players I would start!


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[wookie70]

I think Daz cemented his place today. Ryan actually played really well and made good decisions but McGregor imposes himself on attackers in a way very few centre halves do these days. He is also course and distance for this cup and we need a few on the pitch that have won it.

Hallberg might just get in for his set pieces. He has thrown lots of good balls into the box and rarely hits a poor free kick. I think Newell is the better player but he has went off the boil at the same time Hallberg has started to impress. Absolutely brilliant that despite a small squad and a pretty settled team, having a successful season, we have quite a bit of competition for places.

[Hibeewilly]

Now the league is out the way I’d play this team for the final:

Rocky

McGinn
McGregor
Hanlon

Boyle
Hallberg
Gogic
Irvine
Doig

Doidge
Nisbet
That would be my team as well....unlucky on Macey but Rocky did well today. McGregor should be the first name on the team sheet as he's in fantastic form....MOM today for me

[Comiston Hibee]

Why not Porteous and McGregor, Hamlin on the bench?

[Sammy7nil]

Why not Porteous and McGregor, Hamlin on the bench?

I think the Pied Piper is suspended :greengrin:greengrin:wink Maybe Hanlon could play.

[sorrow sorrow]

Marciano,mcgregor and porteous where excellent today.
Would start the 3 of them next week if I was jack Ross.

[Hibbyradge]

Why not Porteous and McGregor, Hamlin on the bench?

Because Hanlon and Porteous are both better players than McGregor.

[blackpoolhibs]

Because Hanlon and Porteous are both better players than McGregor.

I'm sure Porto will be a better player in time, but Daz is in very good form at the moment, in fact probably in better form than both Porto and Hamlin.:wink:

It's a tough one for the manager, but on current form i feel Daz has won one of those spots, and Porto loses out for next week.

[MWHIBBIES]

Why not Porteous and McGregor, Hamlin on the bench?

Hanlon is the best with the ball, and the left footer. In a game in which we'll likely have plenty of the ball, that is vital. Hes also been the best of the three this season.

[scoopyboy]

Why isn’t it out the question to play the both of them? Hanlons positions seems untouchable?

Ask Jack Ross, because he is the one that will call it. It is either Daz or Porto if everyone available.

[Hibbyradge]

I'm sure Porto will be a better player in time, but Daz is in very good form at the moment, in fact probably in better form than both Porto and Hamlin.:wink:

It's a tough one for the manager, but on current form i feel Daz has won one of those spots, and Porto loses out for next week.

Porto and Hanlon have been the defence that took us to third place. Daz has had a couple of good performances, one of which was almost a friendly.

I'll be surprised if he gets the nod, but I understand why folk feel that way. It's the counter side of what happens when a player has a sub-standard game when we get immediate calls to drop him etc.

[scoopyboy]

Now the league is out the way I’d play this team for the final:

Rocky

McGinn
McGregor
Hanlon

Boyle
Hallberg
Gogic
Irvine
Doig

Doidge
Nisbet

Rocky or Macey, Daz or Porto and Newell or Hallberg are the three questions for me.

By the way I wouldn't rule out a 4 4 2

[BlackSheep]

Daz all the way. Our team and tactics against St Johnstone need a shake up otherwise it could be same again from us.

Perhaps his presence in the defence will be the answer and allow us to play our attacking game.

[S4uzee]

Rocky or Macey, Daz or Porto and Newell or Hallberg are the three questions for me.

By the way I wouldn't rule out a 4 4 2

Surely Ross has learnt from his mistake of 4-4-2

[scoopyboy]

Surely Ross has learnt from his mistake of 4-4-2

How's that?

He played that formation against Dundee United and Aberdeen, thought it worked ok in those games.

[WhileTheChief..]

I’m comfortable with either, defence has been fine all season.

Pretty sure JR will go with Porteous.

[S4uzee]

How's that?

He played that formation against Dundee United and Aberdeen, thought it worked ok in those games.

I would’ve said that was more 3-5-2

[blackpoolhibs]

Porto and Hanlon have been the defence that took us to third place. Daz has had a couple of good performances, one of which was almost a friendly.

I'll be surprised if he gets the nod, but I understand why folk feel that way. It's the counter side of what happens when a player has a sub-standard game when we get immediate calls to drop him etc.

I know Porto has been in the side most weeks, but i feel personally Daz is more suited for St Johnstone. To be perfectly honest, i'm not that bothered either way, but i do feel Daz is in better form than Porto and deserves to play on merit.

[scoopyboy]

I would’ve said that was more 3-5-2

It was 4 4 2, in the semi Josh Doig got a roasting for pushing too far up and was asked in no uncertain terms do you think we are playing 3 5 2.

Sometimes I find it hard to determine what formation we are playing if I'm being honest.

Hibs know St.Johnstone are going with 3 at the back, St.Johnstone don't know how Hibs will play it.

[S4uzee]

It was 4 4 2, in the semi Josh Doig got a roasting for pushing too far up and was asked in no uncertain terms do you think we are playing 3 5 2.

Sometimes I find it hard to determine what formation we are playing if I'm being honest.

Hibs know St.Johnstone are going with 3 at the back, St.Johnstone don't know how Hibs will play it.

Interesting to know that regarding Doig

I agree it can be difficult to work out sometimes due to McGinn’s positioning at both RCB and RB.

I personally prefer 3 in CM

[Billy Whizz]

It was 4 4 2, in the semi Josh Doig got a roasting for pushing too far up and was asked in no uncertain terms do you think we are playing 3 5 2.

Sometimes I find it hard to determine what formation we are playing if I'm being honest.

Hibs know St.Johnstone are going with 3 at the back, St.Johnstone don't know how Hibs will play it.

Whatever way we play Scoopyboy, we need to defend much better against them on Saturday. We’ve lost very preventable goals in the last few games against them

[sorrow sorrow]

Jack Ross will go with what has worked for him all season,Hanlon and porteous.
have no problem with that and I bet mcgregor doesn’t either.

Personally I feel our front 3 of Doidge, Boyle and Nisbet will decide the game not what our central defence will be.

[scoopyboy]

Whatever way we play Scoopyboy, we need to defend much better against them on Saturday. We’ve lost very preventable goals in the last few games against them

No argument from me there Billy, I believe we will.

[northstandhibby]

I think Jack will pick Porto to start as if he plays a blinder or at least solidly and we go on to win the cup it will certainly enhance his worth to our club. Daz is probably the wafer thin safer option however Porto despite his youth has been a revelation since breaking through to the first team despite his occasional mistake. Its brilliant to have the choice of these two talented defenders.

[Andy74]

Jack Ross will go with what has worked for him all season,Hanlon and porteous.
have no problem with that and I bet mcgregor doesn’t either.

Personally I feel our front 3 of Doidge, Boyle and Nisbet will decide the game not what our central defence will be.

It hasn’t worked well for Porteous against St Johnstone though.

[Eyrie]

Now the league is out the way I’d play this team for the final:

Rocky

McGinn
McGregor
Hanlon

Boyle
Hallberg
Gogic
Irvine
Doig

Doidge
Nisbet

Macey in goal, but otherwise that's the team I'd go with.

McGregor is in excellent form and well suited to dealing with St Johnstone's approach. Similarly Hallberg moves the ball quicker than Newell who prefers to retain possession, and that's what we'll need against a well organised St Johnstone side.

Regardless of next week's result, Davidson has been robbed by Gerrard getting the managerial awards.

[SingaporeHibs]

Daz, MOTM for last two games......he deserves the place

[Hibby Kay-Yay]

Macey

Porto
McGregor
Hanlon

Boyle
Newell
Gogic
Irvine
Doig

Nisbet
Doidge

[JohnM1875]

Daz was class again today. Has to start for me.

I'm never worried when anything is played near him. Can't say the same for Porto lately,which I hate saying. Cause I think Porto has so much potential.

[Tommy75]

Whatever way we play Scoopyboy, we need to defend much better against them on Saturday. We’ve lost very preventable goals in the last few games against them

Yeah we seem to have saved our worse defensive displays for St Johnstone.

Looking at the final leauge table, only Dundee Utd, Ross County and Hamilton have scored fewer goals than St Johnstone (joint with Aberdeen on 36). If we are as solid as we can be, and don't lose the psychological battle at set pieces, I think we'll be fine.

[Onion]

Rocky or Macey, Daz or Porto. Great problem for Jack Ross. Most players fit, in decent form with competition for places.

We've suffered big Hampden games when down to the bare bones and it's not ended well. Seriously, can't recall a better chance for Hibs to win the Cup than this one.

[KeithTheHibby]

Daz for me. Purely for his experience. I also think Hallberg will play ahead of Newell. Next week could be a bit of a battle in midfield and that’s why I think he will play Hallberg.

[Lancs Harp]

Just addressing Daz or Porto question if it comes down to that, then Daz, steadier and more reliable I'd argue in better form and has the game we need to defend against St Johnstone. To be honest we should be strong enough to win with either.

[Since90+2]

Daz for me. Purely for his experience. I also think Hallberg will play ahead of Newell. Next week could be a bit of a battle in midfield and that’s why I think he will play Hallberg.

If it's going to be a battle we'd be better sticking with h Newell over Hallberg.

[Billy Whizz]

If it's going to be a battle we'd be better sticking with h Newell over Hallberg.

I’m the opposite

[Lancs Harp]

I’m the opposite

Agree if a war in midfield surely Hallberg is better equiped to deal with that than Newell. My issue with Newell is that we are generally poor when Newell and Irvine are in the same team despite both being decent players. The balance just isnt right.

[MWHIBBIES]

Macey

Porto
McGregor
Hanlon

Boyle
Newell
Gogic
Irvine
Doig

Nisbet
Doidge

Playing 3 center backs totally takes away our flexibility and won't happen

[Billy Whizz]

Agree if a war in midfield surely Hallberg is better equiped to deal with that than Newell. My issue with Newell is that we are generally poor when Newell and Irvine are in the same team despite both being decent players. The balance just isnt right.

I’m glad I’m not Jack Ross on Saturday. He just needs to pick a winning team, nothing else matters

[hibbysam]

I’m glad I’m not Jack Ross on Saturday. He just needs to pick a winning team, nothing else matters

Exactly, I don’t actually think it matters who plays from the choices, Rocky or Macey, Daz or Porteous, Newell or Hallberg - I’ve got my preference but I don’t think we’ll be any worse off regardless. Porteous normally has his best games when he’s under the most pressure.

[Hibbyradge]

I know Porto has been in the side most weeks, but i feel personally Daz is more suited for St Johnstone. To be perfectly honest, i'm not that bothered either way, but i do feel Daz is in better form than Porto and deserves to play on merit.

I'm not bothered too much either, but I'd prefer if Ryan started.

[blackpoolhibs]

I'm not bothered too much either, but I'd prefer if Ryan started.

If we win i wouldnt care if you were centre half Dave. :greengrin

[Hibbyradge]

If we win i wouldnt care if you were centre half Dave. :greengrin

We wouldn't. 😂

[blackpoolhibs]

We wouldn't. 😂

Ah you found the flaw in my point. :greengrin

[Hibbyradge]

Ah you found the flaw in my point. :greengrin

If I was playing it would go to penalties and you'd miss yours!

[Franck Stanton]

Don't understand why it between Ryan or Daz for final .
Why not both ?
A back there of Ryan Daz Paul
Would be hard on McGinn I know.
McGinn has had a great season & one of our best players, but horses for course & all that.

[O'Rourke3]

Don't understand why it between Ryan or Daz for final .
Why not both ?
A back there of Ryan Daz Paul
Would be hard on McGinnis I know.
McGinnis has had a great season & one on our best players, but horses for course & all that.Presume you mean McGinn in which case you are asking Boyler to make the right back job his when we move to a four.
Its a choice between the two and it's currently, Daz. . Mc Ginn is a starter because of his ability to switch roles without weakening the team.

Sent from my SM-T580 using Tapatalk

[Aldo]

Don't understand why it between Ryan or Daz for final .
Why not both ?
A back there of Ryan Daz Paul
Would be hard on McGinn I know.
McGinn has had a great season & one of our best players, but horses for course & all that.

I think the following are guaranteed starters on Sat

McGinn, Hanlon, Doig, Gogic, Irvine, Boyle, Nisbet and Doidge.

Macey or Rocky
Daz or Ryan
Newall or Hallberg

I think the only decision to be made is Daz or Ryan

Macey and Hallberg would start


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[Brightside]

Playing 3 center backs totally takes away our flexibility and won't happen

Yeh it’s been mentioned a few times now but we transition quickly to 442 or even a back 5. That’s comes from McGinn switching from RCB to RB, or Doig being told to play more as a LB than a wingback, or even in extreme cases Boyle sitting in. Playing 3 dedicated CBs would make us very defensive.

[Brightside]

I think the following are guaranteed starters on Sat

McGinn, Hanlon, Doig, Gogic, Irvine, Boyle, Nisbet and Doidge.

Macey or Rocky
Daz or Ryan
Newall or Hallberg

I think the only decision to be made is Daz or Ryan

Macey and Hallberg would start


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

Macey will start. Newell will start. Porto will start. It’s perhaps not what I would go with but I do think it’s what Ross will go with.

[JohnM1875]

Macey will start. Newell will start. Porto will start. It’s perhaps not what I would go with but I do think it’s what Ross will go with.

Totally agree, reckon both will start as well. I'd prefer Daz personally, but think he'll stick with the team that's played most minutes together.

[Brightside]

Totally agree, reckon both will start as well. I'd prefer Daz personally, but think he'll stick with the team that's played most minutes together.

StJ games are always a bit industrial which is why I would go with Hallberg just to change it up a bit. But I can’t see Jack doing that.

[LeithMike]

Now the league is out the way I’d play this team for the final:

Rocky

McGinn
McGregor
Hanlon

Boyle
Hallberg
Gogic
Irvine
Doig

Doidge
NisbetAgree entirely with that team. Think it is the strongest we can put out taking into account form and the opposition. Its not to say a team with Porteous, Macey and Newell cant win but the team you've named looks morr fit for purpose to me.

Sent from my SM-N960F using Tapatalk

[The Count]

Edging towards Daz but it is strange that we are all unsure when Porto is the £1million pound plus player.

[GreenCastle]

McGregor is in fantastic form - has cup final experience and is a leader.

Surely has to start.

Also agree we need to combat Saints industrial strengths and but also stick to our style. A bit of me thinks Hallberg starts and then bring on Newell later on to keep the ball.

[calumhibee1]

Edging towards Daz but it is strange that we are all unsure when Porto is the £1million pound plus player.

McGregor would be a £5m player if performances were the only barometer :agree:

To me, it’s really a case of if you’re good enough, you’re young enough. Daz is still an exceptionally good centre half, the best we’ve got and imo has to start.

[B.H.F.C]

Unless anyone gets injured, I think this is the only real decision Ross has to make.

I think he will go with Porteous and the only change to the semi final team will be Gogic in for Hallberg.

[Greenbeard]

Based on form and to combat Saints strengths I'd start Daz, with Porto potentially coming on for the last 15 if his old legs start to go or if Saints start targetting him on the deck. Porto's "gift-gaff" v Saints two weeks ago is also in my mind. Saints players are 100% going to be sledging Porto about it all game if he starts.
Hallberg has gone up in my estimations his last couple of games, but I'd still start Newell. Hallberg is the ideal first option midfielder off the bench.

[blackpoolhibs]

If I was playing it would go to penalties and you'd miss yours!

I have had a full knee replacement. :wink:

[Scouse Hibee]

Porteous starts

[Hiber-nation]

Makes no sense to me but thankfully I'm not a football manager. Hope Ryan proves us all wrong.

[Saint Hibee]

Come on Ryan - we need a demonstration of zen like calm today!