Cup Final XI

[King Cosell]

Macey

Porteous
McGregor
Hanlon

Boyle
Gogic
Irvine
Newell
Stevenson

Doidge
Nisbet


Harsh on Doig & McGinn but McGregor & Stevenson are better defenders and we can't afford to go a goal down.

[hibbysam]

Macey

Porteous
McGregor
Hanlon

Boyle
Gogic
Irvine
Newell
Stevenson

Doidge
Nisbet


Harsh on Doig & McGinn but McGregor & Stevenson are better defenders and we can't afford to go a goal down.

No, no and triple no.

[AliboyFC]

I would play murphy

[The Sundance Kid]

Macey

McGinn
Porteous
Hanlon

Boyle
Gogic
Irvine
Newell
Doig

Nisbet
Doidge

[Northernhibee]

I don't know. Assuming they're fit, Nisbet, Doidge, Boyle, Hanlon and McGinn have all booked their places. Probably Doig and Porteous too.

The rest of the team have two games and two weeks to show why they deserve to be in the starting eleven. Aberdeen and Celtic are open auditions for who gets those remaining places.

[B.H.F.C]

Macey

Porteous
McGregor
Hanlon

Boyle
Gogic
Irvine
Newell
Stevenson

Doidge
Nisbet


Harsh on Doig & McGinn but McGregor & Stevenson are better defenders and we can't afford to go a goal down.

Stevenson isn’t a better defender than Doig. Doig replacing Stevenson has been a big part of our defensive improvement.

Unless we pick up any further injuries, the only real decision will be who plays in the middle of the park IMO.

[CMurdoch]

Macey

Porteous
McGregor
Hanlon

Boyle
Gogic
Irvine
Newell
Stevenson

Doidge
Nisbet


Harsh on Doig & McGinn but McGregor & Stevenson are better defenders and we can't afford to go a goal down.

If you are going down that route you would be better with Hallberg rather than Newell.
That would give you:
Maximum power and legs in midfield to overpower the opponents
Stevenson stopping Rooney rampaging up the wing.
McGregor, Doidge, Porteous, Hanlon and Nisbet heading away and strength at set pieces stopping Rooney, Kerr etc
Leaving our superior forwards to score goals.
Keep 11 players on the pitch and no goal gifts and the jobs a carrot!

Basically keeping the ball out at one end whilst scoring at the other.
A cunning plan.

[Pretty Boy]

Macey

McGinn
McGregor (huge call)
Hanlon

Boyle
Halberg (huge call)
Gogic
Irvine
Doig

Nisbet
Doidge

I think most of the team picks itself at the moment. I love Newell but he's not been at it lately and Halberg staked a huge claim yesterday. McGregor just seems more suited to a game v St Johnstone but I fully expect Porteous, who I am also a big fan of, to get the nod.

[TheHibernator]

Macey

McGinn
Porteous
Hanlon

Boyle
Irvine
Gogic
Hallberg
Doig

Nisbet
Doidge

[K-Zazu]

I would play McGregor

[Lancs Harp]

Macey

McGinn
McGregor (huge call)
Hanlon

Boyle
Halberg (huge call)
Gogic
Irvine
Doig

Nisbet
Doidge

I think most of the team picks itself at the moment. I love Newell but he's not been at it lately and Halberg staked a huge claim yesterday. McGregor just seems more suited to a game v St Johnstone but I fully expect Porteous, who I am also a big fan of, to get the nod.

Not 100% on Gogic and Halberg starting but can see where you are coming from. Agree on Daz over Porto though. Just a much safer option and can deal alot better with the balls in the box St Johnstone are certain to try. It will be a difficult match and we could do without handing them golden chances which Im sad to say IMO Porto is more likely to do. Despite improving he's still to prone to be rash and make bad decisions.

Having said that Im sure whatever eleven we put out they will rise to the occasion and the cups coming back to Leith.

[ErinGoBraghHFC]

Macey

McGinn
Porteous
Hanlon

Boyle
Irvine
Gogic
Newell
Doig

Nisbet
Doidge


Picks itself, surely?🤷

[thegaffer12]

Macey

McGinn
Porteous
Hanlon
Doig

Hallberg
Gogic
Irvine

Boyle
Doidge
Nisbet

Murphy/Newell to come on as a sub if goals are needed, McGregor and Stevenson if we're up

[B.H.F.C]

Macey

McGinn
McGregor (huge call)
Hanlon

Boyle
Halberg (huge call)
Gogic
Irvine
Doig

Nisbet
Doidge

I think most of the team picks itself at the moment. I love Newell but he's not been at it lately and Halberg staked a huge claim yesterday. McGregor just seems more suited to a game v St Johnstone but I fully expect Porteous, who I am also a big fan of, to get the nod.

It might not end up being a big call in Newell depending on the extent of his injury. Was actually surprised he stayed on as long as he did yesterday.

Ross will play him if he’s available but I’d rather see Hallberg. Didn’t think I’d be wanting to see Hallberg in the team but I thought he was superb yesterday.

[badabing67]

Did Newell get an injury on Saturday

[GreenNWhiteArmy]

Same team as yesterday but Gogic for Newell. There's an argument to be made for Mcgregor for Porto too I suppose

I think Tanser is out for the season so hoping Boyle has a field day

Paisley saints created plenty chances, just like we did in LC SF. We need to take them like we did yesterday

[The Modfather]

Macey

McGinn
McGregor (huge call)
Hanlon

Boyle
Halberg (huge call)
Gogic
Irvine
Doig

Nisbet
Doidge

I think most of the team picks itself at the moment. I love Newell but he's not been at it lately and Halberg staked a huge claim yesterday. McGregor just seems more suited to a game v St Johnstone but I fully expect Porteous, who I am also a big fan of, to get the nod.

Swap Murphy for Gogic and that would be my team. We need to get Murphy match fit as we struggle to break St Johnstone down.

[Billy Whizz]

We’ve no idea who’s going to be for for Wednesday, never mind the final
If Newell’s injury is as serious as 1st looked, might not see him again this season
I just hope we don’t pick up any more injuries before the final, Porteous could also be a doubt if he has a hamstring problem. We’re lucky we have cover in certain areas, but can’t afford to lose anyone in the final 3rd

[Unseen work]

Surprised so many are wanting to drop players that have done it all season for some such as Hallberg, Murphy etc who are just back from injury or been inconsistent.

[King Cosell]

Surprised so many are wanting to drop players that have done it all season for some such as Hallberg, Murphy etc who are just back from injury or been inconsistent.

Horses for courses, we've lost our last 3 against them and haven't scored.

[loanheadhibby]

Macey

Porteous
McGregor
Hanlon

Boyle
Gogic
Irvine
Newell
Stevenson

Doidge
Nisbet


Harsh on Doig & McGinn but McGregor & Stevenson are better defenders and we can't afford to go a goal down.
You're not seriously wanting Josh Doig dropped for Lewis Stevenson.
Jeez it's St Johnstone we're playing not Man City.

[LeithMike]

Macey

McGinn
McGregor (huge call)
Hanlon

Boyle
Halberg (huge call)
Gogic
Irvine
Doig

Nisbet
Doidge

I think most of the team picks itself at the moment. I love Newell but he's not been at it lately and Halberg staked a huge claim yesterday. McGregor just seems more suited to a game v St Johnstone but I fully expect Porteous, who I am also a big fan of, to get the nod.That's the team I'd go with too. It's really harsh on Porteous given his contribution this season but you feel we'd be a bit more solid with Darren. That said, Jack apears to have a lot of confidence in the players and is fairly loyal so I expect Porteous to get the nod (if fit after yesterday - which is by no means certain). Hopefully that vote of confidence would help him relax and concentrate.

Sent from my SM-N960F using Tapatalk

[LeithMike]

That's the team I'd go with too. It's really harsh on Porteous given his contribution this season but you feel we'd be a bit more solid with Darren. That said, Jack apears to have a lot of confidence in the players and is fairly loyal so I expect Porteous to get the nod (if fit after yesterday - which is by no means certain). Hopefully that vote of confidence would help him relax and concentrate.

Sent from my SM-N960F using TapatalkPS - also see the case for Stevenson if a back 4.

Sent from my SM-N960F using Tapatalk

[Northernhibee]

PS - also see the case for Stevenson if a back 4.

Sent from my SM-N960F using Tapatalk

Two things to consider about St Johnstone is that they like to press high up the pitch and they also conceded a few chances today from crosses from deeper positions.

Lewis always positions himself as an easy pass to our midfield which may help, but is also decent at those sort of crosses. There's a genuine case to suggest starting with him to counter the way that they play.

[Lancs Harp]

Two things to consider about St Johnstone is that they like to press high up the pitch and they also conceded a few chances today from crosses from deeper positions.

Lewis always positions himself as an easy pass to our midfield which may help, but is also decent at those sort of crosses. There's a genuine case to suggest starting with him to counter the way that they play.

Personally wuld be very surprised to see Lewis start. Doig offers more going forward than Lewis ever would and persoanlly would prefer the positive approach. Doig gets the shirt for me (as he has done for the majority of the season). Forgetting the past and addressing who is the better player right now? its Doig for me.

[MWHIBBIES]

Should not being going out to stop them. Should be going to play our game. Doig must play because Rooney is a big donkey who scores a few headers so folk think he is good.

They looked shaky from crosses. Essential that Doidge plays well and fight them for everything.

Its strange. I believe in the 3 recent defeats to them we've not started both strikers, which gives their defence an easier game and always an extra man. Gotta push them back and work them.

[hibbysam]

Should not being going out to stop them. Should be going to play our game. Doig must play because Rooney is a big donkey who scores a few headers so folk think he is good.

They looked shaky from crosses. Essential that Doidge plays well and fight them for everything.

Its strange. I believe in the 3 recent defeats to them we've not started both strikers, which gives their defence an easier game and always an extra man. Gotta push them back and work them.

Doidge is huge defensively as well, arguably our best defender when set pieces against. Nisbet is also huge due to his link up play, Boyle and Doidge don’t quite carry the same threat of dropping short and pulling their back three around. This then allows Boyle to go up against Booth and stops him marauding forward.

[Unseen work]

I can’t believe some wouldn’t play Doig, that genuinely baffles me.

Rooney would be better against Stevenson and they would most likely target him. Height and speed over Stevenson.

[gbhibby]

Macey

McGinn
Porteous/McGregor
Hanlon

Boyle
Hallberg
Newell
Murphy
Doig

Doidge
Nisbet
Gives us options on both sides need width against St Johnstone. Murphy could be a match winner

[hibbysam]

Macey

McGinn
Porteous/McGregor
Hanlon

Boyle
Hallberg
Newell
Murphy
Doig

Doidge
Nisbet
Gives us options on both sides need width against St Johnstone. Murphy could be a match winner

Not overly keen on Murphy in the middle, would rather see him start on the bench and when he comes on go 4-2-3-1 with Nisbet dropping into the hole and Murphy playing off the left, could cause them all sorts of issues late on.

Macey

McGinn
Porteous
Hanlon

Boyle
Newell
Gogic
Irvine
Doig

Nisbet
Doidge

For me our strongest side. If Newell isn’t fit enough Hallberg comes in. No need to make changes that are unnecessary. No daft mistakes, we’ve got better players it’s about staying patient and making sure we take our chances. They’ll allow us plenty of the ball. When they open up and bring Middleton and O’Halloran on, that’s when we should be bringing Murphy on to exploit the areas.

[CJHibby]

I think JR, all players being fit and well, will pick the same team as yesterday other than Gogic in for Hallberg. I want to see Hibs go offensive, aggressive and confidently. If the real Hibernian turn up we'll be a-okay :flag:

[Brightside]

Macey

Porteous
McGregor
Hanlon

Boyle
Gogic
Irvine
Newell
Stevenson

Doidge
Nisbet


Harsh on Doig & McGinn but McGregor & Stevenson are better defenders and we can't afford to go a goal down.

Unless we have injuries there is no chance of Lewis & Daz playing.

[Aldo]

Macey

McGinn
McGregor (huge call)
Hanlon

Boyle
Halberg (huge call)
Gogic
Irvine
Doig

Nisbet
Doidge

I think most of the team picks itself at the moment. I love Newell but he's not been at it lately and Halberg staked a huge claim yesterday. McGregor just seems more suited to a game v St Johnstone but I fully expect Porteous, who I am also a big fan of, to get the nod.

I don’t think Hallberg is a huge call PB. It’s the most sensible one for me.

Whilst I think JN is a very good footballer I think having Irvine, Gogic and Hallberg will mean we are more competitive in the middle.

I think St J style would suit those 3.

As for Daz or Ryan. I’d be happy with either however I think Ryan is a bit more mobile!


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[B.H.F.C]

I don’t think Hallberg is a huge call PB. It’s the most sensible one for me.

Whilst I think JN is a very good footballer I think having Irvine, Gogic and Hallberg will mean we are more competitive in the middle.

I think St J style would suit those 3.

As for Daz or Ryan. I’d be happy with either however I think Ryan is a bit more mobile!


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

Would be a big call to leave Newell out given he’s played him in every game he’s been available for. I think he’s been poor since he came back from injury but there’s no way Ross will leave him out unless he’s injured IMO.

[Aldo]

Would be a big call to leave Newell out given he’s played him in every game he’s been available for. I think he’s been poor since he came back from injury but there’s no way Ross will leave him out unless he’s injured IMO.

It would be but might be the right one.

Still got 2 games to get through and I hope we come through them without injuries or suspensions.

A point on Wednesday secures 3rd and I’d be really tempted to rest a few of our key players against Celtic


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[danhibees1875]

McGregor or Porteous

2 from Gogic, Newall, and Halberg. Maybe even Murphy, but less likely.

The rest of the team "picks itself" at this point I reckon.



Over the next two games I'd expect to see a bit of rotation with 2 objectives in mind; firstly ensure no-one from the likely starting lineup is injured or fatigued, secondly to ensure all the fringe guys (McGregor, SDG, Stevenson, Magennis, Murphy, Wright) are match sharp for the occasion in case they need called upon.

[PH91]

Macey

McGinn
Porteous
Hanlon

Boyle
Irvine
Gogic
Newell
Doig

Nisbet
Doidge


Picks itself, surely?🤷

I'm sure this will be the team if all available.

St johnstone will let us have the ball so i would personally prefer to keep hallberg in over gogic to have a bit more control of the ball in the middle, even at the expense of being a bit less defensively solid.

I think Ross, though, has made it pretty clear over the last few months that the above is what he sees as our strongest 11 so i don't think it will be anything else.

Great to have murphy back as an option from the bench. He needs to get some decent minutes over the next 2 games to try and get his match sharpness back up to speed.

[jacomo]

Surprised so many are wanting to drop players that have done it all season for some such as Hallberg, Murphy etc who are just back from injury or been inconsistent.


We’ve struggled against St Johnstone all season. I didn’t see yesterday’s game but I understand Hallberg and McGregor made strong cases for themselves.

I feel like going with the same 11 as last time against them would be a mistake.

[Greenio]

Surprised so many are wanting to drop players that have done it all season for some such as Hallberg, Murphy etc who are just back from injury or been inconsistent.


Same.

Glad Hallberg played well on Sat, but that was one game against a pretty poor team.

Can't see Ross making any changes unless he has to through injury.

It will be

Macey

McGinn
Porteous
Hanlon

Boyle
Irvine
Gogic
Newell
Doig

Nisbet
Doidge

[KingPat4]

Daz for Porto and Gogic for Halberg.

Ryan was targeted as a weakness by Saints in the semi and they were proved right. Too big a game to take risks.

[Calidad]

As yesterday. Gogic or Hallberg is obviously the big decision, as the latter played well yesterday. I think Gogic, will probably get the nod, however. It would also be fully deserved. Of course, if Newell is injured, then it becomes less complicated for JR.

Wouldn’t be upset if big Daz played either.

On a different note, I’d like to see McGinnn given a rest before the final. He’s virtually played every game.

[yerauldda]

There’s no way Porteous will be dropped. I’m not his biggest fan but JR is. He will play.

As others have mentioned, Gogic/Hallberg will be the big call but I think Gogic will get the nod.

Great to have Murphy back off the bench.