Poty

[Tambo]

Five nominations. Who would they be?

Boyle
Doig
Gogic
Hanlon
Nisbet

[hibbysam]

Five nominations. Who would they be?

Boyle
Doig
Gogic
Hanlon
Nisbet

Boyle
Doig
Nisbet
Newell
Hanlon

In that order for me.

[JohnM1875]

Boyle
McGinn
Hanlon
Nisbet
Doig

Winner being Boyle for me.

[The Spaceman]

Boyle (winner)
Doig
McGinn
Nisbet
Newell

[Centre Hawf]

Boyle - Very important threat for us all season. Even when not performing in a game he has caused issues for defences and carried that threat still. But after the Nisbet transfer debacle he's been a massively important player for us and stepped into the fold tremendously well.

Nisbet - Top scorer. Has adjusted very well to the top flight and rightly has earned the transfer interest.

Doig - After a few shaky performances earlier on against the likes of Frimpong at Celtic, he's grown from them and been a hugely vital piece of the system since October/November. A real talent.

Hanlon - Part of a defence that, for the most part in relative terms, has been superb and probably been statistically the best for a few years now. Can't remember many if any mistakes he's made that has cost us. Also has effectively been the club captain in a football sense this season and has lead the side tremendously well.

Porteous - Same as Hanlon in terms of defensive output but also didn't allow the transfer speculation get to him and came back into the side just as well as he was before it. Has had a couple of moments but on the whole is developing amazingly well.

[danhibees1875]

Boyle
Doidge
Doig
Newall
McGinn

[one day maybe...]

Boyle
McGinn
Nisbet
Doidge
Newell

[Northernhibee]

Boyle
McGinn
Gogic
Hanlon
Nisbet

[erin go bragh]

Boyle
Doig ypoty

[Bostonhibby]

Boyle (winner)

Doidge

Hanlon

McGinn

Marciano

Sent from my SM-A750FN using Tapatalk

[DH1875]

Boyle is a shoe in :agree:

[CapitalGreen]

On a slight tangent, who would be the favourites for the League YPOTY? Is Nisbet eligible?

Doig?
Patterson?
Turnbull?

[MrRobot]

Boyle
Hanlon
Rocky
Newell
Nisbet

Boyle would be the winner for me.

Young player of the year will easily be Doig.

[AliboyFC]

Boyle (winner)
Doig
Rocky
Doidge
Nisbit

[AliboyFC]

On a slight tangent, who would be the favourites for the League YPOTY? Is Nisbet eligible?

Doig?
Patterson?
Turnbull?

Turnbull

[Andy74]

Boyle
Doidge
Gogic
Nisbet
Newell

[Danderhall Hibs]

Newell’s rated really highly eh? I like him when he’s on form but think he’s not on form often enough.

[one day maybe...]

On a slight tangent, who would be the favourites for the League YPOTY? Is Nisbet eligible?

Doig?
Patterson?
Turnbull?

No McCann from St Johnstone in there

[Jones28]

On a slight tangent, who would be the favourites for the League YPOTY? Is Nisbet eligible?

Doig?
Patterson?
Turnbull?

Doig surely has to be up there ahead of Patterson.

[Peevemor]

Doidg
Nesbit
Newall
Doige
Irving

[Diclonius]

Bartin Moyle

[weecounty hibby]

Doig surely has to be up there ahead of Patterson.

You would think but please remember who they both play for

[Billy Whizz]

You would think but please remember who they both play for

Josh has made more than 3 times the amount of top flight appearances, that Paterson has. He’s also younger than him

[Hibs4185]

Darren McGregor came back into the team at a bad time and inspired us to go on a winning run which has ended up turning our season around and lead to us being where we are.

surely worthy of a mention?

[Hibiza]

Boyle , by a mile.

[Inconsequential]

Zander Clark for me. 😁

[Andy74]

Darren McGregor came back into the team at a bad time and inspired us to go on a winning run which has ended up turning our season around and lead to us being where we are.

surely worthy of a mention?

It was welcome but a mention for player of the year?

[Frazerbob]

Boyle
Rocky
Hanlon
Gogic
Doig

[superbam]

Boyle easily
Gogic runner up

[WeeRussell]

Shows how good Boyle has been for us this past few months, given it seems unanimous on him, and he was poor for most of the first half of the season.

[Fergus52]

Shows how good Boyle has been for us this past few months, given it seems unanimous on him, and he was poor for most of the first half of the season.

He was getting pelters on here right up to January.

Not sure Boyle deserves it when he was pretty poor for the first half of the season.

For me poty should be someone who was consistently good the whole season, but can't really argue with anyone saying Boyle when you look at his numbers and how good he has been recently

[Hibs90]

Boyle

[Peevemor]

He was getting pelters on here right up to January.

Not sure Boyle deserves it when he was pretty poor for the first half of the season.

For me poty should be someone who was consistently good the whole season, but can't really argue with anyone saying Boyle when you look at his numbers and how good he has been recentlyBoyle, like Doidge, never let his head go down and still gave 100% even when he'd hit a wee rough patch. That's appreciated by the majority of fans.

[Brightside]

Hanlon
Boyle
Gogic
Porto
Doidge

In that order.

[loanheadhibby]

Five nominations. Who would they be?

Boyle
Doig
Gogic
Hanlon
Nisbet
What about our fantastic right back.

[yerauldda]

Boyle
McGinn
Gogic
Doidge
Newell

[hibee-boys]

Any Brora player.

[calumhibee1]

Boyle
McGinn
Hanlon
Doig
Nisbet

[Jonnyboy]

What about our fantastic right back.

Has had plenty of mentions on this thread so is clearly favoured by many and rightly so

[Magpie]

Boyle POTY
Doig YPOTY
Nisbet close second to Boyle.

[WeeRussell]

What about our fantastic right back.

I think he has to be up there given his consistency this season.

[Iggy Pope]

Was Martin Boyle really that poor first half of the season? Maybe not as electric as he has been recently but poor? He started the season with a double.

[EdinMike]

I’ll break the mould and say Gogic or McGinn. Of course Boyle will probably get it, deservedly as would a few.

[makaveli1875]

Its hard to look past Boyle . He's been creating goals , scoring them , stepping up and taking the penaltys . Even when he doesnt play well he keeps defenders on their toes. He seems to improve almost every season

[Callum_62]

Boyle will rightly win it as he often comes up with the match winning moments

Surprised Porto hasn't been mentioned more often

Sent from my VOG-L29 using Tapatalk

[Eyrie]

In alphabetical order - Boyle, Doig, Gogic, Hanlon, Nisbet.

It'll be Boyle.

[danhibees1875]

In alphabetical order - Boyle, Doig, Gogic, Hanlon, Nisbet.

It'll be Boyle.

It's not decided on alphabetical order though. :confused:

[Eyrie]

It's not decided on alphabetical order though. :confused:

I was only listing them in alphabetical order because I CBA working out who I'd have in positions 2-5. But my winner is Boyle.

[Anthony Soprano]

POTY - Boyle
YPOTY - Doig

both by some distance for me

[WeeRussell]

Was Martin Boyle really that poor first half of the season? Maybe not as electric as he has been recently but poor? He started the season with a double.

He certainly wouldn’t have been in and POTY discussions based on his first half of the season form.

[Bukta#8]

Albert Kidd

[basehibby]

Boyle
Hanlon
McGinn
Newell
Doig - not necessarily in that order

[1van Sprou7e]

Doidg
Nesbit
Newall
Doige
Irving

This

[Fergus52]

Boyle
Hanlon
McGinn
Newell
Doig - not necessarily in that order

Think that would probably be my 5 too.

Would maybe replace Doig for Gogic or Nisbet.

Not been too impressed with Nisbet's all-round play this season, tends to lose the ball needlessly a lot of the time when he drops deep, but can't argue with the amount of goals he's scored.

[basehibby]

Think that would probably be my 5 too.

Would maybe replace Doig for Gogic or Nisbet.

Not been too impressed with Nisbet's all-round play this season, tends to lose the ball needlessly a lot of the time when he drops deep, but can't argue with the amount of goals he's scored.

Actually you are right - Gogic should be in there and no doubt. I'd therefore change my 5 to

Boyle
Hanlon
Gogic
McGinn
Newell

Doig has been a real revelation in this his breakthrough season but has not quite shown the consistent contribution of the above five.

Our front three have been great collectively all season but all have had dips in form - hence no Nissy or Doidge in my list. Boyle however has been effective and a threat even when not at the top of his game - he's been an out ball for us right through the campaign even while he's been kicked all over the park on a weekly basis. Now the goals are flowing his importance to us is obvious but, for me, his flair, electric pace, bravery, consistency and commitment to the cause makes him my POTY by a stretch.

[Saint Hibee]

This

Hang on, is Doige Doidge or Doig?

[basehibby]

He was getting pelters on here right up to January.

Not sure Boyle deserves it when he was pretty poor for the first half of the season.

For me poty should be someone who was consistently good the whole season, but can't really argue with anyone saying Boyle when you look at his numbers and how good he has been recently

Not all of us were giving him pelters back then. For me he was still one of our most important players through that spell even if his form was not the best. This is reflected by the fact he's barely missed a minute from August right the way through.

[Shrekko]

Boyle is POTY, but really amazed to see so many people who don’t have Gogic in their top 5. He’s my nearest challenger to Boyler.

[Phil MaGlass]

He was getting pelters on here right up to January.

Not sure Boyle deserves it when he was pretty poor for the first half of the season.

For me poty should be someone who was consistently good the whole season, but can't really argue with anyone saying Boyle when you look at his numbers and how good he has been recently

With you there, my young player would be Nisbet, made his breakthrough to the Scotland team aswell.

[Paul1642]

I’ll decide once I see who scores the Scottish cup winner for us 👀

[wookie70]

Quite hard looking over the whole season as all the main contenders have had fairly lengthy spells where they haven't been on top form. My five would be

Boyle
Gogic
Hanlon
Newell
Nisbet

Boyle would win it for me too simply because he has been the catalyst to us winning so many games. Doig is without doubt the YPOTY as Porteous, now just turned 22, is presumably too old for that.

I think the most encouraging thing this year is we have a group of players who are all very hard working and who all seem to be about the team rather than themselves. Jack Ross looks like he wants players who can perform with and without the ball and from our CFs right the way back through the team we have players who look pretty comfortable contributing going forward and also doing the less glamorous parts of the game. Our recent starting line ups include 10 outfield players who have all scored this year with subs coming on who have also hit the back of the net.

Statistically we are best of rest in terms of goal difference, goals scored and next best for goals conceded combined with a shoe in for 3rd and 3 semi finals. So despite the players all having parts of the season where form dipped the Team has been pretty consistent and this is a year where it has been all about team for me. The star man will be player of the year but this season will be one I remember for having an excellent team who all worked for each other and Jack Ross deserves great credit for what is being achieved but also for the direction of travel

[blackpoolhibs]

Boyle
Gogic
McGinn
Nesbil
Doig.

[neil7908]

Let's wait until the cup games - we could find a new name.

[Lith]

Boyle POTY
Doig YPOTY



that would be my choice too

[offshorehibby]

As said above

POTY - Boyle
YPOTY - Doig