Marc McNulty

[hfc rd]

Seriously, is he carrying an injury or is his head simply not at Hibs and is elsewhere? He’s been a shadow of the player he was in his 1st spell last season.

I’d love for this thread to be bumped after the Aberdeen game or any other game that comes and he ends up proving me wrong but my God, he’s been awful.

[MWHIBBIES]

No better than Shaw

[ScottB]

I’d imagine the compliance officer will see him miss a game or two after that stamp so you may have to wait awhile to bump.

[Hibs90]

Hes honking. Absolutely honking.

[neil7908]

Can GTF. Would give Gullan a shot rest of the season.

He was poor towards the end of his last spell and BSC Glasgow looks a out his level right now.

[IWasThere2016]

I’d imagine the compliance officer will see him miss a game or two after that stamp so you may have to wait awhile to bump.

A cert, and rightly so

[The Tubs]

I think Gullan might start in Aberdeen. Is Malonga still on a free?

[Callum_62]

I think he's overweight to be honest

He's not the type to show much if our midfield isn't on it, and they absolutely Wernt tonight

He will surely be receiving a ban too

Sent from my VOG-L29 using Tapatalk

[RossScott1991]

He’s god awful. Genuinely hope we don’t sign him. Never understood the excitement in him.

[Joe6-2]

Yeah, give Gullan a go

[hfc rd]

His performances for us indicate its no real surprise that he was a bench warner at League 1 Sunderland.

[supermcginn]

He is absolutely garbage. Bsc Glasgow is his level. Be happy to send him back asap.

[Chorley Hibee]

Absolutely garbage, offers the square root of nothing.

As usual most of our recruitment revolved around players who were previously here, rather than players we actually needed.

For the record I wasn't overly impressed with him the first time around either.

[Scottie]

Hes honking. Absolutely honking.
:agree: Looks like he can't be arsed.

[sean04]

It’s insane the money he is making down south. Should be embarrassed

[Gatecrasher]

He was the same last year though. Once the goals dried up he offered nothing. Still does. He was lucky to stay on the park tonight, his only contribution.

[Borderhibbie76]

He’s god awful. Genuinely hope we don’t sign him. Never understood the excitement in him.

He is ...wasnt enthused when we brought him back tbh and sadly I've been proven right. Hes poor when hes not scoring contributes nothing

[Weegreenman]

No better than Shaw


And very lucky to stay on the park.

[Zazu62]

Compare him to Washington tonight. Pathetic

[SeanWilson]

Seriously, is he carrying an injury or is his head simply not at Hibs and is elsewhere? He’s been a shadow of the player he was in his 1st spell last season.

I’d love for this thread to be bumped after the Aberdeen game or any other game that comes and he ends up proving me wrong but my God, he’s been awful.

Would rather be drinking a pint ....

[Hibs4185]

Honking. Should never wear a hibs jersey again. Anonymous.

Far rather give a young and hungry Gullan a chance than that waste of space.

[OtleyHibs]

Absolutely garbage, offers the square root of nothing.

As usual most of our recruitment revolved around players who were previously here, rather than players we actually needed.

For the record I wasn't overly impressed with him the first time around either.

I was impressed initially last time, the way I remember it and may be wrong is him missing a sitter for Scotland and then the goals dried up.

Not happy with him standing on another players back like that tonight (even a Jambo!) Don’t like to see anyone do stuff like that but even worse when it’s one of ours! It could and should’ve seen us down to ten men which, in hindsight, couldn’t have made us much worse tonight

[Since452]

Waste of a jersey again tonight

[Pretty Boy]

Gullan deserves a start ahead of him in the next game.

[madhatter]

He is honestly just as bad if not worse than Kamberi. His hold up and general play is really poor.

[Sean1875]

If we sent him back to Reading tomorrow I wouldn’t give a ****. He’s been useless for weeks.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[supermcginn]

He is like a man short, can't stick the guy in the slightest.

[supermcginn]

He is honestly just as bad if not worse than Kamberi. His hold up and general play is really poor.

He couldn't lace kamberi's boots.

[cabbageandribs1875]

there's only one sparky i want to see up front for us, he's playing tomorrow night

[Liam6270]

Get him as far away from Easter Road as possible, I never wanted him back, he’s so far up his own arse it’s incredible!

[MWHIBBIES]

Omeonga and Docherty were almost as bad. Scott Allan actually worse. Absolute dog****.

[nickwhibs]

Every player was a disgrace tonight. Not just him

[hfc rd]

Exactly. Kamberi might be a rat but he is 10x the player that imposter is.


This.

[Liam6270]

Every player was a disgrace tonight. Not just him

He was particularly embarrassing, for me he’s been awful since he came back

[hfc rd]

Omeonga and Docherty were almost as bad. Scott Allan actually worse. Absolute dog****.


Can’t argue with that either. I genuinely can’t think of one Hibs player tonight that you can say, he actually played as if he wanted to win this game as much as the fans did.

Hanlon and Stevenson, fantastic servants they have been for the club but sorry the pair of them are finished.

[Green-Hibee-7]

Gullan for the rest of the season. McNulty can see out his nice big contract at Reading. Nowhere near what we need.

[J-C]

He was decent for a handful of games last time around but was decidedly average for the rest, he's decidedly average again this time around.

[supermcginn]

He was decent for a handful of games last time around but was decidedly average for the rest, he's decidedly average again this time around.

He's miles away from average. He's pish

[hibee]

Waste of a jersey, give Gullan a run in the team to see what he can do.

[JammyDoidger]

Never tried a leg. That's the worst bit. He's got quality but no heart shown tonight. Not just him. The lot of them.

[Cod Boy]

Awful he’s no interested

[Hibs90]

Never tried a leg. That's the worst bit. He's got quality but no heart shown tonight. Not just him. The lot of them.

Sorry I see no quality at all. He's murder.

[calumhibee1]

He’s absolutely ****ing rotten. Get him out the team and don’t sign him permanently. Gullan needs to start at the weekend.

[Coco Bryce]

He's utter gash. I really hope we never try and pay a ludicrous amount of money for him. Passenger of the highest order.

[Golden Bear]

He's miles away from average. He's pish

He's also miles away from fitness.

[Hillsidehibby]

I was watching the QF highlights with my daughter who isn't into football. She said "Is that McNulty, Marc that went to Porty the same time as me? I didn't know he was a footballer.
You are correct my wee angel

[1 8 7 5]

Never tried a leg. That's the worst bit. He's got quality but no heart shown tonight. Not just him. The lot of them.

Your at it.

[SideBurns]

He just gives us nothing. He was crap after the split last season, and is continuing that form now.

[Ozyhibby]

He was cheaper than spending the cash to get Nisbet but it looks like it may be a decision that costs us more in the long run.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[calumhibee1]

He's utter gash. I really hope we never try and pay a ludicrous amount of money for him. Passenger of the highest order.

:agree:

I said that the last few weeks but gave him the benefit of the doubt cause he has scored a few. He’s ****ing chronic though.

[Diclonius]

I don't know about you, but I don't fancy begging Reading for another loan next season.

We can do much better.

[calumhibee1]

I don't know about you, but I don't fancy begging Reading for another loan next season.

We can do much better.

Vast majority of strikers in our league are much better.

[fishybeaver]

Not the best tonight, absolutely no service, poor poor display from everyone. I am hurting as much as the next hibby, but calling one of our own a rat is out of order!!

[supermcginn]

He's also miles away from fitness.

He won't get fit not trying a leg and standing on folks backs.

[Heisenberg]

Bound to be banned for Saturday anyway.

[Vault Boy]

The stamp was an embarrassment and worse than his poor performance. A really stupid, selfish and pointless thing to do. Deserves to be banned.

[calumhibee1]

Bound to be banned for Saturday anyway.

****ing yes please.

[mcfly]

Overpaid and over rated

Would not be trying to buy in the summer.

That stamp tonight was terrible.

[marleyhib]

i forget he's playing in most games, i wonder how few touches he actually averages per game? probably costs us about 500 quid each time

[DH1875]

McNulty or Flo. Know which one I would rather have.

[hfc rd]

I forgot about the stamp.

Stupidity beyond belief.

[Sir David Gray]

Cheers for the hat trick against BSC Glasgow.

The rest of his performances have been mediocre at best.

Not impressed at all.

[BILLYHIBS]

:wtf:

What was he doing with that stamp on Clare?

Deserved to walk

Said on another thread he has been poor apart from his hatrick versus the butchers and bakers and candlestick makers of BSC and I stand by that

Offers nothing makes Flo look like the 10m player he is :greengrin

[B.H.F.C]

Coward. Rather than show for the ball and try to influence the game, he thought the way to show he cared was to stamp on a boy on the ground.

How thick can you be, when there are that many cameras around?

[AFKA5814_Hibs]

Only notice he's on the park due to his bright orange boots, certainly not his football talents.

[emerald green]

WTF was he thinking when he stamped on the Hearts player? Was he trying to get sent off? If he had been (rightly) sent off, tonight's result might have been even more embarrassing.

[madhatter]

Hopefully retrospective ban means Gullan in. I'd honestly terminate the loan if possible. He gives us very little, seems to think he is better than he actually is.

[wookie70]

Gullane looked much better when he came on. I'd rather have Flo than McNulty

[Hermit Crab]

He’s getting banned that’s for sure. Dirty and needless.

https://uploads.tapatalk-cdn.com/20200303/e3b6ce3b3e314713ae994622c7b27c83.jpg

[CorrieHibs]

Was never his biggest fan and thought he was vastly overrated. His recent performances have confirmed this.

I actually hope he does see red for that cowardly stamp.

[h1bs4life]

Never noticed it at the game , just seen it on Sky Sport News wtf was he doing. Lucky Clancy was his usual inept self. Hasn't look interested since he came back. Few game suspension coming up , give Gullan a run out.

[Scouse Hibee]

Looked as good as he did before he left the first time.

[Liam6270]

Another maclaren, overrated, slow and no talent at all, get him to ******

[jeffers]

Still think he’s a decent player but not performing anywhere close to his ability. Chat of him and Doidge forming a decent partnership was utter bollocks IMO, their link up play is non existent, two strikers playing as individuals. His stamp tonight is indefensible, looks like it was deliberate and utterly stupid.

[CMurdoch]

His best work since coming back has been defensive.
He has made little impression in an attacking sense and that is where he needs to shine.
Not an easy role but that's why he is paid the big bucks.
Failed at Reading, failed at Sunderland and now failing at Hibs and in real danger of being replaced by young Gullan, a guy on a tenth of his wage.

[munchar]

Unfair to single him out tonight, there were many passengers. The boys hardly played, so won’t be up to speed with his fitness & sharpness. Fans will be hurting tonight, I’m one of them, but there were more experienced fit players tonight who’s performances tonight were embarrassing.

[Hermit Crab]

Unfair to single him out tonight, there were many passengers. The boys hardly played, so won’t be up to speed with his fitness & sharpness. Fans will be hurting tonight, I’m one of them, but there were more experienced fit players tonight who’s performances tonight were embarrassing.

Only the 5 games since returning in Jan

[Centre Hawf]

He can go for the stamp alone. Absolutely disgraceful behaviour from him and something I loathe to see at Hibs and thankfully it’s not something we see all that often.

Add in his absolute powderpuff performances and general look of being unfit and moving like it he’s no where near the level required for a team that wants to chase for Europe. I genuinely do not see what he brings to our team and if he was at any other team in this division they’d probably have binned him to the bench by now.

I was against bringing him back and sadly my fears have come true.

[OstKurve Hibs]

Hope he gets banned for the rest of the season, waste of a Jersey

[munchar]

Only the 5 games since returning in Jan

Hardly played before signing. Not at his best, but effort still there. Shameful the abuse directed towards him on here.

[JohnM1875]

Wouldn't be playing him again this season. I'd be giving Gullan a proper run out in the team.

Wasn't impressed with him the last time and he's done nothing to change my opinion this time. This also isn't just based on losing tonight.

[bigwheel]

Hope he gets banned for the rest of the season, waste of a Jersey

Flo....didn’t know you were on here.....


Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk

[Unseen work]

The stamp certainly isn’t out of character, he’s done similar in games for us before.

Was it hearts last season when he was fouled and as he fell tried to kick the opposition?

Sure there was a couple more.

[OstKurve Hibs]

Flo....didn’t know you were on here.....


Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk

Great response mate, take you long to come up with that ?, the guys *****, defend him all you want, he was ***** the first time he was here and shouldn't have been brought back

[bigwheel]

Great response mate, take you long to come up with that ?, the guys *****, defend him all you want, he was ***** the first time he was here and shouldn't have been brought back

His contribution is a lot better than your posts..that’s for sure


Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk

[RossScott1991]

He’s gash. One I wasn’t excited about, never understood the glamour to get him back. Hopefully we don’t waste anymore time with him.

gullan and try sign nisbet in summer

[OstKurve Hibs]

His contribution is a lot better than your posts..that’s for sure


Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk

Another good one, your on a roll

I'm sayin it as I see it, if you want to sugar coat ***** go ahead,

[madhatter]

Hardly played before signing. Not at his best, but effort still there. Shameful the abuse directed towards him on here.

His stamp was shameful. Hibs performance was shameful. What effort are you seeing as well? At stages of tonight's game I genuinely forgot he was playing. Same goes for Scott Allan to be fair to McNulty. However, the fact remains Gullan did more when he was on - a youngster thrown in at the deep end. I think Gullan had more touches in 5mins than McNulty had in 60mins.

[jeffers]

He’s gash. One I wasn’t excited about, never understood the glamour to get him back. Hopefully we don’t waste anymore time with him.

gullan and try sign nisbet in summer

He's not gash, he's a decent player who isn't performing as well as he can, something that could be levelled at most of the team tonight. Still a better finisher than Doidge in my opinion

[munchar]

His stamp was shameful. Hibs performance was shameful. What effort are you seeing as well? At stages of tonight's game I genuinely forgot he was playing. Same goes for Scott Allan to be fair to McNulty. However, the fact remains Gullan did more when he was on - a youngster thrown in at the deep end. I think Gullan had more touches in 5mins than McNulty had in 60mins.

His stamp was disgraceful, but so was the service he was receiving from the non existent midfield. Still kept showing for the ball & never hid. To many players poor tonight, but zero creativity from midfield the reason for lack of chances tonight.

[MagicSwirlingShip]

Perhaps a few weeks on the sidelines will allow him time to shift the extra timber he is carrying?

Big fan of Mcnulty on his game, last night he was very poor though.

[Robbo6-2]

McNulty has been poor since he returned.

Looks slow and is caught offside far to many times.

Id much rather see our own youngsters get a chance than overpriced bang average player from down south.

Fingers crossed he gets a retrospective ban which allows Gullan a run of a couple of games.

[MacGruber]

When he is banned and if we stick to two up with putting in Gullan we will have no striker for the bench - not a great position we have left ourselves in

[Northernhibee]

Boot this vermin troll. Absolutely no need.

On you go then. Tell me I’m wrong.

[NORTHERNHIBBY]

That was a strange performance from McNulty. Out of character for him. In most work places, he would be pulled aside and asked if he was ok or had anything worrying him.

[Gloucester Hibs]

Play Gullan for the rest of the season, he’s earned it. McNulty’a stamp was shameful and he has done stuff like that before, a liability and just not very good really.

[JimBHibees]

Still think he’s a decent player but not performing anywhere close to his ability. Chat of him and Doidge forming a decent partnership was utter bollocks IMO, their link up play is non existent, two strikers playing as individuals. His stamp tonight is indefensible, looks like it was deliberate and utterly stupid.

He is a decent player that isn't playing well. Some of his stuff has been good pass to Allan on Friday but doesn't look that sharp and link up with Doidge needs a lot of work imo. He was showing for the ball but our centre backs decided to knock it long.

[HibeeHibernian4]

The sort of player that the Danny Swanson lovers of this world absolute adore, and the rest of us shrug and see nothing particularly special.

[staunchhibby]

Totally out of order calling a player a rat.

[BroxburnHibee]

He may not have set the world on fire but some of the bile that's been posted on here is completely out of order.

[Peevemor]

Totally out of order calling a player a rat.


He may not have set the world on fire but some of the bile that's been posted on here is completely out of order.

:agree:

Probably the same people who go on about "Hibs Class".

[Nicho87]

In the papers last week saying unfinished business with Coventry city and championship. Sick of him coming here now to try and get his career back on track. Get rid now. All talk No action

[Golden Bear]

The Club would do well to fine McNulty for " the Stamp," like others, an act of stupidity like that is something I hate to see from a Hibs player.

[calumhibee1]

In the papers last week saying unfinished business with Coventry city and championship. Sick of him coming here now to try and get his career back on track. Get rid now. All talk No action

He’s no chance of getting anywhere near a Championship team. A league two player.

[Centre Hawf]

He may not have set the world on fire but some of the bile that's been posted on here is completely out of order.

I've not been happy with his performances since returning nor him actually coming back. But some of the comments have been a bit poor. It's one thing saying he isn't playing well or good enough, another to call him a rat.

[Hiber-nation]

He’s no chance of getting anywhere near a Championship team. A league two player.

The cringey interview after the BSC game when he was being asked about a Scotland call up has maybe got into his head. Still has the chance to redeem himself but it wouldn't bother me in the slightest if he didn't start again.

[Captain Trips]

Although at Hampden almost a carbon copy of Sproule stamp in same area of pitch. Not what I want to see from Hibs players. Try using that aggression to win a header next time.

[calumhibee1]

I agree. Send him back now.

If we weren’t so short I’d agree I’d just cut our losses. We can’t afford to have Doidge and a relatively untried, although promising, Jamie Gullan as our only options.

[KingPat4]

The Club would do well to fine McNulty for " the Stamp," like others, an act of stupidity like that is something I hate to see from a Hibs player.



Agree with this. Club should take the lead and fine him, it's not the Hibs way to act like that.

:top marks

[sean04]

The Club would do well to fine McNulty for " the Stamp," like others, an act of stupidity like that is something I hate to see from a Hibs player.

Sound terrible but I honestly thought he tried to get sent off. Surely no player is that stupid? If he had done it at 2-0 then maybe say the frustration got the better of him. No excuse for what he done

[Greenbeard]

He is absolutely garbage. Bsc Glasgow is his level. Be happy to send him back asap.
He is still a better bet than Hunberi. But I agree he needs to show a lot more than he has done so far (BSC excepted) to deserve a permanent deal. Waste of a jersey last night and will surely get a wee holiday for standing on Clare. I emphasise standing, not stamping. There wasn't excessive force. It was the sort of thing that happens multiple times in any one game of rugby, sometimes from your own player, without the recipient rolling around like they've got a fractured spine.
Give Super Jamie Gullan a start.

[supermcginn]

He is still a better bet than Hunberi. But I agree he needs to show a lot more than he has done so far (BSC excepted) to deserve a permanent deal. Waste of a jersey last night and will surely get a wee holiday for standing on Clare. I emphasise standing, not stamping. There wasn't excessive force. It was the sort of thing that happens multiple times in any one game of rugby, sometimes from your own player, without the recipient rolling around like they've got a fractured spine.
Give Super Jamie Gullan a start.
He couldn't lace kamberi's boots unfortunately.

[Onceinawhile]

Whose the back up to Jamie Gullan?

Given Mcnulty will be missing, whose the back up forward?

[JimBHibees]

Totally out of order stamping on someone’s spine. Hope we never see him in a Hibs shirt again.

And incidentally, in the cold light of morning I probably wouldn’t call him a rat but he shouldn’t appear for us again.

Spine? Back more like. Incredibly stupid and no idea why he didn't get a red last night.

[tonyrougier123]

I think marc needs to find his magic,needs to put down some roots at a club rather farmed out here and there,if reading are willing to release the boy fair enough ,if not we must move on too in the summer,don't want to spend the next transfer window hankering for players who were on loan,although I would like the idea of omeonga signing permanent now rather than later.

[MrRobot]

He’s absolutely ****ing rotten. Get him out the team and don’t sign him permanently. Gullan needs to start at the weekend.

this. he’s murder

[Hibs90]

I think marc needs to find his magic,needs to put down some roots at a club rather farmed out here and there,if reading are willing to release the boy fair enough ,if not we must move on too in the summer,don't want to spend the next transfer window hankering for players who were on loan,although I would like the idea of omeonga signing permanent now rather than later.

I suspect he will find himself dropping down the leagues very quickly at the current rate.

[JimBHibees]

If he gets a ban ,he will miss semi.

No he wont

[Danderhall Hibs]

He was cheaper than spending the cash to get Nisbet but it looks like it may be a decision that costs us more in the long run.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

Imagine the uproar if we’d signed an unknown player with 18 months of decent stats behind him rather than a proven premiership goal scorer?

You’d have had a field day..

[JimBHibees]

Some of the personal comments on here are embarrassing.

[Greenbeard]

Whose the back up to Jamie Gullan?

Given Mcnulty will be missing, whose the back up forward?
For the moment Boyle if needs be.

[Greenbeard]

He couldn't lace kamberi's boots unfortunately.
Well someone needs to 'cos he kept tripping over them. Maybe the Huns have bought him some velcro straps.

[HFCdeb]

Was a disgrace last night.

[bigwheel]

The lack of balanced analysis on this thread is embarrassing ..McNulty was no worse than any player last night - outside of his poor choice on the challenge with Clare ..

His work rate and movement has largely been effective since he came - and I guarantee Doidge , Allan etc much prefer to play with him than Kamberi .

Some Of the personal critical language about one of our own players is appalling ..this thread shows some Hibs fans at our worst ...

[Pretty Boy]

This thread is a ****ing disgrace for large parts. An utter disgrace and more than a couple of posters need to take a look at themselves.

I am raging after last night and no way is any player or the club as a whole above criticism. Some of the language used on this thread to describe a Hibs player is despicable though. Does McNulty deserve to be dropped? Yes, absolutely. Does he deserve some of the personal abuse being aimed at him for a bad performance and a moment of madness? That's for others to decide themselves but I'm almost ashamed to be partly responsible for providing a platform for it.

[Spike Mandela]

Morelos got off with stamping on a Celtic players back. Precedent.

https://www.thescottishsun.co.uk/sport/football/4140993/morelos-ralston-rangers-celtic-instagram/

[hibee_girl]

This thread is a ****ing disgrace for large parts. An utter disgrace and more than a couple of posters need to take a look at themselves.

I am raging after last night and no way is any player or the club as a whole above criticism. Some of the language used on this thread to describe a Hibs player is despicable though. Does McNulty deserve to be dropped? Yes, absolutely. Does he deserve some of the personal abuse being aimed at him for a bad performance and a moment of madness? That's for others to decide themselves but I'm almost ashamed to be partly responsible for providing a platform for it.

:top marks

[BroxburnHibee]

I've just gone through the thread and deleted some of the vitriol along with some quoted posts.

I'm not for a minute saying players can't be criticised on here but some people could do well with engaging their brains before typing something up on here.

If that upsets anyone too bad.

[HNA12]

Thread closed.
We have deleted posts referring to Hearts fans as vermin etc in the past and will continue to do so. We can leave the dehumanising stuff to other sites. It beggars belief that some fans think it's OK to direct such language towards our own players. Of course players should be criticised when their standards drop but using terms like 'rat' etc to describe one of our own is not acceptable here. We do realise that the vast majority here can get their point across without vitriol so there is no reason why we all can't.
As an aside, if you do use dehumanising language then it's a bit rich to come bleating to us because people have responded to your comment in kind. if you find something directed at yourself intolerable then maybe you should be deleting your own comment as well instead of leaving it to us to clean the mess up. We are supposed to be adults here.