Official Scottish Cup 4th Round: Dundee Utd v Hibernian match day thread.

[Bristolhibby]

In the buildup there was a collective stopping as if expecting the ref to blow for a foul.

Play to the whistle!

J

[Stuart93]

Typical hibs.

Not been anywhere near good enough here because that Dundee Utd team are average as ****

[NC1875]

Score and **** the bed as usual

[Sir David Gray]

Awful time to lose a goal and pish defending.

[danhibees1875]

Defence all over the place there.

[Onion]

Suckr punch seems to have perked up the commentators

[flash]

Let's make a decent left back our number one priority.

[J-C]

Porteous goes out towards the ball and leaves a big space, the lad needs to stop doing this, he does it quite a lot.

[Peevemor]

Been pretty pish since going up 1-0. Whittaker isnt doing enough to justify his place for me. Chronic lack of pace. Slivka on pleaseWe've made 2-3 decent chances since we scored.

[heretoday]

Smartly taken goal.

[Pretty Boy]

Started really well, controlled things well after the goal then we just let them creep back into it and conceded an awful goal.

We need to get right back on it in the 2nd half.

[Stuart93]

I take Scott Allan off at half time. Worst player on the park

[The Captain....]

Typical Hibs..defence isn't good enough.

Sent from my SM-G975F using Tapatalk

[Ozyhibby]

Porteous goes out towards the ball and leaves a big space, the lad needs to stop doing this, he does it quite a lot.

His positional play is very poor.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[Booked4Being-Ugly]

We started off well but god only knows why we sit off teams when we go in front.

[hfc rd]

Typical! Seen this story repeated so often this season

We started off well and could easily have been 2-3 goals up. They get one opportunity and take it. Got no one else to blame other than ourselves.

[GibbytheHibby2]

Defence sleeping

Both CHs posted missing

[flash]

Been pretty pish since going up 1-0. Whittaker isnt doing enough to justify his place for me. Chronic lack of pace. Slivka on please

Incredible take on what you are watching. We were absolutely strolling it until that goal.

[cabbageandribs1875]

Baffling scoreline

[Springbank]

Midfield of Whittaker & Hallberg unlikely to keep a clean sheet or make a difference at the other end.

Weak.

[hibsbollah]

It was a decent goal, Stevenson was tight but was beaten by the pass, it wasn't a defensive shambles as described on here.

[Johnny_Leith]

We are so average.

Allan has been very poor.

[SlickShoes]

Its fairly normal, we are OK, defensively we are bad. It's going to be like that if we persist with the defenders we have and the midfielders giving the ball away like they do.

[Unseen work]

We were by far the better team the first 15 or so and then fell out then back in.

I’m not sure our players know why they get success or do well against teams. To begin with we were playing quick, at pace and had good movement. There was only 1-2 touches per player and they were looking after it.

i don’t know if it was over confidence but we then started dwelling on the ball, taking too many touches and going for World Cup passes, it allowed them to slightly creep back into the game and get more of the ball.

We have been the better team, Flo and Hallberg should both have a goal.

We need Boyler on the ball a hell of a lot more.

[Sprouleflyer]

Typical!

Utd will now have the wind in their sails for the 2nd half.

We will struggle as usual.

[NC1875]

I take Scott Allan off at half time. Worst player on the park

Behave yourself

[dmc1875]

Scott Allan is playing possibly his worst game for us he’s more of a
Liability than anything at the minute I’d be taking him
Off

[Steve20]

Go 1-0 up and do nothing AGAIN.

It’s not good enough. This team needs a shake. Awful the last part of the half.

Need quite a few players in but again left it late as this is only thing we have to play for now. So we had better buck our ideas up in the 2nd half.

[danhibees1875]

I take Scott Allan off at half time. Worst player on the park

He makes something from nothing though. He's not had a good dame IMO, quite sloppy and giving the ball away easily far too often - but I'd rather have him on the pitch for when he does do something great.

United could have said the same about shankland up until he scored.

[MWHIBBIES]

Very poor from Ryan, leaves a huge space under no threat and it's 1-1. We'll win this I think, we've got more than them. Boyle hopeless through the middle so far but effective when wide right.

[Peevemor]

Incredible take on what you are watching. We were absolutely strolling it until that goal.There are a couple of very regular posters who do nothing but moan and criticise.

[Aldo]

Thankfully there are still 45 minutes to sort this out.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[we are hibs]

We've made 2-3 decent chances since we scored.


Incredible take on what you are watching. We were absolutely strolling it until that goal.

Thought we started really well then fell away a bit. We have created chances but we keep giving the ball away too much. We need to improve 2nd half if we are going to win. Not sure why thats so controversial. Its an opinion. No need to worry guys.

[J-C]

His positional play is very poor.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk


:agree: He needs to stay where he is and let Naismith close down the ball, he closed down and the ball was slipped into the space he left, poor.

[Stuart93]

Our defence isn’t good enough. Sloppy.

Again dundee Utd seem to walk past our midfield at times

[cabbageandribs1875]

too many guests

[NC1875]

Very poor from Ryan, leaves a huge space under no threat and it's 1-1. We'll win this I think, we've got more than them. Boyle hopeless through the middle so far but effective when wide right.

Ryan comes out to pick up Whittaker’s man. Whittaker 5 yards off the pace. Finished as a footballer

[hfc rd]

Kick our jambo guests out.

Website is running very slow

[lyonhibs]

Poor, poor decision making from Porteous, breaks from the defensive line to go to the ball and does absolutely nothing, my Mum would've put in more of a challenge on the ball carrier there.

We'll get chances in the 2nd half though, just a scunner of a time to concede.

[Vault Boy]

Hanlon very poor for their goal. Big second half for us.

[Pretty Boy]

Gray and Horgan both taking trousers off at HT, might be a couple of changes in the offing.

[Dmas]

Ryan comes out to pick up Whittaker’s man. Whittaker 5 yards off the pace. Finished as a footballer

Whittaker had a good game so far, some people far too critical of him IMO done far more than Hallberg has offered

[danhibees1875]

Ryan comes out to pick up Whittaker’s man. Whittaker 5 yards off the pace. Finished as a footballer

Very sloppy in the final minute of the half. We should just be holding our shape and marking up. A chain of players lose their man by rushing to cover someone else.

[cameronw-hfc]

Bit of a hammer blow when it's a lot their only shot

[Vault Boy]

Gray and Horgan both taking trousers off at HT, might be a couple of changes in the offing.

Hopefully Naismith's injury isn't a serious one

[we are hibs]

There are a couple of very regular posters who do nothing but moan and criticise.

And theres some regular posters who do nothing but take pathetic digs at other posters. If you dont like my opinions i dont care. I dont particularly value your opinion very highly either, mate.

[Bostonhibby]

Shocking defending against a team that haven't been in it.

Take our chances 2nd half and we really should still win this.

Sent from my SM-A750FN using Tapatalk

[yerauldda]

Playing well enough but Allan and Whittaker aren’t doing enough running in that midfield. Poor from both centre backs stepping up for the goal, big second half coming up.

[Unseen work]

Allan has been slack with some of his touches, passing and easily gave them occasion back on some occasions.

That being said I don’t think United are coping with him at all. He’s picking up lots of good positions, can nip past them and is drawing a couple of players towards him each time.

If he and Flo stop the flicks and play it quick and controlled we will win.

[wookie70]

Porteous goes out towards the ball and leaves a big space, the lad needs to stop doing this, he does it quite a lot. That was my thoughts too. I'd have started Daz. Porteous needed a few games out after his suspension imo to get him thinking about the bigger picture. Allan was terrible, Whitts good on the ball and positionally but struggles when ran at. I thought Hallberg was our standout.

[mcfly]

Defensively we are poor - losing poor goals all season

Week after week it’s the same.

Why are we looking at strikers?? It’s defensively we need replacements.

[Onion]

JR has got the tactics spot on and we've been very unlucky to be 1-1 at HT. Had we been more clinical up front, United would have been dead and buried. They've created 1 chance (with Hibs back line panicking) and taken it.

We just need to keep going and we'll win this. United are less than average.

[Pretty Boy]

Gray is definitely coming on. Away in early and warmer up separate from the other subs.

[hibsbollah]

JR has got the tactics spot on and we've been very unlucky to be 1-1 at HT. Had we been more clinical up front, United would have been dead and buried. They've created 1 chance (with Hibs back line panicking) and taken it.

We just need to keep going and we'll win this. United are less than average.

Exactly. Let's not wet the ******* bed.

[Stuart93]

Defensively we are poor - losing poor goals all season

Week after week it’s the same.

Why are we looking at strikers?? It’s defensively we need replacements.

Yep agree with this.

Shouting for strikers when our defence needs an overhaul

Always giving away soft soft goals

[Unseen work]

JR has got the tactics spot on and we've been very unlucky to be 1-1 at HT. Had we been more clinical up front, United would have been dead and buried. They've created 1 chance (with Hibs back line panicking) and taken it.

We just need to keep going and we'll win this. United are less than average.

Agreed.

My fear is that the get a huge lift from that goal and get momentum from being at home. Potential for them to go on top especially late in the game when we tire from missing games the last couple of weeks.

[jeffers]

I though Hanlon v poor for the goal. He was marking Shankland and moved off him into middle when he didn’t need to. The one player of theirs you don’t want to leave in space.

[Roxyhibee]

Hanlon standing Berra-like as the move goes past him. Porteous poor decision making. Lewis too late and weak to get a decent tackle in.

[cabbageandribs1875]

Whittaker had a good game so far, some people far too critical of him IMO done far more than Hallberg has offered


:agree:

[hfc rd]

SDG for Naismith confirmed

[The 90+2]

Sir Dave on. Come on Hibs.

[Bangkok Hibby]

SDG on, wonder if he's been practising his throw ins :greengrin

[supermcginn]

Defensively we are poor - losing poor goals all season

Week after week it’s the same.

Why are we looking at strikers?? It’s defensively we need replacements.

Got to agree, we are so easy to score against

[Hibby Kay-Yay]

Go 1-0 up and do nothing AGAIN.

It’s not good enough. This team needs a shake. Awful the last part of the half.

Need quite a few players in but again left it late as this is only thing we have to play for now. So we had better buck our ideas up in the 2nd half.

Do nothing?? Had we been more clinical we would have been 2 or 3 up.

[NAE NOOKIE]

Super first 10 - 15 minutes, but after that you could see our intensity drop and it allowed Utd back into the game. It's a classic case of if you don't take your chances the opposition always have a chance. I love Scott Allan, but his insatiable need to be flash every time he gets the ball is working against us in this game, he has missed several opportunities to keep an attack moving by not just making the simple pass.

We need to get a grip in the 2nd half.

[Bobby's Cinema]

Really good performance first half, Utd really not offering a lot in the game to that point.

Our movement top end of the pitch really good.

Allan guilty last 20 of playing up to his reputation for killer passes. Done nothing but give it away.

[NorthNorfolkHFC]

Not a great one for Naismith by the looks.

No contact, twisted his knee.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk Pro

[Onion]

Seriously, what is Porteous doing ???

[Stuart93]

Defence are a shambles

[cabbageandribs1875]

boyle :thumbsup:

[hfc rd]

YAAAASSSSS

Boyle makes it 2-1

[The 90+2]

****in in there squirrel 💚💚💚

[Pretty Boy]

What a goal.

[Sir David Gray]

What a goal!

[Onion]

Boyler !!!!!! Class !!!!!

[hibee_girl]

Boyle!!! :thumbsup::thumbsup::thumbsup::thumbsup::thumbsup: :thumbsup::thumbsup::thumbsup:

[col02]

Get in!

[makaveli1875]

Get in there Boyle

[Booked4Being-Ugly]

Get in Boyler.

[OtleyHibs]

Great goal squirrel! What a run of form he’s been on since coming back

[J-C]

Squirrel we love you :hibees:hibees:hibees

[hfc rd]

Boyle is irreplaceable in this Hibs team

[hibsbollah]

Yes!

Never in doubt.

[Jim44]

Take that. :thumbsup:

[sleeping giant]

Another great goal

[Pretty Boy]

Assist by the worst player on the park, be good when he turns up.....

[Peevemor]

And theres some regular posters who do nothing but take pathetic digs at other posters. If you dont like my opinions i dont care. I dont particularly value your opinion very highly either, mate.Pathetic? Fine.

[CraigHibee]

nice goal by boyle :thumbsup:

[Johnny_Leith]

There's someone who is so far from average at the moment - Martin Boyle.

Outstanding player at the moment, we'll do really well to get him on a new deal.

[PH91]

Great pass out of defence from hanlon, brilliant running from flo and an outstanding finish from boyle. Superb.

[Mr Grieves]

What a player Boyle is

[Aldo]

Need to get Boyle round the table and a new contract put to him


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[Forever_Green93]

Boom! Great goal Boyle.

[Peevemor]

Boyle's on fire.

[cabbageandribs1875]

now can we stop f****ng about this time hibs

[LaMotta]

Boyle proving just how effective he is from a central position.

[Pretty Boy]

Porteous knee again.

[heretoday]

Lively Hibs. Good to see.

[Ozyhibby]

£2m plus Edouard and we will consider it otherwise Boyle has to stay.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[The 90+2]

Assist by the worst player on the park, be good when he turns up.....

You’re better than that PB 👍

[calumhibee1]

Boyle is the best non old firm player in the league.

[CraigHibee]

Porteous knee again.

he's taken a clattering this game

[danhibees1875]

Porteous knee again.

Looks to be walking off okay. If there's even some doubt I'd take him off though - don't want to repeat the scenes v Livi.

[murray26]

Fine effort from our on form Boyler💚💚

[Peevemor]

he's taken a clattering this gameI think he hurt himself there.

[MikeyS]

Porteous knee again.

It looked like his knee was bothering him in the 1st half also.thats a worry

[hfc rd]

Porteous off for McGregor

[The 90+2]

Boyle is the best non old firm player in the league.

He’s getting better and better. So much to his game.

RP off. Daz on.

[Sir David Gray]

McGregor for Porteous.

[J-C]

Boyle is happy in life, married, new baby and a regular Aussie internationalist, happy in life = happy footballer.

[Aldo]

I think he hurt himself there.

Think he did looking at replays!


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[easty]

It was a decent goal, Stevenson was tight but was beaten by the pass, it wasn't a defensive shambles as described on here.

Yep

[Onion]

Hope Porteous is ok... but glad he's been replaced. Needs to be much more disciplined in his role.

[The 90+2]

Boyle is happy in life, married, new baby and a regular Aussie internationalist, happy in life = happy footballer.

He’s the life and soul of the club you could argue.

[Vault Boy]

Shame for Porto. Two good subs to bring on in unfortunate circumstances.

Great goal that from Boyler too, assist from Allan.

[heretoday]

Watch your knees, Darren!

[MikeyS]

Hope Porteous is ok... but glad he's been replaced. Needs to be much more disciplined in his role.

I cant remember a match where he hasn't hurt either himself or an opponent! Hope he isn't out for long.

[hfc rd]

Good attempt by Flo. Would have been a fantastic goal

[Aldo]

Still think we need at least one more goal


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[Peevemor]

Dodds just confused SDG & Boyle. He obviously doesn't know that squirrel's not baldy any more.

[Vault Boy]

Flo has played well today. Consistent threat.

[DH1875]

Still think we need at least one more goal


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

I get that feeling every week lol.

[hfc rd]

I get that feeling every week lol.

Me too 😂

[hibsbollah]

Flo has played well today. Consistent threat.

Most of them have. Maybe I'm easily pleased but I think we've played well:confused:

[Aldo]

I get that feeling every week lol.

I think most of us do.

We’ve started well but we need to press them and get another.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[Onceinawhile]

I get that feeling every week lol.

We could be 5 nil up in injury time and I'd still be thinking we need another.

[Weegreenman]

I cant remember a match where he hasn't hurt either himself or an opponent! Hope he isn't out for long.

He does like a physical game. He’ll end up permanently injured if he doesn’t wise up.

[Aldo]

Flo has started the second half very well. Constantly on the move, wanting the bill and switching it up!


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[easty]

Most of them have. Maybe I'm easily pleased but I think we've played well:confused:

We have. There’s times we could’ve used the ball better but it’s an away tie in the Scottish. That’s always gonna be the case. We’ve been the better team.

[Jones28]

Most of them have. Maybe I'm easily pleased but I think we've played well:confused:

We have, just the pish-the-bed squad making us out to be the worst team on earth.

[Jim44]

Seeing Dave Bowman in the crowd has spoiled my day. :greengrin

[Peevemor]

We have, just the pish-the-bed squad making us out to be the worst team on earth.Yep. Usual suspects.

[Peevemor]

Seeing Dave Bowman in the crowd has spoiled my day. :greengrinHe looks unwell.

[Aldo]

Butcher booked at last


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[hibee_girl]

Butcher finally booked

[Diclonius]

There were about four fouls in succession there before Clancy finally gave one.

[hfc rd]

Finally Butcher gets booked!

[cabbageandribs1875]

clancy points out half a dozen fouls all over the pitch then finally books butcher

[NC1875]

About time

[heretoday]

Commentators extolling the virtues of Davie Bowman, one of the dirtiest players ever to grace the field.

[danhibees1875]

We have, just the pish-the-bed squad making us out to be the worst team on earth.

Admittedly I've skipped a few pages, but has anyone actually been saying that? That's not the tone I've taken from the thread generally.

[Cataplana]

Butcher booked at last. Hope the referee doesn't hang about with a second yellow, that one was long overdue.

[Peevemor]

clancy points out half a dozen fouls all over the pitch then finally books butcherHaha. Mental.

[murray26]

Boyles been outstanding today

[LancashireHibby]

If we’re going to get another then you can guarantee that Boyle will be involved somewhere the line, he’s unplayable at the minute.

[OtleyHibs]

Prior to butchers booking about 3 or 4 of our players showed a great fighting spirit and were willing to get stuck in. Then they’re all high fiving each other, love to see that 👍

[Deansy]

C'mon Hibees - rise above them and finish this game off !!!

[The 90+2]

Yep. Usual suspects.

Any chance we can all just get on instead of tit for tat **** and petty names with opinions you don’t share?

[hibsbollah]

Daz class defending there.

[Onion]

We need to put this game away ! Missing half chances.

[NC1875]

Really need a 3rd here.

[cabbageandribs1875]

Really need a 3rd here.

and a 4th

[heretoday]

We need another. This is the danger hour.

[Onion]

How the Hell are these thugs getting away with constant fouling ?

[The 90+2]

Cash out bet time just in case.

[hibsbollah]

Doidge actually mugged there.

[Tug Wilson]

United are very industrial

[hibsbollah]

United are very industrial

And agricultural.

[Vault Boy]

Didn't realise United were such hatchet men

[Green Badger]

How the Hell are these thugs getting away with constant fouling ?

it’s unbelievable, especially if you consider what Stevenson was booked for.

[coco22]

United are very industrial

I would say more agricultural

[Aldo]

Think we need a change in midfield. Hallberg, Whittaker and Scott looking a bit heavy legged


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[The 90+2]

How the Hell are these thugs getting away with constant fouling ?

When Lewis got carded for nothing. Allan has been much better this half. I would maybe take off Whitts now.

[Tomsk]

Liam McLeod apologising for Billy Dodds talking crap there I think. Respect.

[heretoday]

Right bunch of thugs at the back United.

[Onion]

Samaritans need to call the BBC commentators.

[Sir David Gray]

2-2

[Dinkydoo]

Marciano should have got that

Sent from my SM-G970F using Tapatalk

[cabbageandribs1875]

and once again 2-2

[Joe6-2]

How the Hell are these thugs getting away with constant fouling ?

Are our refs so poor? Or is there an agenda against Hibs? Am I paranoid??

[Onion]

Whittakersr lost him.

[hibee_girl]

2-2 :grr:

[Vault Boy]

I think Whittaker is visibly tiring now. He's played well this half IMO but might need hooked.

[NC1875]

Whittaker. Embarrassing

[Pretty Boy]

Another bad, bad goal to concede. Caught wrong side twice on our right. 2 lapses, 2 goals conceded.

Could Marciano have done better? Seemed to take ages to go in.

[Aldo]

Whittaker sold himself there. But WTF. We have controlled this and let them into it.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[Diclonius]

Two minutes of pressure AGAIN. Goal AGAIN. We need to sort out this soft touch bull****.

[CMac1988]

That's what Whittaker gives you...

[Scorrie]

Rocky slow getting down to that in my view

[hfc rd]

FFS

Typical Hibs

We just can’t seem to close games off!

[HH81]

Out of nothing 2-2.

[makaveli1875]

for **** sake

[Saint Hibee]

Goalie error.

[one day maybe...]

Whittaker left for dead there

[CraigHibee]

as soon as he hit that i had a feeling it was going in

need to take it up a gear

[EdinMike]

Squeaky bum time as usual !

[hibsbollah]

Didn't realise United were such hatchet men

8 hatchet men, a good goalie,a diver and a good poacher up front.

Typical Neilson team.

[stokesmessiah]

Great strike to be fair.

[NORTHERNHIBBY]

Good goal, but we are sleepwalking

[Hibbyradge]

2 shots 2 goals. Unbelievable.

[Mr Grieves]

**** sake man

[Dinkydoo]

I've seen it again. Although Rocky sees it coming, it couldn't have been further into the corner.

Sent from my SM-G970F using Tapatalk

[Sir David Gray]

The amount of goals we concede is criminal.

[Onion]

2 shots, 2 goals from Utd.

[hibsbollah]

Goalie error.

:faf:

Eh, No.

[Keyser Sauzee]

Bogdan deserves his chance now, Marciano should have got that

[Joe6-2]

Oh to be a Hibby! 🙄

[Mon Dieu4]

Gray was equally as much as to blame

[Ozyhibby]

Steven ******* Whittaker.[emoji35]


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[Hibbyradge]

Goalie error.

No chance

[Vault Boy]

Just a great strike that. They're right lucky baws.

[easty]

Whittakersr lost him.

He cannae turn round. Takes him forever.

Which we all know. He should never be in the team

[Roxyhibee]

Whittaker standing watching like a statue.

[MikeyS]

Goalie error.

Very harsh to blame Rocky there, great finish from the big guy. Whittaker completely sold the pies put on the touchline

[Onion]

Have a horrible feeling about this.

[Vault Boy]

No chance the keeper could do anything about that.

[The 90+2]

When Lewis got carded for nothing. Allan has been much better this half. I would maybe take off Whitts now.

**** sake man.

[Weegreenman]

We are dug ***** weak at the back.

[Helensburghhibs]

Looks to me like rocky thought it was going wide. 100 percent an error for me. Shown by the fact he didn't extend his arm

[The 90+2]

They aren’t even booking that **** for that 🤬🤬

[GlesgaeHibby]

Goalie error.

Away an boil yer heed.

[mcfly]

Crazy the amount of goals we lose.

yet the same players seem undroppable.

If we do lose this game it’s a disgrace after dominating so long.

Cmon hibs

[Stuart93]

Typical of us this season

Absolutely typical

[makaveli1875]

Bogdan deserves his chance now, Marciano should have got that

Behave yourself the boy stuck it right in the bottom corner , no chance Bogdan would have stopped that .

[Centre Hawf]

Whittaker is clearly competent at small things and has a decent reading. But there is zero reason to play him when his body means he can be beaten like that, it's literally costing us.

[hfc rd]

Need some defensive reinforcements in this window. It’s our weakest area in the team.

[Stuart93]

Suppose when your back and Whittaker have an average age of 40 teams will run past you

[Springbank]

Whittaker & hallberg are not the answer

[JohnM1875]

People can't be blaming Rocky for that, surely!? Right in the corner, clips the post and goes in.

[The 90+2]

Whittaker is clearly competent at small things and has a decent reading. But there is zero reason to play him when his body means he can be beaten like that, it's literally costing us.

I think he has done alright at the easy stuff. His body isn’t mobile enough any longer and he’s shattered. Now we’re getting over ran.

[hfc rd]

Seriously Hallberg?

[Not So Young]

Could do without a replay

[cabbageandribs1875]

conspiracy theory

1. we wanted a replay for some extra cash in the coffers

[Dmas]

People can't be blaming Rocky for that, surely!? Right in the corner, clips the post and goes in.

Be asking questions of Hanlon on that I don’t understand why he’s not pressing the ball as the guys cutting across the 18 yard box, probably more of a hinderence to rocky standing where he was

[CMac1988]

Gray was equally as much as to blame

There's definitely more to it than just Whittaker but you can't sell yourself so easily.

[MikeyS]

Whittaker & hallberg are not the answer

Think Hallberg has something to offer but reckon his best position is further up field. Hes another one along with Newall & Mallan that we wont see the best of due to how good Allan is in the position.

Just furthermore shows how unbalanced Heckys signings were.

[The Captain....]

Our defending is absolutely pish

Sent from my SM-G975F using Tapatalk

[Hibeesmad]

Could do without a replay

Would prefer to get it over with now but I'm very confident of us beating them at home.

[Peevemor]

There's definitely more to it than just Whittaker but you can't sell yourself so easily.This.

[The 90+2]

This is getting too close for comfort now. How the **** do we manage to crumble all the time? We need a lot more legs defensively.

[OtleyHibs]

Could do without a replay

Whilst I agree with this, we do like to give Robbie Neilson a money spinning replay on our way to winning the cup, it’s becoming a tradition

[Jones28]

Hanlon did well there

[hibsbollah]

People can't be blaming Rocky for that, surely!? Right in the corner, clips the post and goes in.
:agree:
It's Pathetic predictable pish punditry.

[CloudSquall]

And jokers on here were fist pumping the idea of throwing Whittaker in at DM :hilarious

How many times does he have to display the fact his legs have completely gone?

[NORTHERNHIBBY]

I would take 2-2 right now.

[Hibeesmad]

Our defending is absolutely pish

Sent from my SM-G975F using Tapatalk

Naismith and Porteous now injured too. Where's Efe?

[jeffers]

Can’t get Omeonga into that midfield quick enough IMO.

[heretoday]

We're gonna lose this. The defence is sleeping.

[Lago]

Hanging on here

[Vault Boy]

Can’t get Omeonga into that midfield quick enough IMO.

Absolutely

[Centre Hawf]

I think he has done alright at the easy stuff. His body isn’t mobile enough any longer and he’s shattered. Now we’re getting over ran.

Definitely okay at the small things, but when the game gets fast and space opens up he's a liability. To be honest it doesn't help that him and Gray are playing down that right hand side together, anyone with fitness and a touch would rub their hands at running into the gap between them.

[Hibeesmad]

This is getting too close for comfort now. How the **** do we manage to crumble all the time? We need a lot more legs defensively.

Efe Ambrose is the answer to our problems

[delbert]

Whittaker & hallberg are not the answer

You simply cannot absolve the management team from culpability re not getting a defensive midfielder in, we are not competitive enough in the middle of the park, Dundee Utd look like world beaters in there when a hard tackling midfielder could really make a difference but three weeks into the window, nothing. Let’s not even start on the defence where Stevenson, Hanlon and Whittaker have once again been found out, but this time by lower league opposition, time to remind Jack Ross he was brought in to sort nonsense like this out !!

[matty_f]

Scratching my head how we're not out of sight here and yet have that feeling that it's about to go typically Hibs any minute.

[cabbageandribs1875]

poor foul to give away sir david

[The 90+2]

Scratching my head how we're not out of sight here and yet have that feeling that it's about to go typically Hibs any minute.

Kamberi winner. Can smell it.

[Peevemor]

poor foul to give away sir davidHe played the ball.

[Hibeesmad]

Kamberi winner. Can smell it.

Allan penalty

[hfc rd]

Come on Hibs! Get this winner!

[easty]

You simply cannot absolve the management team from culpability re not getting a defensive midfielder in, we are not competitive enough in the middle of the park, Dundee Utd look like world beaters in there when a hard tackling midfielder could really make a difference but three weeks into the window, nothing. Let’s not even start on the defence where Stevenson, Hanlon and Whittaker have once again been found out, but this time by lower league opposition, time to remind Jack Ross he was brought in to sort nonsense like this out !!

What game are you watching? Doesn’t seem like this one.

When have Dundee Utd midfield looked like world beaters?