Highlights

[Mikey]

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zHna56jTIm0

[Pretty Boy]

Was MacLaren offside? Looks it in that footage.

We're due 1 or 6 from the refs so if he was it's nice to see 1 go in our favour for a change.

[greenlex]

I think his kneecap probably was.

[Golden Bear]

Surely not.

[007]

Was MacLaren offside? Looks it in that footage.

We're due 1 or 6 from the refs so if he was it's nice to see 1 go in our favour for a change.

Not offside, picture gets frozen a couple of frames after Lewis's foot makes contact with the ball. Screen grab below is when it makes contact but the picture for some reason is tiny so not sure you'll be able to see it very well.

20601

[Sir David Gray]

Was MacLaren offside? Looks it in that footage.

We're due 1 or 6 from the refs so if he was it's nice to see 1 go in our favour for a change.

Nah not for me.

[CRAZYHIBBY]

Miles on side

[Pretty Boy]

Not offside, picture gets frozen a couple of frames after Lewis's foot makes contact with the ball. Screen grab below is when it makes contact but the picture for some reason is tiny so not sure you'll be able to see it very well.

20601

See I think he looks very, very marginally off in that picture. Linesmen tend to favour the defender when they have the view from that side as well.

I'm jot complaining btw, we are due one and it's just one of those 'honest mistakes' that we hear so much about it so no big deal.

[hibsbollah]

The save from Rogic is like something De Gea would have come up with. I really want us to hang onto Rocky.

[Eyrie]

BT Sport reckoned that he was marginally off by a knee cap but refreshingly didn't make much of it. Just observed how hard a call it was for the linesman.

It was one of those ones where to me Maclaren was just on but if it had been at the other end then I'd say the Celtc player was clearly off.

[Wee Effen Bee]

The save from Rogic is like something De Gea would have come up with. I really want us to hang onto Rocky.
De Gea or Hugo Lloris - or any other top goalies in the world. What prevents Oor Rocky from joining the elite (IMHO) is his lack of consistency. He is prone to the regular error which, unless he is able to eradicate, means he may not progress much further above the level of the SPFL. Selfishly though, I’m glad we have him at the moment and I have enjoyed watching him having some excellent games this year.

[660]

See I think he looks very, very marginally off in that picture. Linesmen tend to favour the defender when they have the view from that side as well.

I'm jot complaining btw, we are due one and it's just one of those 'honest mistakes' that we hear so much about it so no big deal.

Jesus Christ to paint that as hibs being “due one” is moon howling mental drivel.

[Dashing Bob S]

Hoping he’s offside to rub salt into soapy wounds but sadly it was a legit goal

[hibsbollah]

De Gea or Hugo Lloris - or any other top goalies in the world. What prevents Oor Rocky from joining the elite (IMHO) is his lack of consistency. He is prone to the regular error which, unless he is able to eradicate, means he may not progress much further above the level of the SPFL. Selfishly though, I’m glad we have him at the moment and I have enjoyed watching him having some excellent games this year.

On current form Lloris would be struggling to get a game in the East of Scotland league! But he and De Gea have both based their game around ridiculous réaction saves using anticipation, that's why I mentioned him in relation to Rockys save from Rogic. Not all keepers can do that. Obviously you're right about consistency.

[660]

I’m just delighted that we are awarded any sort of goal. After all ,we are due one.

[BigT-Hibeez]

See I think he looks very, very marginally off in that picture. Linesmen tend to favour the defender when they have the view from that side as well.

I'm jot complaining btw, we are due one and it's just one of those 'honest mistakes' that we hear so much about it so no big deal.

Definitely was onside mate, no mistakes.. Great goal!!

[Sammy7nil]

Miles on side

Miles off side but who cares

[overdrive]

I recorded the game and watched most of it this afternoon. I thought Maclaren looked to be level but all the pundits bar McCoist thought he was marginally offside.

As an aside I quite liked McCoist as a pundit today. Seemed quite balanced and was very complimentary towards us before, during and after the game.

[Hermit Crab]

Miles on side


He's level, definitely not miles onside!

[Hermit Crab]

I recorded the game and watched most of it this afternoon. I thought Maclaren looked to be level but all the pundits bar McCoist thought he was marginally offside.

As an aside I quite liked McCoist as a pundit today. Seemed quite balanced and was very complimentary towards us before, during and after the game.


I agree, he's a good pundit/co-commentator.

[1van Sprou7e]

Very comprehensive highlights for the first half... Shame they seemed to skip all the action we had after the second goal

Was at the other end of the stadium but looked like Boyle(?) was very close to scoring

[Mixu62]

Can I also add, take a bow Mr Swanson, made Brown look a mug there!!

[seanshow]

Extended highlights starting on BT sport shortly, 7.30 - 9am ...for anybody up with the larks :)

[Sir David Gray]

Miles off side but who cares

Whether he was or wasn't offside, he most definitely wasn't miles offside.

[Sas_The_Hibby]

Whether he was or wasn't offside, he most definitely wasn't miles offside.

....or miles onside :greengrin

[hibbyfraelibby]

Given the goal stood with that linesman who flagged everything within 5 yards offside in the first half Jamie Mac must have been in his own half when the ball was played...

[Hibee Mac]

He starts off but slows his run perfectly so that he's onside when the ball is played. Great goal, onside and level. Would be mental had that been called off!

[CockneyRebel]

Miles off side but who cares

TV pundits did the "line thing" where they superimpose a line across the pitch at the correct angle and it shows the run was timed to perfection and onside. End of.

[snooky]

He's level, definitely not miles onside!

I suspect there was some crazyhibby sarcasm in there, HC. :wink:

[Allant1981]

Miles off side but who cares

no it wasnt, if anything maybe a couple of inches bit very debatable