Players who played better for Hibs or Hearts

[snooky]

This is for players who have played for both Hibs and Hearts but played better for one of the sides.

Better with Hibs
Alan Gordon
Darren Jackson
Gordon Smith

Better with Hearts
Paul Hartley
Paul Hartley
Paul Hartley

[JeMeSouviens]

****** rubbish with both
Brian Hamilton

[JeMeSouviens]

What about Ralph Callachan? I'm too young to remember him in mingin maroon but he was pretty good for us?

[Peevemor]

Gordon Durie - Hibs

[Monts]

Alan Maybury - Hearts

[Sauzee16]

Michael Stewart Hibernian

[FifeHibs]

Although never officially signed by Hearts Zibi Małkowski he should have got man of the match for them a few times.

[snooky]

Chris Shevlane & Roy Barry - probably eaksy-peaksy for both teams, IMO

[SHODAN]

James Keatings - won the Championship with both, won the Cup with us.

[1van Sprou7e]

Fraser Mullen - Hearts

[ancient hibee]

Hibs. Willie Hamilton

Hearts. Jim Souness
Ian Crawford

[Hibby70]

Eamonn Bannon - Hearts

Who was the full back we had, big ugly dude

Edit: think I'm thinking of Andy Watson did we play him at left back at parkhead once?

[Greentinted]

Willie Jamieson - Hibs
Eamonn Bannon - Hearts (obviously)
Peter Marinello - Hibs
Willie Hamilton - Hibs
Gordon Marshall (snr) - Hearts
Adam Eckersley - Hearts
Malky Robertson - Hearts
And perhaps controversially , Brian Hamilton - Hibs (based on his efforts in 1991)

[PatHead]

Michael Stewart Hibs

[PatHead]

Hibs. Willie Hamilton

Hearts. Jim Souness
Ian Crawford

As I assume you will have seen him, where does Gordon Smith sit

[SouthMoroccoStu]

Rherras - In theory

[WoreTheGreen]

Craig Thompson (ref?) them

[Leith's finest]

Darren Jackson hibs

[Hiber-nation]

Willie Jamieson - Hibs
Eamonn Bannon - Hearts (obviously)
Peter Marinello - Hibs
Willie Hamilton - Hibs
Gordon Marshall (snr) - Hearts
Adam Eckersley - Hearts
Malky Robertson - Hearts
And perhaps controversially , Brian Hamilton - Hibs (based on his efforts in 1991)

Can I add to that list:

Lawrie Tierney - hearts
Ian Black snr - hearts
Jimmy Brown - hearts but had a decent season for us

[Onion]

Paul Hanlon
Jason Cummings

[ancient hibee]

As I assume you will have seen him, where does Gordon Smith sit
Gordon Smith wasn’t at Hearts long enough to have as great a career with them as he had at Hibs.However he played well and I think scored over a dozen goals in the league winning year which would be better than he’d managed over the previous three or four seasons.As you know he went on to Dundee where he also played well although he wasn’t as mobile.He was the sort of player by that stage that even when having an off day looked good.Of course the hair and sun tan helped:greengrin