When have we ever had a major decision against them in our favour?

[Firestarter]

Can't think of one ever. ****ing disgrace they get everything.

Let's do them second half they are ****ing pish. Let's hope they are favourable to us next half knowing they have bawsed up again.

Come on Hibs!!!!

[Joe6-2]

Can't think of one ever. ****ing disgrace they get everything.

Let's do them second half they are ****ing pish. Let's hope they are favourable to us next half knowing they have bawsed up again.

Come on Hibs!!!!

Don’t hold your breath

[lapsedhibee]

Can't think of one ever. ****ing disgrace they get everything.

Let's do them second half they are ****ing pish. Let's hope they are favourable to us next half knowing they have bawsed up again.

Come on Hibs!!!!

I can mind one. Scott Brown booted somebody just before half-time at ER, should probably have been off but didn't even get carded. Colin Murdoch walked off with at half time trying to calm him down.

[LaMotta]

Can't think of one ever. ****ing disgrace they get everything.

Let's do them second half they are ****ing pish. Let's hope they are favourable to us next half knowing they have bawsed up again.

Come on Hibs!!!!
its a ***in joke mate. only consolation is that we were far the better the team and we now have 9 in a row

[JimBHibees]

I can mind one. Scott Brown booted somebody just before half-time at ER, should probably have been off but didn't even get carded. Colin Murdoch walked off with at half time trying to calm him down.

Lol that major no one can remember it against 2 actual goals about 4 retrospective red cards forster 3 yards onside goal etc. Absolutely bent

[bingo70]

Think we just got one.

I’m not sure on the rules of handballs now but clearly hit Stevenson’s hand.

[Allant1981]

Think we just got one.

I’m not sure on the rules of handballs now but clearly hit Stevenson’s hand.

dont think there is much he could have done about it, although if it had been in the other box we would have been screaming for it!

[Pete]

They could’ve had a pen tonight.

Maybe our “goal” meant they were never getting it anyway.

[hibby6270]

Here’s 2 from recent games that we didn’t get .

Forster offside - apparently :confused:
19951

Leigh’s free kick not over the line - apparently.
19952

Let’s not forget that penalty in the Cup Final.

And then tonight .

Will it ever end?

[AgentDaleCooper]

Arguably, they could have had a pen at the end, and lafferty was onside IMO...still utterly gauling but oh well, our record against them stands.

[calamitus]

Let's be honest, a £30 Go Pro duck taped to
a stick would sort this type of thing out. We don't like technology in Scotland. Taint natural.

[Firestarter]

They could’ve had a pen tonight.

Maybe our “goal” meant they were never getting it anyway.

They would usually get that pen Cabs. Not that it was a pen.

****in robbed again. Nearest to shaw in the first goal should get it too.

[lord bunberry]

It’s a complete ****ing joke. The pundits on sky saying the linesman didn’t see it!!! Well he should have been in a position to ****ing see. He seen every offside in the first half alright.
Absolutely raging.

[hibby6270]

Let's be honest, a £30 Go Pro duck taped to
a stick would sort this type of thing out. We don't like technology in Scotland. Taint natural.

:agree::thumbsup:

[TheHarpy76]

Tonight.
They should have had a penalty.

[eezyrider]

Think we just got one.

I’m not sure on the rules of handballs now but clearly hit Stevenson’s hand.

Yes, the ball hit his hand. But to be a penalty Stevenson would have to have played the ball with his hand which he clearly didn't.

EZ

[Big L]

****in robbed again! They never had a shot on target and I don't think they had a corner. We didn't take advantage of the high line they played. K

[EskbankHibby]

Yes, the ball hit his hand. But to be a penalty Stevenson would have to have played the ball with his hand which he clearly didn't.

EZ

Yup.

If the one in the Falkirk game at Easter Road (where the defender grabs then moves the ball on the ground in the box) was not a penalty, none of the two handballs in the box tonight are penalties - no way.

[Sylar]

Tonight.
They should have had a penalty.

That linesman had an abysmal night, and he should be demoted from officiating at the top level in Scotland.

Not only Shaw's goal, not only Stevenson's handball, but several of the times he flagged for offside he got them wrong - for the same reason he couldn't see to give the goal - he wasn't up with play.

[Newcastlehibby]

Yes, the ball hit his hand. But to be a penalty Stevenson would have to have played the ball with his hand which he clearly didn't.

EZ

He was clearly trying to move his hand/arm out of the way. Not deliberate hand ball, so no penalty.

[majorhibs]

Tonight.
They should have had a penalty.

You zoomers need less chloroform. Never a pen. 1-0 like it should- different game. Get back on this planet!

[inglisavhibs]

Tonight.
They should have had a penalty.
wrong again, has to be deliberate and no way it was. clutching at straws as usual. the shaw goal however:greengrin

[TheHarpy76]

You zoomers need less chloroform. Never a pen. 1-0 like it should- different game. Get back on this planet!

Is there really any need for personal abuse?
It looked to me that Stevenson controlled the ball with his arm. We would have been furious if it happened up the other end.

[Firestarter]

Is there really any need for personal abuse?
It looked to me that Stevenson controlled the ball with his arm. We would have been furious if it happened up the other end.

That's the softest personal abuse ever read.

Maybe stick to being furious our game changing match winning goal was chalked off....AGAIN

[Firestarter]

its a ***in joke mate. only consolation is that we were far the better the team and we now have 9 in a row

It's actually no funny anymore mate. They get away with **** all the time and don't even start me on that wee rat bassa Jamie Walker who super John ripped the arse out of all evening. Goosefrabba!!!

[21.05.2016]

The major, game changing decisions in derbies are ALWAYS in their favour. Thats 3 times in the last 5 years that we have had perfectly legitimate goals chopped off against them. Totally beyond a joke how much luck they get from officials against us, they get away with absolute murder time after time. Absolutely robbed yet again.

Absolutely gutted for Shaw, what a moment that would have (SHOULD have!) been for him.

[Hi Heid Yin]

He was clearly trying to move his hand/arm out of the way. Not deliberate hand ball, so no penalty.

:agree::agree::agree:

[theonlywayisup]

Tonight.
They should have had a penalty.

Don't know the latest ruling for handball, but below is what I've found from Google.

Law 12 in the FIFA Rulebook explains the regulations and procedures for a deliberate handball in football during the game.


The simplest explanation of the football handball rule is, did the player's hand or arm, from the tips of the fingers to the shoulder, play the ball? And if so, was it done deliberately?


A ball which is first kicked and then hits a player's hand or arm is not ruled as ball handling. The referee must use judgment to decide whether the handball ball was accidental contact.

Never in a month of Sundays could you say that Stevenson deliberately handled the ball. There was no intent. There was also no advantage or disadvantage to either team. Also, some people talk about the players hand being in an unnatural position, but don't know what the rules say about that. It's a joke that anyone seriously believes that to be a penalty.

[hibsbollah]

Is there really any need for personal abuse?
It looked to me that Stevenson controlled the ball with his arm. We would have been furious if it happened up the other end.

For the good Major, that post is the modicum of restraint :greengrin

[Hi Heid Yin]

We were denied a goal!
They were denied a dubious penalty - which if it had been given does not equate to scoring a goal!
We ultimately were the victims of a gross miscarriage of justice - and there we were thinking that a Leigh griffiths "non-goal" would be unlikely to happen again so soon.
Seriously, a cheap video replay directly to a wee panel of adjudicating officials and a wee voice in the ear-piece of the referee would have sorted this sort of thing out in less than a minute.

[John_R_Corbett]

Tonight.
They should have had a penalty.Never a penalty in yer puff

[theonlywayisup]

Here’s 2 from recent games that we didn’t get .

Forster offside - apparently :confused:
19951

Leigh’s free kick not over the line - apparently.
19952

Let’s not forget that penalty in the Cup Final.

And then tonight .

Will it ever end?

Can we also add Grant Brebner wrongly sent off before half-time in the Gary O'Connor last minute winner game.
Also, the Hampden penalty when the contact was made outside the box but the player falls into the box.
I also recall an attack on Fletcher when he was running through to get a ball that Gordon would probably comfortably reach only for Berra to shoulder charge Fletcher in the box - no attempt to play the ball nor get in front of the ball to protect it - no this was a full body shoulder charge on a player in full flight.
What about the two or three Hertz players not sent off during a Derby but then retrospectively dealt with - no advantage to Hibs.

Back to the OP's question - I'm trying to think of any that have gone in our favour.:tumble:

[Eyrie]

If these wrong decisions are meant to even out then we can look forward to beating Hearts 10-0 in the next game.

But they don't, so we'll have to settle for a narrow 1-0 win.

[Fife-Hibee]

Whether it was a penalty or not makes no difference we should have been 0-1 up and the pattern of the game would have changed there wouldn't have been a penalty claim! Well certainly not that one! We were ****ing robbed again!! 😡

[CentreLine]

Can we also add Grant Brebner wrongly sent off before half-time in the Gary O'Connor last minute winner game.
Also, the Hampden penalty when the contact was made outside the box but the player falls into the box.
I also recall an attack on Fletcher when he was running through to get a ball that Gordon would probably comfortably reach only for Berra to shoulder charge Fletcher in the box - no attempt to play the ball nor get in front of the ball to protect it - no this was a full body shoulder charge on a player in full flight.
What about the two or three Hertz players not sent off during a Derby but then retrospectively dealt with - no advantage to Hibs.

Back to the OP's question - I'm trying to think of any that have gone in our favour.:tumble:

Somebody, perhaps Hibs TV, should put together a (not so) short film of all of these supposed refereeing gaffs in the derby matches. Including, of course, all of the retrospective red cards. It would go viral in minutes don't you think?
Even the punters sitting in the seats behind the police box could see that was over the line.

[Hibernia&Alba]

The officials were appalling last night; they got so many decisions wrong. Having watched brief highlights, I have to admit that was a clear penalty at the death for the handball. If that had been awarded and we'd lost, I think I would have exploded. The difference is sometimes you get penalties and sometimes you don't; you still have to score it. We did score but were denied a legitimate goal.

[John_R_Corbett]

The officials were appalling last night; they got so many decisions wrong. Having watched brief highlights, I have to admit that was a clear penalty at the death for the handball. If that had been awarded and we'd lost, I think I would have exploded. The difference is sometimes you get penalties and sometimes you don't; you still have to score it. We did score but were denied a legitimate goal.No it wasn't

[Hibernia&Alba]

No it wasn't

Just being honest. IMO, it was a clear handball.

[John_R_Corbett]

Just being honest. IMO, it was a clear handball.The ball hitting his hand doesn't automatically make it a penalty.

[Hibernia&Alba]

The ball hitting his hand doesn't automatically make it a penalty.

I know that, but, having watched the replay I think Stevenson could have 'done more' to avoid the ball :wink:. I'd be demanding it every time.

[theonlywayisup]

I know that, but, having watched the replay I think Stevenson could have 'done more' to avoid the ball :wink:. I'd be demanding it every time.

From Google - the handball look more "accidental" than "deliberate" to me, there was no intent to play the ball with his hand.

Law 12 in the FIFA Rulebook explains the regulations and procedures for a deliberate handball in football during the game.

The simplest explanation of the football handball rule is, did the player's hand or arm, from the tips of the fingers to the shoulder, play the ball? And if so, was it done deliberately?

A ball which is first kicked and then hits a player's hand or arm is not ruled as ball handling. The referee must use judgment to decide whether the handball ball was accidental contact.

[The Harp Awakes]

Can we also add Grant Brebner wrongly sent off before half-time in the Gary O'Connor last minute winner game.
Also, the Hampden penalty when the contact was made outside the box but the player falls into the box.
I also recall an attack on Fletcher when he was running through to get a ball that Gordon would probably comfortably reach only for Berra to shoulder charge Fletcher in the box - no attempt to play the ball nor get in front of the ball to protect it - no this was a full body shoulder charge on a player in full flight.
What about the two or three Hertz players not sent off during a Derby but then retrospectively dealt with - no advantage to Hibs.

Back to the OP's question - I'm trying to think of any that have gone in our favour.:tumble:

I can remember Jamie Walker getting a retrospective red for the head butt. Who were the other retrospective reds for Hearts players again?

[21.05.2016]

I can remember Jamie Walker getting a retrospective red for the head butt. Who were the other retrospective reds for Hearts players again?

McGowan, Templeton and Ryan Stevenson I think

[James70]

Going back a bit now I remember Neil Berry's horrendous tackle on Paul Wright which put him out of football for a considerable length of time. I don't think that Berry was even booked.