PDA

View Full Version : Players ratings v Thistle



erin go bragh
02-12-2017, 07:16 PM
Any chance some of they brilliant 2000 plus fans could post some ratings .
Thanks in advance.

1875M
02-12-2017, 07:28 PM
Marciano 8 - Some great saves, especially the 1 v 1 and the one in the 2nd half

Ambrose 6.5 - Some dodgy moments but Ok overall
Hanlon 8 - Thought he was fab - composed and a very good performance
McGregor 7 - First game back in a while,, I was talking my pal saying he didnt't look up to match speed in the first 5 minues but adjusted quickly, good performance.

Boyle 8 - Maybe a bit generous but I thought he was fantastic today, caused real problems
McGeough 7 - Good again
Slivka 6 - Anonymous today I thought, especially in the 1st
Bartley 7 - Broke up play well and a typical Bartley performance
Stevenson 7 - Won all his 50/50s today and a good perfromance again


Stokes 6 - Thought he was OK, nothing special though
Murray 6 - Done all his usual running, did OK i thought

everyone agree with that? :na na::na na::na na:

LaMotta
02-12-2017, 07:36 PM
Marciano 8 - Some great saves, especially the 1 v 1 and the one in the 2nd half

Ambrose 6.5 - Some dodgy moments but Ok overall
Hanlon 8 - Thought he was fab - composed and a very good performance
McGregor 7 - First game back in a while,, I was talking my pal saying he didnt't look up to match speed in the first 5 minues but adjusted quickly, good performance.

Boyle 8 - Maybe a bit generous but I thought he was fantastic today, caused real problems
McGeough 7 - Good again
Slivka 6 - Anonymous today I thought, especially in the 1st
Bartley 7 - Broke up play well and a typical Bartley performance
Stevenson 7 - Won all his 50/50s today and a good perfromance again


Stokes 6 - Thought he was OK, nothing special though
Murray 6 - Done all his usual running, did OK i thought

everyone agree with that? :na na::na na::na na:

Agree mainly but thought Stevenson was MOM for us. So he has to get an 8 for me.

Rocky's save with his foot was outstanding. He has been a matchwinner for us at least twice this year.

Comiston Hibee
02-12-2017, 07:42 PM
Can’t disagree too much with OP
Good to see Darren back; always feels
More confident when he is playing

Springbank
02-12-2017, 07:43 PM
Think that's a decent summary

We had Hanlon as m.o.m

Slivka 4/10 today. So much more to come from him but today passed him by.

Barker and oli Shaw both very decent off the bench too.

Hiber-nation
02-12-2017, 07:59 PM
Boyle, Stevenson, Hanlon, McGeouch, McGregor, Marciano all very good.

Slivka didn't get involved enough and and Stokes wasn't great.

greenlex
02-12-2017, 08:01 PM
Really disappointed with Slivka today. A chance to make his mark and just didn’t.
On the flip side very impressed with Shaw’s contribution.

Springbank
02-12-2017, 08:03 PM
Really disappointed with Slivka today. A chance to make his mark and just didn’t.
On the flip side very impressed with Shaw’s contribution.

Agree 100%

Shaw has a lot of class

Steve20
02-12-2017, 08:05 PM
Stevenson would be my man of the match.

GlesgaeHibby
02-12-2017, 08:07 PM
Really disappointed with Slivka today. A chance to make his mark and just didn’t.
On the flip side very impressed with Shaw’s contribution.

Agree, although slivka did better 2nd half but still not great. Stevenson had a very good game today.

theonlywayisup
02-12-2017, 08:07 PM
Marciano 8 - Some great saves, especially the 1 v 1 and the one in the 2nd half

Ambrose 6.5 - Some dodgy moments but Ok overall
Hanlon 8 - Thought he was fab - composed and a very good performance
McGregor 7 - First game back in a while,, I was talking my pal saying he didnt't look up to match speed in the first 5 minues but adjusted quickly, good performance.

Boyle 8 - Maybe a bit generous but I thought he was fantastic today, caused real problems
McGeough 7 - Good again
Slivka 6 - Anonymous today I thought, especially in the 1st
Bartley 7 - Broke up play well and a typical Bartley performance
Stevenson 7 - Won all his 50/50s today and a good perfromance again


Stokes 6 - Thought he was OK, nothing special though
Murray 6 - Done all his usual running, did OK i thought

everyone agree with that? :na na::na na::na na:

Overall, I agree. But thought Ambrose was much more than a 6.5 - he strolled it and was great going forward.

penihibs
02-12-2017, 10:45 PM
Agree mainly but thought Stevenson was MOM for us. So he has to get an 8 for me.

Rocky's save with his foot was outstanding. He has been a matchwinner for us at least twice this year.
Mom for me aswell great 2cd half .
Goalie had two brilliant saves or we were goosed !!

Still Smiling
02-12-2017, 11:09 PM
Thought Oli Shaw did well when he came on, receives and controls the ball better than Murray.

ehf
03-12-2017, 12:00 AM
Marciano won us the points today, Stokes and Slivka disappointing, everyone one else 5 or 6.

Sammy7nil
03-12-2017, 08:12 AM
Marciano 8 - Some great saves, especially the 1 v 1 and the one in the 2nd half

Ambrose 6.5 - Some dodgy moments but Ok overall
Hanlon 8 - Thought he was fab - composed and a very good performance
McGregor 7 - First game back in a while,, I was talking my pal saying he didnt't look up to match speed in the first 5 minues but adjusted quickly, good performance.

Boyle 8 - Maybe a bit generous but I thought he was fantastic today, caused real problems
McGeough 7 - Good again
Slivka 6 - Anonymous today I thought, especially in the 1st
Bartley 7 - Broke up play well and a typical Bartley performance
Stevenson 7 - Won all his 50/50s today and a good perfromance again


Stokes 6 - Thought he was OK, nothing special though
Murray 6 - Done all his usual running, did OK i thought

everyone agree with that? :na na::na na::na na:

My gripe is your comments for Efe Stokes Slivka don't seem to be reflected in their score :confused:

SChibs
03-12-2017, 09:13 AM
My gripe is your comments for Efe Stokes Slivka don't seem to be reflected in their score :confused:

I'd say 6 was a standard score to be honest. Didn't do anything spectacular but nothing particularly bad either