Player ratings

[RamYer1902]

Marciano (6) - Nothing to do.

Gray (6) - Got forward well.

Ambrose (7) - Solid, calm, collected.

Forster (6) - Did well.

Stevenson (7) - Reliable as always.

Boyle (7) - Did well. Won the penalty.

Bartley (6) - Did well. Sloppy in possession.

McGinn (8) - Great goal and typical SJM.

Shinnie (8) - Just my MOTM. Involved in everything. Great pass for penalty.

Holt (7) - Did everything but score. Well played.

Cummings (6) - Got his goal and did well until he became petulant in 2nd half.

Subs:

Keatings (7) - Changed the tempo when he came on. Terrific header.

Fyvie (5) - Not much time.

Graham (5) - See Fyvie.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[alihibs1]

Marciano (6) - Nothing to do.

Gray (6) - Got forward well.

Ambrose (7) - Solid, calm, collected.

Forster (6) - Did well.

Stevenson (7) - Reliable as always.

Boyle (7) - Did well. Won the penalty.

Bartley (6) - Did well. Sloppy in possession.

McGinn (8) - Great goal and typical SJM.

Shinnie (8) - Just my MOTM. Involved in everything. Great pass for penalty.

Holt (7) - Did everything but score. Well played.

Cummings (6) - Got his goal and did well until he became petulant in 2nd half.

Subs:

Keatings (7) - Changed the tempo when he came on. Terrific header.

Fyvie (5) - Not much time.

Graham (5) - See Fyvie.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
Agree with most but would push Bartley up to an 8 and Holt up to an 8 aswell.

Sent from my SM-G930F using Tapatalk

[Dashing Bob S]

Marciano (6) - Nothing to do.

Gray (6) - Got forward well.

Ambrose (7) - Solid, calm, collected.

Forster (6) - Did well.

Stevenson (7) - Reliable as always.

Boyle (7) - Did well. Won the penalty.

Bartley (6) - Did well. Sloppy in possession.

McGinn (8) - Great goal and typical SJM.

Shinnie (8) - Just my MOTM. Involved in everything. Great pass for penalty.

Holt (7) - Did everything but score. Well played.

Cummings (6) - Got his goal and did well until he became petulant in 2nd half.

Subs:

Keatings (7) - Changed the tempo when he came on. Terrific header.

Fyvie (5) - Not much time.

Graham (5) - See Fyvie.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

Absolutely nothing I would change about that assessment.

[houstonhibbee]

Marciano (6) - Nothing to do.

Gray (6) - Got forward well.

Ambrose (7) - Solid, calm, collected.

Forster (6) - Did well.

Stevenson (7) - Reliable as always.

Boyle (7) - Did well. Won the penalty.

Bartley (6) - Did well. Sloppy in possession.

McGinn (8) - Great goal and typical SJM.

Shinnie (8) - Just my MOTM. Involved in everything. Great pass for penalty.

Holt (7) - Did everything but score. Well played.

Cummings (6) - Got his goal and did well until he became petulant in 2nd half.

Subs:

Keatings (7) - Changed the tempo when he came on. Terrific header.

Fyvie (5) - Not much time.

Graham (5) - See Fyvie.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
similar

I gave Ambrose 8 as he was class
Bartley 7
Shinnie 7
Cummings 5
Holt 6

[Brightside]

Marciano (6)
Gray (6) -
Ambrose (8)
Forster (6)
Stevenson (7)
Boyle (6)
Bartley (5)
McGinn (9)
Shinnie (6)
Holt (9)
Cummings (6)
Subs:

Keatings (7)
Fyvie (3)
Graham (4)

[BoomtownHibees]

Marciano (6)
Gray (6) -
Ambrose (8)
Forster (6)
Stevenson (7)
Boyle (6)
Bartley (5)
McGinn (9)
Shinnie (6)
Holt (9)
Cummings (6)
Subs:

Keatings (7)
Fyvie (3)
Graham (4)

Bartley (5) LOL

[Brightside]

Bartley (5) LOL

I thought he was very poor again....he is far to slow when changing direction and this leads to loads of gaps in his area and Ayr played through him plenty of times today...he also should have pressed out quicker at their goal.

[BoomtownHibees]

I thought he was very poor again....he is far to slow when changing direction and this leads to loads of gaps in his area and Ayr played through him plenty of times today...he also should have pressed out quicker at their goal.

I don't think much, if anything, got through him today

[hibbysam]

I thought he was very poor again....he is far to slow when changing direction and this leads to loads of gaps in his area and Ayr played through him plenty of times today...he also should have pressed out quicker at their goal.

That is highly amusing.

[supermcginn]

Bartley 8 for me, brilliant at his role

[tanfield]

Bartley 8 for me, brilliant at his role

This. Thought he was immense! No real failures today

[overdrive]

Marciano - 6

Gray - 6
Ambrose - 7
Forster - 6
Stevenson - 7

Boyle - 7
McGinn - 8
Bartley - 7
Shinnie - 8

Cummings - 7
Holt - 9

Keatings - 6
Fyvie - 3
Graham - 4

[Drumlanrig]

Marciano (6)
Gray (6) -
Ambrose (8)
Forster (6)
Stevenson (7)
Boyle (6)
Bartley (5)
McGinn (9)
Shinnie (6)
Holt (9)
Cummings (6)
Subs:

Keatings (7)
Fyvie (3)
Graham (4)
Bartley (5) Oh dear?

and Shinnie much better than (6) ,watch the game again!!

[21.05.2016]

Marciano 8 - Nothing to do, came out and collected well when required. Not to blame for the goal, was an excellent strike into the top corner

Gray 7 - Got forward and didn't do anything wrong really

Ambrose 7 - Wee bit shaky to start with but was solid

Forster 6 - Did well. First half a bit dodgy but second half he was solid enough.

Stevenson 8 - Bust a gut as per usual

Boyle 7 - Good running for the penalty

Bartley 6 - caught in possession a lot but not a terrible game tbf

McGinn 8 - A toss up between him and Holt for MOTM. Great strike for the 1st goal

Shinnie 8 - Good game. Often critical of him but thought he did really well

Holt 8 - One of his best games for us.

Cummings 6 - Buzzed about and took a good penalty but didn't contribute a great deal else

Subs:

Keatings (7) - Very good when he came on and was unlucky not to get a 2nd. A player i'd love to see more of

Graham and Fyvie weren't on long enough to really judge

[SChibs]

Marciano - 6

Gray - 6
Ambrose - 7
Forster - 6
Stevenson - 7

Boyle - 7
McGinn - 8
Bartley - 7
Shinnie - 8

Cummings - 7
Holt - 9

Keatings - 6
Fyvie - 3
Graham - 4

What makes you think Graham was better than fyivie, just wondering

[Broken Gnome]

What makes you think Graham was better than fyivie, just wondering

Graham was involved in two neat bits of link play that were far better than he's usually capable of. Nothing too special but was quite prominent as opposed to the normal effort.

[skyhibs]

Marciano - 6

Gray - 6
Ambrose - 8
Forster - 6
Stevenson - 7

Boyle - 6
McGinn - 8
Bartley - 7
Shinnie - 7

Cummings - 7
Holt - 6

Keatings - 6
Fyvie - 3
Graham - 4

[Hiber-nation]

Didn't think we were great today and no real standout performances. 7 out of 10 tops for a few of them, job done.

[overdrive]

Graham was involved in two neat bits of link play that were far better than he's usually capable of. Nothing too special but was quite prominent as opposed to the normal effort.

Correct, and Fyvie's first contribution was passing the ball out of play.

[kaimendhibs]

Bartley an 8 for me. Lost count of the number of times he won the ball.

Sent from my SM-G935F using Tapatalk