Goncalves

[Johnny_Leith]

Looked a shocking tackle of sir David gray in the last minute down at the hearts end, can't believe he got away with just a yellow -retrospective red card??

[Jones28]

I thought it was a red the moment I saw it, nothing has changed my mind.

[greenginger]

Looked a shocking tackle of sir David gray in the last minute down at the hearts end, can't believe he got away with just a yellow -retrospective red card??


Don't think they can upgrade a card.

The two Motherwell players who got red cards recently must be fuming, especially Scott McDonald.

[HFCdeb]

Can't believe he wasn't sent off. Shocker of a challenge.

[hibee_girl]

Because he was booked at the time nothing else can be done

[Captain Trips]

Just frustrated that he was owned for most of the game and was actually playing against defenders this week.

[Geo_1875]

I thought it was a red the moment I saw it, nothing has changed my mind.

I agree. Couldn't believe Collum only pulled out the yellow.

Also took him 90+ minutes to book one them despite them having a worse foul count than Hibs.

[Biggie]

stonewall red....standard against them

[JimBHibees]

Looked a shocking tackle of sir David gray in the last minute down at the hearts end, can't believe he got away with just a yellow -retrospective red card??

Definite red they had a review of on SSN and the ref said stick on. Don't think it could be retrospective red.

[JackLadd]

Clearly frustrated by his lack of return and just decided to assault a Hibs player. Thug.

[WeeRussell]

Missed it live but could easily have been red having seen the replay. Strange as I thought he'd been alright up until then, generally just laughing and joking with Hibs players after strong challenges etc.

I think Fyvie agreed with us though as he soon got him told :greengrin

[Jim44]

I was quite impressed by him against Sevco but the opposite against us. Make your own conclusion.

[Booked4Being-Ugly]

It should have been a straight red but the ref bottled it.

When you look at the challenges Bartley's been sent off for this season you've got to wonder sometimes. If that was Bartley that made that challenge on a Hearts player he would have walked.

[macca70]

Initially thought it was a shocker then you see the replay and its worse, defo should have been a red which I'm assuming would have suspended him for the replay.

He is clearly annoyed at not getting a foul himself and makes no attempt at the ball.

The Jambos have the cheek to complain about the ref!!

[macca70]

Sir David's tackle on him in the diagonally opposit corner was a beauty, how the ref decided to give us a goal kick was bizarre but not complaining.

[StPauli]

Thought it was bad at the game and looked worse on the telly, should have been a red for me straight through the back of Sir David.

[Aldo]

He also tried to get SJM booked after a superb chase and well timed tackle. Threw himself down like he had been shot!

From the second I saw it it was a straight red and for me the only thing Gollum got wrong the whole game for me!!


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[O'Rourke3]

Sir David's tackle on him in the diagonally opposit corner was a beauty, how the ref decided to give us a goal kick was bizarre but not complaining.

Came of Goncalves last.....

[The_Sauz]

That's the third/forth time the he has failed to send off a Hearts player against us, the other have been issued a 2 game ban after the game :grr:
We all accuse Craig Thompson of being bad, but Willie Collum is the worst Ref in Scotland :agree:























But at least he is consistently bad :greengrin

[Bostonhibby]

It was a red. Another wee freebie for them so hopefully we get something similar when McGregor or Marvin don't stand back and admire this sly yam style coward and welcome him to a proper game on a proper pitch.

[NadeAteMyLunch!]

Shocker of a challenge and as clear a red as you'll see, even from the Roseburn stand after 6 pints. How Collum can't spot that from yards away is unbelievable. Should be suspended for the replay [emoji849]

[Jack Hackett]

Shocker of a challenge and as clear a red as you'll see, even from the Roseburn stand after 6 pints. How Collum can't spot that from yards away is unbelievable. Should be suspended for the replay [emoji849]

Nah! Quite happy for him to play and waste a spot they could have filled with a player :greengrin

[calumhibee1]

Shocker of a challenge and as clear a red as you'll see, even from the Roseburn stand after 6 pints. How Collum can't spot that from yards away is unbelievable. Should be suspended for the replay [emoji849]

Exactly. Every aspect of the challenge, from it being from behind, dangerous, a sort of scissoring motion, out of control, retaliation to getting absolutely nowhere against the Hibs back four etc was a sending off. Ridiculous decision not to give him a red.

[WeeRussell]

He also tried to get SJM booked after a superb chase and well timed tackle. Threw himself down like he had been shot!

From the second I saw it it was a straight red and for me the only thing Gollum got wrong the whole game for me!!


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

Yeah hadn't thought about it but in fairness he didn't have too bad a game! Annoyed me that we didn't get to take the throw-in after finally getting the ball back from the hearts crowd, when he blew the final whistle but other than that and the topic of this thread, wasnae bad :agree:

[Billy Whizz]

Thought he should have been booked earlier for a challenge

[Speedway]

Daz's assault on Cowie wasn't great either.

Ref had an ok game.

[at last 61]

Will have to noise him up next Wednesday good player but bad temperament so just niggle him all game and watch him lose it.

[Billy Whizz]

Daz's assault on Cowie wasn't great either.

Ref had an ok game.

That was a professional foul, conclaves challenge was cynical and was from behind

[Baader]

Red card, no question about it. Went right through the back of Gray when there was no way he could have actually gotten the ball. Wish we'd made more of it - outrage, bit of pushing and players surrounding the ref..

[greenginger]

Sure looks like the new Gorgie player intake are not too keen on robust challenges.

They play Inverness Caley on Saturday , and judging by the highlights of their tie with Celtic , they know how to put in a sore one.

Hope they get another lesson before the replay, just to soften them up a bit. :greengrin

[Danderhall Hibs]

Daz's assault on Cowie wasn't great either.

Ref had an ok game.

I thought it was brilliant.

[tamig]

Came of Goncalves last.....

That's the way I saw it at the game. Half expected Collum to give a corner but he called it right.

[Jonnyboy]

Any links to seeing that tackle. Happened at the oppopsite end from the Hibs fans so I couldn't see it properly. Looked a bad one even from that distance

[tamig]

Any links to seeing that tackle. Happened at the oppopsite end from the Hibs fans so I couldn't see it properly. Looked a bad one even from that distance

Do we know if Sir David is ok? He looked like he'd been through a couple of wars at the end.

[Billy Whizz]

Any links to seeing that tackle. Happened at the oppopsite end from the Hibs fans so I couldn't see it properly. Looked a bad one even from that distance

It was only a body contact challenge Jonnyboy, no arms or legs involved. One of their players, maybe Concalves, did a similar challenge on Lewis in the 2nd half, and didn't get booked for it

[Jonnyboy]

It was only a body contact challenge Jonnyboy, no arms or legs involved. One of their players, maybe Concalves, did a similar challenge on Lewis in the 2nd half, and didn't get booked for it

Was talking about Goncalves on Gray, Billy

[Billy Whizz]

Was talking about Goncalves on Gray, Billy

Was a red all day, worse than Scott McDonalds sending off 2 weeks ago

[Glory Lurker]

Do we know if Sir David is ok? He looked like he'd been through a couple of wars at the end.

SDG eats wars as a starter before breakfast.

[matty_f]

I thought it was brilliant.

Probably the best moment of the match other than Gray putting a very fair but very robust challenge on Goncalves in the first half.

[WeeRussell]

That was a professional foul, conclaves challenge was cynical and was from behind

MacGregor's foul was more "cynical" than the Hearts boy's. The latter was needless and dangerous.

But I think you meant the same thing :aok:

[BullsCloseHibs]

He showed his true St Midden class on Sunday.
Christ, St Midden and a Cypriot team.....what a cv!

[FC Leige]

He is a skillful player but for a big laddy doesn't seem to like the rough stuff. With Daz and Fontaine/Hanlon getting right in his face i doubt he will trouble us to much. Im more concerned about Walker