Colum

[Dashing Bob S]

Needs to get over May 21st.

[WeeRussell]

So do I

[Scottie]

He was at least ***** tonight for both teams. How many yellow's were dished out ?

And he's one of the best ref's we are meant to have :rolleyes:

[danhibees1875]

What did he do wrong? Thought he had a reasonable game - I don't remember ever being that annoyed at a decision other than a freekick he gave against Gray towards the end.

[GreenCastle]

He was at least ***** tonight for both teams. How many yellow's were dished out ?

And he's one of the best ref's we are meant to have :rolleyes:

This - bad for both.

[Hibee87]

Thought he done fine other than Bartley booking. There was 2 chalanges in first I screemed for a red but on seeing the replays the yellows dished were the correct decision

[Dom'sFirstTouch]

Seen far worse. He had to spend most of his time correcting the West stand linesman.

[Salt N Sauzee]

I still don't know why he booked Bartley?

[Paisley Hibby]

What did he do wrong? Thought he had a reasonable game - I don't remember ever being that annoyed at a decision other than a freekick he gave against Gray towards the end.

Eh?????? Are you serious? What about booking Bartley for a nothing tackle? And given the total number of cards he dished out you'd think that was a bloodbath tonight. It was no such thing. Total walloper. And as for the linesman on the west stand side - jeez!!! Mind you, his Mum had ironed his shorts and shirt very nicely.

[H113EE5]

What did he do wrong? Thought he had a reasonable game - I don't remember ever being that annoyed at a decision other than a freekick he gave against Gray towards the end.

:agree: I thought he did ok. Let play go and brought back players for bookings when play stopped.

[danhibees1875]

Eh?????? Are you serious? What about booking Bartley for a nothing tackle? And given the total number of cards he dished out you'd think that was a bloodbath tonight. It was no such thing. Total walloper. And as for the linesman on the west stand side - jeez!!! Mind you, his Mum had ironed his shorts and shirt very nicely.
Bartley pulled the boy back as they were getting away. He could have not given the yellow or he could have, about 50/50 there tbh. He dished out a lot of bookings because we played some good fast football that united tried to counter with fouls and were rightly booked for doing so.

Sent from my EVA-L09 using Tapatalk

[Topographic Hibby]

Bartley grabbed the guy twice IIRC. Once around the arm and again around his waist. He was getting a bit worked up cause challenges were going in on him unpunished.

Stand back, take a breath....it probably was a yellow (tin hat on...). Overall, ref had a reasonable game (now desperately looking around for a 2nd tin hat.....).

[allezsauzee]

Collum is much better than what we usually get refereeing us in the championship. I thought he did ok

[hibeejeebies]

Eh?????? Are you serious? What about booking Bartley for a nothing tackle? And given the total number of cards he dished out you'd think that was a bloodbath tonight. It was no such thing. Total walloper. And as for the linesman on the west stand side - jeez!!! Mind you, his Mum had ironed his shorts and shirt very nicely.

Big Marv took one for the team and was a justifiable yellow I felt. The frustrating thing was seconds before he let their boy (Durnan?) off without a card, giving him the "don't do that again" finger wag for a far more cynical foul on Martin Boyle. It's this kind of inconsistency that drives football supporters mad.

[McD]

Thought he was poor tonight, booked Bartley and gray for their first fouls, whilst flood and a few other Utd players got away with plenty more. Durnan should have been booked for a worse version of what Bartley did (wasn't his first), but wasn't. A Utd player brought one of ours down on a breakaway, waves play on as Hibs still had the ball but didn't book their player when play stopped.

[McD]

Big Marv took one for the team and was a justifiable yellow I felt. The frustrating thing was seconds before he let their boy (Durnan?) off without a card, giving him the "don't do that again" finger wag for a far more cynical foul on Martin Boyle. It's this kind of inconsistency that drives football supporters mad.


:agree: Can live with the Bartley booking when the same is applied the other way. Durnan wasn't the only one who got away with a telling off for the same thing as Bartley's booking

[Marco G]

Thought he was poor tonight, booked Bartley and gray for their first fouls, whilst flood and a few other Utd players got away with plenty more. Durnan should have been booked for a worse version of what Bartley did (wasn't his first), but wasn't. A Utd player brought one of ours down on a breakaway, waves play on as Hibs still had the ball but didn't book their player when play stopped.
100%. Too happy to warn their players but book ours. Thought Utd were cynical and desperate and could have been down to 9 or 10 men easily.

[Eyrie]

:agree: I thought he did ok. Let play go and brought back players for bookings when play stopped.

I'd agree with this, although the Bartley booking was pedantic at best.

[McD]

100%. Too happy to warn their players but book ours. Thought Utd were cynical and desperate and could have been down to 9 or 10 men easily.


:agree: Said on another thread I don't know how they finished with 11

[hibby6270]

Have seen Collum have worse games than tonight. Whilst some decisions were 'strange', overall he wasn't too bad. Just my opinion.:greengrin

[Weststandwanab]

:agree: Said on another thread I don't know how they finished with 11

They finished with 11 because of the ref's incompetence

[lyonhibs]

What a wee gremlin that gimp is.

[McD]

They finished with 11 because of the ref's incompetence


Says it all mate :aok:

[eastcoasthibby]

I still don't know why he booked Bartley?

Or Gray near the end ..and didn't book Durnan for checking out Boyle as he was going past him into the box ...

[Tom Hart RIP]

Thought Murdoch should have had a straight red for foul on Marvin before half time. Haven't seen replay. He should have had a second yellow for chopping down Dylan in 2nd half. Ray McKinnon subbed him immediately after that.
Also Durnan should have had a yellow for foul on Boyle just after half time then his subsequent yellow would have meant a sending off.

[RoYO!]

He's one of those refs that you can really sense/ feel him starting to lose the plot. It's as if the game runs away from him and he tries to stamp his authority by dishing out yellows. Very surprised to have 11 a side at the end. Think the Utd players went from raging/ bitter to simple acceptance that they were done.

[cleanyman]

I thought Collum had a good game.

[NadeAteMyLunch!]

Bet the clown dishes out yellow cards to all his family members on Christmas morning.

[lucky]

I thought he was inconsistent as usual. But he was better than the East stand assistant who refused to refuse to raise his flag even when the call went out or players were well outside

[AndyB_70]

I find it funny people asking for straight red cards for nothing more than tackles that were only yellow. People have gone soft. He is probably the best ref we have had for a while considering the dross we normally get in this league. I think he could have handled a few things differently but overall I thought he was OK. Let play flow and went back to either talk to players or book them.

[TRC]

Still can't forgive the wee rat for his failure to award a free kick for us against the huns

[Sammy7nil]

I find it funny people asking for straight red cards for nothing more than tackles that were only yellow. People have gone soft. He is probably the best ref we have had for a while considering the dross we normally get in this league. I think he could have handled a few things differently but overall I thought he was OK. Let play flow and went back to either talk to players or book them.

:agree::agree::agree:

[O'Rourke3]

Curates egg. Deliberate push in the back on Marv and Collum saw nothing and they went up the park and had a shot at goal. The first yellow card could easily have been a red. The United player changed his angle to ensure our player got chopped. He gets decisions right but gets a lot wrong too. Had he booked the defender for the first body check the second one where there was nothing between Squirrel and the goalie wouldn't have happened. He must have infra red vision as there were free kicks given for something no one in the ground could see and often not when clear fouls were taking place.

It might have been one of his better games but he's no great shakes.

[HibernianJK]

Or Gray near the end ..and didn't book Durnan for checking out Boyle as he was going past him into the box ...

Gray's challenge was right in front of me was definitely a booking and he didn't complain.

[Islington Hibs]

I thought Collum had a good game.


agree. One or two strange decisions but he allowed sensible play-on's a couple of times. No complaints.

[NORTHERNHIBBY]

Inconsistentencies happen now and again. I thought he had a decent enough game. Booking Bartley seems to be a requirement though.