Ox for Logan?? Anybody..........

[RG04]

Anybody think Stubbs will go back to the guy thats been his number 1 for pretty much 2 seasons??? :flag:

[cleanyman]

Time for The Ox.

[easty]

Cannae see him bringing Oxley back in tomorrow, but if the defence does their job then it'll hopefully not matter who is in goals.

[pacoluna]

I think i would would go for the hampden hero in the semis who got us here :wink:

[Since90+2]

Cannae see him bringing Oxley back in tomorrow, but if the defence does their job then it'll hopefully not matter who is in goals.

It's Rangers we are playing so they will create chances, both our defence and goalkeeper are going to need to play well to win. The keeper decision could be vital.

[hibs0666]

In the boss I trust.

[Ozyhibby]

In the boss I trust.

Really? With picking a goalie? [emoji23]

[alihibs1]

big conrad for me! Defence looks much more assured with logan in goals! GGTTH!:gwa:

[easty]

It's Rangers we are playing so they will create chances, both our defence and goalkeeper are going to need to play well to win. The keeper decision could be vital.

Not for me. I don't think there's much between Oxley and Logan.

[Waxy]

Logan

[cabbageandribs1875]

i've had a feeling the last few weeks that it will be oxley in goals, and if he's not then it will mean he's on his way out(imo)

[erin go bragh]

Big Conrad the Hampden hero again .🏆
He's not let a goal in open play there for 120 mins .

#WearGreen🇳🇬🇳🇬🇳🇬🇳🇬🇳🇬🇳🇬🇳🇬🇳🇬🇳🇬

GGTTH

[erin go bragh]

Not for me. I don't think there's much between Oxley and Logan.

There is a good seven years and four stone between them :)
Logan is more vocal and has much more experience but the Ox is more agile but imo has lost a bit confidence .

GGTTH

[SJM]

i've had a feeling the last few weeks that it will be oxley in goals, and if he's not then it will mean he's on his way out(imo)


Well there's some good news :aok: would he get a better contract anywhere else though? :confused:

Logan every day of the week for me.

[marinello59]

Anybody think Stubbs will go back to the guy thats been his number 1 for pretty much 2 seasons??? :flag:

I wouldn't have dropped him in the first place. Logan will start though.

[SunshineOnLeith]

Would prefer Oxley but expect Logan.

[Diclonius]

Logan will start. Would make no sense randomly reinstating Oxley for our last game of the season.

[cabbageandribs1875]

Well there's some good news :aok: would he get a better contract anywhere else though? :confused:

Logan every day of the week for me.


i'd love to know out of curiosity which keeper our defence have more confidence in, to be fair we've witnessed a few scary moments with conrad in just 4-5 games since the heroics at the SF, and a few scary moments from oxley in 30+ games, this will be a huge call by stubbs in who gets the gloves, will he stay loyal to our long-term keeper...or a keeper that was specifically just brought in for the one game(the SF)

[SpaceBob]

Would prefer Oxley but expect Logan.

This is how I feel about it s well. I actually think Oxley is the better keeper just lacking a little confidence.

[Unseen work]

i'd love to know out of curiosity which keeper our defence have more confidence in, to be fair we've witnessed a few scary moments with conrad in just 4-5 games since the heroics at the SF, and a few scary moments from oxley in 30+ games

I said the same, logan has had some very near miss mistakes and a couple of mistakes that have resulted in goals in his 5 or so appearances.

He also doesn't distribute the ball as fast or as well as oxley imo, seems to wait till everyone is in there position the punt it. Oxley gets it and releases it sharp if it's on

[Unseen work]

Also a bit concerning otso doesn't seem to be though of as capable yet

[nellio]

Logan for me. Commands his box so much better. Comes out for things as well.

Perhaps not as good a shot stopper but overall I prefer Logan.

[The Kaiser]

Logan for his experience.

Oxley back as number 1 next season having been kept out the firing line and getting a good pre season under his belt.

[cabbageandribs1875]

I said the same, logan has had some very near miss mistakes and a couple of mistakes that have resulted in goals in his 5 or so appearances.

He also doesn't distribute the ball as fast or as well as oxley imo, seems to wait till everyone is in there position the punt it. Oxley gets it and releases it sharp if it's on



i think it's safe to say stubbs will get stick IF whichever keeper he chooses makes a costly mistake

[Ronniekirk]

Big Conrad the Hampden hero again .[emoji471]
He's not let a goal in open play there for 120 mins .

#WearGreen[emoji1184][emoji1184][emoji1184][emoji1184][emoji1184][emoji1184][emoji1184][emoji1184][emoji1184]

GGTTH

Contad to emulate semi final display and be a Hampden Cult Hero http://uploads.tapatalk-cdn.com/20160520/08fb5f74f0b4c785a643100dd6b77c59.jpg

[Unseen work]

i think it's safe to say stubbs will get stick IF whichever keeper he chooses makes a costly mistake

100%

And that goes for every position on the pitch.

You can see it already if Cummings starts and doesn't score, or if keatings starts and doesn't score.

[BroxburnHibee]

Whoever is in goal needs our support

[Big_Franck]

Logan for me. He's not perfect but from what I've seen he's the best keeper we have. He will also be going back to Hampden full of confidence and belief. I don't think you'd be able to say the same about Oxley if he were to play tomorrow.

[Waxy]

i think it's safe to say stubbs will get stick IF whichever keeper he chooses makes a costly mistake

Stubbs will only get stick from the people who think he should be able to predict the future.

[GlesgaeHibby]

Logan for me. He's had a few shaky moments, but unlike Oxley he has managed to be man of the match for a heroic performance (that got us to the final!) and has the capability of doing so again. It may go to penalties, and I'd feel far more confident with Logan as he managed to rattle the cages of some of the Dundee Utd players.

[07BigD]

Stubbs will only get stick from the people who think he should be able to predict the future.
And the truth shall set you free

Sent from my D6503 using Tapatalk

[Big_Franck]

100%

And that goes for every position on the pitch.

You can see it already if Cummings starts and doesn't score, or if keatings starts and doesn't score.

Isn't that the case with fans and fans' message boards everywhere though? Of course we debate whether or not the team line up and use of substitutions was right, it's a huge part of the debate and discussion on football forums. Some posters go too far though, there has been occasional personal abuse of Stubbs on here which is out of order.

[Pretty Boy]

Not for me. I don't think there's much between Oxley and Logan.

Agreed.

A position that will be looked at in the summer imo.

[Paisley Hibby]

Glad I don't have to choose between them. But if Stubbs opts for Oxley and we go to penalties, I'd want Logan on instead...

[Ozyhibby]

Agreed.

A position that will be looked at in the summer imo.

Has to be. It's been a real weakness this season and one that could have been avoided.

[Alfred E Newman]

He is not a great keeper but it's Oxley for me. Logan was not convincing against Falkirk.

[Pete]

No. It has to be Logan.

No chopping and changing.

[stantonhibby]

I think Oxley is better but think Logan will play.

[Dunedin Hibs]

Whoever is in goal needs our support

Agree completely. Stubbsy will choose the team he has confidence in to win. No second chances here. Back whatever team we field, we win together,we lose together. Our manager will choose, as that is his job and I have confidence he knows what he is doing. He has some tough key decisions. Whoever plays in green and white should have our 100% backing...no regrets at the end of the day. Cloud 9, or Coud -9, here we come....get into them Hibs and lets end the season with the ultimate bang!

[basehibby]

They both have their strengths and weaknesses - Logan judges his angles superbly - Whereas the Ox is more agile and distributes the ball very well

[we are hibs]

Logan is a far better keeper than Oxley. Id be shocked to see Oxley play another meaningful game for us. Hopefully we replace him with a goalkeeper who isn't scared at coming off his line.

[Franck Stanton]

Has to be Logan imo. Better keeper by far. Not perfect by any stretch of the imagination, but, the best we have at the moment. Commands his area much better than Oxley, isn't as prone to silly errors which result in losing a goal. Distributes the ball quicker and better than Oxley. Added bonus, IF, and it is a B I G IF, game goes to penalties, ask yourself this " Who would I want between the sticks for a penalty shoot-out ? " Only one answer folks, Conrad got us there - deserves to play in final.

Any way, no matter who plays - GOOD LUCK GUYS - Give it your all, that's all anyone can ask of you. Win your personal battles and bring the bloody thing back to Easter Road. Fed up of the monkey on our backs. JUST DO IT.

[eastterrace]

Has to be Logan imo. Better keeper by far. Not perfect by any stretch of the imagination, but, the best we have at the moment. Commands his area much better than Oxley, isn't as prone to silly errors which result in losing a goal. Distributes the ball quicker and better than Oxley. Added bonus, IF, and it is a B I G IF, game goes to penalties, ask yourself this " Who would I want between the sticks for a penalty shoot-out ? " Only one answer folks, Conrad got us there - deserves to play in final. Any way, no matter who plays - GOOD LUCK GUYS - Give it your all, that's all anyone can ask of you. Win your personal battles and bring the bloody thing back to Easter Road. Fed up of the monkey on our backs. JUST DO IT. did he not lose a silly goal against Falkirk at Easter rd sure the ball went under his body

[SquashedFrogg]

Glad I don't have to choose between them. But if Stubbs opts for Oxley and we go to penalties, I'd want Logan on instead...

Me and the boy just cleared the dining room table and set out the ornaments in out formation. Picked the team also. Had to reign him in a bit due to FIFA mentality!

Actually quite a brain pickler.

3-5-1-1

Gut feeling is Ox in goals. Midfield 3 is the toughie! Went for McGinn, Marv and Fyvie as 3 CM's

We went for Stoke's up front with Hendo in behind.

Took the opportunity to demonstrate (with the wooden giraffe, glass chicken etc) how big Franck and the boys used to play :agree:

[The Spaceman]

Either goalkeeper will have my backing :hibees

[erskine-hibby]

I'm happy for either, just hope the defence do their job also.

[Waxy]

If Logan plays and makes a bad mistake i can forgive him. Without him we wouldn't have got here.If Oxley plays and makes a bad mistake, i'd go a bit radge.Happy to give Oxley a clean slate for next season but for me it just must be Logan.

[Captain Trips]

For me Rangers are dangerous from freekicks as we have seen. That has to be a factor in who is in.

[Captain Trips]

I am more worried about us missing chances costing us up the other end.

[Edson Arantes]

Has to be the Ox.

[jgl07]

Just after the semi-final win over Falkirk I entered the draw for the Edinburgh Monarchs' Speedway Racenight.

I called my horse Conrad Logan.

Tonight I found out that I had won the first prize!

A portent for Saturday?

[FromTheCapital]

Oxley for me.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk