PDA

View Full Version : Match ratings



Hibstrooper
12-04-2015, 07:37 PM
Oxley 7 - great save from Walker(?) not much else to do

Fontaine 8 - easy day at the office
Hanlon 8 - commanding performance
Forster 8 - great performance considering he hasn't played a lot

Stevenson 7 - usual energy & commitment
Fyvie 8 - was everywhere
Allan 7 - took the pee at times
McGeouch 8 - back to his best, great runner with the ball
Boyle 7 - pegged back their full back

Cummings 7 - goals
El Alagui 9 - won EVERYTHING in the air, great to have you back big man!

Malonga 2 - off form
Djedje 6 - great energy and assist

Today was the opposite of so many derbies at Tynecastle and it was great to see us get that breakaway second at the end.

SaulGoodman
12-04-2015, 07:39 PM
10 everyone. Even Malonga for turning up.

The Harp Awakes
12-04-2015, 07:43 PM
Oxley 7 - great save from Walker(?) not much else to do

Fontaine 8 - easy day at the office
Hanlon 8 - commanding performance
Forster 8 - great performance considering he hasn't played a lot

Stevenson 7 - usual energy & commitment
Fyvie 8 - was everywhere
Allan 7 - took the pee at times
McGeouch 8 - back to his best, great runner with the ball
Boyle 7 - pegged back their full back

Cummings 7 - goals
El Alagui 9 - won EVERYTHING in the air, great to have you back big man!

Malonga 2 - off form
Djedje 6 - great energy and assist

Today was the opposite of so many derbies at Tynecastle and it was great to see us get that breakaway second at the end.

Pretty much agree with that. Maybe would have given Boyle an 8 as thought he was exceptional in the first half especially. Best game in a Hibs shirt.

Ryan91
12-04-2015, 08:06 PM
Oxley 7 - great save from Walker(?) not much else to do

Fontaine 8 - easy day at the office
Hanlon 8 - commanding performance
Forster 8 - great performance considering he hasn't played a lot

Stevenson 7 - usual energy & commitment
Fyvie 8 - was everywhere
Allan 7 - took the pee at times
McGeouch 8 - back to his best, great runner with the ball
Boyle 7 - pegged back their full back

Cummings 7 - goals
El Alagui 9 - won EVERYTHING in the air, great to have you back big man!

Malonga 2 - off form
Djedje 6 - great energy and assist

Today was the opposite of so many derbies at Tynecastle and it was great to see us get that breakaway second at the end.

I'd give Fyvie, Allan and McGeouch all 9s IMO, they ran the show today, Boyle probably deserves an 8 for the number of times he made runs and got behind them, probably would have got at least an assist if Malonga hadn't been greedy. The rest I agree with.

Pretty Boy
12-04-2015, 08:09 PM
Oxley 8

Hanlon 9
Fontaine 9
Forster 9

Stevenson 7
Fyvie 8
Allan 7
McGeough 7
Boyle 7.5

Cummings 8
El Alagui 9

gegs70
12-04-2015, 08:14 PM
I'd give Fyvie, Allan and McGeouch all 9s IMO, they ran the show today, Boyle probably deserves an 8 for the number of times he made runs and got behind them, probably would have got at least an assist if Malonga hadn't been greedy. The rest I agree with.

Fyvie was excellent my man of the match.

hibsbollah
12-04-2015, 08:18 PM
Oxley 7

Hanlon 8
Forster 10 Did everything, EVERYTHING, right. Looked like Sauzee.
Fontaine 9

Stevenson 6 wobbly first 45, improved second half
Fyvie 8
Allan 8 Sees twice as much of the ball as the rest of the midfield.
McGeogh 8
Boyle 8

Cummings 7
El Alagui 9 Classy 89 mins, great assist for Cummings, but THAT finish was the icing on the cake.

Subs
Malonga- terrible decision on the breakaway. Needs something to go his way pronto.
Djedje- looked good.

muzzando
12-04-2015, 08:49 PM
Oxley 7

Hanlon 8
Forster 10 Did everything, EVERYTHING, right. Looked like Sauzee.
Fontaine 9

Stevenson 6 wobbly first 45, improved second half
Fyvie 8
Allan 8 Sees twice as much of the ball as the rest of the midfield.
McGeogh 8
Boyle 8

Cummings 7
El Alagui 9 Classy 89 mins, great assist for Cummings, but THAT finish was the icing on the cake.

Subs
Malonga- terrible decision on the breakaway. Needs something to go his way pronto.
Djedje- looked good.

This, except a 9 for Fyvie and 8 for Cummings

WeeRussell
13-04-2015, 11:47 AM
Oxley 7

Hanlon 8
Forster 10 Did everything, EVERYTHING, right. Looked like Sauzee.
Fontaine 9

Stevenson 6 wobbly first 45, improved second half
Fyvie 8
Allan 8 Sees twice as much of the ball as the rest of the midfield.
McGeogh 8
Boyle 8

Cummings 7
El Alagui 9 Classy 89 mins, great assist for Cummings, but THAT finish was the icing on the cake.

Subs
Malonga- terrible decision on the breakaway. Needs something to go his way pronto.
Djedje- looked good.

Agree in the main with this. I really like Stevenson and think he has been quality this season but a lot of stray passes yesterday and one of his poorer games (by recent high standards) - almost looked nervous, which is strange! Still good enough though.

Defence - Brilliant. I haven't been totally convinced over the hype for Forster in the past - but EXCELLENT today.. his block late in the second half sums his performance up! Hanlon confident on the ball and Fonts as solid as ever.

Three in CM all got strong pass marks, ran the show!

I am in love with Farid El Alagui.

:giruy2:

Joe's ice cream
13-04-2015, 12:06 PM
Fully agree ref Stevenson - 1st half in particular he looked rushed in everything he was doing - was discussing with others during that period that he just needed to calm and slow it down a bit.
He has made me eat my words em this season thou and have nothing but praise for his commitment and ability which he has shown on a consistent basis.
That said my man crush is still very much on Fontaine 😳

cameronw-hfc
13-04-2015, 12:15 PM
Oxley 8, 2 great saves from Walker and last minute header back to him from Hanlon

Hanlon 9- few good battles with Sow and Zeefuik, won them all
Forster 10- motm, great center back but also will do anything to prevent a goal
Fontaine 8- not really the busiest of the 3 but still solid

Stevenson 6- good at the back but poor attacking
Fyvie 8- ran around a lot and neat player
Allan 9- toyed with the, showed them no respect and was terrific to watch.
McGeogh 7- good player, good energy and pace but greedy at times, takes too many touches
Boyle 9- so fast and knows how to use it, few nice touches and passes today

Cummings 8- good game, always a threat
El Alagui 9- great to have him back, brilliant in the air but also runs around a lot with some nice touches also, that finish was outstanding.

Subs
Malonga- whats wrong with him?
Djedje- tried to square it 3 times now whilst on goal, glad he got this one right, was a perfect pass.

patlowe
13-04-2015, 12:19 PM
Oxley 8, 2 great saves from Walker and last minute header back to him from Hanlon

Hanlon 9- few good battles with Sow and Zeefuik, won them all
Forster 1- motm, great center back but also will do anything to prevent a goal
Fontaine 8- not really the busiest of the 3 but still solid

Stevenson 6- good at the back but poor attacking
Fyvie 8- ran around a lot and neat player
Allan 9- toyed with the, showed them no respect and was terrific to watch.
McGeogh 7- good player, good energy and pace but greedy at times, takes too many touches
Boyle 9- so fast and knows how to use it, few nice touches and passes today

Cummings 8- good game, always a threat
El Alagui 9- great to have him back, brilliant in the air but also runs around a lot with some nice touches also, that finish was outstanding.

Subs
Malonga- whats wrong with him?
Djedje- tried to square it 3 times now whilst on goal, glad he got this one right, was a perfect pass.

Bit harsh :wink:

cameronw-hfc
13-04-2015, 01:00 PM
Bit harsh :wink:

All changed :wink:

Elephant Stone
13-04-2015, 01:50 PM
Oxley 7: Made a decent save but had a really dodgy punch that he was lucky to retrieve.

Fontaine 9
Forster 10
Hanlon 9

Stevenson 5: Can't fault his effort or work rate but I thought he had a dreadful game. Having a great season though.
Allan 7
McGeogh 8
Boyle 7

Cummings 8
Farid 9. Offers the team so much. Wonderful player.

ancient hibee
13-04-2015, 05:55 PM
Think Stevenson couldn't understand the Hearts set up at right back.He had so much room that his crossing suffered.Entitled to a poor game in a very good season.

Baldy Foghorn
13-04-2015, 05:57 PM
Oxley 7: Made a decent save but had a really dodgy punch that he was lucky to retrieve.

Fontaine 9
Forster 10
Hanlon 9

Stevenson 5: Can't fault his effort or work rate but I thought he had a dreadful game. Having a great season though.
Allan 7
McGeogh 8
Boyle 7

Cummings 8
Farid 9. Offers the team so much. Wonderful player.

Good win, especially with only 10 men:greengrin

Hermit Crab
13-04-2015, 06:14 PM
Good win, especially with only 10 men:greengrin


:tee hee:

Elephant Stone
13-04-2015, 06:56 PM
Good win, especially with only 10 men:greengrin

Oops:greengrin I actually thought Fyvie was brilliant. 9 for Fyvie.

NAE NOOKIE
13-04-2015, 10:46 PM
Oxley ... 7 ... some decent saves, but not a lot to do, the back 4 kept the Yams at bay

Stevenson .... 7 ... his passing and crossing were poor, but just stuck at it
Forster ....... 9 .... for a guy who has barely kicked a ball all season he was immense
Hanlon ........ 8 ... solid as a rock
Fontaine ......8 .... strolled it and missed scoring a great goal by inches

Allan .... 8 .... seen him have more impact, but he was very good for all that
Fyvie .... 9 ..... thought he was excellent, ran the show at times
McGeough ... 8 ... ran and ran, did everything right
Boyle ... 8 .... kept his discipline very well and did his job, his best game for us.

Cummings ... 8 ... great poachers goal and worked hard, faded badly in the 2nd half, seems to lack the fitness to last 90 mins?
El Alagui .... 10 .... What can you say, won header after header, his knock down for Cummings was sublime, good with the ball at his feet, brave and a great finish ... the best overall display from a Hibs striker since Griffiths.

Malonga .... 4 ... It wasn't so much that he didn't play Boyle in, it was the shocking attempt at a shot. He did a couple of decent things after that to be fair ... like others I wonder how much of his injury was in his head. This guy has played at a level way above the Scottish championship and once changed hands for over a million Euros ... why is he so poor?
Dje Dje ... 6 ... did well to lay on Farids goal and worked hard.