Players who have left

[18/03/07]

Thomson/Mckpake Dundee, Cairney Killie,Baptie ICT all players Butcher would not quote or play for some reason, but are going to be playing Spl. Maybury an Tommy T at Falkirk could come back an bite us. The only other player i know who is elsewhere is Gold who i think has signed for Berwick who will prob play against us on Saturday. Any others?

[Michael]

McGivern at the titans of Stoke-on-Trent...Port Vale.

[Mr White]

James collins to shrewsbury

[oconnors_strip]

Brad Donaldson has signed for livi

[craigmounthibby]

Bradley Donaldson to Livingston. A promising right back......apparently we need one of them.....:rolleyes:

[Sir David Gray]

Players who have left since last season;

Ben Williams - unattached
Ryan McGivern - Port Vale (English League One)
James McPake - Dundee (Scottish Premiership)
Rowan Vine - unattached
Paul Cairney - Kilmarnock (Scottish Premiership)
James Collins - Shrewsbury (English League Two)
Daniel Boateng - unattached
Alan Maybury - Falkirk (Scottish Championship)
Tom Taiwo - Falkirk (Scottish Championship)
Sean Murdoch - unattached
Fraser Mullen - East Fife (Scottish League One)
Duncan Watmore - Sunderland (English Premiership)
Abdellah Zoubir - FC Istres (French League Two)
Danny Haynes - Notts County (English League One)
Kevin Thomson - Dundee (Scottish Premiership)

[hfc rd]

Players who have left since last season;

Ben Williams - unattached
Ryan McGivern - Port Vale (English League One)
James McPake - Dundee (Scottish Premiership)
Rowan Vine - unattached
Paul Cairney - Kilmarnock (Scottish Premiership)
James Collins - Shrewsbury (English League Two)
Daniel Boateng - unattached
Alan Maybury - Falkirk (Scottish Championship)
Tom Taiwo - Falkirk (Scottish Championship)
Sean Murdoch - unattached
Fraser Mullen - East Fife (Scottish League One)
Duncan Watmore - Sunderland (English Premiership)
Abdellah Zoubir - FC Istres (French League Two)
Danny Haynes - Notts County (English League One)
Kevin Thomson - Dundee (Scottish Premiership)



Pretty positively sure that both Rowan Vine and Fraser Mullen left the club in January after being released by TB. Vine went to Morton and Mullen played against us for Raith in the SC.

[basehibby]

Players who have left since last season;

Ben Williams - unattached
Ryan McGivern - Port Vale (English League One)
James McPake - Dundee (Scottish Premiership)
Rowan Vine - unattached
Paul Cairney - Kilmarnock (Scottish Premiership)
James Collins - Shrewsbury (English League Two)
Daniel Boateng - unattached
Alan Maybury - Falkirk (Scottish Championship)
Tom Taiwo - Falkirk (Scottish Championship)
Sean Murdoch - unattached
Fraser Mullen - East Fife (Scottish League One)
Duncan Watmore - Sunderland (English Premiership)
Abdellah Zoubir - FC Istres (French League Two)
Danny Haynes - Notts County (English League One)
Kevin Thomson - Dundee (Scottish Premiership)

Some decent players in there and some very average. But next to nothing you'd call real star quality, which is why we're now playing second level football this season. Stubbs has a heap of work to do but at least he should have a few bob to spare with all that lot gone - he'd better spend it wisely!

[Sir David Gray]

Pretty positively sure that both Rowan Vine and Fraser Mullen left the club in January after being released by TB. Vine went to Morton and Mullen played against us for Raith in the SC.

That's all very true but my list is of players who were registered to us last season and an indication of where they are right now.

Vine has subsequently been released by Morton and Mullen left Raith Rovers at the end of the season and has now signed for East Fife.

[TheFamous1875]

That's all very true but my list is of players who were registered to us last season and an indication of where they are right now.

Vine has subsequently been released by Morton and Mullen left Raith Rovers at the end of the season and has now signed for East Fife.

Also supporting this opinion is that Thomson (who I rate) and McPake are of to an unproven team albeit in the division above us. The only player who's left us and went on to better things is Paul Cairney.

Typing that last sentence really hits it home!


Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk HD

[jacomo]

Some decent players in there and some very average. But next to nothing you'd call real star quality, which is why we're now playing second level football this season. Stubbs has a heap of work to do but at least he should have a few bob to spare with all that lot gone - he'd better spend it wisely!

You don't need star quality to survive in the Scottish top flight - as a host of clubs have proved. You just need organisation, commitment, decent leadership and competent coaching... sadly all lacking last term.

[PeterboroHibee]

Also supporting this opinion is that Thomson (who I rate) and McPake are of to an unproven team albeit in the division above us. The only player who's left us and went on to better things is Paul Cairney.

Typing that last sentence really hits it home!

Has he really? I think Killie are an absolutely dire team, and without Boyd I think theres a good chance they will finish bottom next season.