If petrie stays.....

[Gordy M]

Playing devils advocate here, if LD appoints a successful manager and we manage to gain promotion at the first time of asking, and basically have a great season, would you be happy for RP to remain as an non exec director?

[Thecat23]

Playing devils advocate here, if LD appoints a successful manager and we manage to gain promotion at the first time of asking, and basically have a great season, would you be happy for RP to remain as an non exec director?

For me he's gone past the point of no return. One season won't make up for the dross of the previous 7. He has to go!

[erskine-hibby]

Playing devils advocate here, if LD appoints a successful manager and we manage to gain promotion at the first time of asking, and basically have a great season, would you be happy for RP to remain as an non exec director?

No.

[rcarter1]

Would have no problem at all. I understand the level of feeling against Petrie, however he nonetheless has certain skills and knowledge. If it is put to good use, then good. If Leanne is able to do all the bits of the job that he clearly couldn't do, then good.

[jacomo]

If it all pans out as in the OP, Hibs is a happy ship again, and the right people have the authority to make the right decisions, then yes.

Still not sure what he would bring to Hibs but that's an answer for STF.

[HibbyAndy]

No

[Ronniekirk]

For me he's gone past the point of no return. One season won't make up for the dross of the previous 7. He has to go!
This Petrie wants people to play devils advocate ,it's right up his street so don't indulge him .Although while Lee Ann will read posts on here Rod wouldn't bother

[Baldy Foghorn]

No, his mere presence is doing more harm than good

[weonlywon6-2]

I think he wil go,just not at the moment

[Gerard]

Dear Rod why can't you retire to your country home and be free from the job as non exec chairman of Hibs?

[Dave-O]

No from me

[Gordy M]

No, his mere presence is doing more harm than good
Yeh i get that mate, my point was if we were successful then he wouldnt be doing more harm than good at that particular time. I think he should go, honestly dont think he will, but when the season starts i want all of us, LD, manager and fans all focussed on getting promoted. I worry that this issue will affect the season ahead. Yes the answer is RP should go, i was just wondering whether success on the pitch would lessen the fans angst towards him, thats all.

[erin go bragh]

Petrie is the rotten apple in the barrel . He has to go for the good of the club .



ggtth

[Hibeewilly]

Playing devils advocate here, if LD appoints a successful manager and we manage to gain promotion at the first time of asking, and basically have a great season, would you be happy for RP to remain as an non exec director?
I could be wrong but I don't think the CEO will appoint the new manager herself. I would think that would be board decision but with her input

[blackpoolhibs]

We probably need him to stay now just to sign some players so the new manager has some people to train when he eventually arrives. :rolleyes:

[skipster7]

He needs to go but as LD says there's a process to go through. I'd be happy if there's steps being taken to ensure he's gone by the end of the new season assuming there's a vast improvement on the pitch.

[Leithenhibby]

He may well go, but who will buy-out his 10%

The fans :cb

[chorley_fm]

WHEN he stays, he aint going anywhere...

[hibee]

Yes.

[Saorsa]

Playing devils advocate here, if LD appoints a successful manager and we manage to gain promotion at the first time of asking, and basically have a great season, would you be happy for RP to remain as an non exec director?NO!

[edwards]

Playing devils advocate here, if LD appoints a successful manager and we manage to gain promotion at the first time of asking, and basically have a great season, would you be happy for RP to remain as an non exec director?


NOooooooooo HE CAN GTF




PETRIE OUT

[AL-Qaholik]

No.

I won't be back until he's gone - regardless of any short-term on field successes.

With him anywhere near the club, we will only ever be moments away from further embarrassment and long term damage to the club.