Players Brought In Since 2004-2005

[Turkish Green]

Since RP became Chairman in 2004 Hibs have seen the following players enter the revolving door at ER either as a contract signing or on loan...



David MURPHY
Simon BROWN
Chris HOGG
Guillaume BEUZELIN
Antonio MURRAY
Sam MORROW
Dean SHIELS
Amadou KONTE
Ivan SPROULE
Craig ROCASTLE
Humphrey RUDGE
Oumar KONDÉ
Michael STEWART
Paul DALGLISH
Chris KILLEN
Zbigniew MALKOWSKI
Abdessalam BENJELLOUN
Thomas SOWUNMI
Shelton MARTIS
Rob JONES
Marouane ZEMMAMA
Dermott McCAFFREY
Shana HAJI
Brian KERR
Alan O'BRIEN
Colin NISH
Martin CANNING
Thierry GATHUESSI
Mickaël ANTOINE-CURIER
Clayton DONALDSON
Abderaouf ZARABI
John RANKIN
Patrick NOUBISSIE
Filipe MORAIS
Yves Makabu MA-KALAMBAY
Kurtis BYRNE
Torben JONELEIT
Joe KEENAN
Jonatan JOHANSSON
Grzegorz SZAMOTULSKI
Dénes RÓSA
Derek RIORDAN
David VAN ZANTEN
Fabián YANTORNO
Souleyman BAMBA
Steven THICOT
Steve PINAU
Graeme SMITH
Daniel GALBRAITH
Graham STACK
Liam MILLER
Anthony STOKES
Mark BROWN
Kevin McBRIDE
Patrick CREGG
Abdessalam BENJELLOUN
Aaron CHALMERS
Tom McCREADY
Alan GOW
Martin SCOTT
Michael HART
Valdas TRAKYS
Edwin DE GRAAF
Francis DICKOH
Ricardo VAZ TÉ
Akpo SODJE
Matt THORNHILL
Callum BOOTH
Guðlaugur Victor PÁLSSON
David STEPHENS
Kurtis BYRNE
Darryl DUFFY
Jakub DIVIS
Jonathon GROUNDS
Richard TOWELL
Garry O'CONNOR
Sean O'HANLON
Ivan SPROULE
Isaiah OSBOURNE
Eoin DOYLE
Adam MITTER
Roy O'DONOVAN
Tom SOARES
James McPAKE
Jorge CLAROS
Leigh GRIFFITHS
Matt DOHERTY
Richard TOWELL
George FRANCOMB
Phil AIREY
Alan MAYBURY
Ben WILLIAMS
Shefki KUQI
Kevin THOMSON
Scott ROBERTSON
Tim CLANCY
James McPAKE
Sean MURDOCH
Paul CAIRNEY
Gary DEEGAN
Tom TAIWO
Matty DONE
Ryan McGIVERN
Paul HEFFERNAN
Liam CRAIG
Rowan VINE
Michael NELSON
Owain TUDUR-JONES
James COLLINS
Fraser MULLEN
Danny HAYNES
Daniel BOATENG
Abdellah ZOUBIR
Duncan WATMORE
Middlesbrough
Colchester United
Ipswich Town
Le Havre
Ipswich Town
Ipswich Town
Arsenal
Cambridge United
Institute
Chelsea
Apollon
Hansa Rostock
Nottingham Forest
Livingston
Oldham Athletic
Feyenoord
MAS Fès
1.FC Slovácko
Darlington
Grimsby Town
Raja Casablanca
Dungannon Swifts
Esteghlal
Motherwell
Newcastle United
Kilmarnock
Gretna
Sète
FK Haugesund
York City
AC Ajaccio
Inverness CT
Swindon Town
Millwall
Chelsea
Norwich City
Monaco B
Melbourne Victory
Malmö FF
MS Ashdod
Wolves
Celtic
St.Mirren
Gretna
Dunfermline
Nantes
Genoa
Brighton & HA
Manchester United
Blackpool
QPR
Sunderland
Celtic
Falkirk
Falkirk
Charleroi
Macclesfield Town
Everton
Plymouth Argyle
Ross County
Preston North End
Panserraikos
NAC
FC Utrecht
Panionios
Charlton Athletic
Nottingham Forest
Arbroath
Liverpool
Norwich City
Stirling Albion
Bristol Rovers
Tatran Presov
Middlesbrough
Celtic
Barnsley
Milton Keynes
Yeovil Town
Aston Villa
Sligo Rovers
Blackpool
Coventry City
Stoke City
Coventry City
Motagua
Wolves
Wolves
Celtic
Norwich City
Newcastle United
St.Johnstone
Colchester United
Oldham Athletic
Middlesbrough
Blackpool
Motherwell
Coventry City
Accrington Stanley
Partick Thistle
Coventry City
Carlisle United
Barnsley
Manchester City
Kilmarnock
St.Johnstone
St.Johnstone
Bradford City
Inverness CT
Swindon Town
Hearts
Notts County
Arsenal
Istres
Sunderland




What %age of these would be considered as successes while wearing the green + white?

[Speedway]

Adam Mitter, never off Twitter whilst sat on the Gary Glitter.

There's some pony in that lot.

[.Sean.]

Since RP became Chairman in 2004 Hibs have seen the following players enter the revolving door at ER either as a contract signing or on loan...



David MURPHY
Simon BROWN
Chris HOGG
Guillaume BEUZELIN
Antonio MURRAY
Sam MORROW
Dean SHIELS
Amadou KONTE
Ivan SPROULE
Craig ROCASTLE
Humphrey RUDGE
Oumar KONDÉ
Michael STEWART
Paul DALGLISH
Chris KILLEN
Zbigniew MALKOWSKI
Abdessalam BENJELLOUN
Thomas SOWUNMI
Shelton MARTIS
Rob JONES
Marouane ZEMMAMA
Dermott McCAFFREY
Shana HAJI
Brian KERR
Alan O'BRIEN
Colin NISH
Martin CANNING
Thierry GATHUESSI
Mickaël ANTOINE-CURIER
Clayton DONALDSON
Abderaouf ZARABI
John RANKIN
Patrick NOUBISSIE
Filipe MORAIS
Yves Makabu MA-KALAMBAY
Kurtis BYRNE
Torben JONELEIT
Joe KEENAN
Jonatan JOHANSSON
Grzegorz SZAMOTULSKI
Dénes RÓSA
Derek RIORDAN
David VAN ZANTEN
Fabián YANTORNO
Souleyman BAMBA
Steven THICOT
Steve PINAU
Graeme SMITH
Daniel GALBRAITH
Graham STACK
Liam MILLER
Anthony STOKES
Mark BROWN
Kevin McBRIDE
Patrick CREGG
Abdessalam BENJELLOUN
Aaron CHALMERS
Tom McCREADY
Alan GOW
Martin SCOTT
Michael HART
Valdas TRAKYS
Edwin DE GRAAF
Francis DICKOH
Ricardo VAZ TÉ
Akpo SODJE
Matt THORNHILL
Callum BOOTH
Guðlaugur Victor PÁLSSON
David STEPHENS
Kurtis BYRNE
Darryl DUFFY
Jakub DIVIS
Jonathon GROUNDS
Richard TOWELL
Garry O'CONNOR
Sean O'HANLON
Ivan SPROULE
Isaiah OSBOURNE
Eoin DOYLE
Adam MITTER
Roy O'DONOVAN
Tom SOARES
James McPAKE
Jorge CLAROS
Leigh GRIFFITHS
Matt DOHERTY
Richard TOWELL
George FRANCOMB
Phil AIREY
Alan MAYBURY
Ben WILLIAMS
Shefki KUQI
Kevin THOMSON
Scott ROBERTSON
Tim CLANCY
James McPAKE
Sean MURDOCH
Paul CAIRNEY
Gary DEEGAN
Tom TAIWO
Matty DONE
Ryan McGIVERN
Paul HEFFERNAN
Liam CRAIG
Rowan VINE
Michael NELSON
Owain TUDUR-JONES
James COLLINS
Fraser MULLEN
Danny HAYNES
Daniel BOATENG
Abdellah ZOUBIR
Duncan WATMORE
Middlesbrough
Colchester United
Ipswich Town
Le Havre
Ipswich Town
Ipswich Town
Arsenal
Cambridge United
Institute
Chelsea
Apollon
Hansa Rostock
Nottingham Forest
Livingston
Oldham Athletic
Feyenoord
MAS Fès
1.FC Slovácko
Darlington
Grimsby Town
Raja Casablanca
Dungannon Swifts
Esteghlal
Motherwell
Newcastle United
Kilmarnock
Gretna
Sète
FK Haugesund
York City
AC Ajaccio
Inverness CT
Swindon Town
Millwall
Chelsea
Norwich City
Monaco B
Melbourne Victory
Malmö FF
MS Ashdod
Wolves
Celtic
St.Mirren
Gretna
Dunfermline
Nantes
Genoa
Brighton & HA
Manchester United
Blackpool
QPR
Sunderland
Celtic
Falkirk
Falkirk
Charleroi
Macclesfield Town
Everton
Plymouth Argyle
Ross County
Preston North End
Panserraikos
NAC
FC Utrecht
Panionios
Charlton Athletic
Nottingham Forest
Arbroath
Liverpool
Norwich City
Stirling Albion
Bristol Rovers
Tatran Presov
Middlesbrough
Celtic
Barnsley
Milton Keynes
Yeovil Town
Aston Villa
Sligo Rovers
Blackpool
Coventry City
Stoke City
Coventry City
Motagua
Wolves
Wolves
Celtic
Norwich City
Newcastle United
St.Johnstone
Colchester United
Oldham Athletic
Middlesbrough
Blackpool
Motherwell
Coventry City
Accrington Stanley
Partick Thistle
Coventry City
Carlisle United
Barnsley
Manchester City
Kilmarnock
St.Johnstone
St.Johnstone
Bradford City
Inverness CT
Swindon Town
Hearts
Notts County
Arsenal
Istres
Sunderland




What %age of these would be considered as successes while wearing the green + white?
Wow. Players in bold were absolute humpy. Yogi and Collins signed some real dross but Calderwood bought predominantly garbage, PF's first January window was a horror show and Butcher hasn't fared any better on the signing front.

Shameful waste of resources. Do we have a scouting network?

[Mark79]

Some of those names bring back some mixed memories.

Who is shana haji though?

Also I'll get in first and say why is there only one of the sowumni brothers on it?

[Diclonius]

Some of those names bring back some mixed memories.

Who is shana haji though?

Also I'll get in first and say why is there only one of the sowumni brothers on it?

They're the same person mate. Common misconception on here.

[stokesmessiah]

Wow. Players in bold were absolute humpy. Yogi and Collins signed some real dross but Calderwood bought predominantly garbage, PF's first January window was a horror show and Butcher hasn't fared any better on the signing front.

Shameful waste of resources. Do we have a scouting network?

Whilst i agree with most of the players you highlighted, i still think Akpo Sodje was a decent player and was really starting to find his feet when we ended his contract.

[Haymaker]

Some of those names bring back some mixed memories.

Who is shana haji though?

Also I'll get in first and say why is there only one of the sowumni brothers on it?

Haji was some wee Iranian player IIRC, signed and never heard of again.

[worcesterhibby]

Wow. Players in bold were absolute humpy. Yogi and Collins signed some real dross but Calderwood bought predominantly garbage, PF's first January window was a horror show and Butcher hasn't fared any better on the signing front.

Shameful waste of resources. Do we have a scouting network?

I agree with many of your assessments, but Ricardo Vaz Te was obviously an excellent player surrounded by muppets. He went on to feature regularly for West Ham in the EPL.

[hibs4thecup1988]

Wow. Players in bold were absolute humpy. Yogi and Collins signed some real dross but Calderwood bought predominantly garbage, PF's first January window was a horror show and Butcher hasn't fared any better on the signing front.

Shameful waste of resources. Do we have a scouting network?

Done wasn't humpty...Brilliant in quarter final at Killie last year

[Auckland Hibs]

Good god, there's some complete dross on that list :confused:

[Curly1875]

Done wasn't humpty...Brilliant in quarter final at Killie last year

1 good game doesn't make him a good player for hibs

[Golden Bear]

And post Mowbray era, how many went on to bigger and better things?

Very, very few which in itself is a testament to the abject failure of both our scouting system and successive Managers who failed to bring in players who added value to the Club. The Board can't be blamed for everything as other "lesser" but more successful Clubs have managed with far fewer resources than us.

It's a *loody disgrace in fact.

[Sweep]

:dizzy: Wow 114 players in 10 years? Thats a new team every season.

[3pm]

Wow. Players in bold were absolute humpy. Yogi and Collins signed some real dross but Calderwood bought predominantly garbage, PF's first January window was a horror show and Butcher hasn't fared any better on the signing front.

Shameful waste of resources. Do we have a scouting network?

Sean, I actually think you've been quite generous there. There should have been more in bold.

[Islington Hibs]

:dizzy: Wow 114 players in 10 years? Thats a new team every season.


Sums up with what is wrong. No consistency. No one given time to bed down and settle in and no loyalty or mutual respect with the support can be built up.

This ties in with another post re Vines comments and I think the route of Petries failure. You can not run and football club as a constant merry-go-round wasting countless thundered of thousands on short term fixes then discard the proceeds. Pathetic and I hope our new CEO is well aware of this abject shambles.

Going forward build loyalty through youth- the likes of Stanton. Harris, Cummings hopefully and support with a few proven imports who understand the style and ethos.

[calumhibee1]

IMO there's 28 successful signings out of the 115 in that list and 79 that offered absolutely nothing, while the other couple were just indifferent.... :bitchy:

[GlesgaeHibby]

Since RP became Chairman in 2004 Hibs have seen the following players enter the revolving door at ER either as a contract signing or on loan...



David MURPHY
Simon BROWN
Chris HOGG
Guillaume BEUZELIN
Antonio MURRAY
Sam MORROW
Dean SHIELS
Amadou KONTE
Ivan SPROULE
Craig ROCASTLE
Humphrey RUDGE
Oumar KONDÉ
Michael STEWART
Paul DALGLISH
Chris KILLEN
Zbigniew MALKOWSKI
Abdessalam BENJELLOUN
Thomas SOWUNMI
Shelton MARTIS
Rob JONES
Marouane ZEMMAMA
Dermott McCAFFREY
Shana HAJI
Brian KERR
Alan O'BRIEN
Colin NISH
Martin CANNING
Thierry GATHUESSI
Mickaël ANTOINE-CURIER
Clayton DONALDSON
Abderaouf ZARABI
John RANKIN
Patrick NOUBISSIE
Filipe MORAIS
Yves Makabu MA-KALAMBAY
Kurtis BYRNE
Torben JONELEIT
Joe KEENAN
Jonatan JOHANSSON
Grzegorz SZAMOTULSKI
Dénes RÓSA
Derek RIORDAN
David VAN ZANTEN
Fabián YANTORNO
Souleyman BAMBA
Steven THICOT
Steve PINAU
Graeme SMITH
Daniel GALBRAITH
Graham STACK
Liam MILLER
Anthony STOKES
Mark BROWN
Kevin McBRIDE
Patrick CREGG
Abdessalam BENJELLOUN
Aaron CHALMERS
Tom McCREADY
Alan GOW
Martin SCOTT
Michael HART
Valdas TRAKYS
Edwin DE GRAAF
Francis DICKOH
Ricardo VAZ TÉ
Akpo SODJE
Matt THORNHILL
Callum BOOTH
Guðlaugur Victor PÁLSSON
David STEPHENS
Kurtis BYRNE
Darryl DUFFY
Jakub DIVIS
Jonathon GROUNDS
Richard TOWELL
Garry O'CONNOR
Sean O'HANLON
Ivan SPROULE
Isaiah OSBOURNE
Eoin DOYLE
Adam MITTER
Roy O'DONOVAN
Tom SOARES
James McPAKE
Jorge CLAROS
Leigh GRIFFITHS
Matt DOHERTY
Richard TOWELL
George FRANCOMB
Phil AIREY
Alan MAYBURY
Ben WILLIAMS
Shefki KUQI
Kevin THOMSON
Scott ROBERTSON
Tim CLANCY
James McPAKE
Sean MURDOCH
Paul CAIRNEY
Gary DEEGAN
Tom TAIWO
Matty DONE
Ryan McGIVERN
Paul HEFFERNAN
Liam CRAIG
Rowan VINE
Michael NELSON
Owain TUDUR-JONES
James COLLINS
Fraser MULLEN
Danny HAYNES
Daniel BOATENG
Abdellah ZOUBIR
Duncan WATMORE

Middlesbrough
Colchester United
Ipswich Town
Le Havre
Ipswich Town
Ipswich Town
Arsenal
Cambridge United
Institute
Chelsea
Apollon
Hansa Rostock
Nottingham Forest
Livingston
Oldham Athletic
Feyenoord
MAS Fès
1.FC Slovácko
Darlington
Grimsby Town
Raja Casablanca
Dungannon Swifts
Esteghlal
Motherwell
Newcastle United
Kilmarnock
Gretna
Sète
FK Haugesund
York City
AC Ajaccio
Inverness CT
Swindon Town
Millwall
Chelsea
Norwich City
Monaco B
Melbourne Victory
Malmö FF
MS Ashdod
Wolves
Celtic
St.Mirren
Gretna
Dunfermline
Nantes
Genoa
Brighton & HA
Manchester United
Blackpool
QPR
Sunderland
Celtic
Falkirk
Falkirk
Charleroi
Macclesfield Town
Everton
Plymouth Argyle
Ross County
Preston North End
Panserraikos
NAC
FC Utrecht
Panionios
Charlton Athletic
Nottingham Forest
Arbroath
Liverpool
Norwich City
Stirling Albion
Bristol Rovers
Tatran Presov
Middlesbrough
Celtic
Barnsley
Milton Keynes
Yeovil Town
Aston Villa
Sligo Rovers
Blackpool
Coventry City
Stoke City
Coventry City
Motagua
Wolves
Wolves
Celtic
Norwich City
Newcastle United
St.Johnstone
Colchester United
Oldham Athletic
Middlesbrough
Blackpool
Motherwell
Coventry City
Accrington Stanley
Partick Thistle
Coventry City
Carlisle United
Barnsley
Manchester City
Kilmarnock
St.Johnstone
St.Johnstone
Bradford City
Inverness CT
Swindon Town
Hearts
Notts County
Arsenal
Istres
Sunderland





What %age of these would be considered as successes while wearing the green + white?

Quiet day at the office today? :greengrin

[Turkish Green]

Shameful waste of resources. Do we have a scouting network?

I doubt that scouts are used going by the amount of 3rd rate foreign players that have come and gone. I suspect that certain preferred agents are used. It would be interesting to check out if all the dross came from various agents or only a few.

Do clubs still give players trials or is that old school?

[KeithTheHibby]

:dizzy: Wow 114 players in 10 years? Thats a new team every season.


Exactly. And in that time we have had in charge..

Mowbray

Collins

Mixu

Yogi

Calderwood

Fenlon

Butcher

Tells it's own story. 5 in the last 7 years.

[Turkish Green]

Sums up with what is wrong. No consistency. No one given time to bed down and settle in and no loyalty or mutual respect with the support can be built up.

This ties in with another post re Vines comments and I think the route of Petries failure. You can not run and football club as a constant merry-go-round wasting countless thundered of thousands on short term fixes then discard the proceeds. Pathetic and I hope our new CEO is well aware of this abject shambles.

I didn't say so in my OP but this was the reason for this thread. Hibs used to be more successful when they produced their own players and only augmented them with a few external signings. But since RP took control it appears that the policy is bring in players on the cheap, on short therm deals. The Griffiths saga will emphasize that.

Reap what you sow, Mr Petrie.



PETRIE OUT

[Turkish Green]

Exactly. And in that time we have had in charge..

Mowbray
Collins
Mixu
Yogi
Calderwood
Fenlon
Butcher

Tells it's own story. 5 in the last 7 years.
And we would laugh at the number of managers/coaches that Mad Vlad brought in over at the PBS. Hibs are almost (but not quite) as bad.

[Golden Bear]

I didn't say so in my OP but this was the reason for this thread. Hibs used to be more successful when they produced their own players and only augmented them with a few external signings. But since RP took control it appears that the policy is bring in players on the cheap, on short therm deals. The Griffiths saga will emphasize that.

Reap what you sow, Mr Petrie.



PETRIE OUT

The Bosman ruling changed the nature of the football transfer market for ever and Clubs were forced to re-evaluate both the way they organised their youth teams and their dealings in the transfer market.

It appears that we've still not got it right.

[Puddocky]

Slightly off-topic, but I see that Benji, Ivan, McPake and Byrne are all listed twice. Fair enough for Ivan who signed on two separate occasions, have I missed something for the others?

[Willis1875]

Antonio Murray is a goal machine at his current club,albeit at a fairly low level

[TheFamous1875]

It's shocking to look at the decline of quality brought into Easter Road since 2004.

Mowbray:

In: Shiels, Murphy, Beuzelin, Jones, Benji, Zemmama, Stewart, Killen, Hogg, Sproule

Out: Riordan, O'Connor, Murray, Caldwell

Collins:

In: I can't think of any good signings he made.

Out: Brown, Thomson, Whittaker, Sproule, Stewart, Killen,

Mixu:

In: Nish, Rankin, Riordan, Bamba, Murray.

Out: Murphy, Beuzelin, Shiels.

Yogi:

In: Stokes, Miller, Stack.

Out: Benji, Fletcher, Jones, Stokes.

Calderwood:

In: Sparky, O'Connor, Vaz Te, Sproule.

Out: Zemmama, Bamba, Riordan, Vaz Te, Miller, Hogg.

Fenlon:

In: McPake, Claros, Robertson, Taiwo, Doyle, Maybury, Thomson, Williams.

Out: Sparky, O'Connor, Claros, Murray, Wotherspoon, Doyle, Sproule.

Butcher:

In: no one of note yet.

Out: Williams.


Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk HD

[NadeAteMyLunch!]

Considering we currently have a squad of 14, including no goalkeepers, there will be another 10 names or so to add to that extensive list soon. Hopefully they're not all pish

[TheFamous1875]

Again, this season will be another 'transitional' period. I can't see us getting promoted, but I can see us getting promoted the season after (if all goes well) at a canter.


Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk HD

[DH1875]

I'd say there's 32 players on that list that where good/decent players. The rest were and are proper kite.

[Turkish Green]

Slightly off-topic, but I see that Benji, Ivan, McPake and Byrne are all listed twice. Fair enough for Ivan who signed on two separate occasions, have I missed something for the others?
Possibly because they were brought in originally on loan in one season then signed the next.

[21.05.2016]

So much utter garbage on that list it's unreal!

[Michael]

Mowbray signed some decent players (especially Murphy, what a player)...but thereafter it's utter garbage bar a few exceptions. We only seem to sign pish!

[Pray4Marc]

Wow. Players in bold were absolute humpy. Yogi and Collins signed some real dross but Calderwood bought predominantly garbage, PF's first January window was a horror show and Butcher hasn't fared any better on the signing front.

Shameful waste of resources. Do we have a scouting network?

This is a point I've made plenty times, who was scouting these players? Was it the managers or someone employed on our club to manage the scouting system. Petrie put funds in place to sign the players. Eg wages. He didn't scout them.

[Vault Boy]

I was starting to worry that we had a poor history of signings, but then I realised that Junior Agogo is missing from the list and I'm feeling better about the whole thing.

[Sir David Gray]

Adam Mitter, never off Twitter whilst sat on the Gary Glitter.

There's some pony in that lot.

I'm pretty sure that Adam Mitter was a figment of some people's imaginations.

Did anyone actually see the guy in person? :confused:

[Mr White]

I'm pretty sure that Adam Mitter was a figment of some people's imaginations.

Did anyone actually see the guy in person? :confused:

I did. He was playing keepy-upy with Brian Kerr.

[emerald green]

That list is absolutely shocking, and maybe goes quite a long way to explaining why HFC finds itself where it is today.

The large majority on that list are/were ganting, and I had actually erased some of them from my memory they were so bad. Is this the level of player we are reduced to signing? Who sanctioned these players coming into the club? Who thought they were good players? Step forward RP and successive managers at HFC.

The club needs to take a step back now, and stop bringing in lots of crap players and use what money it has on trying to bring in fewer but better quality players. Having been relegated that will be that bit harder. That's just one of the serious consequences for any club following relegation.

[Sir David Gray]

Some more players to add to the list;

Junior Agogo
Andrew McNeil
Ian Murray
Pa Saikou Kujabi
Mark Venus (yes he did play once for the first team!)

[Cameron1875]

All started when we replaced Scott Brown with Brian Kerr.
And replaced Whittaker with Kevin Mccann.

That signaled the Hibernian Board intentions and that slide in calibre of player has never been addressed bar the odd gem like Stokes and Griffiths.

[GreenArmyyy!]

1 good game doesn't make him a good player for hibs

Completely agree, Brian Kerr had one good game at Hibs.....

[Unseen work]

Some absolute shocking signings. We replace quality with average players, average with dross, dross with worst dross

The decline of Hibernian fc since 2006 has been unbeleivable

[The Leith Dutch]

Best I can do on the back of a Fag Packet:

GK - Grzegorz SZAMOTULSKI

LB - David MURPHY
CB - Rob JONES
CB - Sol BAMBA
RB - George FRANCOMB

MF - Dean SHIELS
MF - Craig ROCASTLE
MF - Liam MILLER
MF - Guillaume BEUZELIN

FW - Leigh GRIFFITHS
FW - Anthony STOKES

[givescotlandfreedom]

Just a point but we would have all been going bananas if Petrie had vetoed a signing the incumbent manager had wanted if we could afford him.

[Diclonius]

Completely agree, Brian Kerr had one good game at Hibs.....

He had two good minutes at Hibs. His career could only go down after that.

[Sir David Gray]

Best I can do on the back of a Fag Packet:

GK - Grzegorz SZAMOTULSKI

LB - David MURPHY
CB - Rob JONES
CB - Sol BAMBA
RB - George FRANCOMB

MF - Dean SHIELS
MF - Craig ROCASTLE
MF - Liam MILLER
MF - Guillaume BEUZELIN

FW - Leigh GRIFFITHS
FW - Anthony STOKES

Ben Williams is the best goalkeeper we've had over the last 10 years IMO.

I would also have Zemmama in there ahead over Rocastle (he only played 14 games for us).

Apart from that, I would probably agree.

[TheFamous1875]

Sproule effectively as a RWB is a bit concerning. I'd imagine Stewart and Bamba would provide enough cover for him to get forward!


Williams.

Bamba. Jones. Murray.

Sproule. Stewart. Beuzelin. Murphy.

Zemmama.

Griffiths. Stokes.


SUBS: Szamotulski; Benji, L. Miller, Shiels, Riordan, Hogg, O'Connor.


Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk HD

[The_Horde]

WillIams

Bamba Jones Murray Murphy

Sproule Boozy Zouma Deeks

Sparky Stokes

[lord bunberry]

I did. He was playing keepy-upy with Brian Kerr.

Talented guy, most players use a ball