Player Ratings (St Mirren)

[Hibstrooper]

Williams 6 - little chance with either goal, not much else to do

Maybury 6 - Puts in a lot more effort than some others
Forster & Nelson 0 - Oh dear, what a horrible pairing
Stevenson 5 - We need Lewis from 4 months ago back

Harris 4 - Looked to have gone back into his shell, not one decent ball in
OTJ 4 - misplaced some easy passes and left our defence exposed early on
Thomson 6 - tried to take a bit responsibility but again no end product
Stanton 5 - couple of good runs, needed him on the ball more in 2nd half

Haynes 3 - clearly doesn't give a toot
Collins 3 - gives a toot but just isn't very good

Cummings 7 - did x10 more than Collins in an attacking sense
Watmore 5 - Couple of nice runs but again poor end product

Forster and Nelson simply can't play as a pairing again, 2 easy goals right through the middle and I don't think either won a header or a tackle all game. Cummings should be from the start next week too.

[sleeping giant]

Only player to get pass marks from me is Cummings.

[hibsbollah]

Nobody deserves above pass marks. We're in deep trouble.



Williams 5

Stevenson 4
Forster 5 caught out trying to dribble out of defence for the second, but otherwise did ok.
Nelson 2 just a horrible display. We know he can't pass, but when he gets out jumped after 12 seconds to concede a goal you wonder what the point of him is. Captain calamity.
Maybury 5

Harris 5 some good, some bad. Looks to have his confidence back which is something.
Thomson 5 hardly the messiah. Free kicks and corners wasted, spoiled some decent second half contribution in open play.
Tudor Jones 4
Stanton 5 looked our most likely scorer. A mediocre MOTM.
Haynes 5

Collins 1 It's not good enough to keep saying he's not getting any service. He is just not capable of the basics and we need to cut our losses. I can't stand the sight of his first touch one minute longer.

Subs
cummings: busy
watmore: an improvement on jones

Ref: fussy to the point of making it a non contact sport.

[Sir David Gray]

Williams-5

Maybury-4
Forster-3
Nelson-3
Stevenson-5

Stanton-6
Thomson-5
Tudur Jones-4
Harris-4

Haynes-3
Collins-3

SUBS
Watmore-5
Cummings-5

[JMac]

1's to all, they should be ashamed of themselves

[IWasThere2016]

Williams - left exposed. Distribution very poor at time.

Back 4

Maybury - finished.
Forster - asleep
Nelson - NEVER a footballer.
Lewis - Endeavour as always.

Harris - dire first 45. Better 2nd.
OTJ - Jesus wept.
Thomson - our best player today IMHO.
Stanton - second to Thomson.
Haynes - Jesus wept #2

Collins - concrete boots.

Subs
Cummings and Watmore - must start next week


Pass marks for KT, Sammy, Lewis and the subs. The rest need shot.

[Centre Hawf]

Stanton Thomson Watmore and Cummings get pass marks. The rest need to go have a word

[SteveHFC]

Williams-4

Maybury- 1
Forster-3
Nelson- -1
Stevenson-5

Stanton-6
Thomson-5
Tudur Jones-5
Harris-4

Haynes-2
Collins- 1

SUBS
Watmore-5
Cummings-5

[rcarter1]

Williams - left exposed. Distribution very poor at time.

Back 4

Maybury - finished.
Forster - asleep
Nelson - NEVER a footballer.
Lewis - Endeavour as always.

Harris - dire first 45. Better 2nd.
OTJ - Jesus wept.
Thomson - our best player today IMHO.
Stanton - second to Thomson.
Haynes - Jesus wept #2

Collins - concrete boots.

Subs
Cummings and Watmore - must start next week


Pass marks for KT, Sammy, Lewis and the subs. The rest need shot.

This at least brings a smile to my face. If we are going down (and its still unlikely), were going to need a sense of humour..

[NadeAteMyLunch!]

Stanton, Watmore and Cummings get pass marks. Lewis and KT just about. The rest can away and fling ***** at the moon

[dp00]

Williams-5

Maybury-4
Forster-3
Nelson-3
Stevenson-5

Stanton-6
Thomson-6
Tudur Jones-4
Harris-4

Haynes-2
Collins-3

SUBS
Watmore-5
Cummings-5




Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[gegs70]

I just have no idea what our best team is...

Robertson.and hanlon are a huge miss but who.is going to score the goals?

[craigmounthibby]

I just have no idea what our best team is...

Robertson.and hanlon are a huge miss but who.is going to score the goals?
Bingo. That is the problem. Doesn't seem to matter who plays, or in what formation, we do not look like scoring.

[MWHIBBIES]

Williams - Fine, nothing to do. 6/10

Maybury - Done fine too, got forward more than usual 6/10

Forster - Absolutely awful and responsible for the second goal - 2/10

Nelson - Worse than Forster, honking 1/10

Stevenson - See Maybury 6/10

Harris - Done fine but nothing when they were 11 - 5/10

Jones - meh 5/10

Thomson - Much better than Craig but still nothing spectacular 6/10

Stanton - Solid 6/10

Collins - Non existent, difference between him and Steven Thomson was startling 3/10

Haynes - Rubbish - 3/10

Subs
Cummings - 7/10, make a big difference and unlucky not to score

Watmore - again, made a difference, should have started instead of Haynes, 6/10

two center halfs sold the game in the first 15, as they have done as a pairing more than once this season, ICT at home and Hearts 2 weeks ago, shouldn't play together again as they look like they don't know who each other are.

[IWasThere2016]

Our CHs don't communicate. It's worse than watching two small kids playing. My wee lad plays CH and he and his other CH - they're 14 - would've put the Coma Twins of Forster and Nelson to shame yesterday. Garbage the pair - especially Nelson.

[Winston Ingram]

Our CHs don't communicate. It's worse than watching two small kids playing. My wee lad plays CH and he and his other CH - they're 14 - would've put the Coma Twins of Forster and Nelson to shame yesterday. Garbage the pair - especially Nelson.

Nelsen is an imposter

[KiddA]

The worrying thing is Nelson is still under contract next season :rolleyes: he has to be gone in the summer what a truly awful center half :grr: Forster is at least young and can get better.

[DH1875]

The worrying thing is Nelson is still under contract next season :rolleyes: he has to be gone in the summer what a truly awful center half :grr: Forster is at least young and can get better.

Your not wrong. Forster was at fault for both goals though and has been poor for weeks. If we had anyone else I'd take him out the team for the next couple of games.