Davy Mac
20-01-2014, 09:54 AM
Sorry if someone else has posted ratings, not seen the highlights and my ratings from what I remember this morning
Williams 5 - Exposed by his defence and might have done better with the goals
Maybury 3 - Like the Sellick Cup Final, caught out, slow, wanders out of position, no likey.
McGivern 1 - Still think he should have started in the middle with Nelson, Forster RB & sadly Lewis LB
Forster 4 - Unsettled with the change of position IMO, also indecisive at times
Nelson 4 - Poorest game I've seen from him, all the defence couldn't handle the pace of St Mirren's players in the first 30 mins - horrible to watch
Stevenson 4 - Caught too far forward for one of the goals when LB, again, he's been playing so well too.
Harris 6 - Got better as they game went on and glided with the ball in the 2nd but non-existent when he first came on.
Cairney 3 - Nah, not for me, I said after the Utd game he plays for himself and not the team, Saturday he didn't even do that. On Terry's punt list me thinks
Craig 3 - Jeepers creepers where did that performance come from, I thought he had turned things around for himself, he was gash, whiney and poor leadership
Robertson 5 - Best performer in the first but still contributed very little other than huff and puff but at least it showed
Cummings 5 - Needs a goal, tricky and willing and like his vibe
Collins 6 - You've got to say he took his goals well but his first touch is hurried and very inconsistent. Probably MOM or Stanton
Stanton 6 Excellent young man, more of that please and probbaly just vgot edged out by Collins for MOM
Zoubir 2 - Nothing to offer and powder puff
Ref 4 - Another poor inconsistent performance and didn't get the big decision right
Fans 4 - Frustrated, as we just didn't see this coming but nothing should surprise us as we've seen all too often.
Butcher 4 - Got the startuing defence wrong IMO and although recovered slightly hopefully he will know weild the axe on some of the shxte we've got
Williams 5 - Exposed by his defence and might have done better with the goals
Maybury 3 - Like the Sellick Cup Final, caught out, slow, wanders out of position, no likey.
McGivern 1 - Still think he should have started in the middle with Nelson, Forster RB & sadly Lewis LB
Forster 4 - Unsettled with the change of position IMO, also indecisive at times
Nelson 4 - Poorest game I've seen from him, all the defence couldn't handle the pace of St Mirren's players in the first 30 mins - horrible to watch
Stevenson 4 - Caught too far forward for one of the goals when LB, again, he's been playing so well too.
Harris 6 - Got better as they game went on and glided with the ball in the 2nd but non-existent when he first came on.
Cairney 3 - Nah, not for me, I said after the Utd game he plays for himself and not the team, Saturday he didn't even do that. On Terry's punt list me thinks
Craig 3 - Jeepers creepers where did that performance come from, I thought he had turned things around for himself, he was gash, whiney and poor leadership
Robertson 5 - Best performer in the first but still contributed very little other than huff and puff but at least it showed
Cummings 5 - Needs a goal, tricky and willing and like his vibe
Collins 6 - You've got to say he took his goals well but his first touch is hurried and very inconsistent. Probably MOM or Stanton
Stanton 6 Excellent young man, more of that please and probbaly just vgot edged out by Collins for MOM
Zoubir 2 - Nothing to offer and powder puff
Ref 4 - Another poor inconsistent performance and didn't get the big decision right
Fans 4 - Frustrated, as we just didn't see this coming but nothing should surprise us as we've seen all too often.
Butcher 4 - Got the startuing defence wrong IMO and although recovered slightly hopefully he will know weild the axe on some of the shxte we've got