Ordering off's at Tannadice (NHC)

[maturehibby]

I hear Dundee united are appealing against Russels sending off in the incident -
Looked a bit like Templeton's ordering off when he took exception to Mcpakes tackle and lashed out with the boot .
Save your time and money United as it wont be overturned as he did the same as Templeton and deserved to go .

[givescotlandfreedom]

I hear Dundee united are appealing against Russels sending off in the incident -
Looked a bit like Templeton's ordering off when he took exception to Mcpakes tackle and lashed out with the boot .
Save your time and money United as it wont be overturned as he did the same as Templeton and deserved to go .

Do you think if Gunning was Leigh Griffiths he'd have gotten away with his celebtation after scoring?

[shagpile]

I hear Dundee united are appealing against Russels sending off in the incident -
Looked a bit like Templeton's ordering off when he took exception to Mcpakes tackle and lashed out with the boot .
Save your time and money United as it wont be overturned as he did the same as Templeton and deserved to go .

Both orderings off were justified. Don't listen to Andy Walker & his opinion. The man is an idiot.

[Pretty Boy]

Both clear sending offs.

An appeal would be a waste of money.

[Argylehibby]

Do you think if Gunning was Leigh Griffiths he'd have gotten away with his celebtation after scoring?

He was pointing to his arm not making a sparky style gesture.

[givescotlandfreedom]

He was pointing to his arm not making a sparky style gesture.

It looked a lot like one to me and he ran up towards the Dundee fans to do it.

[Argylehibby]

It looked a lot like one to me and he ran up towards the Dundee fans to do it.

Dont know if he has a tatoo on that arm or if it was somethng else he was pointing to (muscles?) but a sparky gesture would (IMO) have a hand clasped over the other arm and would involve a rapid movement of that other arm. In this case there was a finger pointing at the arm and no movement. It looked to me more a case of pointing to his muscle (Andy Murray style from a couple of years back) or at a tatoo which couldn't be seen from the camera angle.

[Future17]

I hear Dundee united are appealing against Russels sending off in the incident -
Looked a bit like Templeton's ordering off when he took exception to Mcpakes tackle and lashed out with the boot .
Save your time and money United as it wont be overturned as he did the same as Templeton and deserved to go .

The funny part was Barry Smith suggesting that the referee would rescind the cards without the need for an appeal. Aye. Welcome to the SPL Barry.

[Gettin' Auld]

If you're going to get a red card, you might as well make it for something worthwhile.

Let this 4 year old bairn show everyone how to get a REAL red card. :greengrin


http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FnVeeh5hMCw&feature=related

[Tricla]

Both clear sending offs.

An appeal would be a waste of money.

Just watched it for the first time and I disagree with the red cards.

A minor scuffle IMO.

A talking to and a yellow card each would have been more than enough.

The game has become far too pussy assed IMO.

If a Hibs player was sent off for either offence I'd be annoyed.

[Ritchie]

Just watched it for the first time and I disagree with the red cards.

A minor scuffle IMO.

A talking to and a yellow card each would have been more than enough.

The game has become far too pussy assed IMO.

If a Hibs player was sent off for either offence I'd be annoyed.

I agree, there was nothing at all in it!