would this team win the league this season?

[ivan03]

...................Williams

Whittaker.. McPake.. Bamba.. Murphy

................Broonie.. Thomson

Shiels..................................Zemmama

...........Stokes.....Fletcher.........

subs include;
O'Conner
Griffiths
Hanlon
Ozzy
Miller(liam)
Benji

[Aldo]

They would be very close. What bout this one

Colgan

Smith Sauzee fenwick
Lovell Jack O'Neil Russell Uli
Zitelli Mixu

[Aldo]

They would be very close. What bout this one

Colgan

Smith Sauzee fenwick
Lovell Jack O'Neil Russell Laursen
Zitelli Mixu
.

[danhibees1875]

They would be very close. What bout this one

Colgan

Smith Sauzee fenwick
Lovell Jack O'Neil Russell Uli
Zitelli Mixu

Probably all a bit old to win the league with them tbh.

[Aldo]

Probably all a bit old to win the league with them tbh.

Now they are but you get ma drift

[hibbybrian]

No chance according to .netters :wink:


Williams - the next Simon Brown

Whittaker - never a right-back - can't defend
McPake - injury prone
Bamba - bombscare
Murphy - no pace

Broonie - too hot-headed
Thomson - Mummies Boy

Shiels - too inconsistent
Zemmama - see Shiels and add in Ramadan

Stokes - dressing room problems
Fletcher - too one footed

:greengrin

[danhibees1875]

Now they are but you get ma drift

Haha aye mate :-P

[hibsfan7]

this team would no bother

herriot
brownlie
black
blackley
shaedler
edwards
stanton
cropley
gordon
o,rourke
duncan

[Pretty Boy]

They would be very close. What bout this one

Colgan

Smith Sauzee fenwick
Lovell Jack O'Neil Russell Uli
Zitelli Mixu

Comfortably.

What a team that was.

[neilmartinrocks]

this team would no bother

herriot
brownlie
black
blackley
shaedler
edwards
stanton
cropley
gordon
o,rourke
duncan

i think that team would could do the treble.

[frazeHFC]

Riordan at his best beats Stokes, Fletcher, GOC, Shiels etc at their best imo.

[VickMackie]

No.

[neilmartinrocks]

Riordan at his best beats Stokes, Fletcher, GOC, Shiels etc at their best imo.

AGREED:aok:

[PISTOL1875]

No chance according to .netters :wink:


Williams - the next Simon Brown

Whittaker - never a right-back - can't defend
McPake - injury prone
Bamba - bombscare
Murphy - no pace

Broonie - too hot-headed
Thomson - Mummies Boy

Shiels - too inconsistent
Zemmama - see Shiels and add in Ramadan

Stokes - dressing room problems
Fletcher - too one footed

:greengrin


YOu have to agree with that bit though ???

[Dinkydoo]

Zibi

Van Zanten
Murdock
Thicot
Kujabi

EDG
Kerr
Jimmy Scott
O'Brien

Konte
Hurtado

...OLE OLE OLE!

Kujabi and Scott don't deserve to be in that side FFS.

[Leishy1995]

Kujabi and Scott don't deserve to be in that side FFS.

Scott definitely not.

[hibsmad]

Riordan at his best beats Stokes, Fletcher, GOC, Shiels etc at their best imo.

As a partnership I certainly would go with Riordan and O'Connor (in their prime) ahead of Fletch and Stokes.

[Andy74]

...................Williams

Whittaker.. McPake.. Bamba.. Murphy

................Broonie.. Thomson

Shiels..................................Zemmama

...........Stokes.....Fletcher.........

subs include;
O'Conner
Griffiths
Hanlon
Ozzy
Miller(liam)
Benji
No.

[Hibercelona]

Zibi

Van Zanten
Murdock
Martis
Edge

EDG
Kerr
Wiss
O'Brien

Konte
Hurtado

...OLE OLE OLE!

There! :grr:

[yekimevol]

...................Williams

Whittaker.. McPake.. Bamba.. Murphy

................Broonie.. Thomson

Shiels..................................Zemmama

...........Stokes.....Fletcher.........

subs include;
O'Conner
Griffiths
Hanlon
Ozzy
Miller(liam)
Benji

.....................Andersson

Whittaker.. McPake.. Murray(1st time).. Murphy

..................Boozy.... Thomson

sproule................Broonie................Rior dan (1st time)

........................O'Conner(1st time)..............

williams
bamba
deano
killen
zemmama
benji
jay shiels (just for that crunching tackle)

[Hibercelona]

.....................Andersson

Whittaker.. McPake.. Murray(1st time).. Murphy

..................Boozy.... Thomson

sproule................Broonie................Rior dan (1st time)

........................O'Conner(1st time)..............

williams
bamba
deano
killen
zemmama
benji
jay shiels (just for that crunching tackle)


I would have Fletcher over O'Connor every time.

Otherwise, pretty decent.

[R'Albin]

...................Williams

Whittaker.. McPake.. Bamba.. Murphy

................Broonie.. Thomson

Shiels..................................Zemmama

...........Stokes.....Fletcher.........

subs include;
O'Conner
Griffiths
Hanlon
Ozzy
Miller(liam)
Benji

That starting 11 is as good as any in the league just now, however the subs are never league winning standard expect for O'Connor when not fat and Liam Miller when not playing like a complete pussy.

If they went an entire season without injuries then yes, if not, no chance.

[Dinkydoo]

I like Kujabi actually. He is very game and seems like a bit of a character. Would rather watch him than a boring clogger of a left back that was equally bad.

Too much of a liability for me at left back, as a left mid he might be better, running down the wing.

[VickMackie]

Too much of a liability for me at left back, as a left mid he might be better, running down the wing.

I don't think he took on a man all game in the final. What goods that if he's to be a winger?

I appreciate the manager may have asked him to play cautious but he could have tried to beat someone during the game.

[Macaroon]

...................Williams

Whittaker.. McPake.. Bamba.. Murphy

................Broonie.. Thomson

Shiels..................................Zemmama

...........Stokes.....Fletcher.........

subs include;
O'Conner
Griffiths
Hanlon
Ozzy
Miller(liam)
Benji

By over 20 points.

[allezsauzee]

Why are we assuming Williams is the man who should be in goals? He might prove to be as bad as Makalamby, Zibi or Simon Brown

[Hibercelona]

Why are we assuming Williams is the man who should be in goals? He might prove to be as bad as Makalamby or Simon Brown

Wee correction there.

Nobody has, is or ever will be as bad as Zibi.

[allezsauzee]

Wee correction there.

Nobody has, is or ever will be as bad as Zibi.


Not much to choose between the 3 of them. I'd have gone with Stack as best of the recent Hibs keepers varying from mediocre to truly dire. Lets hope Ben lives up to expectations

[pacorosssco]

Going on the team where it was at the actual time and players being the age they were then

Mowbray's inherited and built on team would comfortably finish second. If it were the team that won the League Cup they would comfortably finish second> Could they challenge Celtic No they were both too inconsistent. Both side would run current Celtic team close but lose out on squad depth.

[jacomo]

Wee correction there.

Nobody has, is or ever will be as bad as Zibi.

I'd give Zibi a 10 year contract if the alternative was Simon Brown.

[surreyhibbie]

this team would no bother

herriot
brownlie
black
blackley
shaedler
edwards
stanton
cropley
gordon
o,rourke
duncan

No sweat. None at all.

Sigh....

[WindyMiller]

As a partnership I certainly would go with Riordan and O'Connor (in their prime) ahead of Fletch and Stokes.


Only because you never saw O'Rourke and Gordon.




:agree: