Players returning

[Iceman1875]

Who has been the most successful player returning to Hibs after leaving for pastures new? I can think o'connor, sproule, murray, brebner (after loan) riordan with deek proberly being the biggest success.

Also, out of the squad Mowbray had, can you see any of them returning further down the line / end of their career ie fletcher, brown, Thomson, whitty, murphy, jones, Caldwell, boozy! ;-)

[Greentinted]

Michael Weir and Pat McGinlay.

Hard to predict what will be happening in our game in the next few years with the powers-that-be doing their best to endorse and reabsorb Sordid Sevco into the fold presently, and added to our stock (in terms of Scottish football as a whole) being at an all-time low.

Saying that, I would love to see Fletch back someday but methinks I'm overdosing on wishful thinking.

[Cocaine&Caviar]

John Collins?

[Speedy]

Caldwell in my time

[jgl07]

Paul Hartley

Bobby Johnstone

Joe Baker

[Frazerbob]

Paul Hartley

Bobby Johnstone

Joe Baker

Paul Hartley?

[scoopyboy]

Paul Hartley?

returned to haunt us, but that is not the question.

[jgl07]

returned to haunt us, but that is not the question.

He was on an S-form with Hibs before he signed professional terms with Hamilton.

[Cocaine&Caviar]

Saying that, I would love to see Fletch back someday but methinks I'm overdosing on wishful thinking.

One of the ones that left without any Hibs family or geographical connections, so less likely I would imagine.

[scoopyboy]

He was on an S-form with Hibs before he signed professional terms with Hamilton.

Apologies guv, didn't realise that.

[wandering_hibee]

Joe Baker

Pat McGinlay

[Tom Hart RIP]

John Blackley

Peter Cormack

Shades

[Nuitdelune]

Pat McGinlay

I still have a plastic model of Pat on my mantlepiece

[jdships]

Who has been the most successful player returning to Hibs after leaving for pastures new? I can think o'connor, sproule, murray, brebner (after loan) riordan with deek proberly being the biggest success.

Also, out of the squad Mowbray had, can you see any of them returning further down the line / end of their career ie fletcher, brown, Thomson, whitty, murphy, jones, Caldwell, boozy! ;-)

Joe Baker , Pat McGinlay are the two that top my list !!

[fat freddy]

Bobby Smith

[Steve-O]

How many have actually been better in their second spell?

Very few I would suggest.

[CallumLaidlaw]

One of the ones that left without any Hibs family or geographical connections, so less likely I would imagine.

He still comes up regularly tho. Was at the cup final. He's best mates with Jamie mcluskey

[IFONLY]

Dean Shiels!!!!

[muzzhfc]

ian murray and pat mcginley are 2 id from my time. while murray didnt "do" much last season or the one before, when he first rejoined us he was very useful and served his purpose.

[hibee92]

ian murray and pat mcginley are 2 id from my time. while murray didnt "do" much last season or the one before, when he first rejoined us he was very useful and served his purpose.

I'd say the same. Garry O and Deeko were fairly successful personally but Nid done a good job for a wee while.

[Squealing pig]

defo big pat mcginley top. deeks close second. did wee crunchie have two spells?

[brydekirk]

James mcpake

[Squealing pig]

mixu

[--------]

Joe Baker, Pat McGinlay


Them, and Bobby Johnstone, Ian Murray, and Gary Caldwell.