Hibs vs Dun Utd - Player Ratings ?

[The Voice Of Reason]

Wasn't at todays game (or "debacle" by the sounds of things).

Yet another game where we haven't scored......major worry.

Player Ratings would be appreciated please chaps. :aok:

[Hiber-nation]

Stack 5 - some good saves in the first half then yet another blunder for their 2nd
Francomb 5 - did well going forward in 1st half but can't defend to save himself
Doherty 5 - too slow, pure and simple
Hanlon 5 - never strong enough
Kujabi 6 - tried his best and drove on in 2nd half while others hid
Osbourne 2 - pitiful
Claros 2 - just as bad
Stevenson 4 - not good enough today
Soares 2 - hardly touched the ball
Griffiths 4 - hit the bar in 1st half but that was it
O'Donovan 3 - hardly had a sniff

Subs - all 3 gash.

[hibsbollah]

Stack 3 Basic error. again.
Francombe 4 felt sorry for him trying to mark mackay stevens, who is pure quality.
Hanlon 6 much better these days. Tried to hold the sinking ship together.
:doh:erty 4
Kujabi 5


Soares 2
Claros 1
Stevenson 4 not captain material.
Osborne 1 the worst hes played.

Griffiths 6 played well first half
ROD 4 meh.

subs

Garry considering his erse is the size of a small planet, he did ok.

Spoon. i dont want to see him ever again.
Ivan. ran at a defender and got off a shot. thats about it.


The midfield was an embarrassment. This has nothing to do with Fenlon, tactics, fitness. Its a matter of having no personal pride in your job of work. They stopped trying and should be ashamed of themselves.

[Elephant Stone]

Stack 5. Should've stopped their second but had some good saves and good cross takes.

Kujabi 7. Didn't deserve to be on a losing team today. Did everything for himself going forward and never lost determination when others seemed to give up. MOTM.
Doherty 5
Hanlon 6. Needs to cut out the obvious fouls. Distribution wasn't as poor today.
Francomb 4

Soares 0
Stevenson 6
Claros 0
Osbourne 0


O'Donovan 0
Griffiths 6

[Albion Hibs]

Stack 5 - Some very good saves to keep us in the game
Francomb 5 - did well in the first half, did not see him in the 2nd
Doherty 5 - EPL? I dont think so. If his position is RB that is where he should play
Hanlon 6 - Was MOM for me thought he did really well against Daly
Kujabi 5 - tried to get forward, everytime he defends in the box it looks like he is about to give away a pen
Osbourne 4 - Tried, he is not a right midfielder so dont know why we inist on playing him there.
Claros 3 - The player that everyone thought was the next best thing.....a bad day for him
Stevenson 3 - Perhaps the armband effected him
Soares 2 - thought he was poor, but did not think we were anywhere near as good when he went off
Griffiths 4 - Another tryer, unlucky not to score in the first
O'Donovan 3 - ran about

Subs - GOC and Ivan both came on and had as many shots in 30 mins as the rest of the team had in 90, nothing wrong with being direct.

I disagree with those that though Fenlon's tactics were right, I thought they were all wrong. The game was far too open from the first minute, we were playing a team that is much faster on the attack, yet we gave them all the room in the midfield. Give how we can play I dont agree with 2 up front, I would rather one CF and pack the midfield, but more than anything get our better players in the right position, Osborne to start off with.

[At The Edge]

Stack - 5 made some decent saves, still flaps at cross ball, howler for the 2nd

Kujabi - 7 hard to play LB LM at the same time, ran and ran made some good moves, but ashame his teammates were playing at being traffic cones
Hanlon - 6 had an ok game, still panics at points
Doherty - 4 probably the worst i've saw him, i'll put it down to an off day
Francomb - 5 was ok first half, second half not so, tries the world cup pass when a simple ball to keep posession would be better

Ozzy -2 see Doherty, absolute stinker today
Claros -1 poodle, did not want to get involved at all today
Stevenson -5 tried and tried some more, whenn you're the whole midfield itt can be tough
Soares - 2 Brutal, 1st touch is awful, 2nd touch......there was none, the ball had gone with the opposition player

Sparky -5 tried but hoof ball isn't going to get him much success
O'Donovan - tried again, again when you're service is like incoming cruise missiles theres not a lot you can do!

Subs meh!

in all all a very poor Hibs performance and one that i hope is not repeated this season or we will be plying our trade with Livingston and Falkirk etc etc next season

[Spike Mandela]

Stack 4 - poor kick outs and at fault for second.
Francomb 5 - under pressure all the time from Utd wingers
Doherty 5 - not great
Hanlon 5 - really missing McPake
Kujabi 7 - constantly trying and our most creative player
Osbourne 3- the poorest midfield in SPL
Claros 3 - the poorest midfield in SPL
Stevenson 3 - the poorest midfield in SPL
Soares 3 - the poorest midfield in SPL
Griffiths 4 - service from midf.ield non existant
O'Donovan 3 - offers very little

Subs - all 3 uninspired.j

[Beefster]

Stack - 2

Francomb - 3
Doherty - 3
Hanlon - 3
Kujabi - 6

Osbourne - 3
Claros - 3
Stevenson - 3
Soares - 1

Griffiths - 3
O'Donovan - 1

Woeful, spineless and utterly *****.

[DaveF]

Stack - 3 Indecisive as ever, causing mayhem for all around him. Amateur effort for their 2nd

Kujabi - 7 Best player on the park, but that isn't much praise given what was around him.
Hanlon - 6 Reasonable, but lack of communication with Doherty when challenging Daly led to the 1st goal.
Doherty - 5 Some good, some bad.
Francomb - 5 Looks like a player on edge.

Ozzy -1 Possibly the worst he'll ever play (hopefully)
Claros -1 Never in the game. Done nothing of note at all.
Stevenson -5 Tried as ever, but never stood a chance.
Soares - 3 Not as anon as Claros and Osbourne, but ineffective.

Sparky -6 Good effort off the post, plenty running, no service.
O'Donovan - 4 No real impact.

Subs - Every change sent us backwards. Utterly gash.

Unless the midfield get's its arse in gear, we are ****ed.

[woodyloon]

Stack - 3

Francomb - 4
Doherty - 4
Hanlon - 6
Kujabi - 6

Osbourne - 1
Claros - 1
Stevenson - 2
Soares - 1

Griffiths - 3
O'Donovan - 2

[JennaFletcher]

First half...

Stack 6
Francomb 5
Doherty 5
Hanlon 7
Kujabi 8
Osbourne 6
Claros 5
Stevenson 5
Soares 4
Griffiths 6
O'Donovan 4

2nd half...

First half...

Stack 3
Francomb 3
Doherty 3
Hanlon 3
Kujabi 7
Osbourne 3
Claros 3
Stevenson 4
Soares 3
Griffiths 2
O'Donovan 2

Not a good performance at all, though the 1st half was massively more encouraging.

[NAE NOOKIE]

Stack ........... 4 ...... His favourite film must be walk the line, poor kicking and poor effort at 2nd goal.

Kujabi ........ 6 ....... tried and tried but had no support of any quality.

Hanlon ..... 5 ....... Not too bad a game today and coped quite well against Daly.

Doherty ...... 4 ....... average

Francombe .... 4 ..... average

Ozzy ...... 1 ...... woefull, was he feeling ill or something, he is slower than me

Claros ...... 1 ...... If it hadnt been for the purple boots I wouldnt have known he was on the park.

Stevenson ..... 3 ...... If only because he showed more effort than those around him.

Soares ...... 2 ...... cant bring myself to give him the same score as Ozzy and Poodle ... sorry pitbull

Sparky ..... 3 .... ineffctive, tries to do it all himself when he should look for a pass, though to be fair no service to him at all.

O'Donovan ..... 2 .... Not much doing there

Subs ..... 3 .... both Ivan and G'Oc got shots in. Spoony ?

First half we competed OK.

Second half we were utterly utterly gash !!!

[matty_f]

Thought nobody bar Kujabi was worth pass marks today. Abysmal performance.

[Jonnyboy]

Stack - 3 Indecisive as ever, causing mayhem for all around him. Amateur effort for their 2nd

Kujabi - 7 Best player on the park, but that isn't much praise given what was around him.
Hanlon - 6 Reasonable, but lack of communication with Doherty when challenging Daly led to the 1st goal.
Doherty - 5 Some good, some bad.
Francomb - 5 Looks like a player on edge.

Ozzy -1 Possibly the worst he'll ever play (hopefully)
Claros -1 Never in the game. Done nothing of note at all.
Stevenson -5 Tried as ever, but never stood a chance.
Soares - 3 Not as anon as Claros and Osbourne, but ineffective.

Sparky -6 Good effort off the post, plenty running, no service.
O'Donovan - 4 No real impact.

Subs - Every change sent us backwards. Utterly gash.

Unless the midfield get's its arse in gear, we are ****ed.


Thought nobody bar Kujabi was worth pass marks today. Abysmal performance.

Agree with both here

[SteveHFC]

Stack - 1 - Just Awful

Francomb - 2
Doherty - 3
Hanlon - 5
Kujabi - 6

Osbourne - 0
Claros - 0
Stevenson - 3
Soares - 0

Griffiths - 4
O'Donovan - 1

[staunchhibby]

Claros is a wasted space.Has done absolutely nothing considering the hype he brought with him.

[Bad Martini]

I seen griffiths fight to keep a few balls in and run to chase down a good few too. He also was very unlucky smashing the upright in the first half.

That's the only "positives" from an hour and a half in the freezing cold mist and Pish served up as "Fitba".

[Albion Hibs]

Really struggling to understand all this Kujabi love, for the amount of time he spent going forward he delivered nothing into the box, unlike Francomb who actually got up the pitch and produced something, he was also probably the best player in the first half.