Keep or bin for next season?

[R'Albin]

Keepers

Brown
Stack

Defenders

Hart
Booth
Hanlon
O'Hanlon
Murray
Stephens
Towell

Midfielders

Wotherspoon
Galbraith
Scott
Stevenson
Sproule
Palsson
Osbourne

Strikers

O'Connor
Sodje
Griffiths



Doyle
Welsh
Stanton
Taggart
Smith

Out of this lot, who would you keep on for next season? The ones in bold are the ones that I would, and the list at the bottom are guys who I haven't seen play before so can't judge. Left out Agogo and Thornhill as they are basically gone. O'Connor could well be gone as well but I added him in anyway.

[PatHead]

Keep when, this window or for next season?

[R'Albin]

Keep when, this window or for next season?

Oops forgot to add, for next season :aok:

[Scouse Hibee]

Keepers

Brown
Stack

Defenders

Hart Bin
Booth
Hanlon
O'Hanlon
Murray Bin
Stephens
Towell Bin

Midfielders

Wotherspoon Bin
Galbraith Bin
Scott Bin
Stevenson
Sproule Bin
Palsson Bin
Osbourne

Strikers

O'Connor
Sodje Bin
Griffiths



Doyle
Welsh
Stanton
Taggart
Smith

Out of this lot, who would you keep? The ones in bold are the ones that I would, and the list at the bottom are guys who I haven't seen play before so can't judge. Left out Agogo and Thornhill as they are basically gone. O'Connor could well be gone as well but I added him in anyway.

,

[SMAXXA]

Keepers

Brown - Bin
Stack - Bin

Defenders

Hart - Bin
Booth - keep
Hanlon - Bin
O'Hanlon - Bin
Murray - Bin
Stephens - keep
Towell - Bin

Midfielders

Wotherspoon - Bin
Galbraith - Bin
Scott - Bin
Stevenson - Bin
Sproule - Bin
Palsson - Bin
Osbourne - keep

Strikers

O'Connor - keep
Sodje - Bin
Griffiths - keep



Doyle - keep until I can make an informed decision
Welsh - keep until I can make an informed decision
Stanton - keep until I can make an informed decision
Taggart - keep until I can make an informed decision
Smith - keep until I can make an informed decision


The above is purley my view on who I dont think are good enough for a Hibs starting eleven if we are going to make a drastic improvement. Some I have classified as binned may well be kept as a squad player, but not too many to be honest. I could go into the same debates as I have previously posted about why I dont rate players etc so not gona go that again this is purley my bin / keep view in a nutshell :wink:
.
This should be interesting to see the results, no be better with a poll?

[PatHead]

Keepers

Brown
Stack

Defenders

Hart
Booth
Hanlon
O'Hanlon
Murray
Stephens
Towell

Midfielders

Wotherspoon
Galbraith
Scott
Stevenson
Sproule
Palsson
Osbourne

Strikers

O'Connor
Sodje
Griffiths



Doyle
Welsh
Stanton
Taggart
Smith

Have kept more than OP though may change my mind on some of them by the end of the season. Likes of Paulson has shown flashes early on and with right players alongside could still develop. I also think O'Hanlon has improved lately and am still undecided on him. I suppose most of it depends on who we sign to stop us being seen as a soft touch

[Sir David Gray]

At the moment, the only player who deserves to be here next season is Eoin Doyle.

I honestly wouldn't bat an eyelid if anyone else left.

[SMAXXA]

At the moment, the only player who deserves to be here next season is Eoin Doyle.

I honestly wouldn't bat an eyelid if anyone else left.

Bit harsh on the likes of Ozzy I recon mate.

Thing is where im coming from with the likes of Hanlon, Wotherspoon, Stevenson, Galbraith, Hart, Murray Stack etc is when you look at how bad we have been for the last few years, despite the new arrivals we brought in, these guys have been the constants in an absalutley dire Hibs team.

[Albion Hibs]

Brown
Stack

Defenders

Hart
Booth
Hanlon
O'Hanlon
Murray
Stephens
Towell

Midfielders

Wotherspoon
Galbraith
Scott
Stevenson
Sproule
Palsson
Osbourne

Strikers

O'Connor
Sodje
Griffiths

[AlbertK86]

Keepers

Brown - Bin
Stack - Bin

Defenders

Hart - Bin
Booth - keep
Hanlon - Bin
O'Hanlon - Bin
Murray - Bin
Stephens - keep
Towell - Bin

Midfielders

Wotherspoon - Bin
Galbraith - Bin
Scott - Bin
Stevenson - Bin
Sproule - Bin
Palsson - Bin
Osbourne - keep

Strikers

O'Connor - keep
Sodje - Bin
Griffiths - keep



Doyle - keep until I can make an informed decision
Welsh - keep until I can make an informed decision
Stanton - keep until I can make an informed decision
Taggart - keep until I can make an informed decision
Smith - keep until I can make an informed decision


The above is purley my view on who I dont think are good enough for a Hibs starting eleven if we are going to make a drastic improvement. Some I have classified as binned may well be kept as a squad player, but not too many to be honest. I could go into the same debates as I have previously posted about why I dont rate players etc so not gona go that again this is purley my bin / keep view in a nutshell :wink:
.
This should be interesting to see the results, no be better with a poll?

Agree exactly with your picks

[seven nowt]

Keepers

Brown - Keep
Stack - Bin

Defenders

Hart - Bin
Booth - Keep
Hanlon - Keep
O'Hanlon - Bin
Murray - Bin
Stephens - Bin
Towell - Bin

Midfielders

Wotherspoon - Keep
Galbraith - Bin
Scott - Bin
Stevenson - Bin
Sproule - Bin
Palsson - Keep
Osbourne - Keep

Strikers

O'Connor - Keep (Although if he wanted to join another club, I wouldn't be too devastated)
Sodje - Bin
Griffiths - Keep

[Wotherspiniesta]

At the moment, the only player who deserves to be here next season is Eoin Doyle.

I honestly wouldn't bat an eyelid if anyone else left.

Osbourne? :confused:

[Sir David Gray]

Osbourne? :confused:

Maybe.

I would like to see a bit more of him though before making a final decision on him. He's only really played a few games so far.

[Wotherspiniesta]

Keepers

Brown
Stack

Defenders

Hart
Booth
Hanlon
O'Hanlon
Murray
Stephens
Towell

Midfielders

Wotherspoon
Galbraith
Scott
Stevenson
Sproule
Palsson
Osbourne

Strikers

O'Connor
Sodje
Griffiths



Doyle
Welsh
Stanton
Taggart
Smith

[Wotherspiniesta]

Maybe.

I would like to see a bit more of him though before making a final decision on him. He's only really played a few games so far.

Osbourne is the ONLY player in our sqaud with any genuine quality IMO. I'd not only keep him, I'd build the team around him.

[Sergeant Hibs]

Keepers

Brown - Bin
Stack - Keep

Defenders

Hart - Bin
Booth - keep
Hanlon - Bin
O'Hanlon - Bin
Murray - Keep
Stephens - bin
Towell - Keep

Midfielders

Wotherspoon - Keep
Galbraith - Bin
Scott - Bin
Stevenson - Keep
Sproule - Keep
Palsson - Bin
Osbourne - keep

Strikers

O'Connor - keep
Sodje - Bin
Griffiths - Undecided


Doyle - Not seen yet
Welsh - Not seen yet
Stanton - Not seen yet
Taggart - Not seen yet
Smith - Not seen yet

[SMAXXA]

Keepers

Brown - Bin
Stack - Keep

Defenders

Hart - Bin
Booth - keep
Hanlon - Bin
O'Hanlon - Bin
Murray - Keep
Stephens - bin
Towell - Keep

Midfielders

Wotherspoon - Keep
Galbraith - Bin
Scott - Bin
Stevenson - Keep
Sproule - Keep
Palsson - Bin
Osbourne - keep

Strikers

O'Connor - keep
Sodje - Bin
Griffiths - Undecided


Doyle - Not seen yet
Welsh - Not seen yet
Stanton - Not seen yet
Taggart - Not seen yet
Smith - Not seen yet


Interesting all the different views. Im interested to see the reason you would keep Murray over Stephens mate?

[Sergeant Hibs]

Interesting all the different views. Im interested to see the reason you would keep Murray over Stephens mate?

I consider Stephens as a liability and I'm sure I'm not alone and I'd prefer Ian Murray as I could see him going on to take a coaching role

[Aldo]

Easier for me to say who I would keep

Stack (if fit) and Brown

Stephens - see enough to suggest with a better older pro would do ok

Hanlon - been made scapegoat for a lot . Have to remember he has played 3 different positions. Also see Stephens

Booth - as MF

Lewis - about 6 months ago no but in recent performances yes.

Ozzy - clearly our best MF.

GOC - if he bucks the trend and plays for team.

LG - if he continues to play as he did on Mon.

Wootherspoon - possibly if they could find his right position.

In a better team all the above would be good additions to be team

[SMAXXA]

I consider Stephens as a liability and I'm sure I'm not alone and I'd prefer Ian Murray as I could see him going on to take a coaching role

Entitled to ur opimion mate, I on the other hand think hes been one of our best players the last good few games, I agree he can have the od laps but he is gaining experience. I was a bit surprised he was dropped for the derby as altho I like Murray and he was maybe in their for his experience but on form think the big man was a bit hard done by. Especially as he is good in the air.