PDA

View Full Version : Settle a bet for me?



Scònaldò
17-12-2011, 09:08 AM
I'm not too sure where to look for this info so I thought I'd ask on here so any help would be appreciated. What it is, a yam fud in the work is saying that they lot along at the PBS have been to hampden more times than us in the last 20 years, I'm not too sure but I think he's very wrong. Can anyone help me settle this? I thank you. PS. That's including semi finals and finals.

lapsedhibee
17-12-2011, 09:12 AM
That's including semi finals and finals.

If it's close, sneak in the QP match in the big cup.

Jones28
17-12-2011, 10:06 AM
Hibs:

Vs Dunfermaline twice in 2007 (Scottish Cup semi-final)
Vs Killie in March 2007 (CIS Cup Final)
Vs Hearts in April 2006 (Scottish cup semi-final)
Vs Dundee Utd in April 2005 (Scottish cup semi-final)
Vs Livingston in 2003 (CIS cup final)
Vs Rangers in 2003 (CIS cup semi-final)
Vs Aberdeen

Think the Aberdeen game was 1999/2000, not 100% as I was only wee at the time! Sure the rest are accurate though.

Hearts haven't been as many times as us in the last 20 years I think, that list alone is more than them without the League/Skol cup in 91

Makaveli
17-12-2011, 10:11 AM
Hibs:

Vs Dunfermaline twice in 2007 (Scottish Cup semi-final)
Vs Killie in March 2007 (CIS Cup Final)
Vs Hearts in April 2006 (Scottish cup semi-final)
Vs Dundee Utd in April 2005 (Scottish cup semi-final)
Vs Livingston in 2003 (CIS cup final)
Vs Rangers in 2003 (CIS cup semi-final)
Vs Aberdeen

Think the Aberdeen game was 1999/2000, not 100% as I was only wee at the time! Sure the rest are accurate though.

Hearts haven't been as many times as us in the last 20 years I think, that list alone is more than them without the League/Skol cup in 91


Ayr :(
Livingston (SC semi)
Celtic (SC final)

...surely Hibs

bigstu
17-12-2011, 10:28 AM
I was going to say v Rangers in 1993 but that final was played at Celtic Park (i think)

Hibbyradge
17-12-2011, 10:30 AM
Skol Cup final and semi 1991 count?

soupy
17-12-2011, 10:34 AM
I was going to say v Rangers in 1993 but that final was played at Celtic Park (i think)Correct

R'Albin
17-12-2011, 10:48 AM
Hibs:

Vs Dunfermaline twice in 2007 (Scottish Cup semi-final)
Vs Killie in March 2007 (CIS Cup Final)
Vs Hearts in April 2006 (Scottish cup semi-final)
Vs Dundee Utd in April 2005 (Scottish cup semi-final)
Vs Livingston in 2003 (CIS cup final)
Vs Rangers in 2003 (CIS cup semi-final)
Vs Aberdeen

Think the Aberdeen game was 1999/2000, not 100% as I was only wee at the time! Sure the rest are accurate though.

Hearts haven't been as many times as us in the last 20 years I think, that list alone is more than them without the League/Skol cup in 91

Also: Huns (2003 semi finals) and St.Johnstone (2007 semi finals) :aok:

Makaveli
17-12-2011, 10:50 AM
Also: Huns (2003 semi finals) and St.Johnstone (2007 semi finals) :aok:

St Johnstone was at Tynecastle, Huns game is in the list you quoted.

rossevenil
17-12-2011, 10:53 AM
St Johnstone was at Tynie,but definitely the LC Final and Semi Final in 91
and did we not beat Livingston in the SC Semi at Hampden in 2000/2001 season ?


Sorry just seen Makaveli had mentioned Livi game

R'Albin
17-12-2011, 10:54 AM
St Johnstone was at Tynecastle, Huns game is in the list you quoted.

Oops forgot about that! Wasn't thinking.. and I didn't notice the Huns one :rolleyes:

micksoo
17-12-2011, 11:15 AM
Hibs 12

Scottish Cup
Aberdeen 2000
Livingston 2001
Celtic 2001
Hearts 2006
Dunfermline 2007
Dunfermline 2007

League Cup
Rangers 1991
Dunfermline 1991
Ayr 2002
Rangers 2004
Livingston 2004
Kilmarnock 2007

Hearts 11

Scottish Cup
Airdrie 1992
Airdrie 1992
Aberdeen 1996
Rangers 1996
Falkirk 1998
Hearts 1998
Celtic 2005
Hibs 2006
Gretna 2006

League Cup
Rangers 2003
Rangers 2008

Makaveli
17-12-2011, 11:23 AM
Hibs 12

Scottish Cup
Aberdeen 2000
Livingston 2001
Celtic 2001
Hearts 2006
Dunfermline 2007
Dunfermline 2007

League Cup
Rangers 1991
Dunfermline 1991
Ayr 2002
Rangers 2004
Livingston 2004
Kilmarnock 2007

Hearts 11

Scottish Cup
Airdrie 1992
Airdrie 1992
Aberdeen 1996
Rangers 1996
Falkirk 1998
Hearts 1998
Celtic 2005
Hibs 2006
Gretna 2006

League Cup
Rangers 2003
Rangers 2008

You missed out Hibs-Dundee Utd (Scottish Cup, 2005).

Strictly speaking the Skol Cup games were more than 20 years ago, so going by that list it's 11-11...

edit: I'm sure Hearts 1998 semi was at Ibrox and the final at Celtic Park, so Hibs inch it 11-9.

Kammy1875
17-12-2011, 11:25 AM
Hearts won the Scottish at Celtic park. I don't think the semis where there either also the Airdrie games werent at hampden.

Hibbyradge
17-12-2011, 11:31 AM
As has been pointed out earlier in the thread, there's also the Queens Park game.

Your Yam mate is stuffed. :thumbsup:

Scònaldò
17-12-2011, 12:03 PM
As has been pointed out earlier in the thread, there's also the Queens Park game.Your Yam mate is stuffed. :thumbsup:Superb, thank you one and all :)!