I have a 44.4% record when predicting the success of managers. What about you?

[judas]

I have a 44.4% record when predicting the success of managers. What about you? My results are demonstrated below.

Manager/Judas Success Prediction?/ActualSuccess/Outcome

Duff Jim/Yes/No/Wrong
Alex Mcleish/No/Yes/Wrong
God/No/No/Correct
Bobby Williamson/Yes/No/Wrong
Mowbray/Yes/Yes/Correct
Collins/No/No/Correct
Mixu/Yes/No/Wrong
Yogi/No/No/Correct
Calderwood/Yes/No/Wrong
Success Rate 44.44%

[clerriehibs]

I have a 44.4% record when predicting the success of managers. What about you? My results are demonstrated below.

Manager/Judas Success Prediction?/ActualSuccess/Outcome

Duff Jim/Yes/No/Wrong
Alex Mcleish/No/Yes/Wrong
God/No/No/Correct
Bobby Williamson/Yes/No/Wrong
Mowbray/Yes/Yes/Correct
Collins/No/No/Correct
Mixu/Yes/No/Wrong
Yogi/No/No/Correct
Calderwood/Yes/No/Wrong
Success Rate 44.44%

When do you predict, though? A prediction the day before the new manager is appointed is a safer bet than a prediction on the day the previous incumbent gets booted.

[judas]

When do you predict, though? A prediction the day before the new manager is appointed is a safer bet than a prediction on the day the previous incumbent gets booted.

After some initial doubts, I am throwing my hat in with Fenlon.

I get the same feeling about him, I got with Mowbray.

I like the guys manner - he looks edgy. If I can judge a character (and at 44.4% you may wonder), I think he might just be the man. I can seehim ripping some throats out in the dressing room once he gets going. I would LOVE hims to get on with Brown - that could be a great combo.

Currently I am envisaging complete and utter domination over Hearts in the coming years.

[Beefster]

Duff Jim/Yes/No/Wrong
Alex Mcleish/Yes/Yes/Correct
God/Yes/No/Wrong
Bobby Williamson/No/No/Correct
Mowbray/Yes/Yes/Correct
Collins/Yes/No/Wrong
Mixu/No/No/Correct
Yogi/No/No/Correct
Calderwood/Yes/No/Wrong
Success Rate 55.56%

56% Who da man?

[judas]

Duff Jim/Yes/No/Wrong
Alex Mcleish/Yes/Yes/Correct
God/Yes/No/Wrong
Bobby Williamson/No/No/Correct
Mowbray/Yes/Yes/Correct
Collins/Yes/No/Wrong
Mixu/No/No/Correct
Yogi/No/No/Correct
Calderwood/Yes/No/Wrong
Success Rate 55.56%

56% Who da man?

Damn you (he he!). Not quite Nostradamus, but certainly respectable.

[Dashing Bob S]

Duff Jim/No/No/Correct
Alex Mcleish/Yes/Yes/Correct
God/No/No/Correct
Bobby Williamson/Yes/No/Wrong
Mowbray/No/Yes/Wrong
Collins/Yes/No/Wrong
Mixu/No/No/Correct
Yogi/Yes/No/wrong
Calderwood/No/No/Correct
Success Rate 56%

[allezsauzee]

think you are being harsh on yourself. i think williamson was a better manager than the ginger judas

[Iggy Pope]

I have a 44.4% record when predicting the success of managers. What about you? My results are demonstrated below.

Manager/Judas Success Prediction?/ActualSuccess/Outcome

Duff Jim/Yes/No/Wrong
Alex Mcleish/No/Yes/Wrong
God/No/No/Correct
Bobby Williamson/Yes/No/Wrong
Mowbray/Yes/Yes/Correct
Collins/No/No/Correct
Mixu/Yes/No/Wrong
Yogi/No/No/Correct
Calderwood/Yes/No/Wrong
Success Rate 44.44%

Collins was not a success? Despite winning more silverware than the rest put together and the same as more than a few before that.
I think you're 44% is actually a bit generous as you have that wrong.
And Yogi got the same European qualification as two other successes in the shape of Mowbray and McLeish so maybe the criteria is wrong? What is a success when basically, they've all been ****ing bollox.

[ekhibee]

I said Hughes and Calderwood would both be pish, guess that makes me 100% right?

[HibbiesandtheBaddies]

Define success :nerd:

[HibeeMG]

Duff Jim/No/No/Correct (Bald managers never work!)
Alex Mcleish/Yes/Yes/Correct
God/Yes/No/Wrong
Bobby Williamson/No/No/Correct
Mowbray/Yes/Yes/Correct
Collins/Yes/No/Wrong (as with Le God, never let your heroes manage the club!)
Mixu/No/No/Correct
Yogi/No/No/Correct
Calderwood/Yes/No/Wrong
Success Rate 62.50%

[Lucius Apuleius]

Never rated Duff.
Thank McLeish for bringing Le God, apart from that, team was declining. Ginger prick.
Le God (not God, there is only one), should have been given a lot more time.
Blobby, boring
Mowbray, good
Collins, wish he had stayed but some p1ss poor signings
Mixu, wrong appointment
Yogi, wrong appointment
CC, wrong appointment

Out of them all, I wish Le God had been given the time to do something.

[Beefster]

think you are being harsh on yourself. i think williamson was a better manager than the ginger judas

I concur. Never mind 6-2, 0-3, AEK, Sauzee, Latapy or reaching a SC Final, give me a turgid 4-1 loss at home to Dunfermline every time.