Greatest Scottish Album - Vote Proclaimers

[SouthMoroccoStu]

http://entertainment.stv.tv/tv/268153-claire-grogan-to-present-stvs-scotlands-greatest-album/

We need to all get together and vote for Sunshine on Leith.

Fantasic album and craig and charlie are one of our own.

[Iain G]

http://entertainment.stv.tv/tv/268153-claire-grogan-to-present-stvs-scotlands-greatest-album/

We need to all get together and vote for Sunshine on Leith.

Fantasic album and craig and charlie are one of our own.

Looks like you vote for the favourite songs and some compilation of the highest votes goes together...I suspect it will result it a really awful album of populist music, which is a shame given how good the Scottish indie scene has been over the years... :agree:

[KWJ]

My favourite would probably be malcolm middleton's a brighter beat tbh.

[heretoday]

Anything by Alex Harvey or the Incredible String Band. Hibby Hippies!

[Hibee87]

I would say the best scottish album is probibly glasvegas :agree:

[basehibby]

http://entertainment.stv.tv/tv/268153-claire-grogan-to-present-stvs-scotlands-greatest-album/

We need to all get together and vote for Sunshine on Leith.

Fantasic album and craig and charlie are one of our own.

It is a great album! But I would refuse to vote for favourite music on the basis of what fitba team the artists support - entirely separate thing IMO.

Charlie and Craig would have a load of artists to lock horns with for the honour including The Sensational Alex Harvey Band, Gerry Raferty, Big Country, the Rezillos, Average White Band, Associates, Orange Juice, Lulu, The Skids, most of AC/DC and many more.

[Iain G]

It is a great album! But I would refuse to vote for favourite music on the basis of what fitba team the artists support - entirely separate thing IMO.

Charlie and Craig would have a load of artists to lock horns with for the honour including The Sensational Alex Harvey Band, Gerry Raferty, Big Country, the Rezillos, Average White Band, Associates, Orange Juice, Lulu, The Skids, most of AC/DC and many more.

Plenty of good Scottish music after 1987 as well you know ;)

[SkintHibby]

Anything by RUNRIG.

And I think The Proclaimers first album was much better than SOL.

[JoeTortolanoFanClub]

Looks like you vote for the favourite songs and some compilation of the highest votes goes together...I suspect it will result it a really awful album of populist music, which is a shame given how good the Scottish indie scene has been over the years... :agree:

Tinseltown in the Rain by The Blue Nile for me :thumbsup:

[Hiber-nation]

Looks like you vote for the favourite songs and some compilation of the highest votes goes together...I suspect it will result it a really awful album of populist music, which is a shame given how good the Scottish indie scene has been over the years... :agree:

:agree:

Real Radio are associated with this competition which makes me think you won't get far past Lulu, Texas and Wet Wet Wet sadly.

[suavegav]

http://entertainment.stv.tv/tv/268153-claire-grogan-to-present-stvs-scotlands-greatest-album/

We need to all get together and vote for Sunshine on Leith.

Fantasic album and craig and charlie are one of our own.
hipsway by hipsway is the best in my opinion

[Forthview]

Anything off Psychocandy must be a winner, The Jesus and Mary Chain for the young indie boys looking in.:not worth

[Carheenlea]

Waste of time this competition.

Everyone knows that "Philophobia" by Arab Strap is the best.

[HibsCan]

Simple Minds....the band....not you lot :wink:

[SkintHibby]

hipsway by hipsway is the best in my opinion

Forgot about that - FANTASTIC album!:agree:

[CraigK]

Sorry, but whilst The Proclaimers are brilliant, musically i would have to vote for either The Mary Chain, Idlewild or Josef K.

Ps, how hot does Clare Grogan look in that picture?!

[Jonnyboy]

http://entertainment.stv.tv/tv/268153-claire-grogan-to-present-stvs-scotlands-greatest-album/

We need to all get together and vote for Sunshine on Leith.

Fantasic album and craig and charlie are one of our own.

Actually they're two of our own

signed

A Pedant :greengrin

[Judas Iscariot]

I would say the best scottish album is probibly glasvegas :agree:

They are actually awful :taxi

[micka_weer]

Enjoying "liver lung" by frightened rabbit very much just now

[nonshinyfinish]

Waste of time this competition.

Everyone knows that "Philophobia" by Arab Strap is the best.

Indeed it is. :agree:

[hibsbollah]

Teenage Fanclub's 'Bandwagonesque'. FACT.

[nonshinyfinish]

Teenage Fanclub's 'Bandwagonesque'. FACT.

Not even the best Fannies album. ALSO FACT!

[howdenthehibby]

Galus by GUN

[Hamish]

This should really be no contest as the best album from a Scottish group in the last 40 years is Average White Band - 'White Album'

[Malthibby]

The Alexander Brothers 'A Highland Tribute.' Magical.
GG

[Granton Stanton]

Not even the best Fannies album. ALSO FACT!

Agree. Grand Prix for me

[hibsbollah]

Not even the best Fannies album. ALSO FACT!

OK, Thirteen or Songs from Northern Britain are more polished and produced but none of them have bandwagonesques energy and wahwah distorted guitars. Double FACT. Fact Fact infact.

[nonshinyfinish]

OK, Thirteen or Songs from Northern Britain are more polished and produced but none of them have bandwagonesques energy and wahwah distorted guitars. Double FACT. Fact Fact infact.

Production aside, Grand Prix and SFNB (and arguably Thirteen) just have better songs on them.

Don't get me wrong though, Bandwagonesque is great. And that IS a fact.

[WestStandhibee]

primal scream - screamadelica :thumbsup:

[pacorosssco]

primal scream - screamadelica :thumbsup:

well said that man.

:top marks

[hibsbollah]

Production aside, Grand Prix and SFNB (and arguably Thirteen) just have better songs on them.

Don't get me wrong though, Bandwagonesque is great. And that IS a fact.

I love em all so i actually dont know what im arguing about :greengrin

[Hillsidehibby]

Tinseltown in the Rain by The Blue Nile for me :thumbsup:


From the most excellent album A Walk Across The Rooftops.

[Geo_1875]

Love and Money got to be in with a shout.

[.Sean.]

Screamadelica.