PDA

View Full Version : I am a Hibs player - get me out of here - who should stay ? Who should go ? Vote now!



GreenCastle
25-01-2011, 11:52 AM
Based on I am a "Celebrity get me out of here"

Lot's of views on here.

So who would you keep ?

Who deserves to be kept ? (offered a new contract maybe)

Who has the potential to be kept for the future ?

VOTE NOW :greengrin

pacorosssco
25-01-2011, 12:06 PM
Sadly id let murray go as seems to be finished . maybe could gain a reprieve at centre half.

Id keep zemmama and miller if not too expensive to see how they work out with better players around.

apart from youngsters and mark brown and riorden the rest of the senior players can go

GreenCastle
25-01-2011, 12:10 PM
Murray is a tough one - I think I would keep him as he loves the club and on the bench could be the type of player if we were 1v0 up would come on and hopefully calm the younger players.

Zemmama yes - give him a good pre season and on his day can be unplayable - we know he won't do it every week but this is the SPL we are playing in.

Pretty Boy
25-01-2011, 12:18 PM
Brown, Thicot, Hanlon, Stephens, Zemmama, Miller, Wotherspoon, Byrne, Duffy and Riordan for me.

The rest can go. I'd probably let a couple of the ones i'd keep go as well if better option became available.

GreenCastle
25-01-2011, 01:49 PM
So far as expected pretty much.

I think there must be a few undercover yams voting too :jamboid:

Diclonius
25-01-2011, 02:02 PM
Brown - Stay - Best keeper we've had in years.
Stack - Go - Too many injury problems. We can do better.
Smith - Go - :faf:
Thicot - Go - If he was going to become a regular it would have happened before now.
Hart - Go - Sadly doesn't seem to be up to it.
Dickoh - Stay - Probably the best defender we have at the club right now.
Hanlon - Stay - This guy could go on to be magnificent.
Stephens - Stay - Youngster and has looked pretty good from what I've seen of him.
Hogg - Go - His form has plummeted since Jones left.
Booth - Stay - Youngster.
Murray - Go - Sadly I think he's finished. All the best Ian.
Zemmama - Stay - The most technically gifted player we have, bar none.
Miller - Go - Pathetic attitude, and he's been awful for well over a year.
McBride - Stay - The only midfielder we have who can pass a ball.
de Graaf - Go - Flattered to decieve.
Rankin - Go - He works hard but his technical ability just isn't good enough.
Stevenson - Stay - Giving this guy another chance, he's shown glimpses in the last few months that he can reach his cup final form.
Galbraith - Stay - Looks a good prospect.
Wotherspoon - Stay - Again, a good prospect.
Welsh - Stay - Youngster, our most promising player in years if we are to be believed.
Trakys - Go - Obviously a panic singing by Yogi and while he has had a couple of good games, we can do better.
Byrne - Stay - Promising youngster.
Duffy - Go - This season's Alan Gow anyone?
Riordan - Stay - Terrible attitude but he can change a game.
Nish - Go - An excellent player on his day - which is about one in ten. Far too inconsistent.

iwasthere1972
25-01-2011, 02:14 PM
So far as expected pretty much.

I think there must be a few undercover yams voting too :jamboid:

9 to be exact. Well what Hibby would vote for de Graaf staing at ER? Thought not.

jonny
25-01-2011, 02:18 PM
3 votes for Smith :hijack:

HibsMax
25-01-2011, 02:23 PM
Just looked at the results so far.

Looks like we should keep everyone.

Opinions, eh? :wink:

GreenCastle
25-01-2011, 02:29 PM
Just looked at the results so far.

Looks like we should keep everyone.

Opinions, eh? :wink:

We are keeping the ones who get the majority :wink::greengrin

smurf
25-01-2011, 02:30 PM
Brown Retain. Should be our automatic number one.

Stack Bye. George Street will miss him...

Smith Bye.

Thicot Bye. All the best.

Hart Bye. Apparently this guy had pace? Unbelievably bad signing from Hughes. Finished.

Dickoh Undecided?

Hanlon Retain. Definitely.

Stevens Don't know enough to comment.

Hogg Bye. All the best Hoggy. A great professional. Always gave 110% but time to move on.

Booth Retain. Definitely.

Murray Mmmm... Retain as a squad player but the legs...

Zemmama Would love to retain. But his actual appearance stats in his 5 years at the club tell the story. Unless reasonable on wage demands let go. He's definitely not IMHO in the Derek Riordan exceptional case scenario...

Miller Bye. Premiership? My backside. Imposter. Lazy. Half hearted. Not interested...

McBride Bye.

De Graff Bye. Hart category...

Rankin Bye. Petrie!!!:greengrin

Stevenson Bye. Always liked Lewis. All the best wee man.

Galbraith Undecided...

Wotherspoon Definitely Retain.

Welsh Don't know enough?

Trakys Bye. See Hart and De Graff...

Byrne Not convinced?

Duffy Not convinced?

Riordan Absoluitely retain.

Nish Bye. Petrie!!!:greengrin In fairness not nearly as bad as some make out. But for all concerned a move would be a good thing.

Jim44
25-01-2011, 03:23 PM
Like an idiot, I did not read the post properly and voted for the players I wanted to see leaving the club. Can't do anything about it now though.

Hiber-nation
25-01-2011, 03:29 PM
Like an idiot, I did not read the post properly and voted for the players I wanted to see leaving the club. Can't do anything about it now though.

Obviously you're not the only one as Smith, Thicot, Hart, Rankin, Nish and De Graaf all have at least 7 votes....in fact Thicot has 30! Unbelievable...

GreenCastle
25-01-2011, 03:55 PM
Like an idiot, I did not read the post properly and voted for the players I wanted to see leaving the club. Can't do anything about it now though.

:greengrin

Looks like Wootherspoon has broken the 100 person fan club mark :agree:

Fergus52
25-01-2011, 04:36 PM
typical of hibs fans that liam miller has that many votes.

apart from the start of last season he has been murder and will be one of our highest earners, eating up alot of our wage buget.

ClewsHibs
25-01-2011, 04:39 PM
Like an idiot, I did not read the post properly and voted for the players I wanted to see leaving the club. Can't do anything about it now though.

same with me :doh:

Purehibee_MYB
25-01-2011, 04:44 PM
I misread and voted players to go...ooops.. :offski:

(((Fergus)))
25-01-2011, 04:49 PM
3 votes for Smith :hijack:


i go mixed up and voted for all those who should go. :doh:

looks like a few others did too.