PDA

View Full Version : Hughes, Mixu, Collins - Stats??



Craig_in_Prague
03-10-2010, 09:28 AM
Guess they've all had about the same time period as Hibs manager.

Can any of our statos, please inform the W/L/D performance of these 3 managers?

Personally I don' think Any of them were good enough and we need to find a new manager and direction.

They all had decent starts as managers, but interested in their results as a whole whilst in charge.

BroxburnHibee
03-10-2010, 09:31 AM
Collins - W23 D15 L16

Mixu - W19 D18 L25

Yogi - W19 D12 L22


Courtesy of iHibs.co.uk

HFC 0-7
03-10-2010, 09:49 AM
Collins - W23 D15 L16

Mixu - W19 D18 L25

Yogi - W19 D12 L22


Courtesy of iHibs.co.uk

Collins win rate was 42.59%, Mixu's, 30.64% and Yogi's is 35.85%.

When you look at that it shows Collins, record was pretty special. Mowbray had 48.15% and Mcleish had 47.24%. Eddie Turnbull had a win rate of 48.24%.

This shows you how bad Yogi and Mixu are in contrast to our 'successful' managers. It also shows how strange peoples views are on Collins as his win rate is pretty good and he brought us a trophy!

Just because I want shot of him, since february, Yogi's win rate (28games) has been 17.85%, the previous 25 games of his tenure showed a win rate of 56%. Something went wrong!

(((Fergus)))
03-10-2010, 10:24 AM
Collins win rate was 42.59%, Mixu's, 30.64% and Yogi's is 35.85%.

When you look at that it shows Collins, record was pretty special. Mowbray had 48.15% and Mcleish had 47.24%. Eddie Turnbull had a win rate of 48.24%.

This shows you how bad Yogi and Mixu are in contrast to our 'successful' managers. It also shows how strange peoples views are on Collins as his win rate is pretty good and he brought us a trophy!

Just because I want shot of him, since february, Yogi's win rate (28games) has been 17.85%, the previous 25 games of his tenure showed a win rate of 56%. Something went wrong!

Indeed it did! *cough* dropping Maka *cough*

Interestingly, Collins had a win rate during his first 25 games of 56% too. The difference with Collins is that he had a slump at the end of his first season then another winning run at the start of the next (66% over first 12 games). Mixu just gradually petered out over his tenure, like Chinese water torture. Yogi, as you say, did phenomenally well then just crashed and burned from February.

In terms of average points won per game, they line up as follows:

TM: 1.59 points per game
JC: 1.56
JH: 1.28
MP: 1.25

The benchmarks (league winners) were as follows:
09/10: 2.29 points per game
08/09: 2.26
07/08: 2.34
06/07: 2.21
05/06: 2.39

Green_one
03-10-2010, 10:37 AM
Indeed it did! *cough* dropping Maka *cough*

Interestingly, Collins had a win rate during his first 25 games of 56% too. The difference with Collins is that he had a slump at the end of his first season then another winning run at the start of the next (66% over first 12 games). Mixu just gradually petered out over his tenure, like Chinese water torture. Yogi, as you say, did phenomenally well then just crashed and burned from February.


To be fair, Collins inherited a very good group of players, which included 6 worth over £11M in total. Collins did have harder gaqmes in that he played two semis and a final. Hughes may have played in Europe but he also had the easiest cup run in Hibs post war history.