Who do you want as first choice keeper?

[SHODAN]

Stack, Smith or Brown. Simples.

[burghhibs]

Stack, Smith or Brown. Simples.

Anyone but Smith, never want to see him in a Hibs top Again

[Hibercelona]

Anyone but Smith, never want to see him in a Hibs top Again

Why? Whats Smith done wrong? :dunno:

Stack was first in line and hasn't done all too bad, so i'd stick with him first to see how he continues.

[degenerated]

Why? Whats Smith done wrong? :dunno:

Stack was first in line and hasn't done all too bad, so i'd stick with him first to see how he continues.

Motherwell 6-6 ring any bells :greengrin

[Jaz]

Where's the "Someone (anyone) else" option?

[Chuckie]

David Grof

[Hibercelona]

Motherwell 6-6 ring any bells :greengrin

Indeed. He's been the keeper in a few shockers.

But looking at the goals, I find it hard to blame him for a vast majority of them.

I'd still Stick with Stacks though. He does look the most comfortable.

And besides.... he hooks people. :greengrin

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yXxChycLh3k

[Danderhall Hibs]

The best chance of another top Hib's goalie being between the posts has left the building. We effectively don't have a goalie!

We could always get Maka back? Still without a club I believe?....

[IWasThere2016]

Stack for me

[HibbyAndy]

Mark Brown for me. With Stack number 2.

[Ritchie]

To be honest I don't think there is too much difference between the 3 of them.

So I'm not really fussed who is first choice.

[Calvin]

We could always get Maka back? Still without a club I believe?....

I know you joke but I'm the tiny minority that would still have him between the sticks :tin hat:

I've not seen Brown play yet, and Stack and Smith I'm fairly indifferent towards. I wouldn't be gutted to see any of them play, but none of the three stand out as a definite pick.

[sahib]

Stack, Smith or Brown. Simples.

Out of that four, it has got to be Simples for me. The others have had their chances.

[blackpoolhibs]

We could always get Maka back? Still without a club I believe?....

Thats a shock. :devil::tin hat::stirrer:

[blackpoolhibs]

I know that.. You know that .. Unfortunately the manager hasn't spotted it. And we're all supposed to put our hands in our pockets and support a buffoon of a manager that's the only guy on the planet that can't see it?

Sniff sniff.

[allezsauzee]

Smith had a bit of a nightmare against Motherwell and didn't look clever against Hearts, however the defence were a bit of shambles in both games as well. Plus Yogi can't exactly have filled him with confidence when he dropped him because Bamba didn't like having him in goals. I dont think there's much to choose between him and Stack tbh. Brown hasn't played any competitive games for us so I can't really choose him above 2 decent if not brilliant keepers.

[TamHibs]

I would give Brown the jersey - wasn't so long ago he kept the most clean sheets on the league (whilst at ICT I believe?)


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[Pretty Boy]

I know that.. You know that .. Unfortunately the manager hasn't spotted it. And we're all supposed to put our hands in our pockets and support a buffoon of a manager that's the only guy on the planet that can't see it?

Good to see you have written Brown of after a couple of friendlies.

If only we still had Maka doing his 6ft 5 fairy act all would be well in the world eh?

[SHODAN]

Out of that four, it has got to be Simples for me. The others have had their chances.

Yeah, sorry mate. Forgot to add him to the poll. :grr: