Apologies if any one else has posted this already but ...

[Gala Foxes]

do we really want to see Hibs players "winning" "penalties" like that

[matty_f]

do we really want to see Hibs players "winning" "penalties" like that

I thought he fell over, rather than dived to be honest. Got a text from one of my Yam mates who was watching on tv and he said the same.

[greenlex]

do we really want to see Hibs players "winning" "penalties" like that

I havent seen it on TV but I dont think he dived did he? I thought he was on his way down and the ref gave it. Did he dive looking for a pen or what?

[Hainan Hibs]

against that bunch, yes.

[HONG KONG PHOOEY]

I thought he fell over, rather than dived to be honest. Got a text from one of my Yam mates who was watching on tv and he said the same.

Correct he tripped. did not dive did not claim for a penalty.

[matty_f]

against that bunch, yes.

:greengrin Fair point.

[johnbc70]

Was not a penalty but he never dived, unlike the hearts player who dived in front of the West Lower and started laughing when the linesman gave him the free kick.

[paxtonhibby]

do we really want to see Hibs players "winning" "penalties" like that

Eh,JR tried to stay on his feet after being clipped.Christ,the team was bad enough without bringing "simulation" into the mix.Or maybe you were in the south with a poor view?

[Gala Foxes]

fair play, he didn't dive but equally it was never a pen

[Sir David Gray]

I was right in line with it and I was shocked when I saw McDonald pointing to the spot.

It was never a penalty but I don't believe Rankin dived.

[Gala Foxes]

have watched their goals 3 time on Sky Sports news now - how bad were they

[marinello59]

do we really want to see Hibs players "winning" "penalties" like that

Garbage thread of the season

[Gala Foxes]

Garbage thread of the season

no probs, happy to take the flack, never a pen but against them I suppose you take them all.
, glad it wasnt against us though, imagine the backlash

[Hainan Hibs]

no probs, happy to take the flack, never a pen but against them I suppose you take them all.
, glad it wasnt against us though, imagine the backlash

Aye true, I think .net would've been in meltdown if that had been wee Susan in the Hibs box.

[HONG KONG PHOOEY]

Aye true, I think .net would've been in meltdown if that had been wee Susan in the Hibs box.

Why because the ref mad a bad decision ? Surely you cannot blame Rankin for the penalty ?

[Gala Foxes]

Why because the ref mad a bad decision ? Surely you cannot blame Rankin for the penalty ?

not a case of blame, just stating the obvious, never a pen

[dawn]

not a case of blame, just stating the obvious, never a pen
Don't understand the point.
No one here is saying it was a penalty, What exactly should we have done, refuse to take it?:faf:

[Gala Foxes]

Don't understand the point.
No one here is saying it was a penalty, What exactly should we have done, refused to take it?:faf:

okay , my fault ,lets shut down the thread, just pissed off that today was so bad that even our goal shouldn't really even have been a goal

[dawn]

okay , my fault ,lets shut down the thread, just pissed off that today was so bad that even our goal shouldn't really even have been a goal

Aye, IMO the op is a crap point, but imagining us refusing to take a penalty because it wasn't a penalty, that is funny!:greengrin