PDA

View Full Version : Question Hat trick


Jonnyboy
18-02-2010, 11:07 PM
Can you name the Hibs player that scored a hat trick against Bayern Munich? :wink:
iwasthere1972
18-02-2010, 11:51 PM
Can you name the Hibs player that scored a hat trick against Bayern Munich? :wink:

No. :doh:
MWHIBBIES
18-02-2010, 11:59 PM
Can you name the Hibs player that scored a hat trick against Bayern Munich? :wink:Can you?
iwasthere1972
19-02-2010, 12:31 AM
Can you name the Hibs player that scored a hat trick against Bayern Munich? :wink:

C'mon Doddie waken up and put us out of our misery. I've got to be up at 7. :grr:


:greengrin
hibbybrian
19-02-2010, 03:56 AM
Can you name the Hibs player that scored a hat trick against Bayern Munich? :wink:

Scored in Germany too :thumbsup:

Surname began with S - turned out to be "not Hibs Class" and was punted to the Jambos though :wink:
Baldy Foghorn
19-02-2010, 07:47 AM
Scored in Germany too :thumbsup:

Surname began with S - turned out to be "not Hibs Class" and was punted to the Jambos though :wink:

shevlane??:confused:
lapsedhibee
19-02-2010, 08:11 AM
shevlane??:confused:

Think Chris Shevlane was at the PBS before ER, rather than the other way round.

Surname began with S, perhaps best ever player ... I'll say ... Murdo McLeod.
H18sry
19-02-2010, 08:22 AM
:confused:Smith
Baldy Foghorn
19-02-2010, 08:28 AM
Think Chris Shevlane was at the PBS before ER, rather than the other way round.

Surname began with S, perhaps best ever player ... I'll say ... Murdo McLeod.

So who was he with when he scored the hat trick? Dundee, Drumcondra??
hibbybrian
19-02-2010, 10:19 AM
So who was he with when he scored the hat trick? Dundee, Drumcondra??


Can you name the Hibs player that scored a hat trick (playing for Hibs) against Bayern Munich? :wink:

I reckon that's what Johnnyboy means :wink:


:confused:Smith

not Gordon Smith, although he did score a goal for Hibs against Bayern Munich :thumbsup:
Jonnyboy
19-02-2010, 11:20 AM
Scored in Germany too :thumbsup:

Surname began with S - turned out to be "not Hibs Class" and was punted to the Jambos though :wink:

Can there actually be two players that achieved this Brian? The May '49 one I don't have scorers for and my question relates to May '60 :greengrin
davebt
19-02-2010, 12:27 PM
In the May 49 game Gordon Smith scored 2 Reilly, Souness & Ormond scored one each. Don't have details of the other scorer.

For the May 1960 game the the Handbook edition of the programme issued against Hearts lists the scorers as Jock Buchanan with 2 and Johnny McLeod the other scorer. The cover of the newspaper/programme issued for the game is here (http://hibsprogrammes.co.uk/html/600512bm.html)
Jonnyboy
19-02-2010, 12:32 PM
In the May 49 game Gordon Smith scored 2 Reilly, Souness & Ormond scored one each. Don't have details of the other scorer.

For the May 1960 game the the Handbook edition of the programme issued against Hearts lists the scorers as Jock Buchanan with 2 and Johnny McLeod the other scorer. The cover of the newspaper/programme issued for the game is here (http://hibsprogrammes.co.uk/html/600512bm.html)

The Scotsman newpaper match report of the May '60 game tells a different story so my question may be invalid.

Now I like the Hibs Handbook and I like the Scotsman but which is right?

There's only one way to find out

Fiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiight

:greengrin
hibbybrian
19-02-2010, 01:33 PM
In the May 49 game Gordon Smith scored 2 Reilly, Souness & Ormond scored one each. Don't have details of the other scorer.

For the May 1960 game the the Handbook edition of the programme issued against Hearts lists the scorers as Jock Buchanan with 2 and Johnny McLeod the other scorer. The cover of the newspaper/programme issued for the game is here (http://hibsprogrammes.co.uk/html/600512bm.html)

The first match was on 12th May 1950 - I have a scan of the German newspaper with the match report which lists the scorers as:

Souness (8') Ormond (40') Souness (51') Smith (68') Souness (75') and Johnstone (78')

5456

These scorers are also listed on one of the databases - probably from another source.

The data I have on the 1960 game is as per Dave's post - I don't have the Scotsman report :grr:
Bayern Bru
19-02-2010, 01:45 PM
Jim Souness was my bet...
chinny baxter
19-02-2010, 02:16 PM
Kenny ALLISON
hibbybrian
19-02-2010, 02:23 PM
Kenny ALLISON

Kenny Allison scored in a 3-0 win over Bayern Munich at ER in September 1958 - the other scorers are listed as Turnbull and an OG
davebt
19-02-2010, 03:26 PM
The Scotsman newpaper match report of the May '60 game tells a different story so my question may be invalid.

Now I like the Hibs Handbook and I like the Scotsman but which is right?

There's only one way to find out

Fiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiight

:greengrin

:hilarious

here's another one. The Hibs programme for the game against Bayern in November 60 has a run down on the previous games and lists the scorers in the 1950 tour game as Reilly, Ormond, Souness, Smith 2 and Johnstone. here (http://hibsprogrammes.co.uk/601123.html)
chinny baxter
19-02-2010, 03:42 PM
Did we not get fed up beating Bayern:wink:
PeeJay
19-02-2010, 03:44 PM
Did we not get fed up beating Bayern:wink:

Impossible - nobody can get fed up beating Bayern! :agree:
iwasthere1972
19-02-2010, 03:46 PM
Did we not get fed up beating Bayern:wink:

:agree: Think that's how the war started.
Jonnyboy
20-02-2010, 07:52 PM
In the May 49 game Gordon Smith scored 2 Reilly, Souness & Ormond scored one each. Don't have details of the other scorer.

For the May 1960 game the the Handbook edition of the programme issued against Hearts lists the scorers as Jock Buchanan with 2 and Johnny McLeod the other scorer. The cover of the newspaper/programme issued for the game is here (http://hibsprogrammes.co.uk/html/600512bm.html)

Had another look at the Scotsman report Dave and it says Buchanan scored all three with one of those a tap in after McLeod had hit the post.