Non OF Squad

[CallumLaidlaw]

If you were a manager, and you were able to pick a squad of 22 players (2 for each position) from the "other 10" teams in the league, who would you pick.
I definitely can't think of all of these ar 07.43 in the morning, so was interested in seeing how the squad progressed as more people put their suggestions in.
Off the top of my head -

GK
Nicky Weaver
??? (Stack/Maka/Ruddy/Gallacher??)
LB
Lee Wallce
Ian Murray

RB
???
???

CB
Andy Webster
Sol Bamba
Goncalves
???

LM
Andy Driver
???

RM
Zemmama
???

CM
Liam Miller
???
???
???

CF
Anthony Stokes
Derek Riordan
???
???

Thoughts?

[Barney McGrew]

If it's being based on current form, then I'd have Charlie Mulgrew, Murray Davidson and Kevin Kyle in there too.

McBride also has to be a shoe-in.

[KWJ]

Thon Motherwell boy on loan from Everton. Jutkeivicz

Forbes
Mikey Stewart would probably be around there.
Gomis
Bauben.
Sandaza
James McArthur
Cerny
Jody Morris?
Taouil.
James Fowler perhaps.
Lee Dixon
Craig Conway

And of course, every Hibee.

[Hibs90]

GK
Makalambay
Balogh

LB
Lee Wallce
Ian Murray

RB
Moutoakill
Wotherspoon

CB
Sol Bamba
Goncalves
Webster
Ifil

LM
Andy Driver
Jim O'Brien

RM
Zemmama
Dorman

CM
Kevin McBride
Liam Miller
James McArthur
Stephen McGinn

CF
Derek Riordan
Casilunovo
Kevin Kyle
Lee Miller (even if it was just for the amount of free kicks he would win you)

[MyJo]

Weaver
Balogh

Moutaouakil
Wotherspoon

Webster
Bamba
Goncalves
Ifil

Murray
Mulgrew

Zemmama
Arfield

McBride
Miller
McArthur
Dorman

Driver
O'Brien

Riordan
Jutkiewicz
Kyle
Forbes

[steve75]

GK
Weaver

LB
Wallace
Murray
Mulgrew

RB
?

CB
Andy Webster
Bamba
Goncalves
Ifil

LM
Driver
Myrie-Williams

RM
Wotherspoon
Zouma
Pawlett

CM
Gomis
Miller
Mcbride


ST
Sandaza
Riordan
Kyle
Jutkiewicz

[Danderhall Hibs]

Has Nicky Weaver been good? I've only seen him once or twice. Based on the stats Stack's better.

[Lmc2105]

GK
Paul Gallagher (St Mirren)
Robert Olinek (Falkirk)
Nicky Weaver (Dundee Utd)

RB
Darren Barr (Falkirk)
Kovacevic (Dundee Utd)
David Weatherspoon (Hibs)

CB
Bamba (Hibs)
Jose Goncalves (Hearts)
Ryan O'Leary (Killie)
Darren Dodds (Dundee Utd)

LB
Ian Murray (Hibs)
Lee Wallace (Hearts)
Paul Dixon (Dundee Utd)

RM
Zemamma (Hibs)
Danny Swanson (Dundee Utd)
Scott Arfield (Falkirk)

CM
Liam Miller (Hibs)
Gomis (Dundee Utd)
Kevin Mcbride (Hibs)
Stephen Mcginn (St Mirren)

LM
Andrew Driver (Hearts)
Derek Riordan (Hibs)

ST
Kevin Kyle (Killie)
Colin Nish (Hibs)
Fraser Fyvie Aberdeen)
Juktevic or however u spell it (well)
Anthony Stokes (Hibs)


i went for the keeper at falkirk becuase i think he has been outstanding this years and some of the saves he has made have been incredible

young lad at killie at centre half another good we player who i think would be a good edition to the team

Dodds good to have an old head in the tean no nonsense def and also good at corners both defending and attacking

but yeah not half the team most people would go for:wink:

[Wotherspiniesta]

GK:
Makalambay
Weaver

LB:
Lee Wallace
Ian Murray

RB:
Craig Thomson
David Wotherspoon

CB:
Sol Bamba
Jose Goncalves
Andy Webster
Lee Wilkie (when fit)

LM:
Andy Driver (when fit)
Ross Forbes

RM:
Jennison Myrie-Williams
Merouane Zemamma

CM:
Liam Miler
Kevin McBride
Jody Morris
James McArthur

FW:
Derek Riordan
Lukasz Jutkiewicz (thanks to wikipedia for the spelling)
Francisco Sandaza (when fit)
Anthony Stokes

[patlowe]

When you think of all the players I haven't mentioned here (McArthur, Swanson, Dixon, Sandaza, Mulgrew, Stewart, Palazuelos, Jonsson, Morris, Nish, Benji, Jutkievitc(sp?), Forbes, Murphy, Buaben, Wilkie, Moutinho, Flynn, all the Aberdeen youngsters, Diamond, Considine, Stack, Maka etc etc, many young and Scottish btw) is the standard of the SPL that bad? Or is the whole SCOTTISH FOOTBALL IN CRISIS!!! stuff entirely because Rangers and Celtic are utter guff?

Anyway, here's a couple of IMO decent non-OF teams;

1st XI

Weaver

J.Ross
Bamba
Webster
Wallace

Zemmama
Miller
Arfield
Driver

Miller
Riordan

2nd XI

Ruddy

Wotherspoon
Barr
Goncalves
Murray

Taouil
McBride
Gomis
Conway

Kyle
Stokes

[Sir David Gray]

Based on the fact that we currently have the best defensive record in the league, I think it's only right that you have Stack in goals and Murray, Hogg, Bamba and Wotherspoon as the back four.

Liam Miller is an absolute must in the middle of the park, so too is Zemmama and Derek Riordan has to be up front.

The other nine teams can fight it out for the other three places in the starting XI.

[lumbo_hfc]

Thon Motherwell boy on loan from Everton. Jutkeivicz

Forbes
Mikey Stewart would probably be around there NO CHANCE
Gomis
Bauben.
Sandaza
James McArthur
Cerny
Jody Morris?
Taouil.
James Fowler perhaps.
Lee Dixon That boy that played for Arsenal? Whos he at now? :greengrin
Craig Conway

And of course, every Hibee.

.

[.Sean.]

GK
John Ruddy
Thomas Cerny

LB
Lee Wallce
Ian Murray

RB
Darren Barr
David Wotherspoon

CB
Sol Bamba
Jose Goncalves
Zander Diamond
Mark Reynolds

LM
Andy Driver
Danny Invincible

RM
Merouane Zemmama
Morgaro Gomis

CM
Kevin McBride
Liam Miller
James McArthur
Jody Morris
Mehdi Taouil(sp)

CF
Derek Riordan
Francisco Sandaza
Damien Casalinuovo
Pedro Moutinhou

Would win the league :agree:

I can easily think of another 5 or 6 that narrowly missed out. There are some genuinely talented players playing outside the OF.

[Scotthibs1875]

GK
John Ruddy
Thomas Cerny

LB
Lee Wallce
Ian Murray

RB
Darren Barr
David Wotherspoon

CB
Sol Bamba
Jose Goncalves
Zander Diamond
Mark Reynolds

LM
Andy Driver
Danny Invincible

RM
Merouane Zemmama
Morgaro Gomis

CM
Kevin McBride
Liam Miller
James McArthur
Jody Morris
Mehdi Taouil(sp)

CF
Derek Riordan
Francisco Sandaza
Damien Casalinuovo
Pedro Moutinhou

Would win the league :agree:

I can easily think of another 5 or 6 that narrowly missed out. There are some genuinely talented players playing outside the OF.

Surely there is better players you could think of than that?
I would have Nicky Weaver instead of Cerny
I don't think you can have wotherspoon as right back as it isn't his natural position. Thought that motherwell right back was good was really quick and looked good on the ball.
Mark Reynolds is gash, just fouls folk all day! Andy Webster is a much better defender.
Pedro Moutinho isn't good either, i would have Stokesy in their even though he isn't playing that well still think he will become a good player:thumbsup:

[SteveHFC]

GK:
Greame Stack
Nicky Weaver

RB:
David Wotherspoon
Darren Barr

CB:
Sol Bamba
Andy Webster
Jose Goncalves
Zander Diamond

LB:
Lee Wallace
Ian Murray

RM:
Merouane Zemmamma
Morgaro Gomis

CM:
Liam Miller
Scott Robertson
James McArthur
Scott Arfield

LM:
Andrew Driver
Danny Invincible

CF:
Derek Riordan
Lukas Jutkiewicz
Lee Miller
Damian casalinuovo

[Robbie1875]

22 Christian Nades. World Beaters.

[CallumLaidlaw]

GK:
Greame Stack
Nicky Weaver

RB:
David Wotherspoon
Darren Barr

CB:
Sol Bamba
Andy Webster
Jose Goncalves
Zander Diamond

LB:
Lee Wallace
Ian Murray

RM:
Merouane Zemmamma
Morgaro Gomis

CM:
Liam Miller
Scott Robertson
James McArthur
Scott Arfield

LM:
Andrew Driver
Danny Invincible

CF:
Derek Riordan
Lukas Jutkiewicz
Lee Miller
Damian casalinuovo

I'm liking the look of this team.
I would swap Scott Arfield for Bauben
Riordan to LM, drop Danny Invincible, and bring in Stokes.